A Prayer for the Damned

CHAPTER THIRTEEN

Eadulf and Gormán had been trying to follow the trail but had eventually given up. They had come to a stretch of stony ground where the tracks had disappeared and even though Gormán had circled the area several times he had been unable to pick them up again.

‘Let’s continue to head in the direction of Cashel,’ suggested Eadulf. ‘If our suspicion is right and the killer is heading back there, we should soon be able to pick up some signs again. The split horseshoe is easy to spot where the ground is soft.’

Gormán agreed and they turned their horses along the track. They had travelled but a short distance, traversing a copse of beech and aspen ringed round wi$i clumps of thorn bushes and broom, and moving across a small hillock, when Gormán gave a stifled gasp. Eadulf followed his extended hand.

A little distance in front of them and slightly below, as the hill inclined into a small valley, was a single rider, leading a second horse by the reins. Eadulf recognised the piebald. It was the animal that he had last seen being ridden by Muirchertach Nár.

Gormán had already given a grunt of satisfaction and was digging his heels into his mount, sending it cantering forward down the slope. Eadulf gave an inward groan and followed the warrior’s example.

Ahead of them, the rider must have heard the sound of their approach because he turned in the saddle to look back. The thought crossed Eadulf’s mind that their quarry might fly but the figure drew rein, rested in the saddle, and in an unperturbed fashion watched their approach.

It was a few moments before Eadulf realised who the rider was. He gasped in surprise. It was Brother Drón. And now that they drew close, Eadulf knew there was no doubt that the horse he was leading was the animal that Muirchertach Nár had been riding.

They reined in as they came abreast of him.

‘You have a lot of explaining to do,’ was Eadulf’s greeting.

Brother Drón stared at him as if he were insane. ‘Explaining? For what?’ he demanded.

‘Where did you get that horse?’ Eadulf said, gesturing to the piebald.

Brother Drón’s lip curled in disdain. ‘What business is it of yours, Saxon?’ he demanded. ‘You have no authority to demand answers of me.’

Gormán was leaning forward on his saddlebow. ‘But I do, brother.’ He raised his hand to touch the golden necklet round his throat with a significant gesture. The necklet signified that he was of the Nasc Niadh, the élite warrior guard of the king of Muman.

‘If you must know, I am taking it back to the fortress,’ snapped Brother Drón

‘That is not what I asked,’ replied Eadulf coldly. ‘I asked where you found the animal, not where you are taking it.’

Brother Drón looked as though he was going to refuse but Gormán said: ‘It would be better if you answered.’

The man hesitated, frowning in annoyance. ‘I was riding by the woods back there and saw it standing with its reins caught in a thorn bush. It probably tossed its rider and then got caught up. I am taking it back to. .’

‘You have said that,’ Eadulf interrupted irritably. ‘Are you telling us that you simply found the horse riderless?’

‘I thought that was precisely what I said.’

‘What are you doing out here, brother?’ demanded Gormán. ‘You were not with the main hunting party when we left the fortress this morning.’

Brother Drón shrugged. ‘I do not see how that concerns you, even if you are a member of the king of Muman’s bodyguard,’ he countered.

Gormán’s mouth tightened and he clapped a hand on the hilt of his sword. Brother Drón did not miss the gesture. His eyes narrowed.

‘If it means so much to you,’ he said tightly, ‘I was not with the hunt. I came riding on my own. Satisfied?’

‘For what purpose?’ demanded Eadulf. ‘Why did you come riding here on your own?’

‘I was looking for someone.’

‘Who?’

‘Really. .’ began Brother Drón.

‘Who were you looking for?’ Eadulf’s voice was a sharp crack, making Brother Drón blink.

‘I was looking for one of my charges, if you must know. One who scandalously rode off to follow the hunt without permission. A shameful act. An affront to the abbey she serves since her superior, the abbot, is only newly dead.’

