THE BEDROOM IS strange. Unfamiliar. I don’t know where I am, how I came to be here. I don’t know how I’m going to get home.
I have spent the night here. I was woken by a woman’s voice—at first I thought she was in bed with me, but then realized she was reading the news and I was hearing a radio alarm—and when I opened my eyes found myself here. In this room I do not recognize.
My eyes adjust and I look around in the near-dark. A dressing gown hangs off the back of the closet door—suitable for a woman, but for one much older than I am—and some dark-colored trousers are folded neatly over the back of a chair at the dressing table, but I can make out little else. The alarm clock looks complicated, but I find a button and manage to silence it.
It is then that I hear a juddering intake of breath behind me and realize I am not alone. I turn around. I see an expanse of skin and dark hair, flecked with white. A man. He has his left arm outside the covers and there is a gold band on the third finger of the hand. I suppress a groan. So this one is not only old and gray, I think, but also married. Not only have I screwed a married man, but I have done so in what I am guessing is his home, in the bed he must usually share with his wife. I lie back to gather myself. I ought to be ashamed.
I wonder where the wife is. Do I need to worry about her arriving back at any moment? I imagine her standing at the other side of the room, screaming, calling me a slut. A medusa. A mass of snakes. I wonder how I will defend myself, if she does appear. The guy in the bed does not seem concerned, though. He has turned over and snores on.
I lie as still as possible. Usually I can remember how I get into situations like this, but not today. There must have been a party, or a trip to a bar or a club. I must have been pretty wasted. Wasted enough that I don’t remember anything at all. Wasted enough to have gone home with a man with a wedding ring and hairs on his back.
I fold back the covers as gently as I can and sit on the edge of the bed. First, I need to use the bathroom. I ignore the slippers at my feet—after all, fucking the husband is one thing, but I could never wear another woman’s shoes—and creep barefoot onto the landing. I am aware of my nakedness, fearful of choosing the wrong door, of stumbling in on a lodger, a teenage son. Relieved, I see the bathroom door is ajar and go in, locking it behind me.
I sit, use the toilet, then flush it and turn to wash my hands. I reach for the soap, but something is wrong. At first I can’t work out what it is, but then I see it. The hand gripping the soap does not look like mine. Its skin is wrinkled, the nails are unpolished and bitten to the quick and, like that of the man in the bed I have just left, the third finger wears a plain gold wedding ring.
I stare for a moment, then wriggle my fingers. The fingers of the hand holding the soap move also. I gasp, and the soap thuds into the sink. I look up at the mirror.
The face I see looking back at me is not my own. The hair has no volume and is cut much shorter than I wear it; the skin on the cheeks and under the chin sags; the lips are thin; the mouth turned down. I cry out, a wordless gasp that would turn into a shriek of shock were I to let it, and then notice the eyes. The skin around them is lined, yes, but despite everything else, I can see that they are mine. The person in the mirror is me, but I am twenty years too old. Twenty-five. More.
This isn’t possible. I begin to shake and grip the edge of the sink. Another scream begins to rise in my chest and this one erupts as a strangled gasp. I step back, away from the mirror, and it is then that I see them. Photographs. Taped to the wall, to the mirror itself. Pictures, interspersed with yellow pieces of gummed paper, felt-tipped notes, damp and curling.
I choose one at random. Christine, it says, and an arrow points to a photograph of me—this new me, this old me—in which I am sitting on a bench on the side of a quay, next to a man. The name seems familiar, but only distantly so, as if I am having to make an effort to believe that it is mine. In the photograph we are both smiling at the camera, holding hands. He is handsome, attractive, and when I look closely, I can see that it is the same man I slept with, the one I left in the bed. The word Ben is written beneath it, and next to it, Your husband.
I gasp, and rip it off the wall. No, I think. No! It cannot be… I scan the rest of the pictures. They are all of me, and him. In one I am wearing an ugly dress and unwrapping a present, in another both of us wear matching weatherproof jackets and stand in front of a waterfall as a small dog sniffs at our feet. Next to it is a picture of me sitting beside him, sipping a glass of orange juice, wearing the dressing gown I have seen in the bedroom next door.
I step back farther, until I feel cold tiles against my back. It is then I get the glimmer that I associate with memory. As my mind tries to settle on it, it flutters away, like ashes caught in a breeze, and I realize that in my life there is a then, a before, though before what I cannot say, and there is a now, and there is nothing between the two but a long, silent emptiness that has led me here, to me and him, in this house.
I GO BACK into the bedroom. I still have the picture in my hand—the one of me and the man I had woken up with—and I hold it in front of me.
“What’s going on?” I say. I am screaming; tears run down my face. The man is sitting up in bed, his eyes half-closed. “Who are you?”
“I’m your husband,” he says. His face is sleepy, without a trace of annoyance. He does not look at my naked body. “We’ve been married for years.”
“What do you mean?” I say. I want to run, but there is nowhere to go. “ ‘Married for years’? What do you mean?”
He stands up. “Here,” he says, and passes me the dressing gown, waiting while I put it on. He is wearing pajama trousers that are too big for him, a white T-shirt. He reminds me of my father.
