The Devil's Bones

CHAPTER 20

AFTER CALLING DEVRIESS, I HEADED TO CAMPUS. IT was early yet-not quite 7:30-and all the offices in the Anthropology Department were still dark and empty. Even the osteology lab, where Miranda often arrived by 7:00, remained locked. I was intrigued to find a vase of flowers-red roses-sitting in the stairwell just outside the lab’s door. A small card was nestled amid the flowers; the envelope was unsealed, so I slid out the card to see who was getting roses. I doubted that it was me, but then again, you never know.

“For Miranda,” the neat block letters read, “my new favorite.” Below the inscription was a drawing of a heart pierced by an arrow. I felt a pang of jealousy the moment I read the words. But what disturbed me more was the blood dripping from the heart and pooling beneath it.

An hour later, Miranda answered when I phoned the lab. She sounded jangled and edgy, and I wasn’t surprised. “I saw the flowers,” I said. “Who do you think sent them?”

“I don’t want to think about it,” she said. “It creeps me out.”

“Better to figure it out than not to know,” I said.

“You’re probably right,” she said, “but I hate to get upset about it, because that gives whoever it is more power over me than I want.” I didn’t say anything, and after a moment, she went on.

“I’m afraid it’s Stuart Latham,” she said. “He called yesterday, asking if I was involved with the investigation into Mary’s death.”

This revelation stunned me. “My god,” I said, “what did you tell him?”

“I told him I couldn’t discuss any forensic cases with him. But-true to form-he didn’t want to take no for an answer.” She laughed a brief, bitter laugh. “First he tried to charm me, and when that didn’t work, he played the grieving widower-the real victim in the case-and tried to guilt it out of me. Finally, when that didn’t work, he started getting mean.”

“How so? Did he threaten you in any way?” I felt my pulse getting faster and my blood pressure rising.

“No, nothing overt,” she said. “Just talking about how selfish and heartless I am.” She paused. “How I flirted with him and led him on back when I used to see them. How unhappy that made him realize he was in his marriage. How hard a time he’s had getting over the rejection.” She fell silent again, except for her breathing. From the sound of it, I wondered if she was crying. “The thing I’m ashamed of, Dr. B., is that I did flirt with him. I don’t know why. No, that’s not true; I do know. He was handsome, and he was a grown-up, and it was obvious that he was attracted to me. I think it was the seductiveness of being desired, you know?”

I did know; what surprised me was that Miranda knew, and that she’d found it out from the likes of Stuart Latham.

“Anyhow,” she said, “I never meant to cause trouble in their marriage, and I stopped flirting with him when I realized it was starting to.”

“So how did the phone call end?”

“Abruptly,” she said. “I told him never to call me again, and I hung up on him.”

“You think he sent the flowers as an apology?”

“Did you see the card?”

“Yes,” I admitted.

“Did that look like an apology?”

“If it was an apology,” I said, “it was a kinda scary one.”

“Kinda,” she said. “Like the pope is kinda Catholic.”

“Are you okay?”

“I will be,” she said. “Soon as I get a chance to take a long, hot shower and wash the scum off.”

“If he contacts you again, tell me,” I said. “We’ll call the campus police or KPD. The last thing he needs right now is to be any higher on the radar screen of the cops.”

She thanked me and hung up. From what she’d said, it sounded plausible that Stuart Latham had sent the flowers, and the possibility was troubling. Two other possibilities-two other suspects, as I thought of them-had occurred to me, and both of those were troubling as well.

One possibility was Edelberto Garcia, who I still feared might be interested in Miranda as more than a colleague or occasional babysitter. There was something about Garcia’s cool smoothness I didn’t fully trust, although I recognized that it might be jealousy rather than logic that lay behind my suspicions.

The other possibility was Garland Hamilton, and the thought that Hamilton might have sent Miranda the flowers chilled me to the bone. A few months before, Hamilton had locked his sights on Jess, and now Jess was dead. When I considered this possibility, I couldn’t help praying that the flowers had come from Stuart Latham.

