Small Town Siren

Chapter Two

“Well, look at that. Your friends are here.” Christa grinned as she rang up a customer. “And they’re sitting in your section. I wonder what that means.”

“Maybe it means they’re hungry.” Abby stared as Jack Barnes and Sam Fleetwood slid into a booth. Sure enough, it was in her section. Abby glanced around Christa’s Café. This late in the afternoon there wasn’t a lot of traffic. She counted two people at the counter and another small group in the section Christa was working. It would be hours before the dinner rush. By then, she and Christa would be back at her place, their long shifts over for the day.

Christa looked pointedly at the cowboys who had been haunting Abby’s dreams for the last month. “They’re hungry, all right. Those boys have been hungry for a month.”

What had changed in the last week? Ever since that day when they had sat in Christa’s living room and watched the Longhorns play, something had changed between them. Before that day, it had been Sam who called on her with Jack only making the occasional appearance. Suddenly, Jack was everywhere. In the last week, she’d been out with the two of them almost every night she wasn’t working. On the nights she was working, they would show up at the café and insist on escorting her home. It was weird. And a little wonderful. The last week she’d felt protected.

Abby pulled out her order pad and smoothed down the little pink skirt of the uniform she was wearing. When she looked up, Sam was studying the menu, but Jack’s eyes were squarely on her.

They were two glorious slabs of masculinity. They both wore tight jeans and western shirts, but the similarities stopped there. Sam was smiling and jovial. Jack was more thoughtful. Abby couldn’t stop dreaming about them. It was just her luck that the minute she decided to live a little, she ran into the two most gorgeous cowboys she’d ever seen, and they were gay. It was disappointing, but it certainly made her comfortable around them. Well, she acknowledged, it made her comfortable around Sam. Sam was the light-hearted, friendly one. Jack, truth be told, scared her a little. He was intense, and she always felt like he was watching her every move, waiting for her to step out of line.

Then he went and blew the whole bad guy image by fixing her mom’s porch steps. She could still remember every minute of that day, though it had happened weeks before. She’d been frustrated and just about ready to call a handyman when Jack had pulled his truck over and hopped out. He’d calmly asked for the hammer and finished the work with a brisk efficiency. He had downed the tall glass of iced tea she’d given him but refused her offer of supper. He’d tipped his hat and been on his way after giving her his cell number and instructions to call him when things broke down.

She hadn’t, of course. It was just a friendly gesture. She’d been thrilled he stopped to fix the steps, but she knew she was on her own. It wasn’t the easiest place to be, but she’d done it before.

Abby smiled as a mental picture of her husband flashed through her brain. Ben had been kind to both her and Lexi. He’d been everything she could have hoped for in a husband. The sex might not have been the hottest, but he would have dealt with that nasty old Caleb Nevins who’d tried to swindle her over her mother’s clogged pipes. Jack had heard her complaining about Cal overcharging her at the café, and not two hours later, she had a refund check in her hand. Jack Barnes certainly knew how to handle the occasional con artist, and she had no doubt it was Jack and not some change in Cal’s heart.

But until last Saturday, Jack had been very careful not to touch her physically. Sam touched her casually all the time. He was always there to help her out of her car or give her a friendly hug. When they sat on the couch to watch the game on the weekend, he would casually sling an arm around her shoulder, but Abby knew it was just Sam being Sam. He was a tactile person, and Abby didn’t mind. If she’d been more secure, she would have slipped her hand into Sam’s sometimes just for the comfort of warm skin against hers. It had been a very long time since a man had held her.

