A Great Reckoning

CHAPTER 14

Silence fell over the student body as Commander Gamache walked onto the stage.

He stood at the very center and waited. Only when he had their complete attention did he start to talk.

He told them what had happened. He spoke simply, clearly. Neither minimizing the horror of having a professor murdered on campus, nor turning it into a melodrama.

He gave them just enough information to stop much of the more lurid speculation, but not so much as to compromise the investigation.

He did not mention the revolver. He just said that Professor Leduc had been killed by a single shot to the head.

He said nothing about the map.

“Are there any questions?” he asked when he’d finished.

A hundred hands went up.

“That are not ‘Do we know who killed Professor Leduc?’” he clarified, and most of the hands went down. “Or ‘Do we know why he was killed?’”

Most of the rest of the hands went down.

“Yes, Cadet Thibodeau.” Gamache pointed to a third-year student, who stood up.

“When will we be allowed back in our rooms?”

Gamache considered him for a moment. “Are you asking if what we find in your rooms during the search will be held against you? Dope, for instance. Or booze. Or stolen exam papers.”

There was shifting in the seats.

“We will have a quiet word about what we find, but it will be kept internal unless there’s a particularly grievous breach or it’s evidence in this crime.”

Cadet Thibodeau nodded and sat down, clearly concerned but relieved.

There were a few other questions, about procedure, and classes, and what they could say to family and friends.

“Tell them the truth,” said Gamache. “Some of you will be questioned by Chief Inspector Lacoste and her homicide team. Mostly those of you who were students of Professor Leduc or who met with—”

“Liar.”

Gamache raised his hand to his forehead, to better see who had spoken. But the person remained hidden in the crowd.

“If you have something to say, stand and face me,” said Gamache, his voice deep and calm, carrying to the very back of the room.

The cadets turned in their seats and looked around the auditorium.

At the front of the room, Gamache waited. When no one stood up, he continued as though there’d been no interruption.

“You’ll be allowed back in your rooms within the hour. If you know anything that could be helpful, however trivial you think it is, keep it to yourself until you can speak to one of the investigators. Unfortunately, you now have a chance to see a homicide investigation from the inside. It is not attractive. It is not exciting. A lot will be revealed that people had hoped to keep hidden. And not simply the contents of your rooms.”

Nervous laughter met that comment. And when it died down, the Commander continued.

“Make no mistake, it will all come to light. Far easier if you volunteer than that it be dragged out into the open.”

“Hypocrite,” the same voice yelled.

Now there was an audible murmur in the room as students reacted. Some with shock. Some with nervous amusement.

Commander Gamache stared into the gathering of cadets and slowly they grew silent. The room waited for his response, bracing for the explosion.

After a few very long moments, Commander Gamache did what none of them expected.

He smiled. Very, very slightly. And then the smile faded and he spoke. Softly, but the words penetrated each and every person in the room.

“Be careful. This is a time of menace. There’s a murderer among us. Almost certainly in this room.” He paused, and then he looked at them with such caring that a few sighed, breathing out lifelong tension. “It’s too easy to feed the anger. Too cowardly to stoke the hate. You must look inside yourself and decide who you are and who you want to be. Character is not created in times like these. It’s revealed. This is a trying time. A testing time. Be careful.”

Then Armand Gamache walked off the stage.

“Coward,” the voice pursued him.

The word hit, then glided off Commander Gamache’s back. He didn’t pause, didn’t hesitate, his stride unbroken.

Amelia sat forward, leaning toward the stage. Even after the Commander had disappeared. She stared at the empty space once occupied by him.

Commander Gamache had spoken those words to each and every cadet, including herself. But his eyes had lingered on one young man. And that was when his expression had changed. And that look of almost aching caring had settled there.

He knew exactly who had shouted those words, shot those words, at him. And Gamache had spoken directly to the young man. Be careful.

“Huh,” she murmured.

“What?” said the cadet beside her.

“Screw off,” she said, though her heart wasn’t in it. She was thinking.

Chief Inspector Isabelle Lacoste, standing at the back of the room with Jean-Guy Beauvoir, inhaled sharply.