By midmorning I was lost in the pages of the latest issue of the Journal of Forensic Sciences-one of my colleagues was fine-tuning a way to estimate age by studying cranial sutures-when I gradually became aware of a soft, insistent tapping sound and then a familiar voice saying, “Doc, mind if I come in?” I roused myself back to the present.

“Sorry. Sure, come on in.” I looked up at the same moment I placed the voice. Steve Morgan walked in, and the sight brought a smile to my face, despite the stress of the past two days. Steve was a TBI agent who’d been a student of mine years before; more recently he’d been part of a joint TBI-FBI investigation into official corruption in the Cooke County Sheriff’s Office.

“I hope you’re here to tell me y’all have caught Garland Hamilton,” I said.

He winced and shook his head. “I wish I were, but I’m not,” he said. “I think you’ll find this interesting, though. We’ve been watching his bank accounts and looking at his credit cards.”

“And?”

“We found a storage unit he rented about six months ago, and inside was something that belongs to you.” He stepped back into the hallway, then reappeared, cradling a cardboard box in his arms. The box was 36 inches long, 12 inches high, and 12 inches deep. I knew the exact dimensions because I had spent years putting skeletons into boxes just like this one. I had a pretty good idea whose skeleton was in this particular box, too: I’d have bet a year’s salary that the box contained the postcranial skeleton-the bones from the neck down-of Leena Bonds, a young woman killed in Cooke County thirty years earlier. I had recovered the woman’s body from deep in a cave in the mountains, where the combination of cool air and abundant moisture had transformed her soft tissue into adipocere, a soaplike substance that preserved her features remarkably well over the decades. Midway through the investigation into Leena’s murder, someone had broken into my office and stolen the box. That someone had been Garland Hamilton.

I motioned toward my desktop, and Morgan set the box down. I raised the lid, which was hinged along one of the three-foot sides. Inside, I saw the bones of a young white female, each bone bearing the case number in my writing. Two parts of the skeleton were missing, as I knew they would be: the skull and the hyoid, both of which I had taken to show my anthropology class the day the box was stolen. The woman’s skull-Leena’s skull-and the fractured hyoid bone from her throat had been buried eight months ago up in Cooke County by Jim O’Conner. O’Conner was now the county’s sheriff, but thirty years earlier he’d been simply a young man who loved Leena, when she was still an innocent girl. Before her uncle had molested her and her aunt had strangled her.

The bones took me back in time, the way the smell of baking bread or fresh-mown grass can take you back to your childhood. For me, seeing a skeleton was like reading a diary-a diary recording injuries, illnesses, handedness, and a host of other parts of life that remained written in the bones long after death. In the room that adjoined my office, I had a library full of such diaries-diaries of life and death. Every one was uniquely fascinating, and I always remembered its details. Every one was uniquely sad, too-Leena’s doubly so. I shook myself free of the memory and looked up at Morgan.

“Sorry,” I said. “I was just taking a quick trip down a dark stretch of memory lane.”

He nodded. “I understand,” he said. “Take your time.”

“I’m done,” I said. “You mentioned you were looking at Garland Hamilton’s credit-card receipts. Anything that points to where he is now?”

“No,” he said. “The storage-unit rental was about six months ago, and he paid for a whole year up front. Latest activity”-he hesitated-“was a couple hours after he escaped. A security camera at a SunTrust ATM on Hill Avenue shows him using the cash machine. He got a four-hundred-dollar cash advance and four hundred dollars out of checking. The most the machine would let him get.”

“Where’d he get the cards?”

“I don’t know,” said Morgan. “He didn’t have them in jail, so he must have had them stashed someplace safe and easy to get to. Maybe the storage unit.”

“Weren’t his accounts frozen?”

Morgan shook his head. “If he were bankrolling international terrorism or embezzling millions, the feds would freeze his accounts. Otherwise there’s no legal basis for it. He won’t get real far on eight hundred bucks, but it lets him drop off the radar at least for a while.”

“Any idea where he might be? You think he’s staying put, or do you think he’s on the run?”

Morgan frowned. “Hard to tell. Typically, escaped murderers run, but he’s not typical. He’s smarter than most, and he knows how cops think.”

“So he might run after all,” I said. “Figuring that you guys would expect him not to.”

