Chambers of Death

Chapter Twenty-Eight

“You look downcast, Brother. Shall I sing you a bawdy song to make you laugh, although you may have to do penance for it after?” Huet mimed a young man wooing an invisible maiden. “Or would you prefer a more prayerful one to please your soul?” The steward’s younger son became an old man, bent with the pain of his sins, praying for God’s forgiveness.

Thomas leaned back on the bench in the kitchen and watched with admiration. “Where did you learn such skills, Master Huet? Surely they were not taught as part of your priestly training?”

The young man’s smile was enigmatic. “Have you been a monk since boyhood?”

“I became a clerk first,” Thomas answered. This was not the first time he had been asked this question and had an easy enough half-truth prepared should he be asked for whom he had served and where. As his spymaster, a man who preferred more skilled deception, had warned, Thomas might be caught out with this crude stratagem one day. So far, few had ever cared to delve deeper than his first reply.

“And you were God’s most dutiful servant, never sinning?”

“I sinned eagerly and often enough.”

“And thus took these vows as penance?”

Thomas bowed his head, knowing silence suggested an adequate enough answer.

“Forgive me, Brother, for I meant no ill by that question. I oft speak before reason can advise otherwise.”

“Nor was I offended. It was I who erred by inquiring into matters I had no right to know.”

“And thus we each allow the other his secrets.” Huet winked, then laughed to suggest his comment was only a jest.

Thomas was not fooled by the contrived lightness of the man’s tone and turned his gaze away to conceal his wariness. Huet had lied about returning to see Hilda asleep on the bench and thus Thomas had cause to be distrustful, forcing himself to maintain an objective distance. In truth, had the circumstances of their meeting been different, he knew he would have enjoyed joisting wits with this man, whom he found both talented and companionable, but this situation did not permit such relaxation.

“Did you hear the latest news about Hilda?” Thomas asked, deliberately changing the subject.

“She is dead?”

The monk let Huet’s response resonate in his ears to catch what meanings he could, but all he heard was sorrow. “Near enough, I fear,” he said. Perhaps his suspicions of the man were ill-conceived. The steward’s son seemed very fond of the cook and may well have lied only to save her life. “I felt some trembling in her neck and a little breath of life from her mouth, but she had bled much. I have too little skill to help her and must pray that God lets her stay a while longer on earth and identify the one who did this unconscionable act.”

Huet frowned.

Involuntarily, the monk shivered. Surely Huet knew that Thomas was aware of the lie told and thus could expose the steward’s son any time he wished. If the man had made up the tale solely to keep the cook from hanging, he would expect Thomas to remain silent. After all, Huet’s words only provided support to the monk’s and thus the lie was well-intended. Thomas had no reason to speak up.

Or was this man malevolently clever? If this son of Master Stevyn had lied because it somehow placed him safely away from both time and place of the murder, Thomas was in danger. Perhaps Huet thought the monk would remain silent out of fear that he might be the next victim if he revealed the lie, an unlikely conclusion since most murderers killed witnesses.

Suddenly, Thomas became aware of just how vulnerable he was. The two of them were alone, and leaning against the table as he was, he was off balance should Huet wish to attack him. He had no wish to die with a knife shoved into his belly before he could defend himself. Slowly, he straightened up.

Huet folded his arms and studied the monk. “I heard she tried to kill herself.”

“Who told you that?” Thomas raised an eyebrow. Was the sheriff deliberately spreading this falsehood to suggest Hilda had done so out of guilt for the murder of Tobye? Must the cook remain condemned even if she was innocent?

Huet raised a matching eyebrow. “The man who protects your prioress, Brother. After she heard the commotion, and refused his advice to remain in safety, he followed her. When he reached the hut, he heard the sheriff loudly proclaim our cook had stabbed herself.”

“So he hoped!” Thomas realized he had been foolish to openly criticize Sir Reimund and quickly amended his words with: “Or rather believed.” What a poor attempt to change his meaning, he thought, and one not likely to fool the steward’s observant son. He silently cursed his brief show of temper. “No weapon was found. I examined her and said plainly enough that she could not have wounded herself so grievously, then disposed of the knife from a hut with no windows and a door barred from without.”