“We got married in 1985,” he says. “Twenty-two years ago. You—”
“What—?” I feel the blood drain from my face, the room begin to spin. A clock ticks somewhere in the house, and it sounds as loud as a hammer. “But—?” He takes a step toward me. “How—?”
“Christine, you’re forty-seven now,” he says. I look at him, this stranger who is smiling at me. I don’t want to believe him, don’t want to even hear what he is saying, but he carries on. “You had an accident,” he says. “A bad accident. You suffered head injuries. You have problems remembering things.”
“What things?” I say, meaning, surely not the last twenty-five years? “What things?”
He steps toward me again, approaching me as if I am a frightened animal. “Everything,” he says. “Sometimes starting from your early twenties. Sometimes even earlier than that.”
My mind spins, whirring with dates and ages. I don’t want to ask, but know that I must. “When… when was my accident?”
He looks at me, and his face is a mixture of compassion and fear.
“When you were twenty-nine…”
I close my eyes. Even as my mind tries to reject this information, I know, somewhere, that it is true. I hear myself start to cry again, and as I do so this man, this Ben, comes over to where I stand in the doorway. I feel his presence next to me, do not move as he puts his arms around my waist, do not resist as he pulls me into him. He holds me. Together we rock gently, and I realize the motion feels familiar somehow. It makes me feel better.
“I love you, Christine,” he says, and though I know I am supposed to say that I love him too, I don’t. I say nothing. How can I love him? He is a stranger. Nothing makes sense. I want to know so many things. How I got here, how I manage to survive. But I don’t know how to ask.
“I’m scared,” I say.
“I know,” he replies. “I know. But don’t worry, Chris. I’ll look after you. I’ll always look after you. You’ll be fine. Trust me.”
HE SAYS HE will show me around the house. I feel calmer. I have put on a pair of panties and an old T-shirt that he gave me, then put the robe over my shoulders. We go out onto the landing. “You’ve seen the bathroom,” he says, opening the door next to it. “This is the office.”
There is a glass desk with what I guess must be a computer, though it looks ridiculously small, almost like a toy. Next to it is a filing cabinet in gunmetal gray, above it a wall planner. All is neat, orderly. “I work in there, now and then,” he says, closing the door. We cross the landing and he opens another door. A bed, a dressing table, more closets. It looks almost identical to the room in which I woke. “Sometimes you sleep in here,” he says, “when you feel like it. But usually you don’t like waking up alone. You get panicked when you can’t work out where you are.” I nod. I feel like a prospective tenant being shown around a new flat. A possible housemate. “Let’s go downstairs.”
I follow him down. He shows me a living room—a brown sofa and matching chairs, a flat screen bolted to the wall, which he tells me is a television—and a dining room and kitchen. None of it is familiar. I feel nothing at all, not even when, sitting on a sideboard, I see a framed photograph of the two of us. “There’s a garden out the back,” he says, and I look through the glass door that leads off the kitchen. It is just beginning to get light, the night sky starting to turn an inky blue, and I can make out the silhouette of a large tree, and a shed sitting at the far end of the small garden, but little else. I realize I don’t even know what part of the world we are in.
“Where are we?” I say.
He stands behind me. I can see us both, reflected in the glass. Me. My husband. Middle-aged.
“North London,” he replies. “Crouch End.”
I step back. Panic begins to rise. “Jesus,” I say. “I don’t even know where I bloody live…”
He takes my hand. “Don’t worry. You’ll be fine.” I turn around to face him, to wait for him to tell me how, how I will be fine, but he does not. “Shall I make you your coffee?”
For a moment I resent him, but then say, “Yes. Yes please.” He fills a kettle. “Black, please,” I say. “No sugar.”
“I know,” he says, smiling at me. “Want some toast?”
I say yes. He must know so much about me, yet still this feels like the morning after a one-night stand: breakfast with a stranger in his house, plotting how soon it would be acceptable to make an escape, to go back home.
But that’s the difference. Apparently this is my home.
“I think I need to sit down,” I say. He looks up at me.
“Go and sit yourself down in the living room,” he says. “I’ll bring this in a minute.”
I leave the kitchen.
A few moments later, Ben follows me in. He gives me a book. “This is a scrapbook,” he says. “It might help.” I take it from him. It is bound in plastic that is supposed to look like worn leather but does not, and has a red ribbon tied around it in an untidy bow. “I’ll be back in a minute,” he says, and leaves the room.
I sit on the sofa. The scrapbook weighs heavy in my lap. To look at it feels like snooping. I remind myself that whatever is in there is about me, was given to me by my husband.
I untie the bow and open it at random. A picture of me and Ben, looking much younger.
I slam it closed. I run my hands around the binding, fan the pages. I must have to do this every day.
I cannot imagine it. I am certain there has been a terrible mistake, yet there cannot have been. The evidence is there—in the mirror upstairs, in the creases on the hands that caress the book in front of me. I am not the person I thought I was when I woke this morning.
But who was that? I think. When was I that person, who woke in a stranger’s bed and thought only of escape? I close my eyes. I feel as though I am floating. Untethered. In danger of being lost.
I need to anchor myself. I close my eyes and try to focus on something, anything, solid. I find nothing. So many years of my life, I think. Missing.
This book will tell me who I am, but I don’t want to open it. Not yet. I want to sit here for a while, with the whole past a blank. In limbo, balanced between possibility and fact. I am frightened to discover my past. What I have achieved, and what I have not.