“Hell, you can chase your tail in circles second-and third-guessing that way. Doesn’t get you anything except dizzy, though. His picture’s all over the media, and we’ve sent an APB to every law-enforcement agency in the country. We’ll get him.”

“I hope sooner rather than later,” I said.

“It’ll be sooner,” he said. “Meantime, though, I was wondering-have you thought about carrying a gun?”

“Me? A gun? When I’m out in the field, I’m generally on all fours, with my butt sticking up in the air.” The description got a laugh from Morgan. “What good would a gun do me?”

“I meant for when you’re not in the field,” he said. “When you’re in the office, or at home. I know you’re not a gun-totin’ kind of guy. But maybe for now, till we catch him.”

In fact, I had already considered it. “You think I’m in danger?” I asked.

He considered that. “Depends on which matters more to Hamilton,” he said, “getting away or getting even. He already tried to kill you once. He might consider that unfinished business-a score he’s got another chance to settle, now that he’s on the loose.”

“Gee, this is making me feel better,” I said.

“I’m not trying to scare you,” he said. “I’m just being realistic. Get a weapon. Hell, you’re a TBI consultant; I’m sure we can get you a permit. We’d just need to take you out to the firing range and get you qualified.”

“Damn,” I said. “I hate this. But if you can make it happen, I’ll do it.”

“Good,” he said. “I’ll see what hoops we need to jump through. And I’ll let you know as soon as we find anything on Hamilton.” He shook my hand and turned to go. “Be careful,” he said.

“Sure.”

After Morgan left, I picked up the phone and dialed.

“Cooke County Sheriff,” said a brisk voice in an East Tennessee twang. “Kin I hep you’uns?”

“Yes, ma’am. I’m wondering if the sheriff’s in.”

“Kin I tell him who’s calling?”

“It’s Dr. Bill Brockton from UT.”

“I’ll tell him, hon,” she said. I felt like I was in a truck-stop café rather than on the phone with a law-enforcement agency.

“Hang on, if you don’t care to.” The expression-which actually meant “if you don’t mind”-made me smile.

Ten seconds later, I heard Jim O’Conner’s voice. “Doc, you all right? I hear things have gotten exciting down there.”

“I’ve had better times, but I’m okay,” I said.

“I’m sorry he’s loose.”

“Not half as sorry as I am,” I said. “Listen, you gonna be around late this afternoon?”

“Should be,” he said. “Unless somebody does some spectacular lawbreaking up here in Cooke County. Which,” he added, “is always a distinct possibility.”

“Mind if I come see you?”

“Come on up. Any particular occasion?”

“Got something to show you,” I said.

“I’ll be here. You remember how to find us?”

“Sure,” I said. “Drive east till civilization ends, then follow the sound of the gunfire.”

He laughed. “Yup, you remember. If something comes up and I can’t be here, I’ll give you a call.”

“Same here,” I said. “It’ll be good to see you, Jim.”

“Be good to see you, too, Doc.”

TWO HOURS later and fifty miles to the east, I took the I-40 exit for River Road, the winding, two-lane blacktop that snaked along a tumbling mountain river and into Jonesport, the county seat of Cooke County.

The sheriff’s office was tucked into a granite courthouse that looked more like a small fortress than a seat of county government. As I parked, I noticed a couple of stoop-shouldered whittlers occupying a bench on the courthouse lawn. Shavings were heaped almost knee-high between the feet of each man. I had seen these same whittlers on that same bench in the exact same postures some nine months earlier when I’d been up in Cooke County. I wondered if they had even left their post, or were they permanent fixtures, like the Civil War cannon and the statue of Obadiah Jones, the town’s founder and namesake? I tucked the box of Leena’s bones under one arm. As I passed the bench, I lifted my other hand in greeting. Neither man spoke or waved, but there was a flicker of eye contact and the barest hint of a nod from each aged head, and both pairs of eyes swiveled to the box under my arm.

“That’s a mighty good pile of shavings you-all got there,” I said. “Just be careful you don’t drop a lit match. I’d hate to have to come identify your burned bones.”

“Is them bones you got in that box?” one of the men asked.

“From that Kitchings girl?” asked the other.

