The Malice of Unnatural Death

Chapter Twenty-Six

Exeter Castle

The sheriff was keen to fetch his horse and go for a ride when he was distracted by a guard.

‘Yes? What is it?’ he demanded testily.

‘There is a man here to see you from the cathedral, sir.’

‘What of it? Tell him to be here again later when I may be able to see him for a little while. I am busy.’

‘I do not wish to wait, Sheriff, not when I can see you right away,’ Robert Busse said firmly.

The sheriff groaned inwardly. He didn’t know this old man from the cathedral, but he recognised the type all too well: helooked the sort who would consider any necessary restrictions of the church’s powers as a personal affront. There were alltoo many of them about the city. When a murderer ran from the scene of his offence and into the cathedral close, the men therewould close ranks and do anything in their power to obstruct the city’s men in their attempts to arrest him. Even though,by harbouring a murderer in their midst, they were risking their own lives as well as those of all the men around them. Itwas lunacy, in his mind, to allow such ridiculous abstract demarcations as borders of cathedral responsibility compared withthose of the city, when the result was that known felons could evade justice. Bloody sanctuary! It was a mad way to organise things, and gave people an escape when they had committed the mostoutrageous crimes.

Not only menfolk from the city made use of the church to escape their rightful punishments, either. Christ in chains! It wasonly a little while ago that one of the canons from the cathedral, that thieving scrote John Dyrewyn, broke into a painter’shouse and stole five pounds’ worth of goods. Not because he was owed money or anything, but because he was a thief. No betterthan a common draw-latch. He was seen, the crime was witnessed, and yet there was nothing the city could do to bring him tojustice because, oh dear, the man was a canon, and therefore answerable only to the Church court. And you knew what sort ofjudgement he’d get from his own kind.

Then there was that foul, venal piece of dog-turd, the Rector of St Ive. He kidnapped the wife of John de Thorntone and robbedhim as well, adding simple theft to the brutality of his treatment of the woman. And he blankly refused to return his ill-gottengains or apologise to the lady. Sweet Jesus, you couldn’t invent some of the crimes these supposedly ‘godly’ men were guiltyof.

The memory of all these past offences, and more, made his tone chill. ‘I am very busy just now.’

‘Ah yes. Going hunting?’ Busse said sarcastically. ‘You have a man of mine in gaol for no reason, and you are going to leavehim there just because you wish to enjoy a good day’s hunting? I scarcely think that to be honourable behaviour for a Christian.’

The sheriff bridled. ‘You suggest that I am holding someone unfairly? Let me tell you …’

‘You have a member of the Holy Catholic Church held in your gaol. That itself is illegal, for you took him without informing my lord bishop. He is aware now, and may seek damagesfrom you.’

‘You will not threaten me, Brother. Are you from the cathedral? I do not recognise you.’

‘I am Abbot of Tavistock, Sheriff,’ Busse said with as much pomposity and presumption as he could manage. It was shortly tobecome true, anyway, he told himself. And to console the twinges of guilt still further, he reminded himself that he may betelling a technical untruth, but it was in order to release one of God’s clerks, and that could not be wrong. The greatergood demanded that he did so. ‘As such I have responsibility for God’s flock.’

‘I am sheriff, and I have a writ from the king himself demanding that all those who practise necromancy be arrested and sentto him.’

‘Then why have you taken Langatre?’

‘Because, Abbot, I …’ Sheriff Matthew stopped. There was a glint in Brother Robert’s eye that he didn’t like. It was likethe glint of steel in a bush at the side of a road: warning of an unexpected ambush. He quickly recovered himself and hisconviction. ‘Because he is known to practise magic, and is thought to have murdered his servant. You in the church may havea different view on such matters, but, for me, to commit manslaughter is a crime — and I don’t care whether his servant answeredhim back or not. If he was guilty of something, his master should have brought him to his own tithing, not wrung his necklike a chicken.’

‘If I thought he was guilty, I would bring him to you myself,’ Busse said with asperity. ‘I am not considered an easy judge. It was only two years ago I had a man hanged for stealing oxen.’

The sheriff’s eyes narrowed. He recalled that case. The judge at the time had overstepped his authority, having a man sent tothe gallows without referring the matter to his local coroner. Even the Church was supposed to have the approval of a coronerbefore execution, and the coroner should always be invited to be present at the hanging to ensure that it was legal. In thatcase the justice was remarkable for its swiftness. The church did not approve of people who took its own goods, no matterhow assiduously they would protect those who stole from others. Hypocrites!