Ben comes back in and sets a tray in front of me. Toast, two cups of coffee, a jug of milk. “You okay?” he says. I nod.
He sits beside me. He has shaved, dressed in trousers and a shirt and tie. He does not look like my father anymore. Now he looks as though he works in a bank, or an office. Not bad, though, I think, then push the thought from my mind.
“Is every day like this?” I say. He puts a piece of toast on a plate, smears butter on it.
“Pretty much,” he says. “You want some?” I shake my head and he takes a bite. “You seem to be able to retain information while you’re awake,” he says. “But then, when you sleep, most of it goes. Is your coffee okay?”
I tell him it’s fine, and he takes the book from my hands. “This is a sort of scrapbook,” he says, opening it. “We had a fire a few years ago so we lost a lot of the old photos and things, but there are still a few bits and pieces in here.” He points to the first page. “This is your degree certificate,” he says. “And here’s a photo of you on your graduation day.” I look at where he points; I am smiling, squinting into the sun, wearing a black gown and a felt hat with a gold tassel. Just behind me stands a man in a suit and tie, his head turned away from the camera.
“That’s you?” I say.
He smiles. “No. I didn’t graduate at the same time as you. I was still studying then. Chemistry.”
I look up at him. “When did we get married?” I say.
He turns to face me, taking my hand between his. I am surprised by the roughness of his skin, used, I suppose, to the softness of youth. “The year after you got your PhD. We’d been dating for a few years, then, but you—we—we both wanted to wait until your studies were out of the way.”
That makes sense, I think, though it feels oddly practical of me. I wonder if I had been keen to marry him at all.
As if reading my mind, he says, “We were very much in love,” and then adds, “we still are.”
I can think of nothing to say. I smile. He takes a swig of his coffee before looking back at the book in his lap. He turns over some more pages.
“You studied English,” he says. “Then you did a few jobs, once you’d graduated. Just odd things. Secretarial work. Sales. I’m not sure you really knew what you wanted to do. I left with a bachelor’s and did teacher training. It was a struggle, for a few years, but then I was promoted and well, we ended up here.”
I look around the living room. It is smart, comfortable. Blandly middle-class. A framed picture of a woodland scene sits on the wall above the fireplace, china figurines next to the clock on the mantelpiece. I wonder if I helped to choose the decor.
Ben goes on. “I teach in a high school nearby. I’m head of department, now.” He says it with no hint of pride.
“And me?” I say, though, really, I know the only possible answer. He squeezes my hand.
“You had to give up work. After your accident. You don’t do anything.” He must sense my disappointment. “You don’t need to. I earn a good enough wage. We get by. We’re okay.”
I close my eyes, put my hand to my forehead. This all feels too much, and I want him to shut up. I feel as if there is only so much I can process, and if he carries on adding more then eventually I will explode.
Then what do I do all day? I want to say but, fearing the answer, I say nothing.
He finishes his toast and takes the tray out to the kitchen. When he comes back in, he is wearing an overcoat.
“I have to leave for work,” he says. I feel myself tense.
“Don’t worry,” he says. “You’ll be fine. I’ll call you. I promise. Don’t forget today is no different from every other day. You’ll be fine.”
“But—” I begin.
“I have to go,” he says. “I’m sorry. I’ll show you some things you might need, before I leave.”
In the kitchen he shows me which things are in which cabinet, points out some leftovers in the fridge that I can have for lunch, and an eraser board screwed to the wall next to a black marker pen tied to a piece of string. “I sometimes leave messages here for you,” he says. I see that he has written FRIDAY on it in neat, even capitals, and beneath it the words laundry? walk? (take phone!) tv? Under the word lunch, he has noted that there is some leftover salmon in the fridge and added, salad? Finally, he has written that he should be home by six. “You also have a diary,” he says. “In your bag. It has important phone numbers in the back of it, and our address, in case you get lost. And there’s a cell phone—”
“A what?” I say.
“A phone,” he says. “It’s cordless. You can use it anywhere. Outside the house, anywhere. It’ll be in your handbag. Make sure you take it with you if you go out.”
“I will,” I say.
“Right,” he says. We go into the hall and he picks up a battered leather briefcase by the door. “I’ll be off, then.”
“Okay,” I say. I am not sure what else to say. I feel like a child kept out of school, left alone at home while her parents go to work. Don’t touch anything, I imagine him saying. Don’t forget to take your medicine.
He comes over to where I stand. He kisses me, on the cheek. I do not stop him, but neither do I kiss him back. He turns toward the front door, and is about to open it when he stops.
“Oh!” he says, looking back at me. “I almost forgot!” His voice sounds suddenly forced, the enthusiasm affected. He is trying too hard to make it seem natural; it is obvious he has been building up to what he is about to say for some time.
In the end it is not as bad as I feared. “We’re going away this evening,” he says. “Just for the weekend. It’s our anniversary, so I thought I’d book something. Is that okay?”
I nod. “That sounds nice,” I say.
He smiles, looks relieved. “Something to look forward to, eh? A bit of sea air? It’ll do us good.” He turns back to the door and opens it. “I’ll call you later,” he says. “See how you’re getting on?”
“Yes,” I say. “Do. Please.”
