The Dead Caller from Chicago

Sixty-two

“I should have figured it, by the way he tried to help Snark,” I said. “Your source was Tebbins, not Elvis Derbil.”

“He was a decent guy. He believed so long as the crime in Rivertown stayed small-time, the town could make a comeback.”

I signaled for two more Scotches, singles.

“Trying to get a lady drunk?” she asked.

“Trying to get a lady to understand how a painting could salve desperation.”

“Finally we get to talk about Leo?”

“So long as neither he nor Amanda appears in any of your accounts.”

The waiter came with the Scotch. After he left, I walked her through as much of the story as I’d ever admit.

I raised my drink, a third Scotch on top of the Rob Roy with dinner, and set it back down. The boundary had been tested enough for one night.

“You have questions at this point?” I asked.

“We’re agreed Robinson and Tebbins saw an epic war brewing in Rivertown,” she said, “and that’s why Tebbins contacted me in San Francisco. They saw themselves as the first foot soldiers in a war Rivertown wasn’t going to win.”

I nodded. “They were desperate; they wanted to stay alive. Then, by a stroke of what they could only think was good fortune, Cassone shows up, asking about that old painting Snark Evans stole. Tebbins and Robinson do some research, find out the painting they saw in Snark’s locker is now worth millions. Best of all, it might still be in Rivertown; Snark’s old buddy from the garage might still have it. Pretending to be Snark, they call Leo and hear him obviously lying.”

“Desperate times demand desperate measures, these two good men tell each other; they’re going to steal that painting, save their own lives, and leave town rich men in the bargain.” She shook her head softly, marveling.

“Then Leo goes into hiding, and I come around, out of the blue, asking about Snark Evans. Surely they thought I was on the trail of the painting, too.”

“Adding urgency to their mission,” she said, “but then Tebbins gets killed.”

“By Russians, Robinson and the rest of city hall naturally think, as pushback for stopping their construction. Someone at city hall, maybe Robinson, maybe someone else, retaliates by killing Kostanov and dumping him in the Willahock.”

“Now Robinson has to get out of town, fast,” she said. “He starts watching Leo’s house, maybe waiting for Leo to return, maybe just trying to determine the best way to break in.”

“He’s scared of the constant vigilance of that nosy neighbor,” I said.

“And who comes around? Rudy Cassone. Only one way Cassone could have known about Leo.”

“Cassone tortured it out of Tebbins.”

“He then sees you club Cassone and take something that’s wrapped like a painting back to your place, but you leave behind a bat that Robinson thinks may be useful later on,” she said.

“He grabs the bat, yes.”

“Now he switches to watching the turret, because that’s where the painting is now. Then, much later that same day, up drives Amanda Phelps?”

I nodded.

“She stayed the night?” Jenny’s eyes took on an intensity that didn’t have much to do with the story I was telling. Of course, that might have been the Scotch, setting me to thinking wishfully.

“A couple of hours,” I said, “just enough to examine the painting, but long enough for Robinson to think she fit into my life somehow. He grabbed her when she left and took her back to his place.”

“Hitting even more pay dirt when he went through her purse?”

“His original intent would have been to ransom her directly to me, for the painting. When he found out she was the daughter of one of the richest men in Chicago, he contacted Wendell Phelps instead, demanding not only that Wendell get the painting from me but that he throw in two million dollars as well. Then he continued watching me to make sure I turned over the painting to Wendell. I didn’t, though, because I didn’t yet know anything about the kidnapping. Instead, I met Cassone in a bar, and Robinson assumed I was about to turn over the painting to the mobster. He had to stop that. While I was buying painting supplies at the craft store, he followed Cassone from the bar, shot him, and then clubbed his corpse with the bat I’d left at Leo’s. It was perfect; I’d be the suspect.”

“The next morning, he sees you carry out a painting, tails you to Cassone’s place, and then watches you emerge some time later. He sees you give that painting to someone who he assumes is Wendell Phelps’s agent.”

“Jarobi; yes. Now all he has to do is get the painting from Wendell. Robinson then made up a story about his being followed.”

“Are you sure he made it up?”

“I thought he was trying to make himself appear as an innocent, perhaps even about to be a victim, so I wouldn’t look too closely at him. Now I think he might have been telling the truth. I think Mr. Red and Mr. Black were following him. Anyway,” I went on, “I messed up his plan. I started following him, thinking the tail might lead me to catching Amanda’s kidnapper.”

“Those pesky tattoed Russians again,” she said.

“Plus me, all of us intimidating, all of us on his tail at one point or another, though I think the Russians were only at it sporadically, just enough to make him nervous now and again.”

“Confluence all to hell,” she said. “He couldn’t arrange to exchange Amanda for the painting and the two million with you watching his every move.”

“Until I told him I was going out of town. That solved his biggest problem: me watching him. As soon as I headed to the airport, he called Wendell, probably from Wendell’s office garage, and told him to get the painting and the money ready immediately. Soon enough, Jarobi arrived with the painting, and Wendell put it in his trunk. Then, amazingly, Jarobi left and Wendell, ever the believer in his fortresslike Mercedes, went up to his office, leaving the painting untended in his trunk. Christmas had come. All Robinson had to do was jimmy the lock on Wendell’s car, press the trunk release, and grab the picture. He’d gladly forgo the two million if he could avoid the risk of getting caught at the exchange. The painting was what he really wanted.”

She’d finished her Scotch and reached for mine. “You messed that up, too?”

“I told him that somebody was watching him that morning and that I was back and on his tail. It must have been too much; people were watching him all the time. Instead of keeping him penned in his office, at least long enough for me to grab Amanda, it triggered him to flee. He raced home to grab the painting.”

“And discovered you escaping with Amanda? Why didn’t he just run at that point?” she asked. “Why take off after you and Amanda?”

“I can only assume that the gasoline I was sloshing down the stairs got onto the painting as well, and it caught fire. Now the two million, waiting at Wendell’s, mattered. He took off after us to get Amanda back.”

“Why paint a fake in the first place, Dek?”

“It wasn’t my place to hand over something Leo had hung on to all those years.”

“Speaking of loyalty,” she interrupted, “Amanda Phelps is appreciative?”

“Very. She went to Europe.”

“Ah?”

“No; not an ‘ah?’ as in a question. Amanda has moved on. I have moved on.”

“A man of free will,” she said.

“Totally unencumbered,” I said, answering what she hadn’t quite asked, adding, “Especially these past few hours.”

“Ah,” she said again, though this time without the lilt of a question.

There didn’t seem to be anything more to say, and we left. She decided I’d drive, since she’d finished my Scotch as well as her own. It would be some time before she’d get past her guilt over Mr. Black.

When we got to the outskirts of Rivertown, she asked me to drive down Leo’s block and stop in front of the excavation site.

“Leo heard it’s to be a park,” I said.

“I suppose that’s fitting,” she said. “Two men are buried there.”

I saw no need to correct her.