Fruits of the Poisonous Tree

10

My timing couldn't have been worse. Delayed by the meeting with Jim Catone and pawing through Vogel’s garbage with J.P., I didn’t arrive at Susan Raffner’s until shortly before 7:00 p.m., long after any anticipated quiet moment with Gail had been overrun by the stress and commotion leading up to the march. When I was brought upstairs by a distracted Raffner, still clutching a cordless phone in her hand, Gail was in the company of several intense women, including Mary Wallis, who cast me a startled and embarrassed look.

Gail was speaking in a hard-edged staccato to a harassed-looking woman with a note pad. “Damn it all. I thought we’d made that clear from the start. It doesn’t matter if we march around the courthouse from the left fork or the right-either way we look like a herd of goddamn cattle. The point is to divide there so that we meet at the common. We want to envelop the courthouse.” She made a vase-like gesture with her arms, “Not walk around it like it was some puddle in the road. Where the hell’s Susan?”

She turned to the doorway and saw me there. Susan was back in the hall, talking quietly on the phone. Gail’s face crystallized briefly-hard and angry, both too pale and too flushed in parts; and her eyes were red-rimmed and haggard-gleaming almost feverishly. She seemed totally thrown by my appearance. Her mouth opened slightly and her hand vaguely touched the side of her head, but for a moment nothing was said. I realized with dread that showing my face-especially this close to an emotionally charged public event-served only to remind her of why she was here, and undermined the protective, hard-driving persona she’d adopted for herself. Like a strong breeze on a house of cards, my appearance-for a brief but telling instant-was threatening and unwelcome.

She finally managed to mutter, “Joe.”

“I know you’re busy. I just wanted to wish you luck and tell you I’ll be out there. I’ll get out of your hair now.” I waved awkwardly, turned, and bumped into Susan Raffner, who’d seen enough to understand what had happened.

She grabbed my arm and gestured to Gail, who was only slowly recovering her composure. “Why don’t you both take five in my office? I’ll sort things out here. I think we’re in pretty good shape-not to worry.”

She ushered us both out and down a short hallway, steering us into a large, comfortable corner room filled with bookshelves, overstuffed furniture, and an enormous, cluttered antique desk. She closed the door behind her, leaving us alone.

Instinctively, I reached for Gail’s elbow, startling her and making her pull away. “I’m sorry. I should’ve called or given you some warning. I just wanted to see you, to wish you good luck tonight-let you know I was here… ”

She held up her hand, shaking her head. “It’s okay. You just caught me by surprise. I hoped you’d come by-I guess I thought it would be earlier, and then I forgot all about it.”

She looked at my face and half smiled, moving closer and taking my hand in hers. “I didn’t mean to flip out on you. I feel a little like a juggler on center stage… I just lost my concentration for a second.”

Her voice was still taut, but at least the cause of her tension was no longer me. She was one of the strongest women I’d ever met, but I knew-and I half suspected she did, too-that in the long run she was going to have to let down her defenses, allow the pain and the anger and the loss to flush through her, and then rebuild herself from the inside out.

But that wasn’t now. This time she needed all the stamina she could muster.

Still, I felt bound to ask if she was thinking ahead. This was someone, after all, who was fully aware of how deep rape cuts the soul, even before she’d experienced it personally. “You sure you want to do this? So soon after?”

She gave a lopsided smile and shook her head. “I’d really like to escape to a deserted island for a few months.”

“That could be arranged,” I said quickly. She turned and settled into the huge, soft armchair near the window, looking exhausted. Again, she shook her head, but with no smile this time. “I can’t, Joe. I need to stick this out.”

We’d debated her beliefs too often for me not to understand what she meant. In her view, leaving town, even though wounded, would be to concede to her attacker, abandoning the very principles in which she and her colleagues put their faith. Besides, the die was already cast.

All of which left me with few options. “Would you like to know how the investigation’s going?” She didn’t react at first and then answered slowly, almost shyly.