“Don’t they know?” she whispered.

“Who he is?” asked Beauvoir. “They either don’t know or don’t care. Serge Leduc successfully poisoned the well before Gamache arrived, and added shit for the past couple of months.”

“And he couldn’t fight it?” asked Lacoste.

Around them the room had erupted in speculation. About the murderer, and about the words hurled at the Commander.

“He chose not to,” said Beauvoir. “He said it was a deliberate distraction and there was too much to do to waste time waging war on the Duke.”

“They’re fools.”

“Not all of them.”

While it looked, quite understandably to Lacoste, as if Gamache might have lost control of the academy, Jean-Guy Beauvoir saw something else in that room.

Like her, he’d heard the open insults to Gamache. But Beauvoir now saw pockets of quiet as some of the cadets contemplated what had just happened. And began to evolve their thinking.

“You’re a fool,” hissed Huifen.

“What? Everyone was thinking it,” said Jacques.

“Not everyone. Not anymore anyway.”

Her keen eyes took in the activity around them. And in some cases, the inactivity. The quiet that had come over more than a few of her fellow cadets.

Then she studied him. So handsome. Fine, intelligent features. Muscular. From rock climbing and rowing and hockey. His body contained a strapping energy she found almost irresistible. She dreamed of running her hands over those taut muscles, even as she was doing it. She dreamed of wrapping her arms and legs around him, even as she was doing it.

But now, and not for the first time, she wondered what else was contained in that fine body. In that mind. And what would happen if those straps ever broke.

When Huifen got back to her room, she found a woman waiting for her and an agent searching her belongings.

“Cadet Cloutier?”

“Oui.”

“I’m Chief Inspector Lacoste, of homicide. Have a seat, please.”

Huifen sat on the edge of her bed and watched the agent go through the dresser drawers.

Lacoste took the desk chair and crossed her legs, comfortably.

“Where were you last night, between ten and two in the morning?”

“Here. In bed.”

“Alone?”

“Yes.”

“Did you get up at all, to go to the bathroom? Get a drink?”

“No, I was asleep. Between classes and all the activities and sports, it’s pretty exhausting.”

Lacoste smiled. “I remember. What was your relationship with Professor Leduc?”

“I was one of his students. And I suppose you could call him a mentor.”

“Did he choose you, or did you choose him?”

Huifen regarded the Chief Inspector. It was an insightful and uncomfortable question.

“He chose me. When I was a freshman, he invited me to bring him his morning coffee. Then, after a while, he began inviting me to his rooms in the evening.”

“What for?”

“Talks. We weren’t alone,” Huifen hurried to reassure her, “if that’s what you think. It wasn’t like that. He just spoke to us, about policing, about the Sûreté. He took an interest in certain cadets.”

“His death must be a shock.”

And yet it was clear to Lacoste that this young woman wasn’t at all shocked. And certainly not saddened. But she was nervous.

“It is,” said Huifen.

“You’re just a few months away from graduating and becoming an agent in the Sûreté. You know how this works. Any idea who did this?”

“I think you should ask the Commander.”

“Really? Why?”

“They hated each other. It was obvious.”

“How so?”

“By what they said about each other.”

“What did Professor Leduc say about Commander Gamache?”

“That he was weak, and was weakening the academy and the Sûreté. That he was a coward.”

Lacoste pressed her lips together for a moment before she could speak again.

“And what did Commander Gamache say about Professor Leduc?”

Huifen opened her mouth, then slowly shut it again as she racked her brain. What had she heard him say about the Duke?

She looked at Chief Inspector Lacoste, who was nodding.

“Nothing, right?”

Huifen nodded.

“You won’t make a very good agent if you take gossip as fact, Cadet Cloutier.”

The agent searching the small room leaned down and spoke into Lacoste’s ear and handed her something. She looked at it and thanked him.

“Please pack up a few things,” she told Huifen, getting to her feet. “Overnight things. And please bring this with you.”

She handed the stunned young woman the map of Three Pines, and left.

Down the hall, Inspector Beauvoir was just leaving Jacques Laurin’s room.

