The Body Snatchers Affair

24

The twenty-year-old Palace Hotel, also colloquially known as the “Bonanza Inn” and the “Grand Dame of the West,” was San Francisco’s most luxurious hostelry, far more elegant than the older, second-best Baldwin Hotel in the Uptown Tenderloin. At the time of its construction it had had the distinction of being the largest hotel west of the Mississippi, its many features including 755 guest rooms and suites equipped with private baths, forty-five public and utility rooms, three inner courts, and five redwood-paneled hydraulic elevators referred to by the staff as “rising rooms.” Seven floors of white-columned balconies overlooked the open, glass-roofed Grand Central Court which served as a carriage entrance.

Even though she hurried as much as possible, Sabina arrived ten minutes late for the one o’clock appointment with Carson. Confiscating the $75,000 ransom money, over more of Bertram Blanchford’s pathetic pleas, and then transporting it to the agency and locking it away for temporary safekeeping had taken longer than she’d anticipated.

Carson was waiting on the marble-floored promenade, next to one of the columned archways facing the circular carriageway, when she entered the Grand Court. She spied him immediately, a stationary figure among the stream of arriving and departing guests, bellboys with luggage carts, and carriage drivers and their rigs. A smile brightened his handsome face as she approached. As always, he was nattily if conservatively dressed, today in a gray frock coat with matching vest and striped trousers; the gold-headed stick he carried was tucked under one arm. Sabina’s heart had skipped a beat the first time she’d seen him, and she’d felt the stirrings of excitement on each of the previous occasions they’d been together, but today she felt nothing other than a faint apprehension. Not even his blue eyes, Stephen’s eyes, moved her as they had before.

She allowed him to take her hand in greeting — his touch created no tingling sensations — but not to hold it as he said lightly, “I was beginning to think I’d been stood up.”

“I’m sorry to be late. I was unavoidably detained.”

“One of your investigations?”

“Yes. The close of one.”

“Satisfactorily closed, I trust.”

“For the most part.”

His smile dimmed a bit as he studied her. Whatever else he might be, he was also perceptive. “You don’t seem particularly happy about it,” he said. “Or is it something else that makes you seem so tense and cheerless?”

“I’m afraid so.”

“Something to do with me?”

“Unfortunately, yes.”

“Oh, I see. The matter of considerable urgency you alluded to in your message.”

“Yes.”

“Well, then. Shall we discuss whatever it is over luncheon in the American Dining Room?”

“I’d rather not dine, Carson. I’m not particularly hungry.”

“Then the matter must be serious, considering your usual fine appetite.” He strove for lightness of tone once again, and failed. The smile was gone now, replaced by the shadow of a frown. “It’s too public for conversation here. Where would you like to go?”

“There are benches in the garden. One of those will do.”

He took her elbow as they moved around to the walkway that led into the tropical garden with its array of exotic plants, statuary, and fountains. Marble benches were set at intervals along the walkway and among the greenery, all presently unoccupied; Carson led her to one of the latter next to a tinkling fountain.

“Well, then,” he said when they were seated facing each other. “What’s on your mind?”

Sabina had decided to be blunt. Pussyfooting around the subject would only make this more difficult. She said, “The Gold King Mine high-grading scandal eight years ago.”

Carson stared at her for several heartbeats, rigidly unmoving, as if he had been temporarily turned to stone. Then his shoulders seemed to sag slightly, and though his gaze held hers, there was hurt in it now. Whether it was old or new pain, she couldn’t tell.

“What about the Gold King scandal?” he asked then.

“Were you involved in it in any way?”

“My God. What makes you think that?”

“By your own admission you were employed in the Mother Lode in 1887, in such counties as Amador and such mines as the Gold King. You returned to San Francisco not long after the high grading was exposed and the gang members arrested. You were well acquainted with one of the principals in the scheme, George M. Kinney, a friend and business associate of your father.”

“That’s hardly evidence of complicity in the crime. You must know that my name was never connected to the Gold King conspiracy. Lord, Sabina, do you always investigate your prospective beaux?”

“Not unless I have cause.”

“What cause in this matter? What led you to poke around in my past, to suspect me of wrongdoing?”

“It was brought to my attention that you were being blackmailed by another ringleader recently released from prison, Artemas Sneed.”

Carson winced. “Brought to your attention by whom?”

“The man who calls himself S. Holmes.”

“Holmes? I don’t know anyone by that name.”

“He has used others on occasion. Tall, spare, middle-aged, with a thin, hawkish nose and a prominent chin. Speaks with a pronounced British accent.”

“I’ve never met anyone who answers that description. How on earth would he know of the Gold King and Artemas Sneed?”

A very good question. One I intend to ask Mr. S. Holmes if our paths cross again.