Huet pursed his lips and nodded.

“Why would anyone have wanted to hurt her? I have little acquaintance of the woman, but she seemed a gentle enough soul.”

Perhaps Hilda had witnessed something that pointed to Huet as Tobye’s killer, and the man had tried to kill her for that. After his strong defense of her in the courtyard, others would be less likely to suspect him as the true murderer.

But how could he know in advance that Sir Reimund would choose the cook as his suspect over, say, the pig boy or a laundrywoman? Surely Huet must be innocent.

Or had he simply taken advantage of the situation and found the imprisoned cook easier prey than she might otherwise have been?

In any case, until the killer was caught, Thomas could not risk casting aside any suspicion and knew that his peaceful nights, falling asleep in this man’s arms, were over. If he wanted to avoid any chance of a slit throat, he had best find a bed where there were too many witnesses as protection.

“Yet you have the measure of her, Brother. Her greatest sin was giving out bits of manor food to those of us who knew her soft heart and danced like puppies for treats. She had no children of her own and adopted us all with an eager love.”

“No enemies then?”

“Remember the story of devilish imps who infested the herd of swine, causing them to lose all reason and leap into the sea where they drowned? Satan may so drive a man to madness that he does things he might not otherwise do. Barring such a fiendish act, there was no one who had cause to injure her, any more than she had grounds to kill the groom.”

“Maybe he tormented her more than anyone knew and she could take no more, thus cut his throat. A moment of madness, perhaps, as you have just described.”

“Well argued, Brother, but I have rarely known a soul with so little anger in it. The sheriff must look elsewhere for the one whom Satan drove witless.” Huet’s smile was most engaging.

Thomas felt his face turn hot but was determined not to surrender to the man’s charm. “You know everyone here. Had anyone more cause than she?”

“Why do you ask, Brother? It is not your concern.”

Thomas swallowed hard, then forced a sheepish look. “Monks often find the world’s ways incomprehensible, and we ask too many questions about it. In addition, the Prince of Darkness may not disport himself more often in the world than in priories, but we are inclined to pretend otherwise and look for reasons to support that belief.”

Huet threw his head back and laughed. “You must whet your skills if you would become a teller of tales! Let me demonstrate a more persuasive demeanor.” He mimicked a sly, inquisitive monk. “That look you gave me would not lead any man to conclude you were like the religious you describe.”

Thomas willed himself to smile as if he had only intended a jest. “But I did make you laugh. Have I not learned that from you at least?”

Huet nodded, his expression much bemused.

Thomas sighed. “Nonetheless, the matter is certainly not my concern. I am but idly curious.”

“With all due respect, Brother, I doubt that. Your question is founded in true caring, not the idle prying from which so many suffer. In reply, I would say that several had more reason to kill Tobye than Hilda. He breached maidens and rode wives. The women may have been willing enough, but their gates were owned by others, and he had no right to enter as he did, whatever the invitations. If I were Sir Sheriff, I’d look to cuckolds and angry fathers before I laid a hand on our cook.”

“Any in particular?” Thomas asked, knowing he had just pushed his claim to trifling inquisitiveness a bit too far.

Huet shrugged. His eyes narrowed.

“None?”

“If you wish to satisfy what you name your idle curiosity, you had best ask others to raise questions. I have been too long away to know the most recent offenses. But, if you continue, I advise you to take care. There will be mortals aplenty who might not consider your interest but a simple failing of a cloistered monk.” He bowed. “Now, if you will forgive me, I promised to meet with my father for our long-delayed discussion about my abrupt return home.”

Thomas watched the man leave the kitchen. Were those parting words a threat or a kind warning? Rubbing his forehead, he concluded only two things after this talk with the steward’s younger son: he himself had been dangerously unwise in his speech, and Master Huet was far less ignorant of manor affairs than he pretended.