‘Are you saying that you were looking for one of the two sisters who accompanied Abbot Ultán?’ asked Eadulf, exchanging a glance with Gormán. He recalled that they had seen Sister Marga riding through the forest not so long before.

‘I am, for it is the truth.’

‘Who was it?’

‘If you will have it, I was looking for Sister Marga. I was told that she had ridden out with the others, and on Abbot Ultán’s very own horse. She will be punished for such an affront to his sacred memory.’

Eadulf was silent for a moment.

‘Do you have any idea whose horse that is?’ Gormán asked quietly. ‘Whose horse it is that you claim to have found?’

‘Should I?’

‘Oh, indeed you should.’ Eadulf smiled thinly. ‘That is the horse of Muirchertach Nár.’

Brother Drón’s eyes widened a fraction.

‘And Muirchertach Nár now lies dead,’ added Gormán.

Whatever reaction they were expecting, neither man hid their surprise when Brother Drón threw back his head and laughed.

‘That is God’s justice,’ he chuckled. ‘God’s punishment for his killing of Abbot Ultán.’

Fidelma was about to leave her cousin at the gates of Cashel when there came a shout from one of the guards.

‘Looks as if the rest of the hunters are beginning to return!’ Finguine observed.

In fact, it was only Abbot Augaire in the company of Aibnat, the wife of Muirchertach Nár. Fidelma’s eyes narrowed in disapproval at the sight of the latter. The woman had not endeared herself to Fidelma. In fact, Fidelma was surprised to see the usually sour-faced Aibnat smiling and apparently sharing a joke with the abbot of Conga. It did not seem appropriate for the wife of a man who had been charged with the heinous crime of murder.

As the abbot dismounted, he caught sight of Fidelma, and hailed her with a smile. ‘What news, lady? Have you gathered all your evidence in defence of Muirchertach Nár?’

Fidelma ignored his question and answered with one of her own. ‘I presume that the hunting was good?’

Abbot Augaire shrugged indifferently. ‘I’m afraid that I was separated from the main party early on. I was lost in your forest. Then, by chance, I encountered the lady Aibnat who was in a similar plight and, thankfully, we fell in with Brother Eadulf and a warrior who put us on the right path back to Cashel.’

Attendants had helped Aibnat dismount and the horses were being led away.

‘So you became lost as well?’ Fidelma said to her. ‘I understood attendants were supposed to ride with the ladies to ensure that you all kept together to prevent such misadventures.’

The woman was disparaging. ‘The attendants who were supposed to be looking after the ladies allowed them all to scatter like sheep when the threat of the boars came close. In trying to find my companions, I became lost. Either your attendants need better training or your brother stands in need of knowing how to choose better servants.’

Abbot Augaire came forward to act as a peacemaker. ‘It is easy to get lost in these dark woods of Muman. People are often scattered in the best controlled of boar hunts.’

Aíbnat’s features were unforgiving. She looked round in disapproval. ‘Has my husband returned?’

Fidelma shook her head. ‘Dúnchad Muirisci was the first to return. No one else has as yet.’

‘Where is Dúnchad Muirisci?’ demanded Aibnat. Fidelma tried to ignore the arrogance in her voice.

‘Across the courtyard and beyond that arched doorway you will find Brother Conchobhar’s apothecary. He is being treated there.’

‘Treated?’ snapped Aíbnat. ‘What ails the fellow?’

‘A slight misfortune. He is bleeding a little.’

Aíbnat frowned and mumbled something before turning and hurrying in the direction Fidelma had indicated.

Abbot Augaire stood for a moment, looking after her, before glancing at Fidelma.

‘What was the nature of the misfortune?’ he asked quickly.

Fidelma grimaced indifferently. ‘He says that he fell into a thorn bush, that’s all.’