“She weren’t a Kitchings,” corrected the first one. “She were a Bonds.”

“Bonds. I knowed that,” said his friend. “I just disremembered.”

“Are them bones? That Bonds girl’s bones?” persisted the first one.

“You’d need to ask the sheriff about that,” I said.

“Sheriff’s inside,” said Whittler Number Two.

“Is he doing a pretty good job cleaning up the county?” I asked.

“View from here is pretty much the same all the time,” said the first whittler. “Don’t too many folks commit their crimes right here in front of the courthouse.”

The second one laughed, exposing toothless gums. “They was a lot of crime going on inside the courthouse,” he said.

The first one wheezed out a chuckle at that.

“Course we didn’t know about some of it at the time. New sheriff might be doing stuff we don’t know about neither.”

“I don’t think so,” I said. “Jim O’Conner isn’t that kind of guy. Anyway, I’d best get in. Y’all don’t cut yourselves.” They nodded, bent low over their whittling again.

Jim O’Conner’s head was barely visible behind the immense pile of papers, files, and folders on his desk. I knocked on the door. He raised up, peering over the stack.

“Thank goodness,” he said. “This paperwork’s driving me nuts, and I was desperate for a break. Come on in.”

“Not quite how I imagined I’d find you,” I said. “Figured you’d be out chasing thieves and bootleggers and poachers and such things.”

“Well, the job is mostly administrative,” he said. “Got training logs to fill out, grant requests to write, grant reports to write, court cases to get ready for, hiring requisitions.”

“You’re hiring? Business booming?”

“Well,” he said, “we didn’t have many people to start with. I had to let some of them go, ’cause they were sort of in Orbin Kitchings’s vein,” he said. “Law enforcement for personal profit.”

I grimaced at the mention of the name. Orbin Kitchings had been the county’s chief deputy, and he’d used his badge and his authority to commit crimes with impunity. I’d never forget the interaction I witnessed between Orbin and a small-time marijuana farmer-the deputy had extorted money from the man and had cruelly shot the poor fellow’s dog.

“I’m not surprised you’re having trouble with that,” I said.

“It’s a small county, with a frontier mentality. The line between the good guys and the bad guys gets kind of fuzzy sometimes, especially when money’s involved.”

“Oh, I didn’t mean to be rude,” O’Conner said. “Here, let me clear a spot for you to sit down.” He stood up and came around the desk to remove another stack of papers and files from the one chair in the office. That’s when he saw the box. He looked from the box up to my face, just as I’d done when Steve Morgan brought it into my office at UT. I read the question in his eyes. “Is that what I think it is?”

“Yeah,” I said. “TBI found this when they were searching a storage unit Garland Hamilton had rented.”

The sheriff sucked in a deep breath and blew it out, then started grabbing armfuls of folders and setting them in the corner.

After he’d cleared off one end of the desk, I set the box down and stepped back to give him space, physically and emotionally. He reached out, folded up the lid, and eyed the bones with a mixture of sorrow and tenderness that thirty years seemed to have done little to diminish. One by one, he picked up the bones and turned them over in his hands. A femur. A hip bone. A handful of ribs. His eyes got a faraway look in them.

“Funny thing,” he said. “She’s been gone so long. These bones aren’t her, but they were her. Part of her, anyhow. I couldn’t pick these out of a lineup. I mean, I can’t tell one skeleton from another. But because you say this is her, I know it’s true, and that brings the whole thing back. Does that sound strange?”

“Not at all,” I said. “I’ve seen hundreds of people react this way. We humans seem to have a deep need for closure when somebody we love dies. That’s why when a child goes missing, the parent can never finish their grieving unless or until the body’s found. We want our stories to have endings, even if the endings break our hearts.”

He didn’t say anything, but he nodded, his eyes glistening. Then he noticed the paper bag nestled in one end of the box. He hesitated, but only briefly, then unrolled the top and peered inside. He looked up at me and said, “Do you mind?”

I picked up the bag and gently tipped its contents into his cupped hands: the tiny bones of a half-formed baby, which Leena had been carrying when she was killed. The biggest of the bones, the femur, was smaller than a chicken drumstick. “Damn it, Doc,” he said. “I don’t know who to hate more, her aunt for killing her or her uncle for getting her pregnant.”

