Edge

Chapter 59

IN GAME THEORY the concept of the grim trigger is an interesting one.

This occurs in “iterated” games-those in which the same opponents play the same game against each other over and over again. Eventually players settle into strategies that achieve the best common good, even if it’s less than perfect for their own self-interest. For instance, they learn in the Prisoners’ Dilemma the best outcome is to refuse to confess.

But sometimes Player A “defects,” breaks the pattern, by confessing, which means he gets off scot-free while Prisoner B gets a much longer sentence.

Player B then might play grim trigger, abandoning any semblance of cooperation and defecting forever.

Another way to put it is that if one player decides even one time not to play by the rules, the opponent from then on plays exclusively-and ruthlessly-for his own self-interest.

There was no cooperation involved between Henry Loving and me, of course, in this deadly game we were playing but the same theory applied. By kidnapping a teenager to torture her and extract information, as far as I was concerned, Loving had defected.

I was now playing grim trigger.

Which meant unleashing Joanne Kessler-in her incarnation as Lily Hawthorne-on Loving’s associate, McCall, to lift the information from him. Whatever that took. My interrogation skills are good but it would take time to get somebody like McCall, terrified of Henry Loving, to talk.

I needed somebody he would fear more.

Hence my subtle request to Joanne in the living room twenty minutes before, using chilling euphemisms, which she picked up on instantly. I could see from her eyes.

Appeal to his sense of decency?

As Amanda’s stepmother, yes.

She and I had then gone to the outbuilding. We’d found McCall looking up from the heavy chair, scared, yes, but resolute in not betraying Loving. As I’d gestured Ahmad out, McCall had barked an uneasy laugh. “You’re giving me that voodoo look, Corte. What’s this about?”

Joanne Kessler definitely wasn’t giving him any looks. She was just studying him.

“Why isn’t anybody saying anything?” His voice caught.

The sense of threat in the room reminded me of the Zagaev interrogation Bert Santoro and I had conducted not long ago.

Only this was real.

Joanne had nodded to me and I’d gone to a control panel in the wall and inserted a key and hit several buttons. I’d told her, “No communication out or in. The video’s off. You’re invisible.”

“Look, Joanne,” McCall had said desperately. “I just can’t help you out, I’m sorry. I wish I could but I can’t. I feel for you, I really do. If there was any way…”

She wasn’t paying any attention to him. She’d turned back to me and asked, “Any tools here?”

“Under the sink. Nothing fancy.”

“That’s all I need.” Joanne had then closed the door.

Another thing about the outbuilding. The designers completely soundproofed the place. The reason for this was so that the principals couldn’t hear threats or demands coming from the outside.

The corollary was that neither could you hear screams from inside.

Night was around the compound as we gathered on the front porch of the safe house. Joanne seemed no more agitated than someone who’d survived a bargain basement sale at a mall store, standing her ground at the popular sizes and snagging the best.

She said to me, “They’ve taken her to an old military installation on Route Fifteen near Leesburg, a mile south of Oatlands.”

I knew Oatlands. A venue for Renaissance fairs and dog shows. Peggy and I had taken the boys there once.

She continued, “The facility’s about a hundred yards west of Fifteen down an unmarked dirt road, in the side of a hill, like a bunker. McCall doesn’t know why they want her. It’s very secret. He would’ve told me if he did.”

Joanne was speaking loudly. She realized this and reached up and extracted the cotton balls from her ears.

“Loving’ll be there soon and in about an hour the primary or the people who work for him will too.”

“Nothing at all about why they want her?”

“No. He said it wasn’t hard to find or kidnap Amanda. Anybody could have done that.” Her voice was rock steady as she said, “The reason they hired Loving was that nobody else was willing to torture a teenager, if it came to that.”

Ryan gasped. I noted that Joanne and her husband had not looked at each other since she’d left the outbuilding. He’d glanced inside to see her handiwork. There was a lot of blood on the floor. The reaction on her husband’s face was one you don’t see often in a police officer.

Joanne continued, “The three men who took her are minders. They might work for the primary or maybe Loving hired them. McCall doesn’t know. Only the primary knows what information to extract. Even Loving doesn’t.”

I asked, “Does Loving expect McCall?”

“No. He’s supposed to stay here, within cover.”

This was good. If he’d been required to, say, report to Loving every fifteen minutes, that would have been a tactical problem.

But now it was our move.

What strategy was best?

Rock, paper or scissors?