Once again a call from the guard at the gate told her that others were returning from the hunt. She recognised the short, dark figure of Fergus Fanat immediately. He was carrying his bir loosely in one hand, and Fidelma saw that the point of it had been bloodied. His companion was none other than Sister Marga. For the first time, she could observe the girl carefully. Her assessment of her when she had espied her at the game of immán on the previous day had been correct. She was attractive. Her robe and headdress, the cabhal, had been thrown back, and the form that was revealed was young and pleasing to the eye. The girl had fair skin and dark hair, and the features in the heart-shaped face were moulded into a happy expression. The smile had transformed her from the sombre maiden of the previous day. As she watched them ride through the gates into the courtyard, Fidelma had the impression of closeness between the two young people, almost of a courting couple.

Abbot Augaire watched them in disapproval before turning and following in Aíbnat’s steps towards Brother Conchobhar’s apothecary shop.

‘Good hunting, Fergus Fanat?’ called Fidelma as the pair halted and attendants came forward.

‘A good chase but, alas, I cannot claim a victory,’ replied the northern warrior cheerfully as he slid from his horse.

‘Yet I see your spear point is bloodied,’ Fidelma observed.

‘Ah, indeed. The boar received a sharp prick as it sped by me, but that is about all. After that quick thrust, I never saw hide nor hair of it again. By the time I had finished looking for it, the hunt had moved on. It is a hunter’s saying that you are allowed only one shot at taking the prize. I heard the cry further through the woods but I decided that I had had my chance and should return. It was fortunate that I did, for I was able to help a lady in distress.’ He half bowed courteously to Sister Marga, who had also dismounted, and now blushed but stood without speaking while their horses were led away.

Fidelma looked quizzically at the girl. ‘You were in distress?’

‘I became separated from the other ladies and was lost in the wood for a while until Fergus. .’ She hesitated, blushing.

‘Fergus Fanat in the train of Blathmac of Ulaidh,’ said the young warrior quickly.

Fidelma frowned. Was the northern noble trying to cover up the fact that Sister Marga already knew his name? She addressed the girl.

‘You may know that I am Fidelma of Cashel. You surprise me, sister. I have already noticed that you are interested in immán. .’ Sister Marga coloured hotly. The point had been scored, ‘but I had not expected you to be interested in following the hunt. I was looking for you earlier. Even Sister Sétach had not realised that you had gone.’

The girl hesitated a moment and then tried to regain her composure.

‘Sétach would have disapproved,’ she said quietly. ‘I could not resist the temptation of following the hunt, for my father was a hunter. He was one of the trackers of the Uí MacUais. I suddenly felt that I needed just one more time of freedom, of riding with the hounds and the sound of the hunters’ horns. A good horse under me and. .’

‘Even Abbot Ultán’s horse?’ Fidelma observed quietly.

‘The beast is not responsible for the rider,’ she replied. Then a worried look came to her face. ‘Does Brother Drón know that I took the abbot’s horse?’

‘I think so. The stable lads knew that you had requested a saddle to be put on the beast. In fact, I was informed that Brother Drón rode off after the hunt as well.’

Fergus Fanat was laughing uproariously. ‘Well, if Brother Drón can seek solace in the hunt, you are surely not going to condemn Sister Marga for doing so? As for Ultán’s horse, she only borrowed it for a few hours.’

‘It is no concern of mine if she borrows Ultán’s horse,’ Fidelma agreed. ‘She has now explained to me why she went on the hunt. However, I still would like a word with you, Marga. . alone.’

The girl looked a little defensive. ‘What about?’

‘I want to speak to you about Abbot Ultán.’

A shadow seemed to cross Sister Marga’s features, casting them as in grey stone. ‘I have nothing to say.’

Fergus Fanat was still smiling. ‘Come now, everyone within the vicinity of the lands of the Uí Thuirtrí has something to say about Ultán. Usually nothing good, though.’

Fidelma cast him a disapproving glance.

‘Obviously now is not the time to discuss this,’ she said to the girl. ‘I will come to see you later on. Make yourself available for me and do not leave the fortress unless I say so.’