“I love you, Christine,” he says. “Never forget that.”
He closes the door behind him, and I turn. I go back into the house.
LATER, MID-MORNING. I sit in an armchair. The dishes are done and neatly stacked on the drainer, the laundry is in the machine. I have been keeping myself busy.
But now I feel empty. It’s true, what Ben said. I have no memory. Nothing. There is not a thing in this house that I remember seeing before. Not a single photograph—either around the mirror or in the scrapbook in front of me—that triggers a recollection of when it was taken, not a moment with Ben that I can recall, other than those since we met this morning. My mind feels totally empty.
I close my eyes, try to focus on something. Anything. Yesterday. Last Christmas. Any Christmas. My wedding. There is nothing.
I stand up. I move through the house, from room to room. Slowly. Drifting, like a wraith, letting my hand brush against the walls, the tables, the backs of the furniture, but not really touching any of it. How did I end up like this? I think. I look at the carpets, the patterned rugs, the china figurines on the mantelpiece and ornamental plates arranged on the display racks in the dining room. I try to tell myself that this is mine. All mine. My home, my husband, my life. But these things do not belong to me. They are not part of me. In the bedroom I open the closet door and see a row of clothes I do not recognize, hanging neatly, like empty versions of a woman I have never met. A woman whose home I am wandering through, whose soap and shampoo I have used, whose dressing gown I have discarded and slippers I am wearing. She is hidden to me, a ghostly presence, aloof and untouchable. This morning I had selected my underwear guiltily, searching through the pairs of panties, balled together with tights and stockings, as if I was afraid of being caught. I held my breath as I found panties in silk and lace at the back of the drawer, items bought to be seen as well as worn. Rearranging the unused ones exactly as I had found them, I chose a pale blue pair that seemed to have a matching bra and slipped them both on, before pulling a heavy pair of tights over the top, and then trousers and a blouse and finally a sweater.
I had sat down at the dressing table to examine my face in the mirror, approaching my reflection cautiously. I traced the lines on my forehead, the folds of skin under my eyes. I smiled and looked at my teeth, and at the wrinkles that bunched around the edge of my mouth, the crow’s feet that appeared. I noticed the blotches on my skin, a discoloration on my forehead that looked like a bruise that had not quite faded. I found some makeup, and put a little on. A light powder, a touch of blush. I pictured a woman—my mother, I realize now—doing the same, calling it her war paint, and this morning, as I blotted my lipstick on a tissue and recapped the mascara, the word felt appropriate. I felt that I was going into some kind of battle, or that some battle was coming to me.
Sending me off to school. Putting on her makeup. I tried to think of my mother doing something else. Anything. Nothing came. I saw only a void, vast gaps between tiny islands of memory, years of emptiness.
Now, in the kitchen, I open cabinets: packages of pasta, packets of a rice labeled ARBORIO, cans of kidney beans. I do not recognize this food. I remember eating cheese on toast, macaroni and cheese, corned beef sandwiches. I pull out a can labeled CHICKPEAS, a packet of something called couscous. I do not know what these things are, less how to cook them. How, then, do I survive as a wife?
I look up at the eraser board that Ben had shown me before he left. It is a dirty gray color; words have been scrawled on it and wiped out, replaced, amended, each leaving a faint residue. I wonder what I would find if I could go back and decipher the layers, if it were possible to delve into my past that way, but realize that, even if it were possible, it would be futile. I am certain that all I would find are messages and lists, groceries to buy, tasks to perform.
Is this really my life? I think. Is this all I am? I take the pen and add another note to the board. Pack bag for tonight? it says. Not much of a reminder, but my own.
I hear a noise. A tune, coming from my bag. I open it and empty its contents onto the sofa. My purse, some tissues, pens, a lipstick. A powder compact, a receipt for two coffees. A diary, just a couple of inches square and with a floral design on the front and a pencil in its spine.
I find something that I guess must be the phone that Ben described—it is small, plastic, with a keypad that makes it look like a toy. It is ringing, the screen flashing. I press what I hope is the right button.
“Hello?” I say. The voice that replies is not Ben’s.
“Hi,” it says. “Christine? Is that Christine Lucas?”
I do not want to answer. My last name seems as strange as my first name had. I feel as though any solid ground I had attained has vanished again, replaced by quicksand.
“Christine? Are you there?”
Who can it be? Who knows where I am, who I am? I realize it could be anyone. I feel panic rise in me. My finger hovers over the button that will end the call.
“Christine? It’s me. Dr. Nash. Please answer.”
The name means nothing to me, but still I say, “Who is this?”
The voice takes on a new tone. Relief? “It’s Dr. Nash,” he says. “Your doctor?”
Another flash of panic. “My doctor?” I say. I’m not ill, I want to add, but I do not know even this. I feel my mind begin to spin.
“Yes,” he says. “But don’t worry. We’ve just been doing some work on your memory. Nothing’s wrong.”
I notice the tense he has used. Have been. So this is someone else I have no memory of.
“What kind of work?” I say.
“I’ve been trying to help you to improve things,” he says. “Trying to work out exactly what’s caused your memory problems, and whether there’s anything we can do about them.”
It makes sense, though another thought comes to me. Why had Ben not mentioned this doctor before he left this morning?
“How?” I say. “What have we been doing?”