Joanne turned to Pogue. “A G team?”

I’d never heard the term but it wasn’t hard to deduce.

The operative said, “Two, three hours. We’re not as mobile here as we used to be. More New York and L.A.”

I glanced at Pogue. “You and me?”

“I’d say.” He cast an eye toward Joanne and for a moment it occurred to me that while he may not have been the partner on the Pakistani deli hit, there was history between them.

A voice said firmly, “I’m going too.”

Ryan Kessler.

I said, not unsympathetically, “This isn’t your expertise, Ryan.”

“Because I’ve been sitting behind a desk for six years, watching my ass spread? I’ve been on tac ops in the past. I know what I’m doing.”

“No. Because you’re involved. She’s your daughter. You can’t engage a hostile if you’re involved. It’s not efficient.”

“Look,” the man said, sounding reasonable. “It’s no risk my being there. He doesn’t want me, Corte.”

I pointed out, “He could use you as an edge to get Amanda to talk.”

“She’s a sixteen-year-old girl,” Ryan muttered. “He doesn’t need an edge. He barks at her and she tells him what he wants to know.”

That wasn’t the Amanda Kessler I’d seen.

“You’re too emotional. There’s nothing wrong with that. But you’ll have to stand down.”

“That’s a dirty word to you, Corte, isn’t it? ‘Emotion.’ Tough being a robot, isn’t it?”

“Ryan, honey, please,” Joanne said, reverting to the good wife she’d been earlier. Or, more accurately, the role of the good wife she’d been playing.

I didn’t argue with Ryan. How could I? He was 100 percent right.

He walked close. “Maybe it’s time to take the gloves off, Corte. And be honest. It was all bullshit, wasn’t it? What you said?”

I could see what was coming.

“You’ve just been patting me on the head, haven’t you? The way you’ve been handling me? Is it out of the bodyguard’s manual of tricks? Give your principal some busywork. Lie to him. Tell him he’s going to help you save the day. ‘We’ll take down Loving together, just wait till we’re someplace else.’ Then send him off to guard a field of fucking daisies and ragweed. In Fairfax, at my house, you knew Loving wasn’t going to come at us from that direction, didn’t you? You had me guard it to keep me occupied.”

I hesitated. “Yes, I did.”

“And you still had the balls to tell me what a great job I’d done.” He shook his head. “Oh, fuck, Corte. And when there actually was somebody to take down here-McCall-you didn’t consider me, did you? You called in our friend.” A contemptuous glance at Pogue. “You have a term for it, for keeping us principals busy? Making sure we sit in the corner with our toys and don’t bug the adults? Come on, Corte.”

“Ry, honey, please. You-”

“Shut up!” he snapped to Joanne. Then turned back. “So what do you call it?”

“Bait-and-switch.”

“You son of a bitch,” he muttered. “Guard the side yard, Ryan. Aim low, avoid his femoral artery. You’re probably a great shot… ’”

“I needed to get you on my side.”

“And sharing your war stories. How you got started in the business… your sign cutting, your orienteering. All lies?”

“No.”

“Bullshit.”

My heart went out to him. How could it not? A man who’d been robbed of a career he loved-and by his wife, no less.

Who’d been robbed of his status as a hero.

And lied to by me.

He whispered, “Give me this chance. I’m a good shot and the limp’s nothing. I can move fast, if I have to.”

Joanne said, “No, Ry. Let them handle it.”

“I’m sorry,” I told him.

“Well, I’m going anyway.” He was speaking to me. “You can’t stop me. I know where she is. After you’re gone I’ll just get in somebody’s fucking car and go anyway.” His hand strayed to his weapon.

A moment of dense silence. My eyes needed only to slip toward Lyle Ahmad, and the former marine stepped up behind, easing Ryan to the floor with a basic wrist grip on his gun hand. There was a countermove, by which Ryan, the larger of the men, could have escaped but, if he’d ever known it, he’d forgotten.

His eyes on mine, he growled, “Fucking coward. You couldn’t even take me yourself, could you? Had to have somebody get me from behind.”

I stepped forward and slipped nylon restraints around his wrists.

“No!” he cried.

“I’m sorry.”

“She’s my daughter!”

It was Joanne I was looking at, though. For the first time since I’d met her, tears were now streaking down her cheeks.

Ahmad got Ryan into a sitting position. I leaned down toward his thick, damp face, dark with anger. I said firmly, “I’m going to bring her back to you. This is what I do. I’ll bring her back safe.”