Last Saturday afternoon, though, Jack had been the one to pull her out of her chair and lead her to the couch while they were watching the game. He’d said he wanted her to have a better view of the television, but she’d been able to see just fine. Nevertheless, she had quickly found herself between the two big men, and they didn’t seem concerned with things like personal space. Jack had casually rested his hand around the back of the couch, lightly touching her shoulders. His eyes held no small hint of challenge when she looked at him. It was as if he was claiming some right to touch her and daring her to deny him. Abby might have been able to stand up and tell him off if she hadn’t seen that part of Jack that was horribly vulnerable. It was there in his eyes when he looked at her. He was waiting for her to reject him. Besides, she had told herself when she settled against him, she didn’t want to reject his affection. Jack might be gay, but he was a stunningly gorgeous man. He and Sam must be lacking in female friends out in this small, narrow-minded town. Abby had lots of gay friends, and they tended to be very affectionate. It didn’t stop the longing she felt as she took Jack up on his offer and let her head rest against his broad shoulder. Jack’s arm curled around her, and when she felt Sam pulling her feet into his lap, she didn’t protest, just sighed and enjoyed being close to another human being. This last week she’d spent a lot of time between them, she suddenly realized. Every chance they had, they moved her to the middle. She sat between them in Jack’s big truck when they drove to Tyler to see a movie. She’d been in the middle when they watched TV at her mom’s place. Everywhere they had gone in the last week, she’d had a hunky cowboy on either side of her.

“Do you want me to take that table, Abby?” Christa’s voice pulled Abby out of her thoughts.

Abby winked at her friend. She took out a pen. “Nope. I can handle those two. I bet they want two burgers.” It was all they ever ordered. Sure enough, two minutes and a lot of flirting later, Abby placed their orders.

Christa cocked a single eyebrow. “You sure they aren’t bugging you? I like them, but I can run them out if you want me to. I’m quite handy with a broom when it comes to pests.”

Abby sighed. “No. I like the fact that they make sure to sit in my section. I’m just a little flustered. Those are two gorgeous men, after all.”

Christa’s ponytail bobbed reminding Abby of what she looked like at sixteen. “Well, we can talk about them all night tonight. It’ll be just like a slumber party when we were teens. Right down to the cheap bottle of wine I used to sneak out of mama’s liquor cabinet and eighties music.”

“Why not?” This was the night a nurse came and stayed with her mother to give Abby time off. She had packed a little bag and would spend the night in Christa’s guest bedroom. It served two purposes, this little slumber party. It gave her time with her friend and a willing man to change the oil in her car. Mike was probably already hard at work on her junker.

It was the most she could hope for in this town, to have a nice, slightly drunk night and sleep in a comfy bed for once. Now she wished she’d packed her vibrator. The damn cowboys had her flustered and horny. Abby smiled a little. At least her books were at Christa’s. She could sneak out into the garage, open her box of books, and lose herself in some hot romance. Those books were the only romance she’d indulged in for a very long time. It must be why she was so fascinated by Jack and Sam. They would be horrified if they knew she had fantasized about them last night. They were the fuel for her masturbation. Jack Barnes, Sam Fleetwood, and a pack of double-A batteries. That was all she needed to get going.

Christa gave her a little hug. “I’m so glad you’re here. I can’t tell you how much I’ve missed you. The yearly trip to visit you and Lexi in Fort Worth just isn’t the same as having you here full-time.”

Abby looked into her friend’s pretty face. She missed Christa, too. Unfortunately, some things never changed. “Don’t get used to it. I have to move on. If there’s one thing being back here has taught me, it’s that Willow Fork doesn’t change. I’ve gotten pulled over three times by the sheriff. So far it’s been warnings, but eventually he’ll start giving me tickets for everything under the sun. I think the only reason he hasn’t done it yet is that he knows my mom needs me. I’ve promised him I’ll be gone as soon as she’s on her feet again.”

Christa’s black ponytail swung righteously. “I am going to have such a talk with Len James. How dare he harass you like that?”

Abby sighed. She appreciated her friend’s indignation, but it wouldn’t get her anywhere. She’d sealed her fate twenty years ago in this town by having the audacity to fall for the richest boy in town. Adam Echols had been gorgeous and sexy and just wild as hell. The entire Echols family still blamed her for the car accident that caused his death. They had enough money and influence to make her life a complete hell. They’d had enough influence to run her out of town at the age of seventeen. Ruby Echols had made it plain that she could ruin Abby’s mother. The Echols’s matriarch had threatened to end Diane Moore’s job long before she came into her pension. Abby didn’t have a choice. She had to leave. Her mother barely had a high school diploma. She would never find another job with such good benefits. Abby had been on her own and pregnant with Adam’s daughter at the time, but they sure as hell hadn’t cared about Lexi. They knew Abby was pregnant, and Ruby Echols had flatly stated she didn’t want any child that came out of Abby’s body. She had, of course, also raised the question of whether the child was even Adam’s. Everyone knew Abby was a piece of trailer trash trying to climb her way out by using the sweet generosity of Adam Echols and his innocence.