“Do you have a suspect?”

“We’re looking at someone. He doesn’t know it yet.”

“Someone I know?”

“I’m not sure. I don’t think so.”

Her eyes widened. “It could be a stranger?”

“Possibly. If this is the guy, that’s how he’s worked before.” I probably should have tried Vogel’s name out on her, but something told me she didn’t want to know-not yet.

She nodded, studying the floor. After a few moments, she pushed herself slowly and awkwardly out of the chair, like a woman twice her age, and came to me. “Thank you-that did help.”

“One question?” I asked.

“Sure.”

“Are you on the Victoria’s Secret mailing list?”

She actually laughed then and looked slightly embarrassed. “I didn’t ask for it. It was sort of an inside joke-feminist black humor. You found a copy at the house?”

I nodded and lied. “Yeah-it seemed a little out of character.”

She touched my cheek then, and I was careful not to react beyond smiling.

“Thanks for being there, Joe.”

I nodded. “Good luck tonight.”

“Where’re you going to be?”

“In the background.”

She nodded wistfully, and as she turned toward the door, her face became more composed, a little harder-a face for the outside world. She smiled at me one last time as she left the room. “I like the eau-de-Vicks, by the way-very subtle.”

Two hours later I was standing in front of the darkened Municipal Building, high on the slope overlooking where Main Street split in two at the tip of the courthouse lawn like the water before a ship’s bow. Heightening the image, a long, wide, undulating stream of flickering candlelight slowly flowed down Main from the south, breaking before and surrounding the building like phosphorescence, a credit to Gail’s dramatic flair.

I crossed the steep lawn diagonally, seeing that Gail, Susan, and the other leaders of the march had opted for the route closer to where I was. I joined the crowd at the curb.

Illuminated as they were by the gentle flickering of their hand-held candles, the women seemed both serene and somehow otherworldly, like harbingers of some truth only they fully comprehended. Certainly some of the people watching them were at a loss. As Gail drew near to us, her face upheld and her long hair loose and flowing down her back, I found myself next to two young men dressed in jeans, work boots, and denim jackets. They’d been chatting quietly together before I arrived, their hands buried in their pockets against the evening chill. The three of us-I standing slightly back of the other two-watched those women, united in a common cause, making a statement all the more powerful for its silent and symbolic eloquence.

One of the young men leaned toward the other slightly. “Is that the one that was raped?” he asked quietly.

His companion muttered, as if muted in awe. “Yeah. Third from the left.”

“Pretty,” whispered the first, “I’d fuck her in a minute.”

Bob Vogel’s station wagon was a twisted, rusting, spring-shot heap, the standard ornament on a run-of-the mill backwoods Vermont lawn, and reminiscent of his next-door neighbor’s. Except it was parked in the Jamaica lot of New England Wood Products, where Vogel worked the four-to-midnight shift.

Willy Kunkle and I were in my car far to the rear of the lot, beyond the reach of the anemic floodlights attached to the distant warehouse’s corrugated walls. We were completely wrapped in a couple of thick wool blankets I kept stashed in my trunk for just such occasions. It was 11:45, and I was having serious problems keeping awake, even with the cold. Willy was snoring peacefully, wedged in the corner, looking utterly content.

For me, unlike for Gail and her colleagues, the parade had been a melancholy affair. They had been pleased by the attendance, the coverage-by several outside papers and radio stations, and even WNET-TV from White River-and by the overall tone of the evening. Among other luminaries, Jack Derby-Dunn’s opponent in the SA’s race-made a speech, suitably brief and stirring, which hit home all the more by highlighting Dunn’s absence.

Afterward, there’d been a song or two sung by the crowd, and then, on cue, all the candles but Gail’s had been extinguished-over three hundred all at once-and Gail had quietly placed hers on the steps of the courthouse. It had been both theatrical and magical and had left many of the spectators wiping their eyes.