‘You have no right. .’ protested the girl.

‘I have every right,’ Fidelma assured her grimly. She glanced at Fergus Fanat. ‘I am sure that you will be able to instruct Sister Marga about the powers of a dálaigh?’

Fergus Fanat’s expression changed to one of seriousness.

The lady Fidelma is right. You’d best do as she says,’ he advised.

The girl hesitated before agreeing. They moved away across the courtyard just as one of the guards in the gate tower blew a blast on a horn, signifying that the High King and his retinue were returning.

Finguine came hurrying over to join her.

‘The hunt returns, your brother and the High King,’ he announced unnecessarily. ‘The attendants are carrying three boars, so the hunt has been good.’

Eadulf and Gormán were staring in disbelief at Brother Drón as he sat on his horse chuckling to himself at the news of Muirchertach Nár’s death.

‘God’s justice,’ he repeated. ‘God’s punishment for his slaughter of Abbot Ultán.’

‘God had little to do with it,’ Eadulf replied grimly, ‘unless you are claiming to be the hand of God.’

The coldness in his voice caused Brother Drón to pause uncertainly.

‘What do you mean by that?’ he demanded.

‘Muirchertach Nár was murdered, killed with his own hunting spear. The killer, according to the tracker who found him, rode off with his horse. We have found you riding with Muirchertach Nár’s horse.’

Brother Drón stared at him for a moment and then swallowed.

‘I did not kill him,’ he said quietly.

‘You want us to believe this story you tell about finding the horse?’ Eadulf replied sarcastically.

‘It is the truth.’

‘You have blamed Muirchertach Nár for the death of Bishop Ultán. You wanted revenge and now here you are — the king dead and you riding with his horse.’ Eadulf smiled grimly. ‘It seems the facts are unequivocal.’

Gormán’s hand was resting gently on the hilt of his sword.

‘It is obvious, Brother Drón,’ he said. ‘We will return to Cashel and put this matter before the brehons.’

‘I swear by the holy. .’

‘Save your protestations for the brehons,’ Gormán replied sternly. ‘There will be time enough to plead your case.’

Brother Drón looked visibly shaken and Eadulf had a moment of unease. The man was either a very good actor or he was telling the truth. Then Eadulf decided that the circumstances could bear no other interpretation.

‘I’ll ride in front,’ he told Gormán. ‘Brother Drón will follow me and you can bring up the rear to ensure that he does not attempt to flee.’

But Brother Drón was hunched in his saddle, looking shocked. From the arrogant, confident person of a few moments ago, the change was marked.

‘He will not flee,’ Gormán assured Eadulf grimly, hand still on the hilt of his sword.

‘How can this have happened?’ Brehon Ninnid demanded, his face flushed.

They had gathered in Colgú’s private chamber — Colgú, Sechnassach, Brehon Barran, Brehon Baithen, Brehon Ninnid and Fidelma. Most people had now returned from the hunt and the body of Muirchertach Nár had been quietly returned to the fortress under cover of blankets so that no one would recognise the body. It had been taken directly to Brother Conchobhar’s apothecary.

Fidelma regarded the young brehon of Laigin coldly.

‘That is what we have to discover,’ she said.

Brehon Ninnid’s features were formed into a cynical expression. ‘I thought that Brother Eadulf had gone along on the hunt to see that no accident befell Muirchertach Nár?’

Fidelma coloured a little at the jibe. Her eyes Nárrowed slightly.

‘Eadulf went along and was nearly killed when his horse threw him during a wild boar charge. At least he and Gormán were able to apprehend a suspect.’

‘Brother Drón? I do not believe it,’ Brehon Ninnid snapped. ‘A religious of his background could never do such a thing.’

The High King Sechnassach looked worried. ‘If Brother Drón has done this in retaliation for the killing of Ultán for which you were defending Muirchertach Nár, then I foresee dangers ahead.’