“You haven’t answered my question, Carson,” she said. “Were you involved in any way in the gold-stealing? And please don’t lie to me. I’ll know it if you do.”

He said nothing for a time, both hands tightly clasping the gold handle of his stick. Then he let out a breath and said resignedly, “All right. I’ll tell you the absolute truth. The answer is yes — and no.”

“What does that mean?”

“It means that I was involved, yes, but only briefly and indirectly. I took no active part in the thefts, received not a single penny of the proceeds from the stolen gold. I was fortunate — my name was never brought up because so far as Kinney and the others knew, they had no cause to bring me down with them. I was never part of the gang.”

“Then in what way were you involved?”

“Kinney came up to Amador just after I was hired by the Gold King’s owners and attempted to recruit me,” Carson said with some bitterness. “I had no idea he was a crook until then — it was a shock to learn that he was. He’d had heavy stock-market setbacks and was in dire need of cash, his excuse for having orchestrated the scheme. Sneed was his first recruit, I was to be his second.”

“To do what, exactly?”

“Falsify my reports on new and established veins, to make it seem as though there were not as much gold-bearing ore in certain sections of the Gold King as there was. That would have made it easier for Sneed and his crew to steal and smuggle out the richest dust. For doing this I was to be paid five thousand dollars in cash.”

“Did you agree to it?”

“Not in the beginning. I turned Kinney down at first, but he kept after me — he could be very persuasive. Finally, at a meeting with Kinney and Sneed, and under the influence of several drinks of forty-rod whiskey, I weakened and gave in to temptation. To my everlasting shame.”

“Your family is rich,” Sabina said. “Did you really need the five thousand dollars?”

“No, except that I was young and foolish and independent as the devil, and I hated having to ask my father for money. My salary in those days was not large and I … well, the mining camps were rough-and-ready places and I admit to a weakness for poker in those days.” Carson’s mouth quirked self-deprecatingly. “And to a fondness for sowing more than my share of wild oats.”

“Did you falsify your Gold King reports?”

“No. I came to my senses in time, thank God.”

“Kinney and Sneed must have been upset when you told them.”

“I didn’t tell them. I pretended to follow through, but in fact all I did was prepare two reports — a false one to satisfy them without actually aiding in the thefts, and a genuine, completely honest one for the Gold King’s owners.”

“Did you accept the five thousand dollars?”

Carson shook his head. “I told Kinney my conscience wouldn’t allow it. He said I was a fool, but he didn’t argue; he was only too happy to keep the five thousand for himself.”

A trio of hotel guests came hurrying along the promenade from the carriage entrance, chattering loudly among themselves. Sabina waited until they passed before she said, “If you came to your senses in time, why did you pretend to do Kinney’s bidding? Why didn’t you simply go to the owners or the authorities and reveal the plot to them?”

“I did, though not directly. I am the author of the anonymous letter that led to the gang’s exposure and arrest.” Carson’s tone was bitter again, this time with self-recrimination. “My conscience finally got the better of me after I moved on to Grass Valley, but I didn’t have the courage to go back and expose the scheme in person — I was afraid of being arrested myself and sent to prison, of blackening the Montgomery name. So I settled for writing the letter. God knows, I should have done it sooner.”

“If you had,” Sabina said, “someone in the gang might have realized you were responsible and implicated you.”

“I almost wish that had happened. As it was, I returned to San Francisco and accepted an offer to join Monarch Engineering. But I lived on tenterhooks during the trial and for a long time afterward. Eventually I came to believe my past mistake would remain buried, and so it was until that devil Sneed was released from prison.”

“He’d found out somehow that you wrote the anonymous letter?”

“Guessed it. A man has a lot of time to think when he’s cooped up in a cell for eight years, he said.”

“Did you deny it?”

“I tried to when he first turned up at my office, the day before you and I dined at Haquette’s, but he just laughed. I suppose he could tell from my reactions that he’d guessed correctly. He threatened to expose me, to make my part in the high grading seem much worse than it was, unless I paid him the same amount Kinney offered me — five thousand dollars.”

“Did you give him the money?”

“No. Not one red cent.”

Sabina raised an eyebrow.

“God’s honest truth,” Carson said. “I told him I refused to be blackmailed and in turn threatened him with a charge of attempted extortion.”

“You thought no one would believe the word of an ex-convict, eight years after the fact?”

“I hoped that might be the case. But that’s not why I refused to pay blackmail. I escaped punishment for what I did and almost did in Amador County, but my actions have weighed on my conscience ever since. There would be greater shame in accommodating a man like Sneed to keep my past sins secret than in having them revealed and my reputation sullied. It would almost be a relief to have the truth come out. My only regret if it does is what it would do to my father and the Montgomery family name.”

“Did Sneed make any further attempt to blackmail you?”