‘David de Cornilii? I remember that. I seem to recall that the judge had to be reprimanded for his decisions. Was it not thatsame judge who had a man’s ears cut off for a petty offence?’

‘Those tales are vastly overblown. But I am not considered to be a gentle, mild fellow when it comes to criminals. I am knownto be enthusiastic when it comes to punishing those who merit it. This man, however, is innocent. I know him personally.’

‘Then you may speak for him in the king’s court when he comes before the justices,’ Sir Matthew said dismissively, and wouldhave continued on his way, but Busse stepped nearer, blocking his path.

‘Langatre is a good man who has been of great use to me. I think he will be again. He is not guilty of any maleficia, but rather has saved people from the effects of them. And you should know, Sheriff, that he can see into a man’s future.’

‘What of it?’ Sheriff Matthew grinned. ‘You going to tell me that I need his help now?’

Busse did not blink. ‘I spoke to him last night, Sheriff, in your gaol. I wanted to consult him about my future, but the spiritsand demons who aid him needed to tell him about the dangers to others. I have been at risk in my life, but there is nothing in my immediate future that could put me in danger… whereas, Sheriff, you are in great, mortal peril even as we speak.’

The sheriff tried to respond, but although his mouth opened, no words would come. There was a deep sincerity in Brother Robert’seyes, and the sheriff knew he had much to fear always. Sheriffs were never popular, and had never been held in more contemptthan they were now. There were always those who objected to the way that men like Sir Matthew lined their purses through demandsfor cash in order to swing a court judgment one way or another, and victims would complain bitterly when they saw convictedcriminals released in exchange for a small contribution. Yes, there were always those who sought to bring retribution to asheriff. Not to mention the other matter. He was aware of a curious sensation, as though he had a lump in his belly. A lumpof lead.

Busse watched him closely, and then nodded. ‘You know, don’t you? You know that your life is in peril even as we stand heredebating the future of this young idiot Langatre. And yet while you hold him, he will not explain to you how he might helpyou. You are punishing unnecessarily the only man who might save you.’

Exeter City

Robinet woke with his head less painful than it had been since the attack. For the first time he felt as though he could eatsomething almost as soon as he awoke, rather than suffering the queasiness which had afflicted him yesterday.

Walter was not about yet, so Robinet lay back under his thick blanket. He put one hand behind his head, but incautiously allowed the other to fall onto the blanket itself, and winced. It was always the same: when the weather was cold,a man’s blanket would be covered with a thin layer of moisture in the morning, just like the dew on the grass in summertime. He wiped his hand on the bundle of clothes under his head.

No, he couldn’t lie here all day. He had work to do. Rising, he dressed quickly and walked to the pot dangling over the fire. Yesterday Walter had muttered about the quality of his latest wood, and Newt could see why as soon as he put his head overthe fire — Walter had run out of good burning wood, his oak and beech, and this birch was foul. It burned with an acrid stenchthat caught in a man’s throat and lungs, and Newt was forced to slam his eyes closed and turn away as it seared them.

The bowl’s handle was hot, so he took a fold of his robe to carry it away, and sat on a stool to eat a bowlful of the pottage. At least the smoke hadn’t made that too foul.

‘Up, eh?’ Walter said when he walked in a short time later.

Newt had already finished his first bowl and was sitting nursing a second, feeling the food slipping down his gullet and warminghim. It was one of those rare pleasures, this sensation of heat as a man ate. ‘Where have you been?’

‘Out seeing if I could learn more than you. I don’t know if I have succeeded,’ the older man admitted, leaning against a wall. Over the years, he had gradually saved enough money for stools and a bench, but he had spent much of his early life as a poorchurl living without such luxuries, and he had grown accustomed to standing. Now, even though he had the items about his roomto enable him to sit, he still preferred to stand. There was a sense in him that to sit was to be more of a target, and he had no desire to be that. No, it was better that he should stand and be ready to fly or attackin a moment.

‘Where have you been?’

It was easy to see how Robinet was affected by James’s killing. Robinet was so easy to read, it was astonishing. Of course,that was how he got himself into trouble, because he was such a transparent fellow. The damned fool. Others would have beenmuch more circumspect, but not him. Even here, in the dim light of the house, Walter could see Newt’s pallor. Perhaps it wasin part the effect of his ordeal, when he was knocked down so violently. Some men would keep their wounds better than others,it was true, but Walter reckoned it was nothing to do with that. No. It was James’s death.