They had missed out. Lexi was everything a mom could want from a daughter. She had Adam’s good looks and Abby’s force of will. It was an amazing combination. Abby had never been prouder than the day her daughter started college. Abby knew that her job wasn’t exactly over as a mom, but the really tough work was done. Her daughter was in her sophomore year of college, and her future looked bright. It was time for Abby to figure out what to do with the rest of her life.

“Don’t give Lenny hell, Chris.” Abby gave her a sad smile, thinking of the sheriff. He’d been a nice guy in high school. When he’d gone into a government job here in Willow Fork, he had come under the iron fist of the Echols family. It was just Ruby and her younger son, Walter, now. Hal, the patriarch of the family, had passed on last year according to her mother. Still, Ruby wielded her influence with all the subtlety of a pit bull. “He feels bad enough as it is. What do you expect him to do? He’s an elected official. Nobody gets elected in this town without Echols’s money backing them.”

Christa took a deep breath. “Maybe it’s time that changed, Abby. Those assholes have run this town for way too long. Now Walter is talking about running for state senate. They don’t need any more power than they already have.”

Abby searched her friend’s face. “Have they been giving you trouble about me helping out at the café?”

“No.” Christa’s voice was flat. There was an arrogant look on her face. She was a small-business owner who knew just how good her product was. “My restaurant is the only one in town that serves a decent breakfast. I haven’t seen anything but an uptick in business since you started taking shifts.”

“They’re just curious to see how I turned out,” Abby said with a self-deprecating laugh. It was true, though. Most of them had been shocked to discover she’d worked her way through nursing school. She’d managed it all on her own and still sent some money back every month to help her mother out. Abby had rapidly discovered a world beyond Hal and Ruby Echols’s dominion. It had been a world that Abby conquered in her own small way.

“Or it could be that Sam and Jack suddenly started eating every meal here hoping to catch a glimpse of you. I bet their housekeeper is thrilled with all her free time, lately.” Christa looked over the counter to where Sam and Jack were sitting and talking. Sam laughed heartily. He was really something else. Sam Fleetwood was a testament to the fact that the universe was good to some people. He was broadly built with strong shoulders and a chest that must look lovely without the encumbrance of a shirt. His golden blond hair curled even in its short style, and his handsome face spoke of a man who laughed easily. He was the opposite of his brooding friend. Jack Barnes looked like sin on a stick, and he was…well, he wasn’t paying any attention to Sam now.

Jack was watching her and not like before. Abby’s breath caught. There was no wariness in his dark green eyes. There was admiration in his eyes as he took in the tight uniform that clung to her curves. He didn’t even try to hide it. He just let loose with a slow smile Abby felt in her toes. It was a smile that promised a wealth of dirty fun.

Abby looked to Christa suddenly. Her heart was pounding at the invitation in Jack’s eyes. “What the hell is wrong with Jack? He’s looking at me like I’m a perfectly cut filet and he’s been on vegetarian rations for a month.”

“Wow, he’s not even subtle, is he?” Christa looked at the big, gorgeous cowboy with a sort of amused fascination. “Guess that’s what he needs Sam for.”

She turned to her friend and whispered behind her hand. “I am sure he needs Sam for a lot more interesting things than his subtlety. I’ll be honest, Chris, those two make me crazy. I would give a lot to be able to watch them make love. It would feed my fantasies for years.”

Christa’s mouth hung open for a long moment. She stared at Abby and then glanced back at the men. “Seriously? You think they’re gay?” Her voice was low.