“We’ve been meeting over the last few weeks. A couple of times a week, give or take.”
It does not seem possible. Another person I see regularly who has left no impression on me whatsoever.
But I’ve never met you before, I want to say. You could be anyone.
I say nothing. The same could be said of the man I woke up with this morning, and he turned out to be my husband.
“I don’t remember,” I say instead.
His voice softens. “Don’t worry. I know.” If what he says is true then he must understand that as well as anyone. He explains that our next appointment is today.
“Today?” I say. I think back to what Ben told me this morning, to the list of jobs written on the board in the kitchen. “But my husband hasn’t mentioned anything to me.” I realize it is the first time I have referred in this way to the man I woke up with.
There is a pause, and then Dr. Nash says, “I’m not sure Ben knows you’re meeting me.”
I notice that he knows my husband’s name, but say, “That’s ridiculous! How can he not? He would have told me!”
There is a sigh. “You’ll have to trust me,” he says. “I can explain everything, when we meet. We’re really making progress.”
When we meet. How can we do that? The thought of going out, without Ben, without him even knowing where I am or who I am with, terrifies me.
“I’m sorry,” I say. “I can’t.”
“Christine,” he says. “It’s important. If you look in your diary you’ll see what I’m saying is true. Do you have it? It should be in your bag.”
I pick up the floral book from where it had fallen onto the sofa and register the shock of seeing the year printed on the front in gold lettering. 2007. Twenty years later than it should be.
“Yes.”
“Look at today’s date,” he says. “November thirtieth. You should see our appointment?”
I don’t understand how it can be November—December tomorrow—but still I skim through the leaves, thin as tissue, to today’s date. There, tucked between the pages, is a piece of paper, and on it, printed in handwriting I don’t recognize, are the words November 30th—seeing Dr. Nash. Beneath them, are the words Don’t tell Ben. I wonder if he has read them, whether he looks through my things.
I decide there is no reason he would. The other days are blank. No birthdays, no nights out, no parties. Does this really describe my life?
“Okay,” I say. He explains that he will come and pick me up, that he knows where I live and will be there in an hour.
“But my husband—” I say.
“It’s okay. We’ll be back long before he gets in from work. I promise. Trust me.”
The clock on the mantelpiece chimes and I glance at it. It is old-fashioned, a large dial in a wooden case, edged with roman numerals. It reads eleven thirty. Next to it sits a silver key for winding it, something that I suppose Ben must remember to do every evening. It looks old enough to be an antique, and I wonder how we came to own such a clock. Perhaps it has no history, or none with us at least, but is simply something we saw once, in a shop or at a market, and one of us liked it. Probably Ben, I think. I realize I don’t like it.
I’ll see him just this once, I decide. And then, tonight, when he gets home, I will tell Ben. I cannot believe I am keeping something like this from him. Not when I rely so utterly on him.
But there is an odd familiarity to Dr. Nash’s voice. Unlike Ben, he does not seem entirely alien to me. I realize I almost find it easier to believe that I have met him before than I do my husband.
We’re making progress, he’d said. I need to know what kind of progress he means.
“Okay,” I say. “Come.”
WHEN HE ARRIVES, Dr. Nash suggests we go for a cup of coffee. “Are you thirsty?” he says. “I don’t think there’s much point in driving all the way to the office. I mostly wanted to talk to you today, anyway.”
I nod and say yes. I was in the bedroom when he arrived, and watched him park his car and lock it, saw him rearrange his hair, smooth his jacket, pick up his briefcase. Not him, I thought as he nodded to the workmen who were unloading tools from a van, but then he walked up the path to our house. He looked young——too young to be a doctor——and, though I don’t know what I had been expecting him to be wearing, it was not the sports jacket and gray corduroy trousers that he had on.
“There’s a park at the end of the street,” he says. “I think it has a café. We could go there?”
We walk together. The cold is biting and I pull my scarf tight around my neck. I am glad I have in my bag the cell phone that Ben has given me. Glad, too, that Dr. Nash has not insisted we drive somewhere. There is some part of me that trusts this man, but another, larger part tells me he could be anyone. A stranger.
I am an adult, but a damaged one. It would be easy for this man to take me somewhere, though I don’t know what he would want to do. I am as vulnerable as a child.
We reach the main road that separates the end of the street from the park opposite, and wait to cross. The silence between us feels oppressive. I had intended to wait until we were sitting down before asking him, but find myself speaking. “What sort of doctor are you?” I am saying. “What do you do? How did you find me?”
He looks over at me. “I’m a neuropsychologist,” he says. He is smiling. I wonder if I ask him the same question every time we meet. “I specialize in patients with brain disorders, with an interest in some of the newer functional neuroimaging techniques. For a long time I’ve been particularly interested in researching memory process and function. I heard about you through the literature on the subject, and tracked you down. It wasn’t too difficult.”
A car rounds the bend farther up the road and heads toward us. “The literature?”
“Yes. There have been a couple of case studies written about you. I got in touch with the place where you were being treated before you came to live at home.”
“Why? Why did you want to find me?”
