The Art of Deception

A Wallet and a Watch

“Knock, knock.”

“Come in,” Boldt said. When he saw it was Matthews, he said, “Hello there. It’s been awhile. Have a seat.”

Matthews wondered where his compliments had gone. Boldt had always had something nice to say to her, little observations that had always made her day. They weren’t there anymore, and she missed them.

He said, “John told me about the guy outside your window.”

“He shouldn’t have. It was shoe prints is all.”

“I’ve asked SID to take a look. Better late than never.” Before she could protest, he explained, “On the off chance it’s related to our hotel peeper.”

“It’s not.”

“They’re over there now.”

“Does anyone ever ask around here?”

“We have a photo of a waffle pattern from the construction site-the voyeur watching the hotel. Maybe we can match them.”

“You won’t. I have two candidates of my own,” she said.

“Suspects?”

She shook her head. “Listen, it could have been a handyman.

I had my screens put on a couple weeks ago.”

“That was optimistic of you. Still feels like winter to me.”

“The prints are not connected to Hebringer and Randolf, Lou.”

“I’d rather an educated decision on that be made, a group decision. Okay with you?”

“You’re not yourself.”

He pushed back the office chair and studied her. “You know, after about a hundred people telling me that, I’m tired of hearing it. Yes, even from you.”

“I’d suggest you hand off Hebringer, but I know you better.”

“Yes, you do. So drop it.” He apologized, “I’m sorry. You didn’t deserve that. Something else is bugging me.”

“The city worker drowning?”

“The EMTs tell me there’s a section of the Underground there, still intact. The city won’t let me down the sinkhole because it’s too dangerous. Can you believe that? Someone tell that to Susan Hebringer. So I’m exploring the possibility of an alternate access. There’s a woman at the U, a Dr. Babcock, looking into it.” He added, “So are you going to tell me who your suspects are, or is your plan to try to distract me?”

She never got much past him. She wasn’t even sure why she tried. “The floater, Mary-Ann Walker?”

“Right.” He knew the case.

“She has a younger brother that’s number one. There may be a little transference going on. He seems to think he’s Watson to my Holmes.”

“Lovely.”

“The other possibility is Nathan Prair.”

“Again?”

“He was on the bridge the night we investigated. Sheriff’s Office is involved-don’t ask me how. He’s his same old creepy self, and I think there’s a chance he was watching me, or at least keeping an eye out for me, over at the Shelter.”

“You want me to talk to him? Bring him in?”

“A personality like his? No. Thanks, but no thanks. Guys like Prair, they live with expectation. Bringing him in, we’d add fuel to the fire, and at that point he’d have to prove to himself, to me, to everyone involved how right he was about the perfect match he and I would make. I’ve been through this before with him. The best approach is to give it distance.”

“And that’s it? A list of two? We can handle that.”

“That’s the short list,” she said. “The long list includes every con I’ve ever helped put away who’s now out on parole. It might have to include Langford Neal as well-the boyfriend we’ve charged with running over Mary-Ann and then tossing her off that bridge. He’s a controlling personality, has a history of abuse. I’m a woman who’s making decisions about his future, and that’s bound to sit wrong. I can see him getting curious about me, and that can lead to some ugly behavior.”

“I’m not liking where this is headed,” he said.

“That makes two of us.”

“So let’s do something about it.”

“It’s a passive crime, Lou. That complicates matters. Walker leaves me phone messages that turn my stomach. Prair shows up in parking garages and then disappears. I’ve got some mud and dirt outside a window. What charges do we file? And how much do I want to discourage Walker, given that he just supplied us with evidence we otherwise might not have found?”

“What evidence?”

“Some of his sister’s personal effects, her wallet, a watch, and a pack of cigarettes. There’s some paperwork in the wallet, including what appears to be a traffic citation. We left it all off with Bernie before we dug into it. He’ll process it for latents and hairs and fibers, and then give us a look.”

“If the brother is compromising evidence, then that’s obstruction. You want him locked up, we’ll lock him up.”

“John wants to question him, sure. But I may have scared him off earlier. I was pretty tough on him. I had him roll some prints. My guess: He won’t be showing up at work for a couple days. The other thing is, we don’t know where he got this evidence. At first, John was furious, and rightly so. But then we thought it through: If Neal had this stuff hidden, if Walker found this stuff hidden rather than in plain sight-it actually could help us build a case.”

