The Goblin Reservation

“No. I just see him around at times. But I’d like to meet him. And that is the Ghost?”

“The two are inseparable,” said Maxwell.

“Well, let’s go over, then.”

“We can say hello and go somewhere else.”

“Not on your life,” she said. “This place looks interesting.”

“You’ve never been here before?”

“I’ve never dared,” she said.

“I’ll break the path,” he told her.

He forged slowly among the tables, trailed by the girl and cat.

Alley Oop lunged out into the aisle to meet him, flung his arms around him, hugged him, then grasped him by the shoulders and thrust him out at arm’s length to stare into his face.

“You are Old Pete?” he asked. “You aren’t fooling us?”

“I am Pete,” said Maxwell. “Who do you think I am?”

“Well, what I want to know then,” said Oop, “is who it was we buried three weeks ago last Thursday. Both me and Ghost were there. And you owe us twenty bucks refund on the flowers we sent. That is what they cost us.”

“Let us sit down,” said Maxwell.

“Afraid of creating a scene,” said Oop. “This place is made for scenes. There are fist fights every hour on schedule and there’s always someone jumping up on a table and making a speech.”

“Oop,” said Maxwell, “there is a lady present and I want you to tame down and get civilized. Miss Carol Hampton, and this great oaf is Alley Oop.”

“I am delighted to meet you, Miss Hampton,” said Alley Oop. “And what is that you have there with you? As I live and breathe, a saber-toother! I’ll have to tell you about the time, during a blizzard, I sought shelter in a cave and this big cat was there and me with nothing but a dull stone knife. I had lost my club, you see, when I met the bear, and-”

“Some other time,” said Maxwell. “At least, let us sit down. We are hungry. We don’t want to get thrown out.”

“Pete,” said Alley Oop, “it is a matter of some large distinction to be heaved out of this joint. You ain’t arrived socially until you’ve been thrown out of here.”

But, muttering under his breath, he led the way back to the table and held a chair for Carol. Sylvester planted himself between Maxwell and Carol, propped his chin on the table and glared balefully at Oop.

“That cat don’t like me,” Oop declared. “Probably he knows how many of his ancestors I wiped out back in the Old Stone Age.”

“He’s only a bio-mech,” said Carol. “He couldn’t possibly.”

“I don’t believe a word of it,” said Oop. “That critter is no bio-mech. He’s got the dirty meanness in his eyes all saber-toothers have.”

“Please, Oop,” said Maxwell. “Just a moment, please. Miss Hampton, this gentleman is Ghost. A long-time friend of mine.”

“I am pleased to meet you, Mr. Ghost,” said Carol.

“Not Mister,” said Ghost. “Just plain Ghost. That is all I am. And the terrible thing about it is that I don’t know who I am the ghost of. I’m most pleased to meet you. It is so comfortable with four around the table. There is something nice and balanced in the number four.”

“Well,” said Oop, “now that we know one another, leave us proceed to business. Let us do some drinking. It’s lonesome for a man to drink all by himself. I love Ghost, of course, for his many sterling qualities, but I hate a man who doesn’t drink.”

“You know I can’t drink,” said Ghost. “Nor eat, either. Or smoke. There’s not much a ghost can do. But I wish you wouldn’t keep pointing it out to everyone we meet.”

Oop said to Carol, “You seem to be surprised that a barbaric Neanderthaler can sling the language around with the facility I command.”

“Not surprised,” said Carol. “Astounded.”

“Oop,” Maxwell told her, “has soaked up more education in the last twelve years than most ordinary men. Started out virtually in kindergarten and now is working on his doctorate. And the thing about it is that he intends to keep right on. He is, you might say, one of our most notable professional students.”

Oop raised his arm and waved it, bellowing at a waiter. “Over here,” he shouted. “There are people here who wish to patronize you. All dying of slow thirst.”

“The thing,” said Ghost, “I have always admired about him is his shy, retiring nature.”

“I keep on studying,” said Oop, “not so much that I hunger after knowledge as for the enjoyment I get from the incredulous astonishment on the faces of those stuffed-shirt professors and those goofy students. Not,” he said to Maxwell, “that I maintain all professors are stuffed shirts.”