Abby kept hers at a whisper, too, so the men sitting at the counter eating lunch wouldn’t hear her. “There’s nothing wrong with it.” It was a little shocking that her best friend was homophobic. It wasn’t something she’d expected. Abby felt a sudden horror that she’d outed the two men when they’d been trying so hard to fit in. She was the last person who wanted to cause the two very nice men trouble. She knew how hard it was to fit into a small town. “I could be wrong, of course. It’s perfectly reasonable for two men to just be roommates in their thirties. I’m sorry I said anything.”

Christa rolled her eyes and snorted. “I couldn’t care less what they do in the bedroom, though I suspect it’s much more interesting than you think from some of the stories I’ve heard. I like the hell out of Sam, and I think Jack Barnes is an honorable man. I want you to be happy, Abby. You need to cut loose and live a little. Ben died two years ago, and Adam a long time before that. It’s time for Abby Moore to find herself again.”

“What is that supposed to mean?” Abby asked.

“It means watch out, you got an order up. This is a place of business after all, not some gossip station.” Christa waved her finger with an imperious snap she softened with a wink. “Go forth. Those men need beef.”

Abby walked to the table, tray in hand. She gave them her sauciest smile. “Here you go, boys. Two burgers, one with bacon and cheese, one plain and medium rare.”

Sam looked ready to demolish his burger. “You’re a priceless jewel. I can’t believe how hungry I am.”

“I can.” Jack’s voice was a low growl. Abby had the sudden feeling he might not be talking about food.

She flushed under his gaze. “I’ll go refill your Cokes.” The minute she turned, she hit a slippery spot on the floor and her sneakers slid.

Sam’s arms came up around her to keep her from falling back. She wondered when he had gotten behind her. He moved fast. Jack was there, too. He took the tray from her and held her hand in his.

“Careful there, darlin’.” Sam’s slow drawl was soft and sweet to her ears. “We don’t want you to fall. But, don’t worry too much about it, Abby girl. Jack and I’ll catch you if you go down.”

“You will?” Even to her ears she sounded breathy and surprised.

“I promise.” Jack’s hands securely held hers.

“So do I,” Sam interjected with a happy smile.

Abby nodded, not sure what to do. When she’d fallen back into Sam, she was pretty sure she’d felt the hard press of an erection against her backside. That was crazy. It was probably just his wallet or something else in his pocket.

She would not look down to get visual confirmation, she promised herself.

The last thing she needed was to get caught checking out their packages to see if they were ready for delivery.

“I’ll try to stay on my feet, boys.” Jack’s hands were warm and surrounded hers. It made Abby wonder what it would feel like to have those big hands all over her body. Abby could imagine that callused hand cupping her as he pulled her into the hard strength of his body.

“You all right now?” Jack pulled her away from Sam so that she was steady on her own.

“I’m fine. I’ll get those Cokes,” Abby said shakily because her every nerve ending was on high alert. She was standing between the two most gorgeous men she’d ever seen, and it was too much like a fantasy. She needed to pull herself firmly back into reality. She was thirty-seven years old and a mom. She wasn’t seventeen anymore with a gloriously firm body. Her boobs sagged, and while she tried to stay fit, she’d put on a few pounds. The boys were just playing around. She had to keep her head on straight.

She had to remember, at all times, where she was. This wasn’t Fort Worth where people mostly lived and let live. This was Willow Fork.

It struck her suddenly that maybe the men weren’t as nice as she’d thought they were. It happened from time to time that she made the mistake of trusting the wrong people. Jack and Sam had been in Willow Fork for ten years. They were pretty firmly entrenched in the community, which meant they’d probably spent time with the Echols clan.

It might, she thought warily, be a good way to show her the door.

If she started parading around with these men, it would just prove to everyone in the county that she hadn’t changed. The threats from the sheriff hadn’t worked. Maybe Ruby Echols had come up with another plan.

“What’s wrong?” Jack’s hand tightened on hers. “You looked very sad for a minute. What happened?”

“I’m fine,” Abby said, shaking her head. She moved firmly out of their reach. It was time to stop playing. “I’ll be back in a minute with your drinks.” She walked away to join Christa at the counter.

Jack watched Abby’s fine ass sway as she walked away from them.