The High King’s Chief Brehon, Barrán, explained:

‘First, Ultán was a leading churchman, an emissary of Ard Macha. Blathmac, the king of Ulaidh, in whose kingdom Ard Macha lies, was able to assure me that he could control any protest that Ard Macha might make against the killing of their emissary, providing that he could assure Ségéne, the Comarb of Patrick, that the killer had been caught and punishment pronounced. But now that’ — he glanced at Fidelma — ‘the suspect has himself been slaughtered, things have changed. At the moment, we are told that Brother Drón of Cill Ria is the likely killer of the king of Connacht. Connacht may want retribution from Ard Macha. Before we tell Muirchertach’s heir apparent, Dúnchad Muirisci, we need to give him some assurances. Remember that kings are answerable to their people. It is the people who are powerful in these matters because it is the people who ordain the king. The king does not ordain the people.’

Brehon Ninnid thrust out his chest arrogantly. ‘Then the sooner I speak to Brother Drón the faster this matter will be resolved. I cannot believe a religious would contemplate a revenge killing of Muirchertach Nár.’

‘You can see him whenever you wish,’ Fidelma said.

‘Good. We cannot wait for ever for a solution. Perhaps if we had prosecuted Muirchertach Nár immediately there would not have been any revenge killing.’

Brehon Barran glanced at Fidelma. She was shaking her head in annoyance.

‘You disagree?’

‘It is all too easy,’ she muttered.

The High King sat back and regarded her thoughtfully. ‘I have great respect for you, Fidelma of Cashel. Indeed, I might not be High King if it were not for your ability to solve conundrums. I remember how you solved the riddle of the sacred sword of office. So I owe you much. I am prepared to give you more time to resolve this matter, but why do you say that the obvious path is too easy? Surely, it is a painful path that admits a king has killed an abbot and that a churchman has killed a king in vengeance?’

‘If that is what happened, Sechnassach,’ replied Fidelma softly.

Brehon Ninnid began to say something, but the High King waved him to silence.

‘You have an alternative view?’ he asked.

‘I have no view at this time. If we have learnt anything during the countless centuries that our brehons have devised and developed our law code, it is that truth is more important than law. Are we not taught that truth is the highest power, the ultimate cause of all being? So, therefore, we must discover the truth in order that justice might prevail.’

Brehon Ninnid smiled in a superior fashion. ‘When is the prosecution of the law contradicted by truth?’

‘When a judge chooses expediency in favour of a slow, deliberate investigation,’ Fidelma replied sharply. ‘Do you not recall the old story of the gold cup of Cormac Mac Art?’

‘Pagan fiddlesticks!’ Brehon Ninnid replied in a tone of dismissal.

‘To those who only see the story and fail to realise its symbolism. The story is that Cormac came to possess a gold cup that fell asunder into three sections if three lies were told and would come together again if three truths were told. The act of truth made the cup whole.’

‘What are you saying, Fidelma?’ demanded the High King.

‘I am reminding you of the words of my mentor; of Morann’s advice to the princes of these kingdoms. Let them magnify truth, it will magnify them. Let them strengthen truth, it will strengthen them. Let them preserve truth, it will preserve them. .’

The Chief Brehon Barrán made an impatient gesture with his hand. ‘His words are well known, Fidelma.’

‘Then, in justice, the High King must not rush to judgement, pursuing law and expediency rather than truth.’

Sechnassach sighed deeply. ‘You have made your case. I have said that you will receive more time to hear the evidence, Fidelma. But that time is not unlimited.’

‘Tempus omnia revelat,’ Fidelma reminded him. Time reveals all things.

‘That is so,’ agreed the High King. ‘But for mortals such as we, time is not infinite. Our decisions must be measured in days, not left to eternity. I will speak to Dúnchad Muirisci and also to Blathmac. They are civilised people. But once news of what has happened here is voiced through their kingdoms, they may have difficulty controlling the hotheads who will cry vengeance. Time may not grace us with solutions.’

