Selby sat in Rex Brandon’s office. The door was locked. A copy of the evening Blade, still damp from the press, was spread out on Brandon’s desk.
Brandon said, “That other stuff was vicious, Doug. This attack is really deadly. It’s going to hurt. This is the stuff voters read, believe and fall for.”
Headlines streamed across the front page: SHERIFF AND D.A. FAKE RECOVERY OF JEWELRY TO HIDE INEFFICIENCY.
Brandon skimmed through the news account, turned to the editorial page, said, “Listen to this, Doug. Here’s the way Paden’s fighting now:
In a last desperate attempt to conceal their failure and presumably to try and detract from the credit due Otto Larkin for apprehending the Number One murder suspect in connection with the killing of Rose Furman, Doug Selby, the district attorney, and Rex Brandon, the sheriff, have perpetrated what is probably the greatest comic opera scheme of them all.
It has now been definitely established that these men went to a collector of antique jewelry and borrowed some pieces which would answer the description of the jewelry which was taken from the Lennox home in a burglary last Tuesday night.
They next sent for their staunch ally on The Clarion to be certain there would be plenty of favorable publicity, and then notified Moana Lennox that her jewelry had been recovered and asked her to come and identify it.
It happened that Moana Lennox, who had been prostrated by the shock of the burglary in addition to events indirectly connecting her family with the murder of Rose Furman, was unable to keep the appointment, but she knew that A. B. Carr, the distinguished lawyer who has seen fit to honor this city by making his home in our midst, was an expert on antique jewelry, an avid collector, and a shrewd appraiser.
It happened that Carr had seen Moana Lennox’s heirlooms and so she asked him to drop by the sheriff’s office and see if it would be possible to make an identification.
Not only did Carr fail to identify the jewelry as that of Moana Lennox, but to the discomfited surprise of the red-faced county officials, he made a positive identification of the jewelry as being a part of the collection of Stacy Bodega, the local jeweler who has for a long time made a hobby of collecting interesting bits of antique jewelry.
It was only the work of a few minutes to confirm the hoax which the officers had attempted to perpetrate in order to secure favorable publicity from a friendly newspaper. Stacy Bodega reluctantly admitted that the officials had borrowed this jewelry from him earlier in the day.
In the past, these officials have enjoyed the fawning support of a sycophant press, and favorable publicity has been lavished upon them in screaming headlines whenever they blundered upon any clues which automatically led to the solution of such crimes as they were investigating. One would have thought that these men were combinations of Sherlock Holmes and Solomon.
Then came the murder of Rose Furman, and the comedy of errors which resulted when the district attorney and the sheriff, starting out in their usual bungling way, attempted to muddle through.
Had the breaks been with them, it is probable that once more the subservient Clarion would have been screaming at the top of its vociferous lungs that the astute county officials once again had solved a murder which would have baffled any detectives other than those super-shrewd sleuths who are guarding over the destinies of Madison County.
As it was, Otto Larkin quietly, unostentatiously, and with no fanfare of trumpets, went out and solved that murder case. At least he has the prime Number One suspect in custody, and while it is not the policy of The Blade to attempt to try cases in the newspaper, or to anticipate what a jury may do, we will, nevertheless, state that the evidence which can be introduced, and which should be introduced by a special prosecutor appointed by the attorney general, will be damning.
Rex Brandon was probably a good cattleman. He should be back in the cattle business. There is some question as to whether Doug Selby possesses sufficient brains to make a living in private, competitive practice of law. Selby probably knows better than anyone else. And his own opinion is shown by his actions. Immediately on his return from the Army, he used the halo of his military service to plunge once more into the haven of a job where the taxpayers of this community would see that he enjoyed a fixed income.
It will be interesting to see what Doug Selby can actually do when he is retired to private life, because the chances that he will retain the office of the district attorney after the next election are figured by shrewd gamblers at about ten thousand to one.
Elsewhere in the news columns will be found the story of a meeting of the citizens for the purpose of petitioning the attorney general to send in a special prosecutor to relieve the unwilling and incompetent district attorney’s office of the prosecution of Dorothy Clifton, who is at present under arrest awaiting trial for the murder of Rose Furman.
An attempt by Selby’s sympathizers to stampede the meeting resulted in a disorderly exhibition of name calling which finally broke up with no definite action taken. But the citizens are grimly determined to see that something is done, and another mass meeting will be called in the near future where Selby sympathizers will be so far outnumbered there will be no opportunity for “packing” the meeting.
