“A complete, well-rounded novel, a contender with his very best … It is 100-proof Old Ernest!”
“There are brilliant descriptions in the famous Hemingway style … When he describes the close bonds of love and hate between a group of men who are engaged in a tight and dangerous adventure with death as the ultimate stake, he remains unbeatable in his craft.”
“Remarkably alive with voice and muscle … Hemingway never displayed a brawnier wit … There are memories of Paris as pungent and vivid as anything in A Moveable Feast. And the fishing episode … is only slightly less dazzling than Santiago’s struggle in The Old Man and the Sea.”
“Incredibly moving and powerful.”
“This book contains some of the best of Hemingway’s descriptions of nature: the waves breaking white and green on the reef off the coast of Cuba; the beauty of the morning on the deep water; the hermit crabs and land crabs and ghost crabs; a big barracuda stalking mullet; a heron flying with his white wings over the green water; the ibis and flamingoes and spoonbills, the last of these beautiful with the sharp rose of their color; the mosquitoes in clouds from the marshes; the water that curled and blew under the lash of the wind; the sculpture that the wind and sand had made of a piece of driftwood, gray and sanded and embedded in white, floury sand.”
“Many of the episodes contain the most exciting and effective writing Hemingway has ever done.”
“Marvelously alive, moving quickly and showing glimmers of joy and humor that you might never have noticed in his work before.”
“A part of American literary history, and his fans must read it, as they read all the rest with varying degrees of emotion, exhilaration and just plain joy.”
“An immensely touching book.”
“I fell in love with the book at first sight … caught up by the Hemingway voice (never truer nor more relaxed) … A lovely, loving work, deeply sad and deeply felt.”
“As haunting as any fiction that Hemingway ever wrote.”
“The work of an estimable writer … Hemingway’s voice is still effective, hauntingly so.”