Fidelma rose and inclined her head towards Sechnassach.

‘I will bear that in mind,’ she said quietly. ‘But I will attempt to present the solution in days and not wait until eternity.’

She found Eadulf waiting with Gormán in the corridor outside her brother’s chamber.

‘Has any word of Muirchertach Nár’s death been leaked?’ she asked Eadulf anxiously.

‘We think not. Only Rónán the tracker and two others who helped cover the body and bring it here know of its identity and they have sworn to keep silence until word is released. But it cannot be long before the news spreads. Someone will notice that Muirchertach is missing.’

Fidelma nodded thoughtfully. ‘First, we must tell Aíbnat. Then we should see Dúnchad Muirisci, for he is now heir assumptive to Muirchertach’s throne.’

‘What about Brother Drón?’

‘What has been done with him?’

‘We handed him over to Caol, who has taken him to one of the chambers and stands guard over him,’. Gormán said quickly. ‘I am told that he is still protesting his innocence. Quite volubly.’

‘We will not keep him waiting longer than we have to,’ Fidelma replied. ‘You may tell Caol that Brehon Ninnid is allowed to see him. Eadulf and I first have to speak with the lady Aíbnat.’

Aíbnat met them at the door of her chamber. She stared with open hostility at Fidelma before glancing at Eadulf with an expression that left him in no doubt what she thought of him.

‘What do you want now? My husband has not returned from the hunt,’ she demanded, her voice brittle.

‘We have some bad news for you, lady,’ Fidelma said softly.

Aíbnat stiffened slightly. ‘Bad news?’

‘It is your husband. He has. . been hurt.’

Aíbnat’s expression was controlled. Then, as Fidelma hesitated, she recognised something in her expression.

‘He is dead?’ she whispered.

Fidelma tried to express sympathy towards this arrogant woman. ‘I am afraid he is,’ was all that she could say.

Aíbnat turned quickly away and stood with her back to them, her shoulders slightly hunched. Fidelma followed her into the room, Eadulf at her side. He closed the door gently and they waited awkwardly for a moment.

‘Who killed him?’ Aíbnat asked after a while, turning back to them.

Eadulf exchanged a glance of surprise with Fidelma.

‘What makes you think that someone killed him, lady,’ he said, ‘and that it was not an accident in the hunt?’

Aíbnat swung her gaze round to Eadulf, her features under perfect control. There was now no hint of moisture in her eyes.

‘I know my husband’s abilities. He was a good horseman. Also, it was obvious from the threat that his life was in danger.’

‘The threat? Danger?’ queried Fidelma in surprise. ‘Has he been threatened?’

‘A raven’s feather was found on the pillow of our bed last night when we returned from the evening meal.’

Fidelma’s eyes widened a little. ‘Did you report this to the guard? I was not told.’

Aíbnat shook her head. ‘Muirchertach dismissed it, thinking it was just a silly gesture from one of Ultán’s followers. That man Drón has been muttering dark curses of vengeance. But we thought we were well protected by your warriors. You have failed us. You failed to protect us, just as you failed to protect Ultán.’

‘You should have reported this,’ Fidelma said, ignoring her anger.

‘Whether we did or not, there can be no excuse for not protecting Muirchertach,’ she snapped.

Eadulf was frowning. ‘What is the relevance of this raven’s feather?’ he asked Fidelma.

‘It is a symbol of death and battles,’ she said quickly. ‘The goddess of death often appears in the form of a raven. Where is the feather now?’

Aíbnat shrugged. ‘My husband had it.’

The woman seemed to be emotionally bearing up quite well, but then Fidelma remembered that she had not seemed particularly close to her husband when she had interviewed them on the previous day.