And yet I had left feeling depressed, the voices of those two young men still echoing in my ears, enhanced by several other comments I’d heard in the crowd. Gail and her supporters had their cause to rally around and their enthusiasm to maintain their faith. I just had a thorough working street knowledge of the odds stacked against them.

Naturally enough, Gail had been unapproachable following the rally. Flushed by their perceived success, her supporters had surrounded her like an enveloping cocoon and had virtually carried her away to Susan’s house to celebrate. Stimulated as they were-or, perhaps, depressed as I was-I felt they were ignoring the look in her eyes, which I saw only from afar as she was whisked by. She appeared wrung out and haunted. I hoped Susan would find time to focus on her friend, and not get swept up in the fervor of making a well-timed political point.

It was in this bitter mood that I decided to personally step up the investigation of Bob Vogel-starting that night.

Willy Kunkle stirred next to me, peered at the watch on his right wrist, and let out an exaggerated sigh. “You know what’s going to happen, don’t you? This schlunk is going to get in his car, drive home, and hit the sack, leaving us with bupkis.”

I checked my own watch-just a couple of minutes shy of midnight. “Maybe. You’re getting overtime.”

He grumpily buried himself slightly deeper into his blanket. “That’s no shit.”

A flow of people began spreading out over the surface of the parking lot from a small door in the building’s side, to be absorbed here and there by dozens of cars. Vogel’s heap remained ignored for some ten minutes before a narrow shape, otherwise indistinguishable from this distance, finally hesitated by its side, worked the lock, and then settled inside. A black, oily cloud erupted from the station wagon’s tail pipe and drifted over the rest of the car on a gentle breeze, making the subsequent appearance of head-and taillights look like the distant glimmerings of a lighthouse on a foggy night.

“Jesus,” Willy muttered, “couldn’t we bust him on that alone?”

I waited for the car to make its way to the lot’s entrance before I started my own engine and followed discreetly. There was enough traffic around that I wasn’t overly concerned about being spotted, but we were a long way from West Brattleboro, and I didn’t want Vogel to get a fix on my headlights too early.

Jamaica is located near the Stratton Mountain ski resort, a couple of state parks, and a scenic reservoir, all of which make it a magnet for “seasonal visitors,” in chamber-of-commerce parlance-“flatlanders” to the locals so dependent on their money. As a result, the road passing through it, Route 30, is wide and well maintained-a quick and pleasant way to meander through several quaint villages on a forty-five-minute trip to Brattleboro. It was anticipating this trip that we eventually pulled out onto Route 30 and headed southeast, a good half mile and several cars behind Bob Vogel’s belching, poisonous, but fast-moving vehicle, easily identifiable even at this distance because of its mismatched taillights, one of which had been made vaguely legal by covering a bare white bulb with pink-tinted cellophane.

We hadn’t gone more than a mile, however, to the center of Jamaica village itself, before our travel plans were abruptly revised.

“Where the hell’s he going?” Willy asked as Vogel turned right off of Route 30 and then almost immediately left at a fork in the road.

I slowed down at the corner and waited until the taillights ahead were over the crest of the hill he’d taken. “Beats me-that goes to Wardsboro.”

Willy’s voice became peevish as he realized that his hopes of a quick trip back to Vogel’s place were about to be thwarted. “I know that, but if he took Route 100 farther down, it would take him half the time.”

“Maybe he plans to stop along the way.” My interest, unlike Kunkle’s, had suddenly sharpened, dissipating my earlier fatigue. “Who do we know around here?”

Willy hesitated a moment, grasping the gist of my question. “How ’bout Freddie Gibbons?”

I shook my head. “I think he moved to New Hampshire. Besides, he was a car thief.”

“Well, if anyone needs a car, this guy does.”

We continued in silence for a while, keeping far enough back to catch only occasional glimpses of our quarry. After a quarter of an hour, the first houses of Wardsboro village slid by on either side of us, quickly joined by the church, the town hall, and a typical New England group of white-sided, green-shuttered homes. Willy muttered, “Better close up-Route 100 is just ahead.”