“I’m not sure there’s a lesser of those two evils,” I said. “And it probably doesn’t change the equation that the uncle’s dead and the aunt’s in prison.”

“Not a bit.”

“You said a while back that if we ever recovered these bones, you’d like to bury them with the skull. You still feel that way?”

He nodded.

“What about the fetal bones-do you want to bury those with Leena’s bones?”

“Of course,” he said. “This was Leena’s baby.” He paused.

“Even if it was fathered by a hypocritical, abusive son of a bitch.”

“Yeah,” I said.

He drew another deep breath and then shook himself. He looked at the clock on the wall over his door. “I’m thinking maybe that now would be a good time to call it a day,” he said. “It’s after five, and I don’t think my heart’s in this paperwork anymore for today. You got to hurry right back to Knoxville?”

“I’m not in a big rush,” I said.

“Come on up to the farmhouse with me.”

“I was hoping you’d ask.”

“You want to ride with me, or would you rather follow me up?”

“I’ll follow you,” I said. “That way you don’t have to drive me back to town.”

We walked out together, past the bench, past the whittlers. This time O’Conner had the box of bones under his arm.

“Evening, Sheriff,” said Whittler Number One. Either O’Conner ranked higher in their esteem than I did or they were sufficiently curious to speak first.

“Evening, fellas,” he said.

“Are them there that girl’s bones?”

O’Conner didn’t say anything at first. I could see a couple of different emotions working in his face, then it smoothed out, and he said, “Yes, sir. They are. We’re going to give her a decent burial finally.”

“That’s good,” said the old man. “That was a shame what them Kitchingses done to her. She deserves a decent burial.”

“You all have a good evening,” said O’Conner. “I’ll see you in the morning.”

“Night, Sheriff,” the two men chorused together.

O’Conner placed the box in the backseat of a black-and-white Jeep Cherokee that had a seven-pointed star on the side.

I got into my truck, and together we backtracked along River Road a couple of miles back toward I-40, then turned up a gravel road through dense forest, along a small stream that fed into the river on the other side of the blacktop. My first trip up this gravel road, I’d been blindfolded and bound with duct tape-shanghaied by a giant mountain man named Waylon-and brought up this road to see Jim O’Conner. I hadn’t known what lay along either side of the gravel at the time. My second trip up, I’d been able to see, and I had seen the gravel end at a wall of vegetation-or seem to end. In fact, it plunged beneath a cascade of kudzu vines. We had snaked through a tunnel of kudzu and then emerged into a small hanging valley, where O’Conner was conducting a secret experiment in agriculture. Not marijuana, as I had suspected at one point, but ginseng: he’d found a way to replicate wild black ginseng, the sort prized by poachers, the sort that commanded top dollar in Chinese markets. This trip, I noticed that the road had recently been regraveled. It looked slightly wider, and a film of dust on the weeds alongside hinted at heavy traffic. When we got to the kudzu tunnel, I saw that the vines hiding the tunnel’s mouth had been cut back, transfering what had once been a secret entrance to O’Conner’s little valley into a shaded arbor. The vines had been thinned, which took some frequent attention, I knew, given kudzu’s prodigious ability to grow by several feet a day. Sunlight filtered through. It still wasn’t cool under here, but it was a brief respite from the baking sun of the late-summer afternoon. When we emerged out the other side, into a large clearing with a frame farmhouse at one end, I was surprised at the transformation. Half a dozen vehicles, pickup trucks, and late-model cars were tucked into a small parking lot of gravel. The kudzu vines that had wrapped the back of the house-forming another tunnel connecting with the giant ginseng patch-had also been trimmed back, and the house had been freshly painted. I saw a small satellite dish and junction boxes, where underground telephone wires and television cable emerged from the ground.

As I got out, I said to O’Conner, “I see you’ve made some changes around here.”

He smiled. “A few,” he said. “My cover was blown, so I figured we needed to go ahead and get into the market with this fall’s crop, which’ll be our first. We took some samples to buyers, and we’ve got contracts for all we can produce. Should be several thousand pounds of top-grade ginseng root. We’re not getting quite what the poachers get for the stuff from the national park,” he said, “but close. If we can keep things from drying out in the heat of the summer, we should have several thousand pounds, at almost two hundred dollars a pound.”