Carson nodded. “He slunk away that first time, but then two nights ago he showed up at my home with the same demand and an additional threat. If I didn’t pay, he would not only ruin me by going to the newspapers, he would see to it that I suffered a serious, possibly fatal ‘accident.’”

Two nights ago. The evening the bughouse Sherlock had summoned her to Huntington Park. He must have expected Sneed to come calling at the Montgomery mansion, perhaps even followed him there.

“And your answer then?” she asked.

“The same as before: no. I made him aware that I wasn’t afraid of him and cast him out.”

“Was that the truth? That you weren’t afraid of him?”

“Yes. I encountered more than a few men like Sneed in the mining camps. Full of bluff and bluster, but cowards at heart.”

This, and the rest of what Carson had said thus far, had the ring of truth. Sabina had watched him closely and he’d exhibited none of the telltale signs of the liar: no nervous gestures, or facial tics, or averted or too direct eye contact; no glib or overly earnest statements, no points glossed over or contradictory. But his innocence or guilt in the death of Artemas Sneed was yet to be determined.

Sabina was aware of water splashing in the fountain behind them, of the scents from the exotic blooms — her senses heightening as she pressed on with her questioning. “Did you see Sneed again after that night at your home?”

“No. I assume he gave up and crawled back into whatever hole he’s living in.”

“The Wanderer’s Rest on Davis Street.”

No reaction from Carson except mild surprise.

“You didn’t know he was lodging there?”

“No. It isn’t likely he’d want me to know.”

“That stick of yours,” Sabina said. “It wouldn’t happen to contain a removable steel shaft, would it?”

He blinked, taken aback by the apparent non sequitur. “You mean a sword cane? No, of course not.”

“Do you own such a stick?”

“No. I’ve never carried any weapon except a pistol, and that only during my time in the Mother Lode. What does a sword cane have to do with the matter at hand?”

“It’s the instrument that was used to kill Artemas Sneed.”

“To kill — Sneed is dead?”

“Run through in his room. Perhaps murdered, more likely killed in self-defense during a struggle. There was an unfired pistol in his hand.”

“My good Christ.” Carson’s astonishment, she was sure, was genuine. “How do you know all this, Sabina?”

“I have my sources.” She was not about to admit that she had discovered the body, or that she had failed to inform the police.

“And you think that I may have — No, I swear by all that’s holy, it wasn’t me. I’ve never been to Davis Street in my life.”

“Then you won’t mind telling me where you were between five and seven last evening.”

“Is that when Sneed was killed? I was at the Bank Exchange in the Montgomery Block, imbibing too many of Duncan Nichols’s Pisco Punches with three of my firm’s clients. If you’d like their names—”

Sabina shook her head. There was no need; Carson could not have a more credible alibi.

He said after a short silence, “Who did kill Sneed, I wonder?”

“It could be anyone. An ex-convict, would-be extortionist, and habitué of the Barbary Coast is sure to have made enemies, in and out of prison. The police may never find out.”

“Do they have my name?”

“No. Nor will they have it from me.”

“My part in the high-grading scheme … do you intend to tell the authorities about that?”

“You’ve given me no reason to. You had no direct role in the conspiracy, and you were responsible for the arrest and punishment of the perpetrators. Legally you couldn’t be prosecuted in any event. The statute of limitations on theft-related crimes is seven years. So you needn’t worry — as far as I’m concerned, your family’s good name and yours are secure.”

“I’m in your debt.” Then, “But what do you honestly think, Sabina? Do I deserve punishment for what I did?”

“You have been punished,” she said, “for the past eight years. I imagine you’ll continue to be for the rest of your days.”

“By my conscience, you mean.”

“Yes.”

“And rightly so.” He reached out in a tentative way to press fingertips against her arm, then withdrew his hand quickly as if afraid his touch might have offended her. “Your opinion of me matters a great deal,” he said. “I believe you know that. Have you lost feeling and respect for me, now that you know the truth about my past?”

Sabina looked into his blue, Stephen-like eyes and again felt none of the once-strong attraction. She said slowly, “That isn’t an easy question to answer.”

“Please be truthful. You don’t feel quite the same, do you?”

“Perhaps not.”

“And you’d rather not have anything more to do with me.”

“I can’t say right now, Carson. I do know I’d prefer not to attend the performance at the Baldwin tomorrow evening, or to share any more dinners in the immediate future.”

“I understand.”

There was nothing more to be said. They stood as one and without speaking left the Grand Court and then the hotel. At the bridge that spanned New Montgomery and connected with the Grand Hotel across the street, his parting smile was melancholy, his good-bye handshake weak, his step slow and ponderous as he left her. Watching after him, she couldn’t help wondering if this was the last she would ever see of Carson Montgomery.