“I hate how this has taken over our lives,” Marybeth said to Joe, thunking her fork down next to her half-eaten dinner salad on the picnic table outside the Burg-O-Pardner. Joe was finishing his burger with Rocky Mountain oysters on the side. He didn’t know why he’d ordered so much and knew he’d feel lethargic later in the afternoon.
“We don’t have to let it,” he said, after swallowing. They had local grass-fed beef at the Burg-O-Pardner, ground lean, and they broke state law by cooking it medium rare on request. He wished he didn’t like the hamburgers so much.
“Our girls are weirded out and neglected,” she said. “April is no doubt plotting something while our attention is diverted, and Lucy is miffed how little attention she’s gotten from us about that part in the play. Joe, she’s the lead. She sings and everything. The girl is talented, but you know what she said to me this morning before she went to school?”
“What?”
“She said, ‘Female stars like to say they’re actors, not actresses. So if an older woman kills someone, is she a murderer or murderess?’ ”
Joe put down the rest of his sandwich. “She asked that?”
“Yes. This plays heavily on her mind. No doubt she’s heard things at school.”
“How is April handling it? At school, I mean. High school kids are the worst.”
Marybeth sighed. “They are. And it’s even worse in that she said some of popular kids now think she’s kind of cool having a grandmother who’s accused of murder. Can you imagine that?”
“I can,” Joe said sullenly.
“And there’s a lot going on we’re missing. I almost forgot to tell you, in fact. Eleanor Sees Everything at the library said Alisha Whiteplume didn’t show up for work last Monday and no one’s heard from her. The folks at the high school are getting worried. Apparently, she’s not at her house and her stepdaughter is still with her grandmother. And her grandmother hasn’t heard a word from her.”
Joe’s mouth got suddenly dry. He took a long drink from his iced tea. He said, “Alisha is missing?”
“It’s not like her,” Marybeth said. “You know how responsible she is.”
Joe rubbed his jaw.
“Do you think Nate knows she’s missing?” Marybeth asked, trying to act nonchalant. “I think he’d want to know, don’t you?”
He grunted.
“I know what you’re thinking, that she’s with him. But she wouldn’t leave that little girl without letting her grandmother know.”
“Has anyone called the sheriff?”
Marybeth rolled her eyes. “Eleanor said they called yesterday. She said one of McLanahan’s flunkies said Alisha hadn’t been missing long enough to do anything yet. He implied keeping track of local Indians wasn’t their first priority since they almost always show up eventually.”
“He said that?” Joe asked.
“I don’t know whether he said it outright. Either way, Eleanor was angry about it. But that doesn’t matter. If Alisha is missing, that’s a big deal.”
She let it hang there.
Joe finally broke the silence. “Honey, I’m not sure whether you’re asking me to try to find Bud, clear your mother, try to find Alisha, call Nate, go to the school play, lecture April, or do everything at once. I’m only one guy, and I have a job to do on the side.”
Her eyes narrowed and shut him down. He was immediately sorry he’d let his frustration boil to the surface. He reached out and squeezed her hand. The one without the fork in it.
“Sometimes,” he said, “I think if we traded minds for an hour there’d be so much going on in yours I’d drive off a cliff because I couldn’t take all the voices. You, however, would probably be able to relax because it’s so quiet and not much is going on except maybe you’d want to take a little nap.”
She simply stared at him for a moment before she burst out laughing.
“That’s what I wanted to see,” he said, and chanced a smile back.
But on the haphazard list he’d created in his mind, he added another task: Find Alisha.
Joe pulled into the library parking lot and they sat there a minute before Marybeth went in. He could tell she was processing what she’d heard and sorting it out. He told her about Bud’s absence the week before, hesitating when he confessed forcing the lock, but she seemed unfazed.
“So they don’t know where Bud is, either?” she asked.
“I don’t think so. I can only imagine the scene when McLanahan tells Dulcie Schalk he’s misplaced the star witness.”
“What do they have if they don’t have Bud?”
Joe shrugged. “They may not have the airtight case they thought they had. I could see Hand blowing it wide open.”
“They still have his statements, though?”
“I assume so. We don’t know what he said, but we can assume it’s pretty bad for Missy. But without Bud. ”
“Dulcie wouldn’t hide him, would she?” Marybeth asked. “From what you described, it sounds like he packed up for a few days. It’s not like someone kidnapped him and took him away?”
“There were no signs of a struggle,” Joe said. “I doubt kidnappers would tell him to grab his toothbrush before they took him somewhere.”
“I’ll bet Dulcie will be in full panic mode,” she said. “Same with the sheriff.”
Joe agreed.
“What if we find him first?” she asked.
Joe said nothing. He wasn’t sure he liked where she seemed to be headed. “What if we did?” he asked.
She shook her head. “I’m not sure. But maybe he ran because he’s been making this up all along and his conscience got the best of him? Maybe he’d like a chance to recant his part in the frame-up?”
“Marybeth,” Joe said, reaching out and touching her hand. “There’s still the rifle. And if Earl really was in the process of divorcing her. well, it still doesn’t look very good.”
“How do they know he was going to leave her?” she asked. “Was that from Bud, too?”
Joe shrugged. He hadn’t thought of that.
“Where would Bud go to hide out?” she asked. “We know him pretty well. You know him. Where would he go?”