He smiles. “Because I thought I could help you. I’ve been working with patients with these sorts of problems for a little while. I believe they can be helped; however, they require more intensive input than the usual one hour per week. I had a few ideas about how real improvements could be effected and wanted to try some of them out.” He pauses. “Plus I’ve been writing a paper on your case. The definitive work, you might say.” He begins to laugh, but cuts it short when I do not join in. He clears his throat. “Your case is unusual. I believe we can discover a lot more about the way memory works than we already know.”
The car passes and we cross the road. I feel myself get anxious, uptight. Brain disorders. Researching. Tracked you down. I try to breathe, to relax, but find I cannot. There are two of me, now, in the same body; one is a forty-seven-year-old woman, calm, polite, aware of what kind of behavior is appropriate and what is not, and the other is in her twenties, and screaming. I cannot decide which is me, but the only noise I hear is that of distant traffic and the shouts of children from the park, and so I guess it must be the first.
On the other side, I stop and say, “Look, what’s going on? I woke up this morning in a place I’ve never seen but that’s apparently my home, lying next to a man I’ve never met who tells me I’ve been married to him for years. And you seem to know more about me than I know about myself.”
He nods slowly. “You have amnesia,” he says, putting his hand on my arm. “You’ve had amnesia for a long time. You can’t retain new memories, so you’ve forgotten much of what’s happened to you for your entire adult life. Every day you wake up as if you are a young woman. Some days you wake as if you are a child.”
Somehow it seems worse, coming from him. A doctor. “So it’s true?”
“I’m afraid so. Yes. The man at home is your husband. Ben. You’ve been married to him for years. Since long before your amnesia began.” I nod. “Shall we go on?”
I say yes, and we walk into the park. A path circles its edge, and there is a children’s playground nearby, next to a hut from which I see people emerge carrying trays of snacks. We head there, and I take a seat at one of the chipped Formica tables while Dr. Nash orders our drinks.
When he returns, he is carrying two plastic cups filled with strong coffee, mine black, his white. He adds sugar from the bowl on the table but offers none to me, and it is that, more than anything, that convinces me we have met before. He looks up and asks me how I hurt my forehead.
“What—?” I say at first, but then I remember the bruise I saw this morning. My makeup has clearly not covered it. “That?” I say. “I’m not sure. It’s nothing, really. It doesn’t hurt.”
He does not answer. He stirs his coffee.
“So my husband looks after me at home?” I say.
He looks up. “Yes, though he hasn’t always. At first your condition was so severe that you required round-the-clock care. It has only been fairly recently that Ben felt he could look after you alone.”
So the way I feel at the moment is an improvement, then. I am glad I cannot remember the time when things were worse.
“He must love me very much,” I say, more to myself than to Nash.
He nods. There is a pause. We both sip our drinks. “Yes. I think he must.”
I smile and look down, at my hands holding the hot drink, at the gold wedding band, at the short nails, at my legs, crossed politely. l do not recognize my own body.
“Why doesn’t my husband know that I’m seeing you?” I say.
He sighs and closes his eyes. “I’ll be honest,” he says, clasping his hands together and leaning forward in his seat. “Initially I asked you not to tell Ben that you were seeing me.”
A jolt of fear goes through me, almost an echo. Yet he does not look untrustworthy.
“Go on,” I say. I want to believe he can help me.
“Several people—doctors, psychiatrists, psychologists, and so on—have approached you and Ben in the past, wanting to work with you. But he has always been extremely reluctant to let you see these professionals. He has made it very clear that you have had extensive treatment before, and in his opinion it has achieved nothing other than to upset you. Naturally he wanted to spare you—and himself—from any more upset.”
Of course; he doesn’t want to raise my hopes. “So you persuaded me to come and see you without him knowing?”
“Yes. I did approach Ben first. We spoke on the phone. I even asked him to meet with me so that I could explain what I had to offer, but he refused. So I contacted you directly.”
Another jolt of fear, as if from nowhere. “How?” I say.
He looked down at his drink. “I came to see you. I waited until you came out of the house and then introduced myself.”
“And I agreed to see you? Just like that?”
“Not at first. No. I had to persuade you that you could trust me. I suggested that we should meet once, just for one session. Without Ben’s knowledge if that was what it took. I said I would explain to you why I wanted you to come and see me, and what I thought I could offer you.”
“And I agreed…”
He looks up. “Yes,” he says. “I told you that after that first visit it was entirely up to you whether you chose to tell Ben or not, but if you decided not to I would call you to make sure you remembered our appointments, and so on.”
“And I chose not to.”
“Yes. That’s right. You’ve spoken about wanting to wait until we were making progress before telling him. You felt that was better.”
“And are we?”
“What?”
“Making progress?”
He swallows some more coffee, then puts his cup back on the table. “I believe so, yes. Though progress is somewhat difficult to quantify exactly. But lots of memories seem to have come back to you over the last few weeks—many of them for the first time, as far as we know. And there are certain truths that you are aware of more often, where there were few before. For example, you occasionally wake up and remember that you’re married, now. And—”
He pauses. “And?” I say.
“And, well, you’re gaining independence, I think.”
“Independence?”
“Yes. You don’t rely on Ben as much as you did. Or me.”
That’s it, I think. That is the progress he is talking about. Independence. Perhaps he means I can make it to the shops or a library without a chaperone, though right now I am not even sure that much is true. In any case, I have not yet made enough progress for me to wave it proudly in front of my husband. Not even enough for me to always wake up remembering I have one.