Brandon pushed the paper back, looked up, and said, “People like to be on the side of the winner, Doug. As long as The Blade adopts the position that we’re has-beens and also-rans, and can pour out that sort of propaganda, people are going to fall for it. The Blade will call another mass meeting within the next few days. They’ll manage to stampede a lot of people into petitioning the attorney general to send in a special prosecutor to handle the case against Dorothy Clifton.”
Selby nodded. “Of course that jewelry business backfired, Rex. I led with my chin. I wanted to get Moana where we could question her. I’m suspicious about that theft of the jewelry and... oh, well, the breaks went against me. I’m sorry I dragged you into it.”
“ ‘Dragged me in’ nothing,” Brandon said. “I was with you hand-in-glove. I felt certain it would be a good idea. It...”
The telephone rang. Brandon picked up the receiver. “Hello, Brandon talking,” then said, “Oh, hello. Yes, Sylvia... Yes, he’s right here... Okay, I’ll let you talk with him.”
Sylvia Martin’s voice came over the wire sharp with excitement. “Doug,” she said, “there’s something funny about this whole business. I went in to get an interview from Mrs. Kerry. She didn’t want to see me. When I finally got to her, she wouldn’t talk. I started intimating that I knew something, and believe me, Doug, she’s scared to death. I don’t know what it is, but she’s absolutely frightened stiff. She says Moana comes to see her whenever she’s upset. She insists that Moana was there last night and also spent the night with her a couple of months ago, but she’s white-faced, and her husband is definitely against the whole thing. He said that as far as he was concerned he had nothing to say, and he was gruff about it. Doug, there’s something, somewhere, that needs looking into in connection with this woman’s story. She’s covering up something.”
“Where are you now?” Selby asked.
“I’m still up here.”
“You’ve finished your interview?”
“It was finished for me. I was virtually thrown out on my ear.”
“Okay. Come on back,” Selby said. “I’m going to set off some fireworks and you may want to watch them.”
Selby hung up and said to Rex Brandon, “Okay, Rex. The way things are now we’re in just about as bad as we can get. Personally, I never won any battles remaining on the defensive.”
“What are you going to do?” Brandon asked.
Selby said, “Let’s look at it this way. Carr is mixed into this thing up one side and down the other. He’s supposed to know all about Moana Lennox’s jewelry because she showed it to him. All right, he knows about it. That means she showed it to him. How did it happen she showed it to him?”
“She knew he was interested in antique jewelry and...”
“Bunk!” Selby interrupted. “Carr’s interested in antique jewelry. Carr’s also interested in fees. Carr’s primarily interested in power. The reason Moana Lennox showed that jewelry to Carr is because she wanted Carr to do something for her and she didn’t have the money. So she turned the jewelry over to him and then, in order to account for its disappearance, cut the screen from the inside and, at what she considered was a propitious moment, started screaming.”
Brandon thought that over. “It could be, all right,” he said.
“Try to think of another explanation that covers the facts,” Selby challenged.
Brandon gave the matter thought, then said, “It’s a possibility, all right. But it’s something we’d never be able to prove.”
Selby said, “I’m tired of being on the defensive. I’m tired of sticking around here letting Carr snipe at me. I like him. I appreciate the man’s intelligence. He’s a genius. He’s also a crook. I believe he has that jewelry.”
“Wouldn’t he have disposed of it?”
“He wouldn’t dare to, because he must have known that Moana was going to claim it had been stolen. Therefore, if it should be located in a pawn shop, it could be traced back to him. As I see it, there’s a darn good chance that Carr has that jewelry and is going to hold it until after everything has blown over so it’ll be safe to dispose of it. That jewelry is Carr’s fee.”
“Gosh, if we could only prove something like that, Doug! But we can’t do it.”
“Why not?”
“A. B. C. would have covered his back trail. Moana would never talk. If we tried to reach her we’d run into a play just like we did when we...”
Selby got to his feet. “Okay, Rex. I’m going to break an egg.”
“Do what, Doug?”
Selby grinned. “There’s an old saying that you can’t make an omelette without breaking eggs. I’m going to make an omelette.”
“And the eggs you’re breaking?” Brandon asked.
“I’m personally going to hunt up a justice of the peace and get a search warrant. After all, the jewelry is supposed to be stolen.”
“Gosh, Doug, it’s too risky. If it’s a wrong guess we’d be liable for damages, and we’d be the laughingstock of...”
“Not we,” Selby said. “This is one thing you’re going to keep out of. I’m personally going to...”
Brandon pushed back his chair. “Who the hell do you think you’re talking to? I’m personally going to serve that warrant.”