‘Your husband’s body has been taken to the apothecary of Brother Conchobhar here, lady. It will be washed and prepared, and taken to the chapel where the High King wishes it to receive all honour while you and Muirchertach’s tánaiste decide its fate.’

‘Its fate?’

‘As king of Connacht, it is his right that his remains be taken back to his kingdom in pomp and state.’

Aíbnat nodded slowly. ‘That will be up to Dúnchad to decide. Muirchertach’s father lies in the abbey of Cluain Mic Nois with many other kings of Connacht.’ She paused and added: ‘Has the man who killed Muirchertach been captured?’

‘Man?’ queried Fidelma softly.

Aíbnat’s face was without emotion. ‘I presume whoever killed Muirchertach was a man.’

‘We are investigating.’

‘Well, all you have to do is look among Ultán’s followers. There is only one among them capable of the deed of vengeance. However, I shall have my attendants prepare for my leaving here tomorrow. There is no need for me to remain. Dúnchad Muirisci will doubtless take care of the obsequies and the disposal of Muirchertach’s body.’

Fidelma stared at her thoughtfully for a moment. ‘I am afraid, lady, you will have to remain here until there is a resolution of this matter,’ she said quietly. ‘You will leave only when I say so.’

Aíbnat blinked in surprise at being contradicted. ‘Do you know to whom you speak? You may be sister to the king of Muman but I am wife to the king of Connacht.’

Fidelma smiled coldly. ‘You are now the widow of the king of Connacht who lies murdered and unburied in our chapel. I am the dálaigh given to his defence in the matter of the crimes he was accused of and therefore now the investigator of his murder. You stand before the law equal as all others are in this case.’

Aíbnat’s eyes Nárrowed. ‘I will see Sechnassach, the High King, and tell him of your impertinence.’

‘Excellent. Sechnassach is well acquainted with the law and how things must be governed. In the meantime, should you wish it, a guard will continue at your door. . for your protection. You may also speak to the Chief Brehon Barrán.’

Aíbnat stared at her as if not believing her ears. ‘I will certainly speak to him,’ she snapped. ‘You may send the Abbot Augaire to me. I have need of some religious solace.’

Fidelma did not reply but merely turned and, followed by Eadulf, left the room.

Outside, Eadulf noticed that she was trembling slightly in anger.

In answer to his glance she shrugged. ‘There are few people who have such an effect on me, Eadulf. The woman is so arrogant and cold that I feel I would like to strike her on the cheek.’

Eadulf reached out and squeezed her arm. ‘That is unlike you. However, I have to say that she did not leave a favourable impression on me. In fact, her coldness at the news of her husband’s death was surprising.’

‘I do not think there was much love lost between them,’ Fidelma agreed.

‘She is right about vengeance, though. Brother Drón’s story is so weak that it is laughable. When we came upon him leading Muirchertach’s horse it all fell into place. By the way, why didn’t you tell her that we are holding Drón for the murder?’

‘We have to be certain of everything in this matter, Eadulf.’

‘But it all fits together,’ protested Eadulf. ‘And now we hear that a raven’s feather, the symbol of death, was left on their pillow last night. A threat of vengeance for Ultán’s killing.’

Fidelma regarded him seriously. ‘That is the one thing that doesn’t fit.’

‘Why not?’

‘If anything, it rather precludes Brother Drón from involvement as it is a token of the Old Faith and not the new one. Why would one of the New Faith send a symbol of the goddess of death and battles?’

Eadulf thought for a moment. ‘Old ways die hard. Maybe he put the feather there to mislead whoever took on the investigation — or maybe it was someone else entirely who put it there — someone unconnected with the killing.’

‘Perhaps,’ conceded Fidelma. ‘Does a raven’s feather have the same meaning among the pagan Saxons as it does here?’

Eadulf considered. ‘The women Woden sends to gather the corpses of the slain are accompanied by ravens, so the raven is always a bird of ill-omen.’