“But that’s it?”
“It’s important,” he says. “Don’t underestimate it, Christine.”
I don’t say anything. I take a sip of my drink and look around the café. It is almost empty. There are voices from a small kitchen at the back, the occasional rattle as the water in an urn reaches boiling point, the noise of children playing in the distance. It is difficult to believe that this place is so close to my home and yet I have no memory of ever being here before.
“You say we’ve been meeting for a few weeks,” I say to Dr. Nash. “So what have we been doing?”
“Do you remember anything of our previous sessions? Anything at all?”
“No,” I say. “Nothing. As far as I know I am meeting you for the first time today.”
“Forgive me asking,” he says. “As I said, you have flashes of memory, sometimes. It seems you know more on some days than on others.”
“I don’t understand,” I say. “I have no memory of ever meeting you before, or of what happened yesterday, or the day before, or last year for that matter. Yet I can remember some things from years ago. My childhood. My mother. I remember being at university, just. I don’t understand how these old memories could have survived when everything else has been wiped clean.”
He nods throughout my question. I don’t doubt he has heard it before. Possibly I ask the same thing every week. Possibly we have exactly the same conversation.
“Memory is a complex thing,” he says. “Human beings have a short-term memory that can store facts and information for about a minute or so, but also a long-term memory. Here we can store huge quantities of information, and retain it for a seemingly indefinite length of time. We now know that these two functions seem to be controlled by different parts of the brain, with some neural connections between them. There is also a part of the brain that seems to be responsible for taking short-term, transient memories and coding them as long-term memories for recall much later.”
He speaks easily, quickly, as if he is now on solid territory. I would have been like that once, I suppose; sure of myself.
“There are two main types of amnesia,” he says. “Most commonly the affected person cannot recall past events, with more recent events being most severely affected. So if, for example, the sufferer has a motor accident, they may not remember the accident, or the days or weeks preceding it, but can remember everything up to, say, six months before the accident perfectly well.”
I nod. “And the other?”
“The other is rarer,” he says. “Sometimes there is an inability to transfer memories from short-term storage into long-term storage. People with this condition live in the moment, able to recall only the immediate past, and then only for a small amount of time.”
He stops talking, as if waiting for me to say something. It is as if we each have our lines, have rehearsed this conversation often.
“I have both?” I say. “A loss of the memories I had, plus an inability to form new ones?”
He clears his throat. “Yes, unfortunately. It’s not common, but perfectly possible. What’s unusual in your case, however, is the pattern of your amnesia. Generally you have no consistent memory of anything that happened since your early childhood, but you seem to process new memories in a way I have never come across before. If I left this room now and returned in two minutes, most people with anterograde amnesia would not remember having met me at all, certainly not today. But you seem to remember whole chunks of time—up to twenty-four hours—which you then lose. That’s not typical. To be honest, it doesn’t make any sense, considering the way we believe that memory works. It suggests you are able to transfer things from short-term to long-term storage perfectly well. I don’t understand why you can’t retain them.”
I may be leading a shattered life, but at least it is shattered into pieces large enough for me to maintain a semblance of independence. I guess that means I am lucky.
“Why?” I say. “What has caused it?”
He does not say anything. The room goes quiet. The air feels still and sticky. When he speaks, his words seem to echo off the walls. “Many things can cause an impairment of memory,” he says. “Either long-term or short-term. Disease, trauma, drug use. The exact nature of the impairment seems to differ, depending on the part of the brain that has been affected.”
“Yes,” I say. “But what has caused mine?”
He looks at me for a moment. “What has Ben told you?”
I think back to our conversation in the bedroom. An accident, he had said. A bad accident.
“He didn’t really tell me anything,” I say. “Nothing specific, anyway. He just said I’d had an accident.”
“Yes,” he says, reaching for his bag that sits under the table. “Your amnesia was caused by trauma. That’s true, at least partly.” He opens his bag and takes out a book. At first, I wonder if he is going to consult his notes, but instead he passes it across the table to me. “Look. I want you to have this,” he says. “It will explain everything. Better than I can. About what has caused your condition, especially. But other things as well.”
I take it from him. It is brown, bound in leather. I open it at random. The paper is heavy and faintly lined, with a red margin, and the pages are filled with dense handwriting. “What is it?” I say.
“It’s a journal,” he says. “One that you’ve been keeping over the past few weeks.”
I am shocked. “A journal?” I wonder why he has it.
“Yes. A record of what we’ve been doing recently. I asked you to keep it. We’ve been doing a lot of work trying to find out exactly how your memory behaves. I thought it might be helpful for you to keep a record of what we’ve been doing.”
I look at the book in front of me. “So I’ve written this?”
“Yes. I told you to write whatever you like in it. Many amnesiacs have tried a similar approach, but usually it’s not as helpful as you might think, as they have such a short window of memory. But as there are some things that you can remember for the whole day, I didn’t see why you shouldn’t jot down some notes in a book every evening. I thought it might help you to maintain a thread of memory from one day to the next. Plus I felt that memory might be like a muscle, something that can be strengthened through exercise.”
“And you’ve been reading it, as we’ve been going along?”
“No,” he says. “You’ve been writing it in private.”