“I’m pretty sure he’s the one who insulted Monsieur Gamache,” said Beauvoir, as the two investigators fell into step.

“Why?”

“Why do I think it, or why would he?”

“Both.”

“Because he’s one of Serge Leduc’s Mini-Mes. Was his servant, as a freshman.”

“So was Cadet Cloutier.” She waved toward Huifen’s rooms. “Did you find the map?”

“Yes. He still has it.”

“So does Cadet Cloutier. That’s two accounted for.”

“I told him to pack an overnight case and bring the map with him, but I didn’t tell him where he was going. The little shit looked pretty scared.”

“But if Professor Leduc was their mentor, and they respected him, they almost certainly didn’t kill him,” said Lacoste.

“Well, I wouldn’t rule it out,” said Beauvoir. “Worship can turn to hatred pretty fast in young people. If Leduc found new favorites.”

“Like the other two cadets,” said Lacoste. “The freshmen.”

“Maybe.”

“You take the young woman,” said Lacoste. “I’ll speak to Nathaniel Smythe again. See if he’s found his map.”

Nathaniel produced the map.

“Bon.” She studied it, then handed it back. Three down. “When you met with Serge Leduc in the evenings, what did you do?”

“How do you know I met with him?”

The young man turned an outrageous color.

“I’ve spoken with other cadets, you know.”

“There were a bunch of us,” said Nathaniel. “We didn’t meet often, just when the Duke invited us over.”

“And were there always others? Were you ever alone?”

“Never.”

“And last night?”

“I had dinner, then hockey practice, then came back here and did homework. We had to design a step-by-step investigation of a break-and-enter.”

“When did you go to bed?”

“About eleven, I guess.”

“From what you saw, did anyone particularly dislike Professor Leduc?”

“Well, he wasn’t the most popular professor,” said Nathaniel. “But people respected him.”

“Respected or feared?”

Nathaniel remained silent.

“You? Which did you feel?”

“I respected him.”

“Why?”

“I— I—”

“You feared him, didn’t you?” she asked quietly.

“Never. I was grateful he chose me.”

Lacoste nodded. That might actually be true. With the Duke as his mentor, the other cadets might leave him alone. But Leduc must have known this young man had been one of his rejects, and that Commander Gamache himself had reversed that decision.

Is that why Leduc had adopted him? Because Gamache had favored him? He wanted to sour anything and anyone special to the Commander?

“Please pack some things for a few nights away,” she said, getting to her feet. “And bring the map along.”

Nathaniel also rose. “What? Why?”

“Have you been taught to question orders?”

“No.”

“Then do it, please.”

She left, shaking her head. She could see what Monsieur Gamache was up against in his new post.

“It’s here somewhere,” said Amelia.

First the Sûreté agent and now she herself searched the entire room while Jean-Guy Beauvoir watched.

It didn’t take long. There was a single bed, a desk. A chest of drawers and a small closet, with a school uniform hanging there.

The chest of drawers was empty aside from one drawer of socks and underwear and bras.

But there were books. Stacked on the shelves above the desk, and sitting on the floor, lining the walls. Amelia had created a makeshift bookcase using bricks and old two-by-fours.

She opened each book, shaking it. But nothing fell out.

“Give it up,” said Beauvoir. “The map’s not here.”

He indicated the bed, and she sat. He pulled the desk chair close, and after sitting down he leaned toward her and quietly asked, “Where is it?”

“I don’t know.”

She seemed genuinely perplexed.

While Beauvoir didn’t much like what he saw when he looked at Amelia Choquet, he had to admit since the beginning of the term Cadet Choquet had never pretended to be anything other than what she was.

It was refreshing and alarming at the same time.

But that did not mean, Beauvoir knew, that she wasn’t capable of lying.

“Did you give it to Professor Leduc?”

“What?” she asked. “No, of course not. Why would I?”

“When did you last see it?” Beauvoir asked.

“I don’t know.”

“Try, cadet.”

Up until then, this somewhat attractive professor had been just that to Amelia. A professor. He taught Scene of Crime management and techniques. He was also, she knew, Commander Gamache’s second-in-command.