‘Then there is no need to explain the symbolism. We’d better have a word with Dúnchad Muirisci now that we have told Aíbnat.’ She halted suddenly with a frown. ‘You mentioned Rónán the tracker. I have known him since I was a little girl here. He is a good huntsman, so we must respect what he has to say. I presume that you have checked all he told you?’

‘We were able to follow the tracks he pointed out quite well for a while before we lost them on the stony ground,’ said Eadulf. ‘Anyway, the fact that we caught Brother Drón with Muirchertach’s horse seemed certain enough to me.’

‘Rónán specifically mentioned to you that the horse ridden by the person who met Muirchertach in the wood, and who appears to be his attacker, had a particular identifying mark,’ Fidelma pointed out patiently.

Eadulf stared at her for a moment and then gave a groan.

‘I meant to check that as soon as we came back to the fortress,’ he said. ‘That would be an argument that Drón could not deny.’

‘Then you’d better check it now,’ Fidelma instructed. ‘We should do that before going to break the news to Dúnchad Muirisci and certainly before we go to question Brother Drón further. I’ll meet you at Brother Conchobhar’s apothecary.’

Eadulf hurried away, rebuking himself for overlooking the point that could so easily have confirmed Brother’s Drón’s guilt. He had recounted everything to Fidelma: the finding of the body, Rónán’s observations on the tracks, and the overtaking of Drón. To her credit, Fidelma had not pointed out the obvious but had diplomatically pushed Eadulf into a realisation of what was needed.

Eadulf crossed the courtyard to the stables and found the gilla scuir, the head stable lad. He asked to examine the horse that Brother Drón had ridden. The man looked curiously at him but nodded assent, taking a lantern and leading the way to the stalls.

‘I want to examine its shoes,’ Eadulf explained. ‘I am not very good with horses. How do I go about it?’

The gilla scuir’s expression became somewhat pitying but he said nothing. Fidelma was an expert horsewoman but the stable lad knew all about Eadulf’s unease with horses.

‘Hold the lantern, then, Brother Eadulf,’ he instructed. ‘Which hoof did you want to see?’

‘Front left.’

The stable lad entered the stall, talking softly to the animal, touching its muzzle so that the beast would recognise him, before bending forward and picking up the foreleg, so that the underside of the hoof could be seen.

‘Come into the stall with the lantern,’ he said. ‘Gently now, and hold it so that you can see what you need. What were you looking for? A loose shoe?’

Eadulf shook his head. He peered at the hoof. There was nothing wrong with the horseshoe, no crack, no uneven quality. His mouth compressed to hide his disappointment while he considered the matter.

‘Let’s look at the others,’ he said, just in case Rónán had been mistaken as to which leg it was.

It took a very short time to ascertain that there were no distinguishing marks on any of the shoes of the animal that Brother Drdn had ridden.

Outside the stall Eadulf stood thinking carefully. The only conclusion he could come to was that Brother Drdn was not the rider who had led Muirchertach’s horse from the scene of the slaying. Did this mean he was not the killer? He came back to the present to find the gilla scuir looking at him expectantly.

‘What were you looking for, Brother Eadulf?’ he asked.

‘I was looking for a horse with a cracked or broken shoe.’

The lad’s features broke into a smile. ‘In that case, brother, you were looking at the wrong beast.’ He pointed to another stall. ‘That one came in this evening with the shoe cracked in two. A bad casting of the metal. It happens sometimes. I’m happy to say it wasn’t cast here. One of those northern smiths did that.’

‘Where was the cracked shoe?’ demanded Eadulf.

‘On the left foreleg. Oh, our smith has replaced it now,’ he called as Eadulf made towards the stall. ‘But there’s no doubt about it. The left foreleg. I helped replace it myself.’

Eadulf turned back eagerly. ‘But whose horse is it?’

The stable lad rubbed his chin. ‘Dúnchad Muirisci is his name. The noble prince from Connacht.’