I sped up slightly, saw Vogel slow down at the stop sign, and then watched him turn left. “He’s going the wrong direction, back north toward Route 30.”

Now Willy’s curiosity matched my own. “Did we miss something? A drop-off, maybe?”

I shrugged. “It’s possible.”

A few hundred feet beyond, Vogel veered right off of Route 100, crossed a bridge, and headed for Newfane, five or six miles farther along. At that point, nervous that even infrequent glimpses of us in his rearview mirror might tip him off-especially along this much more isolated dirt road-I killed my headlights and drove by moonlight alone.

This proved easier in theory than in fact. The moon was not full, the sky smeared with occasional clouds, and the air thick with the dust kicked up by the car ahead of us. Both Willy and I ended sitting bolt upright in our seats, craning forward in a futile effort to better see into the gloom, all while traveling at the breakneck speed set by our unsuspecting target. Several times I had to swerve at the last moment to avoid the ditch, and once, despite Willy’s last-second warning, I ran over something large and furry which made me break into a thirty-foot skid that almost put us into a tree.

We both knew this road ended up turning back into pavement above Newfane village, where thicker traffic would allow us to turn on the headlights and stop driving like two suicidal blind men, so our disappointment was keen-and in Willy’s case vocal-when Vogel turned right onto Grout Pond Road, thwarting our hoped-for relief.

“What’s that stupid son-of-a-bitch doing? We’re going to get killed because this dumb bastard doesn’t know where the hell he is.”

But I was beginning to see a pattern. “He’s avoiding the village-and Route 30 again.”

Kunkle grabbed the dashboard as I half slid off the road on a curve, my rear wheels spattering gravel as they groped for some traction. “Why? He doesn’t have any warrants.”

“The car must be uninspected. If he gets caught while he’s on probation, he could get his ticket punched-at least I think that’s what he’s afraid of. And at the speed he’s going, I’d guess he takes this route every night-looks like he knows every curve by heart.” We both hit our heads against the roof as I lurched over a half-buried boulder.

Whatever his reasons, Bob Vogel was wending his way home, by as straight a route as such linked dirt roads as Hobby Hill, Baker Brook, and Sunset Lake would allow. By the time we finally reached Route 9 in West Brattleboro and unobtrusively merged our headlights with those of the steady trickle of late-night traffic, the effects of a smooth road and clear vision were almost anticlimactic. We were so tired from trying to keep the car on level ground through sheer will power alone that we barely noticed such effort was no longer necessary.

I went beyond the turnoff for Vogel’s trailer park as he pulled in, and parked in the lot of an abandoned garden center, across from an exhausted-looking motel with a stuttering, half-lit Welcome sign.

Kunkle sat back cautiously, as if unsure the seat was still behind him. “So what the fuck did that do for us?”

I flexed my stiff fingers. “We have to check his habits-same as you did with Harry Murchison. And this may have given us something to squeeze him with, if we need it.”

He turned away and stared out the side window. I didn’t blame him for being irritated. Above and beyond the danger of the wild goose chase we’d just survived was the fact that Willy was here purely to babysit me, as both Brandt and Todd Lefevre were unavailable. That might’ve been all right if Vogel had done something other than take the scenic route home, but now Willy obviously felt it well within his rights to make me pay for his disappointment.

Until I spotted a lone figure on an ancient bicycle wobbling away from the trailer-park entrance. “I’ll be damned.”

Willy followed my gaze. “That him?”

“It’s the same bike he had chained up next to his trailer.”

We watched him laboriously grind away at the pedals, his body bent over the handlebars, heading east toward the anemic glittering of West Brattleboro’s outermost inexpensive restaurants, motels, and bars.

“What the hell’s he doing on that thing?” Kunkle wondered out loud.