And his son-in-law. She’d learned that from the photo she’d seen in the Commander’s home. But it was a secret she was hoarding, to be used at the moment juste.

But Amelia had not thought of him as a full-blown inspector within the homicide department, and one of the more senior officers in the Sûreté. Didn’t even know he was that.

Until this moment.

Before her eyes, the professor became the senior inspector.

Amelia shook her head and lifted her hands in resignation.

“I don’t know where it is.”

“Professor Leduc asked you to be one of his servants,” said Beauvoir.

“He didn’t ask,” she said. “He told. And he didn’t describe it as a servant. It was an honor, an opportunity.”

“Did you see it like that?”

“I didn’t think I had much choice. I just did it.”

“You don’t sound like you liked the man.”

“I don’t like anyone,” she said.

“Did you dislike him?”

“I don’t dislike anyone.”

“Really?” he said. “You’re above all that nasty human stuff?”

“Look, I’m here to learn how to be a Sûreté agent. Not to make friends.”

“You do know that the people you meet here will be your colleagues for many, many years to come? Perhaps you’d better learn to like, or even to dislike, them.”

“Yessir.”

Beauvoir watched her, and in her eyes he saw intelligence. And if not fear, then worry.

She had reason, he knew, to be worried. She even had reason to be afraid.

Her map was missing. Either she gave it to the dead man, or someone took it and planted it there. Either way, attention was focusing on her. Cadet Choquet was in the crosshairs. He knew it. And clearly she knew it too.

“Pack up a few things, please. You’ll be going away for a few nights. An agent will escort you out.”

“Why? Because of the map?” Amelia called after him, but got no response.

“May I come in?” Lacoste asked, knocking once and opening the door. “You’ve had your meeting with the mayor and the police chief?”

Gamache got up from behind his desk and greeted her, motioning to a chair by the sofa, while he took the other one.

“Oui. That poor man. I feel for him. I’ve tried for the last few months to regain the mayor’s trust. He finally, against the wishes of his councilors, endorsed the volunteer program with the academy at the last town meeting, only to have this happen.”

“But the two aren’t connected,” said Lacoste.

“No, but it puts the academy in a very bad light, wouldn’t you say? When one of our own professors is murdered? How can the mayor now say it’s safe for kids to come and use our pool or the hockey rink?”

“I see,” she said, and saw that Gamache was genuinely saddened. But not, she suspected, by the brutal murder of one of his colleagues. He was saddened that a good man like the mayor, and the children of the community, were being hurt, once again, by Serge Leduc.

“The chief of police was more sanguine,” he said. “Offering to help.”

Isabelle Lacoste straightened the crease in her slacks, then looked up at Armand Gamache.

“I had no idea this was such a hostile environment, patron.”

He smiled. “Nor did I, to be honest. I expected resistance when I first arrived, and God knows, I found it. I expected Serge Leduc to try to contaminate and control the feeling on campus. Which he did. I expected that the third-year students would be a lost generation. Which they are. Almost.”

He looked at her and considered for a moment.

“Do you know why the armed forces recruit eighteen-year-olds?”

“Because they’re young and healthy?” she asked.

“Healthier than a twenty-three-year-old? No. It’s because they’re malleable. You can get an eighteen-year-old to believe almost anything. To do almost anything.”

“The same could be said for street gangs and terrorist organizations,” said Lacoste. “Get them young.”

The thought set her back. The words had come out casually, but their meaning took a moment to sink in. Serge Leduc had essentially turned the Sûreté Academy into a terrorist training ground.

Within a few short years, he’d soured a once fine institution. Not just the academy—from here his cadets would become Sûreté agents. And rise through the ranks. No, not would. Had. They were already inside the Sûreté.

And worst of all, these young men and women wouldn’t see anything wrong with what they did. Or were about to do. Because they’d been told it was right.

Armand Gamache had chosen this post for a reason. To right the balance. And to do that he had to stop Serge Leduc.

She watched as Commander Gamache got up and walked to his desk.

An alertness stole over her. The sort that came to highly trained, finely attuned officers.

Serge Leduc had been stopped. Utterly and completely.

