Molly’s Olde Ale House
Chestnut Street, University City, Philadelphia
Saturday, December 15, 2:40 P.M.
“Okay, keep knocking on the neighbors’ doors for statements-someone had to see or hear something-and let me know when the medical examiner releases the scene,” Homicide Sergeant Matthew Payne said into his cellular phone as he watched Michael J. O’Hara throw back a shot glass-his third-brimming with eighteen-year-old Bushmills Irish whisky. “I’m a few blocks away, almost to the ME’s office, actually.”
The medical examiner’s office was next to the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania.
Payne and O’Hara were seated at the far end of the long wooden bar. Payne had his back against the wall. He looked at O’Hara, and beyond him, glancing around the half-full room of mostly college students watching sports on the overhead flat-screen TVs and-when it opened, bringing in a blast of cold air-at the front door.
“I’m repeating myself, I know, but the murder simply is barbaric beyond belief,” O’Hara said, shaking his head, then extended his arm and held the empty glass above his head to get the bartender’s attention. “Another Bushmills.”
The bartender glanced at Payne. Payne shook his head.
Payne looked at the two empty shot glasses before him-O’Hara had ordered them two each to start when they first sat down-and hoped Mickey wouldn’t override him and have the bartender bring them both another.
Then O’Hara, frustrated, practically slung the empty across the wooden bar. It slid into his two other empty shot glasses, making a loud clink that caused a couple of people down the bar to turn and look.
The bartender, who apparently had witnessed worse behavior, did not seem to care.
“Here ya go, pal,” the bartender said, placing it before O’Hara, then collecting the empties and walking away.
“Tim was a really good guy, Matty, fearless and honest as the day is long,” O’Hara said as he held up the glass, and stared at it a long moment.
Then he tossed back the shot.
“Maybe too fearless,” Payne said.
O’Hara’s tired eyes darted at him.
–
Not quite an hour earlier, Payne had pulled up to the U-City address O’Hara had texted him.
O’Hara was pacing on the sidewalk, following the path that he had packed in the snow halfway up the block. He wore a heavy black woolen coat over faded blue jeans and a brown checkered flannel shirt. His black loafers had a crust of snow.
Mickey barely acknowledged Matt as he parked the car and got out.
O’Hara, his head down, shoulders slumped, and with his hands stuffed in his overcoat pockets, didn’t speak. His face showed a mix of intense concentration and a certain sadness. He motioned with a nod for Matt to follow him to the house.
Just shy of the concrete steps, O’Hara stepped around a yellow-stained melted spot in the snow on the sidewalk.
“That’s mine,” he said, his voice a monotone.
Payne looked at it.
Mickey threw up.
And, judging by the direction of his shoe prints, after he’d left the house.
He’s seen a lot over the years. Not much bothers him.
But it can and does happen to all of us.
He followed O’Hara up the three concrete steps-and immediately saw bloody tracks across the worn paint of the wooden porch. They had an aggressive waffle pattern, suggesting they had been made by heavy boots, for either work or hiking, and they led out from the front door. He could see that the wooden front door was open about three inches, with no evidence of any forced entry.
O’Hara, stepping carefully around the bloody prints, stopped at the door.
He looked back at Payne.
“This is how I found it.”
There was a glass pane in the upper third of the door. A beige lace curtain, knocked from its mount, hung at a crooked angle. As Payne stepped closer, he got a larger view of the interior beyond the lace.
“Jesus,” Payne said softly.
He felt his stomach knot, and understood how O’Hara had succumbed to the nausea.
“Yeah. Jesus.”
Payne looked at O’Hara.
“You went in, Mick?”
O’Hara nodded.
“I know it’s a crime scene,” he said. “But, yeah, the second I saw Emily there I had to. The door was unlocked. When I got closer to her, it was clear she had been long. . gone. . and then I turned and saw Tim’s body. They both already had livor mortis-that is, from whatever blood they had left.”
Payne knew, courtesy of Doc Mitchell’s impromptu lectures during postmortem examinations, that when blood stopped circulating in the human body, gravity took over. The blood settled, and the skin color changed. Even through the window, he could see the distinct pooling pattern on her body, the lower flesh much darker than the light purple of the upper skin. He further knew that rigor mortis, the stiffening of the muscles, occurred about three hours after death, and took place before the heavy pooling.