“If we’re right about the car, he’s keeping a low profile.” I pointed to a long, nondescript building set back from the road slightly. “We are, after all, cutting right across the front door of a state-police barracks.”

I followed him in several stages, moving only once I was about to lose sight of him. Within a mile, he wheeled up to the front of one of the town’s more decrepit bars and leaned his bike against the wall.

Kunkle chuckled beside me. “The Barrelhead. At least I’ll be able to find out what he’s up to in there.”

That the Barrelhead was one of Willy’s listening posts came as no surprise. It was the Rainbow Room for Brattleboro’s down-and-out. In constant jeopardy of losing its license, it was also where we found Willy himself in the old days when he’d still had both arms, a marriage in shambles, and been in a headlong rush toward alcoholism.

I killed the lights again and found a parking space far from the bar’s front door. We got out of the car and stretched in the refreshingly cold night air. There were about six other cars in the lot, enveloped in the red-and-blue glow from the Barrelhead’s neon sign. Jukebox music leaked from the building like secondary smoke.

We moved to the shadows by the side, where a small window decorated with a flickering beer sign allowed us a dim view along the length of the bar inside. Bob Vogel had just seated himself on a stool and was struggling out of his windbreaker, talking to the bartender. There were two other men at the bar itself, neither one of them close to Vogel, and several more in the booths along the opposite wall. A fat waitress in a black-satin uniform, complete with cap, lounged at the far end of the bar in an overloaded long-legged director’s chair, either uninterested or unable to tend to her flock.

“You still come here?” I asked Willy.

“Fuck you.” He suddenly pointed at Vogel. “Well, look at that.”

Having finally removed his jacket, Vogel revealed a filthy but solid-red wool shirt underneath.

“Did J.P. come up with a final analysis on that fiber sample yet?” I asked, knowing that Kunkle, despite his seeming disregard for everyone but himself, actually made a clandestine effort to keep up on every detail in a case.

“Yeah-said it showed engine oil and dirt stains, just like that,” he said, pointing at Vogel, who by now was working on his first shot and beer.

We stood by the window for several minutes more to determine that Vogel was there for his own entertainment and not to meet anyone. Then, after Willy relieved himself against the wall, we retired to my car to wait him out-again.

Willy settled into the folds of his blanket, awkwardly tugging it up around his neck, and fixed his eyes on the sporadic traffic passing by on Route 9 before us. “So-assuming we’re only farting around with Jason Ryan because of Gail’s dykey friends-we’ve got two real suspects, right? Harry Murchison and old Bobby in there?” He jerked a thumb at the bar.

“I remember six others from Gail’s list of possibles, and two from the intelligence meeting.”

He didn’t hide his contempt. “Very diplomatic. You could throw yourself in there, too-you were the last one with her. And from what I hear, the DNA analysis won’t come up with anybody else.”

I didn’t bother responding. His style aside, he was essentially correct. “So how close are we to doing more than sniff through their garbage?” he persisted.

Willy was not a chatty man, nor was he given to seeking the counsel of others. It occurred to me therefore that he was curious about my reasoning. He wanted to know whether Vogel-whom we’d almost broken our necks tailing for no apparent reason-was becoming an obsession with me, to the detriment, perhaps, of Kunkle’s assigned target, Harry Murchison.

I turned the tables on him. “You’re the Murchison expert. What’ve you got?”

“He had motive, opportunity, and means-”

“What motive?” I interrupted.

“He’s a grab-ass generally, and he made eyes at Gail enough for her to put him on her list.”

I conceded the point with a nod.

“He also had the opportunity to preplan the attack when he was in her house fixing the windows. He might’ve even rigged one of them then. I interviewed the guy he worked with that day. He said they were out of each other’s sight off and on the whole time. On both those points alone, he’s stronger than Vogel. We don’t know if Vogel and Gail ever set eyes on each other.”

“Why did he wait a year between rigging the window and breaking in?”