“What just happened?” Sam asked. He slid back into the booth.

“I don’t know.” Jack’s eyes never left his rapidly retreating prey. Jack took his place across from Sam. He looked down at his burger. It didn’t look as good as it had before. “She was responding to us. She practically purred when I held her hand. I would have sworn she was aroused.”

“Maybe you just come on too strong, Jack.” Sam sounded bitter.

“Oh, I come on too strong?” Jack rolled his eyes. “Seriously, Sam. You think I wasn’t watching you last Saturday? Talk about coming on strong. You nearly sucked her toes into your mouth when we were sitting on the couch. Don’t think I didn’t see that. You are the most orally fixated person I have ever met. You just have to put everything in your mouth.”

“Well, blame my mama,” Sam shot back. “I wasn’t breastfed. It had an effect. We just need to try harder.”

Abby was talking to Christa behind the counter. Jack would have given a lot to be in on that conversation. The two women whispered, and Christa laughed lightly. Something had happened to make Abby suddenly wary. She had enjoyed their attentions for the past week. His plan had been working. From the moment he realized she might be amenable to a ménage, Jack had been carefully preparing her for it. She was a serious woman, and he intended to treat her right. They were taking it slow, allowing her to get used to being between the two of them. She had been ready to move on to kissing, and Jack intended to do that tonight. He and Sam were going to talk her into coming out to the ranch to watch a movie and then they would kiss her. Sam had argued for doing a hell of a lot more than that, but Jack was sticking to his courting plan. He wanted everything out on the table before they took her to bed. They would talk about what a relationship could be like between the three of them. He might have to rethink that plan. Now, she was afraid.

“You don’t think Christa warned her off of us, do you?” Jack really hoped that wasn’t true. Jack had a good business relationship with the café owner. Beyond that, Sam considered her husband a friend. Mike Wade was Sam’s drinking buddy. He’d hate to see that go away.

Sam snorted. “Damn, Jack, who do you think told me to open that box of books?”

Jack was relieved, but it didn’t solve the core problem. “I think we should pull back and give her some space.” If they rushed her, she could run.

“Screw that.” Sam looked a little desperate. “It’s been a month. I can’t take another night. This whole dating thing is crazy. Can’t we fuck her now and date her later?”

“No, Sam. You asked me to give this a chance, and I’m giving it the best chance I can. She’s not a one night stand,” Jack said firmly. “She’s nervous now. We need to set this on the right footing. We need to let her know we’re going to treat her like a lady. Let’s ask her out to the ranch. We’ll have a nice meal and show her around. She’ll see how serious we can be.”

Sam looked disappointed, but he rarely argued. “All right. I’ll follow your lead, but damn, Jack, don’t take too long. I’m likely to die of sexual frustration.”

Abby walked back up, two drinks in her hand. She placed them on the table. “Is everything all right with the order?”

Jack hated the flat, professional voice she was using. He needed to get her back to the vivacious woman she was. “This burger better be good, darlin’. I won’t have my product being mistreated.”

Curiosity flashed in her hazel eyes.

Sam took the ball and ran with it. “This burger here is 100% organic beef. It’s the best you can buy.”

“Really?” She looked down at the burgers. “Christa buys your beef?”

“Straight off the Barnes Fleetwood Ranch,” Sam said with a smile. “We’re becoming quite big. When we started, we barely had a hundred head of cattle. Now we run several thousand and have a bunch of ranch hands helping us out. We have a packaging plant, too.”

“We’re still smalltime, and I like it that way.” Jack could talk about business. “If we get much bigger, we’ll have to hire more hands and deal with more people. The quality will go down, too. There’s a reason organic ranching is hard.”

Abby’s eyes sparkled with interest. She was a curious little thing. “So you don’t give the cattle antibiotics?”

“No, unless they’re actually sick, of course.” Sam slathered his bun with ketchup. “We won’t let an animal go without if she needs it, but we don’t proactively dose our herd. We take care of them. They’re grain fed.”

“Yes, I’ve read about that.” Abby was clearly getting into the discussion. “Those big ranches feed them protein and sometimes they feed them other cows. It sounds horrible.”