“That’s playing with fire, and we both know it, Daffy. You don’t want to get in the middle of this.”

“I’m already in the middle. What I’d like is to get to one side, to let John be the center of this guy’s attention. That takes a little manipulation with personalities like this. It can’t be done all at once.”

Boldt put down the pen and removed his reading glasses. A depth to his eyes drew her in. So much going on in there. “So how can I help?” he asked.

“Mersi-do and Mersi-don’t,” LaMoia said, entering Boldt’s office without knocking. He hooked a chair with his boot, spun it around to face them and plopped down into it.

“We’re discussing Daphne’s being harassed, possibly stalked,” Boldt said.

Hands in the air, LaMoia quipped, “It wasn’t me,” and flashed another trademark smile. “My recommendation is that Heiman and I kneecap Walker, and that’s the end of it. He slides around the sidewalks on one of those little dollies for the next ten years. Teach him to mess with our family.”

Matthews chuckled nervously.

“I’d prefer we play a little more in-bounds than that.”

“Suit yourself. Save the taxpayers a wad.” Looking at Matthews he said, “And I gotta tell you, it’s one job I’d put my heart and soul into.” He was openly flirting with her, and she wondered why that surfaced in front of Boldt, of all people.

She wasn’t sure if she should share this or not, but if Boldt found out later that she’d withheld it, there would be hell to pay.

“He made an indirect reference to Hebringer and Randolf.”

Boldt stiffened. “Such as?”

“It was one of the phone messages. He said it was dangerous out there. That I didn’t have to worry about that with him.”

“Then I want you out of your houseboat. You’ll take a hotel room courtesy of the department until we’ve had a chance to follow up.”

“That’s unnecessary.” She had feared an overreaction.

Boldt reminded, “You found boot prints outside your window. Whatever the situation, I want you off of that houseboat.”

To LaMoia: “With Walker mentioning the disappearances, I want him brought in for questioning.”

“You’re reaching, Lou, and we both know that. Listen, phon-ers rarely stalk; stalkers rarely phone. Two different patterns, two different personalities, and I’m thinking two different people.”

“Walker and Prair,” Boldt repeated. “But you don’t know that!”

“Whoa, there,” said LaMoia. “When did Prair get into this?”

Matthews explained most of her encounter at the parking garage-that “a witness” had seen a man in a khaki or brown uniform. She added, “An infatuation like Prair’s is harmless, it’s just annoying. Honestly, I’m more concerned about Walker’s overeagerness to please. But connecting him to the disappearances? That’s unworthy of you.”

“He made that connection for us,” Boldt said.

“It’s a daily news item, Lou. The whole city’s talking about Hebringer and Randolf. Come on!”

LaMoia attempted to break the tension between them. “Nathan Prair is not harmless,” he said. “Just ask that motorist he iced.”

Boldt spoke up quickly. “He was acquitted of that, John. It was found to be a good shooting.”

“It was never a good shooting and the three of us damn well know it,” LaMoia said.

An uncomfortable silence overtook them. LaMoia moved restlessly in the chair. “I’m with Sarge,” he said. “The houseboat is too dangerous for you right now. I’ll clean out my guest room.

You’ll stay with me until we make sense of this.”

Matthews barked out her reaction, glancing at Boldt, who grinned.

“Talk about the wolf in sheep’s clothing!”

LaMoia was not beyond laughing at himself. “I’m not going to hit on you. You-both of you-did me a favor awhile back.

I’m returning it, that’s all.”

“Yeah, right,” Matthews said. Her beeper sounded from inside her purse, silencing all three. Hesitation and expectation hung in the air: If LaMoia’s or Boldt’s pager went off within the next few seconds, then typically it meant a major crime. All three held their breath as Matthews inspected the device, the possibility of another Hebringer or Randolf on everyone’s minds. Her shoulders relaxed. “The Shelter,” she said. “Don’t worry: I know what it’s about.”

“Consider the offer,” LaMoia said.

She looked up at Boldt, anticipating another moment of shared amusement. Instead, Boldt said in all seriousness, “Consider the offer, or pick a hotel. You are not going back to that houseboat.”