Willy shrugged. “Why does any guy jump a broad? Something snaps. Maybe he rigs windows all over town. And it looks like it could’ve been Murchison’s truck on Gail’s street that night. Plus he has no alibi.”

“We haven’t talked to him yet. Faced with a rape charge, he’ll probably come up with some explanation, even if it shows he was cheating on his girlfriend.”

Kunkle scowled at the window for a moment. “So you’re not buying Murchison?”

“Not like I buy Vogel. Like with the red shirt tonight-every time we take a look at him, he gives us something new. Did J.P. tell you we found a catalogue in his garbage with Gail’s address on it?”

Kunkle’s inbred restlessness shot to the surface. “So when do we get a warrant to search and bust the guy?”

He was echoing the same thoughts I’d been mulling over after the rally. My conclusion then held all the more true now. “As soon as we’ve answered every question we can on our own. When I sit down with Bob Vogel, I want to know more about him than he does-like why he drives home the way he does. And what he talks about in there.” I gestured to the bar. “And what he was doing to make him miss his appointment with Boisvert the morning after the attack.”

Kunkle merely nodded, apparently satisfied.

“It shouldn’t be too much longer,” I added. “Maybe a couple more days, especially if Dunn puts on the pressure.”

The bars close at two during weekdays, and it had been after one when Bob Vogel had wheeled his bicycle into the Barrelhead’s lot. Nevertheless, he looked much the worse for wear when he staggered outside exactly at closing time-the last to leave-and fumbled with his handlebars. It was with an element of relief that I saw he was too drunk even to get on the saddle, and contented himself with pushing his transportation homeward. I didn’t need him flattened under some passing truck-not just yet.

Simultaneously, Willy and I swung out of the car and walked over to the bar’s entrance. I faded back slightly to let Willy cover obviously familiar ground.

He pounded on the thick glass window covering the top half of the door.

The predictable answer was instantaneous and reflected the manner of the establishment: “We’re closed-fuck off.”

Kunkle pulled out his badge and tapped it against the window, calling out, “Hello, Ray.”

A muted curse barely reached our ears, followed by footsteps and the sound of the lock being shot back. The actual opening of the door, however, was left to us, as we heard the footsteps retreating without further ceremony.

Raymond Saint-Jacques-short, squat, balding, and in dire need of a shave-was heading back behind the bar as we entered, like a mole seeking the sanctuary of his hole. The gargantuan waitress was still perched on her endangered chair, as oblivious to us as an overdressed fire hydrant.

Willy and I parked ourselves on two stools opposite Ray, who was now safely barricaded among his bottles and shot glasses.

“What do you want?” He kept a wary eye on Kunkle, which made me wonder about the full extent of their shared past.

Kunkle smiled. “We were working late. I told Joe what a wonderful place this was, and what a great conversationalist you were, and he said he wanted to meet you.”

Ray stared at us sullenly for a few moments, fully understanding Willy’s gist. He turned to the waitress, who’d done no more than breathe since I’d first seen her an hour ago. “Nora-go away. Do something outside.”

Nora slid off the creaking chair with the delicacy of a dolphin in heels and drifted off through a door leading to the back.

“What’ll it be?” Ray then asked Willy.

“A beer. Joe?”

“Tonic water.”

Willy laid two twenty-dollar bills on the bar; Ray served us our orders and stuffed the money into his pocket. He didn’t make change. “What do you want?” he repeated, with no less hostility.

Willy took a sip from his beer, allowing me to ask, “You know the guy who just left? The one on the bicycle?”

Ray shook his head. “Nope-Bob somethin’.”

“How long’s he been coming in here?”

“A few months.”

“Good customer? Pays his tab?”

“He’s okay-a little behind sometimes.”

Willy wiped his mouth and spoke, “Not a good guy, though, Ray-could cause you problems.”

Ray merely stood still and looked from one of us to the other, a resigned look on his face.

“Does Bob talk about himself much when he’s here?” I asked.

“He’s usually working the bottle too hard.”

“He have his ups and downs, like most of us?”