The trouble was, Newt had spent so many years wishing to repay the debt. James had hurt him badly. But since the two had bumpedinto each other in the High Street, Walter had seen a change come over his old friend. Suddenly Robinet had grown less colickyand pinched. It was as though meeting James had brought back to his mind what sort of man he really was, and all that jealousyand vengefulness had gone, to be replaced by an easiness in the companionship of an old friend. Newt had rediscovered sucha one, only to have him stolen away in a moment, for a reason he could not comprehend.

‘I’ve been to a couple of taverns and alehouses in the last day or so,’ he said. ‘There’s a lad I know, Art, who often knowswho could be involved in crimes like James’s murder.’

‘Whoever killed James wouldn’t be there bragging about killing a king’s messenger, would he?’

‘You’d be surprised how thick some churls can be,’ Walter said with a slight grin. ‘I’ve known men do just that. And then they lookshocked when they realize you have slipped a knife into their chests for their boasting. I killed a man once who spent allthe evening in an alehouse regaling me with stories of how he planned to kill the king. He was going to sit near the roadsideand plead for alms like any beggar, and when the king was near enough, leap forward to stab him. As if the king wouldn’t haveenough men all about him to protect him from some adventurer like that! It was doing him a service, killing him quickly as I did. The cretin would have suffered for days at the hands of the king’s torturers else, and died a bad death as traitorto the king. Aye, I did him a favour: a quick and easy death.’

‘Did you learn anything?’ Newt asked eagerly.

Walter gave an inward sigh. His mate wouldn’t listen sometimes. Perhaps Walter shouldn’t bother, but Newt ought to realisethat James’s death was not so bad. It was fairly quick: a cord about the neck, pulled tight in an instant, and suffocationwould have brought about a speedy end to his life. Better than many deaths Walter had seen in his life as an assassin.

He shrugged. ‘There was no one who admitted to seeing anyone kill him, no. But there are some hints that a man was in thearea at the same time as you two. A stranger to the city.’

‘Do you know who it was?’ Robinet demanded.

‘No, but some I’ve spoken to have said that he seems to be an oddity. Tall, scrawny, pale — does it sound like the one yousaw?’

Newt considered for a long while. He had only the vaguest of ideas of the man he’d seen — it had been such a fleeting glimpse … and yet, if he were honest, the man he’d seen had appeared shorter, more thickset. Not at all likea slim, tall fellow. ‘I suppose if he was seen by a very short man, he might appear tall?’

Walter laughed. ‘No! These men I spoke to were sensible enough. They know the difference between tall and short, believe me!’

‘How can you be so sure?’ Newt asked, stung by his amusement.

‘They are thieves. If they noticed this man, whoever he was, they’d have made sure of him. They don’t go about robbing a manif he looks as if he’s going to thrash them. They can tell at a glance whether he’s too big or too strong.’

‘If he looked so weakly, why didn’t they attack him, then?’ Newt wanted to know.

‘Because he clearly had little or no money about him. If he had anything, they would have captured him.’

Newt stood. ‘Where is he, then?’

‘Hold hard! Before you decide to run off and attack him, what will you do?’

‘If he’s the man who killed James …’

‘That is the problem, Newt. The “if”. You don’t know it was him any more than the pope.’

‘The pope isn’t here in Exeter.’

‘Perhaps not, but just because a stranger is down here doesn’t mean he killed James.’

Newt sat down again, more heavily. ‘Then what should I do?’

‘Watch him. The men told me where he is staying, and if we go there and wait, no doubt we’ll see something if he was the one.’

‘And how will we be able to tell that?’ Newt scoffed. ‘Look to see whether he’s got plenty of blood all over him, or just wait and watch to see whether he’s likely to kill someoneelse?’

Walter turned his full attention on him, and Newt was suddenly aware of him. Those firm eyes were unsettling at the best oftimes, but just now Newt felt transfixed by that look — it was like being pierced by a lance and pinned to a wall.

‘Walter, I did not mean to say …’ He wasn’t sure what he meant, but he was quite sure that this man was too dangerousto upset, and at the moment he felt sure that he had done just that. ‘Walter, I am sorry.’

Gradually the intensity of Walter’s stare declined, and he nodded. ‘That is how we’ll know,’ he said. ‘When I have studiedthe man, I’ll be able to tell you whether he killed James or not. And when we know that, we’ll know what to do.’

Robinet agreed effusively. He believed his old comrade. No one would be able to endure that stare for very long. He had himselffelt like a rabbit caught in a snare, being watched like that.

But then, he knew that Walter was a professional killer.