“But how—?” I begin, and then say, “Ben’s been reminding me to write in it?”
He shakes his head. “I suggested that you keep it secret,” he says. “You’ve been hiding it, at home. I’ve been calling you to tell you where it is hidden.”
“Every day?”
“Yes. More or less.”
“Not Ben?”
He pauses, then says, “No. Ben hasn’t read it.”
I wonder why not, what it might contain that I do not want my husband to see. What secrets might I have? Secrets I do not even know myself.
“But you’ve read it?”
“You left it with me a few days ago,” he says. “You said you wanted me to read it. That it was time.”
I look at the book. I am excited. A journal. A link back to a lost past, albeit only recent.
“Have you read it all?”
“Yes,” he says. “Most of it. I think I’ve read everything important, anyway.” He pauses, and looks away from me, scratching the back of his neck. Embarrassed, I think. I wonder if he is telling me the truth, what the book contains. He drains the last of his cup of coffee, and says, “I didn’t force you to let me see it. I want you to know that.”
I nod, and finish the rest of my drink in silence, flicking through the pages of the book as I do. On the inside of the front cover is a list of dates. “What are these?” I say.
“They’re the dates we’ve been meeting,” he says. “As well as the ones we had planned. We’ve been arranging them as we go along. I’ve been calling to remind you, asking you to look in your journal.”
I think of the yellow note tucked between the pages of my diary today. “But today?”
“Today I had your journal,” he says. “So we wrote a note instead.”
I nod and look through the rest of the book. It is filled with a dense handwriting that I don’t recognize. Page after page. Days and days’ worth of work.
I wonder how I found the time, but then think of the board in the kitchen, and the answer is obvious: I have had nothing else to do.
I put it back on the table. A young man wearing jeans and a T-shirt comes in and glances over to where we sit, before ordering a drink and settling at a table with the newspaper. He does not look up at me again, and the twenty-year-old me is upset. I feel as though I am invisible.
“Shall we go?” I say.
We walk back the way we had come. The sky has clouded over, and a thin mist hangs in the air. The ground is soggy underfoot; it feels like walking on quicksand. On the playground, I see a merry-go-round, turning slowly even though no one is riding it.
“We don’t normally meet here?” I say, when we reach the road. “In the café, I mean?”
“No. No, we normally meet in my office. We do exercises. Tests and things.”
“So why here today?”
“I really just wanted to give you your book back,” he says. “I was worried about you not having it.”
“I’ve come to rely on it?” I say.
“In a way, yes.”
We cross the road and walk back down to the house I share with Ben. I can see Dr. Nash’s car, still parked where he left it, the tiny garden outside our window, the short path and neat flower beds. I still cannot quite believe this is the place in which I live.
“Do you want to come in?” I say. “Another drink?”
He shakes his head. “No. No, I won’t, thanks. I have to get going. Julie and I have plans this evening.”
He stands for a moment, looking at me. I notice his hair, cut short, neatly parted, and the way his shirt has a vertical stripe that clashes with the horizontal one on his pullover. I realize that he is only a few years older than I thought I was when I woke this morning. “Julie is your wife?”
He smiles and shakes his head. “No, my girlfriend. Actually, my fiancée. We got engaged. I keep forgetting.”
I smile back at him. These are the details I should remember, I suppose. The little things. Perhaps it is these trivialities I have been writing down in my book, these small hooks on which a whole life is hung.
“Congratulations,” I say, and he thanks me.
I feel like I ought to ask more questions, ought to show more interest, but there is little point. Anything he tells me now I will have forgotten by the time I wake tomorrow. Today is all I have. “I ought to get back anyway,” I say. “We’re going away this weekend. To the coast. I need to pack later…”
He smiles. “Good-bye, Christine,” he says. He turns to leave, but then looks back at me. “Your journal has my numbers written in it,” he says. “At the front. Call me, if you’d like to see me again. To carry on with your treatment, I mean. Okay?”
“If?” I say. I remember my journal, the appointments that we had penciled in between now and the end of the year. “I thought we had more sessions booked?”
“You’ll understand when you read your book,” he says. “It will all make sense. I promise.”
“Okay,” I say. I realize I trust him, and I am glad. Glad that I do not only have my husband to rely on.
“It’s up to you, Christine. Call me, whenever you like.”
“I will,” I say, and then he waves and gets into his car and, checking over his shoulder as he does, he pulls out into the road and is gone.
I make a cup of coffee and carry it into the living room. From outside I hear the sound of whistling, punctured by heavy drilling and an occasional burst of staccato laughter, but even that recedes to a gentle buzz as I sit in the armchair. The sun shines weakly through the net curtains and I feel its dull warmth on my arms and thighs. I take the journal out of my bag.
I feel nervous. I do not know what this book will contain. What shocks and surprises. What mysteries. I see the scrapbook on the coffee table. In that book is a version of my past, but one chosen by Ben. Does the book I hold contain another? I open it.
The first page is unlined. I have written my name in black ink across its center. CHRISTINE LUCAS. It’s a wonder I haven’t written PRIVATE! beneath it. Or KEEP OUT!
Something has been added. Something unexpected, terrifying. More terrifying than anything else I have seen today. There, beneath my name, in blue ink and capital letters, are three words.
There is nothing I can do but turn the page.
I begin to read my history.