But it wasn’t Monsieur Gamache’s doing, she told herself. He had nothing to do with it. He had nothing to do with it. Nothing.

She watched as Gamache picked up a dossier and returned to his chair.

“You could’ve fired him, patron,” she said. “You might not have been able to arrest him for corruption, but at least that would stop him from doing more damage.”

“Firing Leduc would solve nothing. The problem would simply be shifted onto someone else. The Leducs of this world will always find fertile ground. If not with the Sûreté, then with another police force. Or a private security firm. No. Enough was enough. It had to end, and the people he’d already corrupted, here and in the Sûreté, had to see that his philosophy would no longer be tolerated.”

“And how did you intend to do that, sir?”

He looked at her closely now, quizzically. “Are you saying what I think you are? Are you suggesting I might have stopped him with a bullet in the small hours of this morning?”

“I need to ask,” she said. “And you need to answer. I’m not making small talk.”

“No, and neither am I,” he said, sitting back in his chair. “You think I’m capable of cold-blooded murder?”

She paused, holding his eyes. “I do.”

That sat between them for a very long moment.

“For what it’s worth, I think I am too,” she said.

“Under the right circumstances,” Gamache said, nodding slowly.

“Oui.”

“The question is, what are the right circumstances?” said Gamache.

“It must have become clear to you, patron, that Serge Leduc was winning. He’d already polluted the third-year cadets. You yourself said they were beyond redemption—”

“I said almost beyond. I haven’t given up on them.”

“Then why not teach a third-year class yourself? You only take the freshmen.”

“True. I gave the seniors someone better. Someone with more to teach them than I ever could.”

“Jean-Guy?” she asked, not even trying to disguise her doubt.

“Michel Brébeuf.”

Isabelle Lacoste sat very still. As though something horrible had entered the room and she didn’t want to attract its notice.

Finally she spoke.

“A known traitor?”

“An example,” said Gamache. “A powerful example of what corruption will do. It robbed Michel Brébeuf of everything he cared about. His colleagues, his friends, his self-respect. His career. His family. He lost everything. Serge Leduc was promising the cadets power and rewards. Michel Brébeuf is the reality check. What really happens to corrupt Sûreté officers.”

“Does he know that?”

“He knows he’s been given this chance to redeem himself. To close the gate.”

Isabelle Lacoste cocked her head slightly, missing the allusion.

“And suppose he doesn’t try to redeem himself?” she asked. “Suppose he sees this as his chance to get back in? Suppose he’s gone back to his old ways and has found his own fertile ground. Aren’t you worried that putting Michel Brébeuf, Serge Leduc, and a school full of impressionable cadets together will be a disaster?”

“Of course I am,” he snapped, then quickly reined himself in. He looked at her, his eyes sharp and the anger just below the surface. “You can’t possibly think I don’t worry about that every moment of every day. But how do you put out a wildfire? With another fire.”

“A controlled burn,” said Isabelle Lacoste, then lowered her voice. “Controlled.”

“You think I’ve lost control?”

“There’s a body being taken to a morgue, and you were heckled by the cadets.” She sighed. “I do think you’ve lost control. And please know, I say that with the greatest respect. If anyone could have solved this problem, it would’ve been you.”

“But you think I’ve made it worse?”

She opened her mouth, then closed it.

“I’m not going to sit here and tell you the murder of Serge Leduc was part of my plan,” said Gamache. “Or anything I thought remotely possible. But I won’t back down. You’ve never run away, Isabelle. Even when you could have. Even when you should have, to save yourself.”

He smiled at her now, with those same deep brown eyes that had looked up at her as he lay dying on a factory floor and she was desperate to stanch the blood. As automatic weapons fire hissed overhead and the walls around them exploded with bullets and the air was thick with dust and shouting and the screams of mortally wounded men and women.

She’d stayed with him. Held his hand. Listened to what they both knew would be his last words. Reine-Marie.

He’d placed those words into Isabelle Lacoste. And with them all his heart and soul. All his happiness, and an apology. Reine-Marie.

Gamache had survived, of course. And Isabelle had not had to deliver that final message.