“It’s a way for them to cut corners,” Jack explained. “It’s cheap. The public wants cheap beef, so they use the parts they can’t sell to feed their herd. It’s easier to keep the cattle in pens than to let them roam and feed naturally. It’s why we’ll have to stay small and local.”

“So you don’t pen up your cattle?” Abby pushed a stray strand of hair behind her ear.

Sam popped a French fry in his mouth. “We’re old-school cowboys, darlin’. We let the herd wander our spread. When we bring them in, we do it on horseback.”

Jack shook his head slightly. Sam did like being a cowboy. “One day I’d like to try to add a dairy farm. I think we could sell to the local stores and even feed into Dallas–Fort Worth.”

Abby smiled shyly. “That’s sounds like a good plan, Jack. I like the fact that you take care of your cattle.”

“Jack and I personally give each heifer a kiss good night,” Sam interjected, causing Abby to laugh. “You should come out to the ranch sometime, Abigail. You would find it very interesting. I’ll take you riding. We’ve got some very gentle mares.”

“It has been a long time since I was in the saddle.”

Jack groaned at the thought of riding Abby. He quickly recovered. “You’ll like our horses. They’re gentle but strong. We take care of them, too. We take damn fine care of everything that belongs to us.”

Sam looked up at Abby. “How about you come out to the ranch tonight? We could show you around and take you riding, and then we can have dinner, maybe watch a movie.”

Abby laughed. “Well, Sam, you make that almost sound like a date.”

“Then I wasn’t trying hard enough, darlin’,” Sam said with a serious expression on his face.

Abby’s mouth came open slightly. Her face flushed as she looked between Jack and Sam. Her confusion was plain to Jack.

“You’re asking me on a date?”

Sam looked a little perturbed. “I apparently wasn’t doing a good job. Yes, Abigail Moore, we would like to ask you on a date. Will you go out with us?” Sam looked at Jack. He seemed just as confused as Abby. “What does she think we’ve been doing for the last week, Jack?”

“I don’t know.” Abby was confused about a few things. Maybe he’d been too subtle. “Abigail, what do you call it when a man takes a woman out, picks her up, pays for everything, and then politely takes her home?”

She gnawed on her bottom lip. Her gaze shifted between the two men. “I thought we were just being friends. I thought maybe I was your hag.” Her voice dropped to a whisper. “Is this some new thing in the gay community?”

“What?” Jack’s shout rang out, and suddenly everybody in the café was watching their table. In all the scenarios that ran through his brain, Abby thinking she was auditioning to be their hag hadn’t come up.

Sam seemed unperturbed. His blue eyes were lit with laughter. “Jack, I believe she thinks we’re gay.”

Jack stood up suddenly. It was obvious Abby was under a misconception that he intended to remedy. “Darlin’, I have never been accused of not enjoying a woman. I haven’t been spending time with you hoping you’ll give me the name of your hairdresser. I’ve been spending time with you to try to get you into bed.”

Sam could barely talk for his laughter. “Well, if we’re gay, Jack, at least I’m the pretty one.”

Abby’s hands were twisting around her notepad. “It’s a perfectly reasonable assumption. You two are unmarried, successful men who spend almost every moment together with no visible female in either of your lives. I’m sorry if I offended you. If it helps, I thought you made a very attractive couple.”

“Damn it, that does not help, Abby,” Jack said.

“Abby, we’re not gay.” Sam slid out of the bench to face her.

“I’m getting that now.” Abby’s eyes were wide.

“But we do like to share.” Sam patted Abby on the back almost sympathetically.

Abby’s mouth formed a perfect O before she turned and fled. She was running by the time she entered the ladies room.

Sam stared after her. “Guess that whole dating thing is over.”

Jack felt his eyes narrow. Everyone was watching, but he had no intention of backing down. He’d tried to take things slow. He’d tried to be a gentleman. That was over. If Abby thought he was backing down, she better think again. “Time for a new plan, Sam.” He strode toward the women’s bathroom.

“Hallelujah!” Sam’s shout rang throughout the small room like a battle cry.