I did the math. “So you’re looking at six figures?”

“Should be,” he said. “Seven if we get real lucky. But you know what? It doesn’t matter all that much. It’s been an interesting experiment. Maybe it’ll help lessen the demand for the poached ’sang, which would be good. And I’ve got half a dozen people working for me, doing honest jobs, which is also a good thing here in Cooke County. But I don’t really need the money, so if this doesn’t work, I’m not hurting.”

I laughed. “Yeah, I know how big that sheriff’s paycheck is,” I said.

“Well, yeah, I’m not gonna get rich off that,” he said. “But I’ve got almost no overhead, apart from the ginseng operation here. My car’s provided. I’ve long since owned this farm outright. I live like a monk when I’m not at work. Hell, I don’t even spend everything the county pays me.”

“You sound like a man whose life is in balance,” I said. “Of course, even when you looked like an outlaw, you seemed pretty balanced and content.”

“It took me a while to get there,” he said. “But yeah. I mean, you are who you are, you aren’t what you do.”

He motioned me up toward the wide wooden porch, where a pair of weathered wooden rocking chairs sat side by side, like an old couple.

“Come on up,” he said. “Sit a spell. You want some iced tea?” I nodded.

The wooden screen door had been freshly painted, too, but the spring still creaked when O’Conner pulled it open. He grinned.

“Always did like that sound,” he said. “The guys working on the house replaced the old spring with a new one that didn’t make any noise. I made them take the new spring off and put the old one back on.”

O’Conner disappeared, then emerged from the kitchen several minutes later, bearing two tall ceramic tumblers. The one he handed me was ice cold and frosted at the top-fresh from the freezer. I took a sip. I’d had O’Conner’s hot ginseng tea once before, but never iced ginseng. I liked it cold. It had the slightly earthy, tangy taste I’d remembered, and hints of honey, plus maybe a little fruit juice in it, too.

“It’s good,” I said. “You ought to bottle this stuff.”

He smiled. “It’s in the business plan-year two,” he said.

“You’ve got a good head for business, Doc.”

I took another sip. “No, I just know something tasty when I get a swig of it,” I said.

O’Conner sat in the other chair and began to rock in time with me. A small end table separated the rockers, a remote control rested on the table. O’Conner pressed a button on the remote, and a ceiling fan stirred a breeze down onto us.

“Another new addition,” I said.

“Yeah,” he said. “Usually there’s a pretty good breeze, but this summer’s been so hot I finally broke down and hauled in some technology. I can’t remember how I did without it. I got a house in town now, but sometimes, if the night’s not too hot, I’ll come up here and sleep on the porch.” He opened a drawer in the end table and pulled out a small silver flask. “You want a little nip of Jack in there?” he said.

“No thanks,” I said.

“That’s right, you don’t drink,” he said. “You mind if I add a little nip to mine?”

“Go right ahead,” I said. “I’m not sure you’ll be helping the taste any, but you probably know what you’re doing.”

“I’ve done rigorous experiments,” he said. “I think I’ve perfected the ratio.” He poured in a small splash-it couldn’t have been more than an ounce-then screwed the cap back on the flask and replaced the flask in the drawer. “Different,” he said, taking a sip and assessing it. “But mighty good.”

“You gonna bottle that version, too?” I asked.

He laughed. “Year three. Good thing I’m not trying to keep any trade secrets from you.”

We rocked until sundown, and beyond, the sheriff and I. As the daylight dwindled, so did our words, and the night wrapped us in a blanket of comfortable silence. After a while I realized that Jim and I were not the only two people present on the porch. Leena Bonds-Jim’s murdered love-was with us, too, somewhere in the darkness beyond him. So was Jess Carter, I realized-with me in the way that everyone you ever love remains with you, no matter what happens to either of you.

As the rockers creaked and the stars came out, I felt the pain and the fear inside me subside. In their place, I was amazed to find-at least for this moment-peace and a feeling I could only have described as quiet, unexpected joy.