Payne pulled out his cellular phone.
O’Hara put up his hand, palm out. Payne raised his eyebrows at the gesture for him to stop, and said, “What?”
“Before you call in the medical examiner, I want to ask a favor, Matty.”
Payne met his eyes.
“Sure, Mick. Name it.”
“You work this case personally. Own it.”
Payne slowly nodded. “Okay. Sure. Want to tell me why? I know he worked for you, but. .”
O’Hara narrowed his eyes, said, “Because you get it,” then motioned with his head for Matt to follow.
–
They stood in a small utility room off the kitchen at the back of the house. It had a dented stackable clothes washer and dryer in one corner. The rest of the space had been fashioned into a home office. Wooden boards for shelving had been mounted to the wall above an old wooden door that served as the desk. The shelving sagged under the weight of books and papers and a computer printer. A folding metal chair lay collapsed under the desk.
Payne stared at the notebook computer on the desk-and the severed head thereon.
Tim O’Brien’s dull, lifeless eyes gazed back in his general direction.
The scene did not surprise Payne.
After passing the badly bludgeoned body of Emily O’Brien, and Payne taking photographs with his cell phone camera, they had approached Tim’s body, the legs and feet of which stuck outside the kicked-in door of the hallway half-bath while the upper torso lay inside. There was an enormous pool of blood. Overhead, the exhaust fan rattled. The bulb in the half-bath was still on, too, casting a harsh light over the body that not only had been crudely eviscerated but also decapitated.
O’Hara and Payne had followed the blood trail to the kitchen, then into the utility room turned home office.
“Remind you of El Gato, Mickey?”
O’Hara nodded.
Months earlier, Sergeant James O. Byrth of the Texas Rangers had come to Philadelphia hunting a twenty-one-year-old thug from Dallas who was trafficking drugs and teenaged Latinas from Central America to Texas and finally on to Philly. Juan Delgado-called El Gato for his jungle cat-like fierceness-befriended the young, vulnerable girls, then preyed on them, forcing them into prostitution, feeding them drugs and forcing them to have sex with a dozen johns in as many hours as the means to pay for their being smuggled into the United States.
When one fourteen-year-old ran away in Philly, Delgado became enraged. He beat her young female companion to death, cut off her head, and dumped the body in the Schuylkill River. He then went to the laundromat in North Philly where the fourteen-year-old girl had found work with other illegal immigrants, and slid the severed head across the floor.
The Mexican national who quietly ran the laundry business, and had witnessed Delgado’s act, became a confidential informant. He helped Byrth and Payne track down Delgado to a dilapidated row house in Frankford, and then, with Byrth as witness to what he declared was an act of self-defense, ended Delgado’s reign of terror with shots from a.45.
Payne, who’d been in the next room when the two rounds were fired, quietly wondered if the confidential informant’s motive had been revenge. But while Payne could not prove it was not self-defense, there was ample evidence of Delgado’s brutal crimes-including El Gato and his crew having kidnapped Amanda Law, throwing her inside a minivan in front of Temple University Hospital and holding her hostage at the Frankford row house.
No one had any doubt whatsoever that El Gato finally had used up at least nine lives and that the bastard deserved to die.
And now Payne understood what Mickey meant when he had said, “Because you get it”-Matt had personally experienced the evil.
When he saw O’Brien’s butchered torso and then the severed head, he had flashbacks to when he’d been at the medical examiner’s office for the autopsy of the young girl’s body pulled from the Schuylkill and again when the confidential informant had showed him her head that he’d hidden in a bag in his basement deep freeze after it had been thrown in the laundromat.
“Like El Gato,” Mickey O’Hara said, “only worse. Delgado was a deluded wannabe thinking he could operate his small crew in the shadows, outside of the cartels. These bastards are the real deal. And they have no problem killing anyone in their way-not just little girls. In Mexico alone, a hundred journalists have been killed over the last decade, another twenty gone missing-and not a single one solved. If their bodies are found, they show clear evidence of torture. Mexico is the fourth most dangerous nation in the world for journalists, after Syria, Somalia, and Pakistan.”
He turned and met Payne’s eyes.
“And now it’s here. This is beyond intimidation. This is retaliation, Matty.”