“And I won’t run away now,” he said. “We stay the course.”

“Oui,” she said.

“We’ve seen worse, haven’t we, Isabelle?” he said.

She smiled. “We have. At least the cadets aren’t armed and shooting at us. Yet.”

Gamache gave a single gruff laugh. “I’ve asked the chief of police to quietly take all the ammunition from the armory. The weapons will stay, but there’ll be nothing to fire.”

Her smile disappeared. “I was joking. But you’re seriously expecting trouble on that scale?”

“I was not expecting a murder,” he said. His face as serious as she’d ever seen. “The cadets must be safe. The only thing more dangerous than a killer is a killer trapped. He is now trapped inside the academy. Best not to have an armory at his disposal.”

“Or an army,” said Lacoste, remembering the reaction in the auditorium. “Serge Leduc had a lot of supporters.”

“Yes, but did you see any grief?”

That set Lacoste back, and after thinking for a moment she shook her head. “No.”

“No,” said Gamache. “The problem with the breath of kings.”

“The breath of kings?”

“Who float upon the tide of state,” said Gamache. “I only wish Jean-Guy was here to appreciate this.”

“Another poem?” she asked, knowing full well it must be.

“Hmmm, Jonathan Swift.”

He handed her the dossier he’d retrieved off his desk.

“What’s this?”

“The gun I held to Serge Leduc’s head,” said Gamache. “Read it and tell me what you think.”

She took it and got up. “Merci. I will. Is there an office I can use?”

“There’s a boardroom across the hall.”

“Perfect.”

Though she was on her feet, Gamache himself had not risen. And so, taking the cue, Lacoste sat back down.

“There’s more?”

“Of a political nature, nothing that will help solve the murder, I’m afraid,” said Gamache. “There are some considerations in running a department. Especially one with as high a profile as homicide.”

“Yes?”

“Justice must be seen to be done.”

“I agree.”

It was an old adage, a cliché even, and Gamache was not given to spouting clichés. So when he did, it must be particularly apropos.

“‘Not only must justice be done,’” she quoted, “‘it must also be seen to be done.’ What are you saying? That I need to hold a news conference?”

“Well, that might not be a bad idea, but my thoughts run to something more nuanced. This is the Sûreté Academy. The professors are all former officers or those on leave, like Inspector Beauvoir, or people who do contract work with the Sûreté. I’m the former head of homicide. Your former boss.”

Chief Inspector Lacoste got it then.

“In effect, it’s the Sûreté investigating the Sûreté.”

“In a murder case,” said Gamache.

She nodded, considering. “You think I should call Chief Superintendent Brunel and ask that an outside agency take over?”

“Non,” he shook his head. “Not take over. You must fight against that. Simply ask that an outside investigator be sent. Someone who can vouch for the fairness of your investigation.”

She sat thinking. Her thoughts were not happy ones. “Have you ever had to do that?”

“Twice. It was not pleasant. But it had to be done. And better to have it come from you than be imposed. I suspect Chief Superintendent Brunel is contemplating it even now.”

Lacoste pulled out her iPhone and punched in the number for the head of the Sûreté. “Is there someone I should ask for specifically?”

“No,” he said, getting to his feet. “That would taint it. You have to take what comes. I’ll leave you to it.”

Gamache stepped into his outer office just as Jean-Guy arrived.

“They’re heading down to Three Pines, patron.”

“Good. Merci.”

Now, close up, Beauvoir could see how stressed Gamache really was.

“There is something,” said Jean-Guy. “One of their maps is missing.”

“Whose?”

“The Goth Girl’s.”

“Amelia?”

Beauvoir raised his brows at the familiarity.

“Cadet Choquet, yes.”

“What did she say?”

“She seemed surprised. She denied there was any special relationship with Professor Leduc, aside from taking him coffee in the morning and gathering for the odd meeting with others in his rooms.”

“So it’s true,” said Gamache. “She was one of them.”

Gamache took a deep, deep breath, then on the exhale he looked out the door and down the empty hallway that had once teemed with cadets and was now completely devoid of life.

He muttered so quietly as to be almost inaudible, “What have I done?”