“I suppose.”

“Night before last,” Willy asked, “what was he like?”

“Wasn’t like anything. He wasn’t here.”

“That unusual?”

The bar was as still as a confessional, the three of us utterly motionless. I could see in Ray’s face that he was becoming interested, tipped off by Willy’s comment about Bob’s character and our having pinpointed the time we were interested in. Gail’s rape had played big enough in the media by now-including on the currently silent television that hung above the bar-that Ray would have to have been brain dead not to know of it.

He finally said, “Yeah. It’s the first night he’s missed since I’ve known him. He came in later, though.”

Willy jumped on that. “How much later?”

“’Bout nine in the morning. He was in a real bad mood.”

I poked at the ice in my untouched drink. “How so?”

We were all playing by different rules now. By telling us Vogel had messed up his routine on the night of the attack, and had appeared at the bar later in a depressed state, Ray had moved from informant to witness, whose statement would in all likelihood make it into court. All three of us knew that, and Willy and I knew further that we’d better tread carefully, making sure we couldn’t later be accused of putting notions into Ray’s head.

But the bartender was no stranger to the process. He and Willy went back a long way. He even seemed to bask in the moment a little, understanding the importance of what he was about to tell us, and knowing we could do nothing but wait for him to do so.

“You want me to freshen those up a little?” he asked with a smile.

Kunkle was not in the mood. “Cut the crap.”

Ray Saint-Jacques looked pleased with himself. “All right. Look, I read the papers, like everybody, so I know about the rape, right? It was sort of a hot subject that morning-even on the radio. Bob didn’t start right in on it. He maybe knocked off a few at first, but later, after everybody else had pretty much left, he started in, saying shit like, ‘Sure as hell I’m fucked now-they’ll be all over me-don’t even have an alibi-fucking broads.’ Stuff like that.”

I chose my words carefully. “Did he explain what he meant? Go into any detail?”

Ray laughed now, his entire mood changed by the conversation. “Well, shit, he didn’t confess, if that’s what you’re after, but it was kind of creepy. It was like he was resigned to it. Most of my customers are a little paranoid, you know-got a record and all, or maybe just think the world’s out to get ’em. But he didn’t seem all worked up-just in the dumps.”

“Did he explain why he didn’t have an alibi?”

“Nope.”

“He didn’t say anything else?”

Ray grinned again and made a tossing-back gesture with his fist and thumb. “Too busy, you know?”

“He drink a lot?” Kunkle asked.

“No more’n the rest of ’em.”

“That’s not telling me a hell of a lot, Ray.” Willy’s voice had gained a touch of menace.

The bartender held up both hands in mock surrender. “Hey-it’s the truth. He drinks, but he always gets out the door. That’s more’n I can say for some of ’em-remember, Willy?”

Kunkle glared at him.

“Has he been drinking more in the last forty-eight hours?” I asked.

He tilted his head to one side, looking thoughtful-or at least pretending to. “Could be, you know?”

That didn’t satisfy Kunkle. “Has he or hasn’t he?”

Ray’s voice suddenly went surly, as if he understood that with me there, there was little Willy could do physically to back up his aggressive tone. “What the fuck am I-his nanny? He has, all right?” He stepped away from the bar, grabbing both our glasses and dropping them into a sink of greasy water at his waist. “I got work to do before I can turn in. Are we done here?”

I slid off my stool. “For the moment.”

“Good. That’ll be six-fifty.”

Willy stood and leaned across the bar, his powerful right hand splayed out on its surface as if he might vault right over it. “Don’t, Ray. I could come back alone.”

The fat man glowered, but kept quiet.

Outside, breathing in the cold, medicinal air, I asked Willy, “How reliable is he?”

Kunkle smiled confidently. “In legal terms? He’s as good as gold. I’ve used him on four affidavits in the past, and every one of them stuck.”

“Let’s hope we’re on a roll, then,” I muttered, and headed for the car.