“Thank you,” Maxwell said.

“There are those who seem to think,” said Oop, “that Homo sapiens neanderthalensis can be nothing other than a stupid brute. After all, he became extinct, he couldn’t hold his own-which in itself is prime evidence that he was very second-rate. I’m afraid that I’ll continue to devote my life to proving-”

The waiter appeared at Oop’s elbow. “It’s you again,” he said. “I might have known when you yelled at me. You have no breeding, Oop.”

“We have a man here,” Oop told him, ignoring the insult, “who has come back from the dead. I think it would be fitting that we should celebrate his resurrection with a flourish of good fellowship.”

“You want something to drink, I take it.”

“Why,” said Oop, “don’t you simply bring a bottle of good booze, a bucket ofice and four-no, three glasses. Ghost doesn’t drink, you know.”

“I know,” the waiter said.

“That is,” said Oop, “unless Miss Hampton wants one of these fancy drinks?”

“Who am I,” asked Carol, “to gum up the works? What is it you are drinking?”

“Bourbon,” said Oop. “Pete and I have a lousy taste in liquor.”

“Bourbon let it be,” said Carol.

“I take it,” said the waiter, “that when I lug the bottle over here, you’ll have the cash to pay for it. I remember the time-”

“Whatever I may lack,” said Oop, “will be forthcoming from Old Pete.”

“Pete?” the waiter glanced at Maxwell.

“Professor!” he exclaimed. “I had heard that you…”

“That’s what I been trying to tell you,” said Oop. “That’s what we’re celebrating. He came back from the dead.”

“But I don’t understand.”

“You don’t need to,” said Oop. “Just rustle up the booze.”

The waiter scurried off.

“And now,” said Ghost to Maxwell, “please tell us what you are. You are no ghost, apparently, or if you are, there’s been a vast improvement in procedure since the man I represent shuffled off his mortal coil.”

“It seems,” Maxwell told them, “that I’m a split personality. One of me, I understand, got in an accident and died.”

“But that’s impossible,” said Carol. “Split personality in the mental sense-sure, that can be understood. But physically…”

“There’s nothing in heaven or earth,” said Ghost, “that is impossible.”

“That’s a bad quotation,” said Oop, “and, besides, you misquoted it.”

He put a hand to his hairy chest and scratched vigorously with blunt fingers.

“You needn’t look so horrified,” he said to Carol. “I itch. I’m a brute creature of nature, therefore I scratch. And I’m not naked, either. I have a pair of shorts on.”

“He’s housebroken,” said Maxwell, “but just barely.”

“To get back to this split personality,” said the girl, “can you tell us what actually did happen?”

“I set out for one of the Coonskin planets,” said Maxwell, “and along the way somehow my wave pattern duplicated itself and I wound up in two places.”

“You mean there were two Pete Maxwells?”

“That’s the way of it.”

“If I were you,” said Oop, “I’d sue them. These Transportation people get away with murder. You could shake them down for plenty. Me and Ghost could testify for you. We went to your funeral.

“As a matter of fact,” he said, “I think Ghost and I should sue as well. For mental anguish. Our best friend cold and rigid in his casket and us prostrate with grief.”

“We really were, you know,” said Ghost.

“I have no doubt of it,” said Maxwell.

“I must say,” said Carol, “that all three of you take it rather lightly. Here one good friend of three-”

“What do you want of us?” demanded Oop. “Sing hallelujahs, perhaps? Or bug out our eyes and be filled with the wonder of it? We lost a pal and now he’s back again and-”

“But one of him is dead!”

“Well,” said Oop, “as far as we were concerned, there was never more than one of him. And maybe this is better. Imagine the embarrassing situations that could develop if there were two of him.”

Carol turned to Maxwell. “And you?” she asked.

He shook his head. “In a day or two, I’ll take some serious thought of it. Right now, I guess, I’m putting off thinking about it. To tell you the truth, when I do think about it, I get a little numb. But tonight a pretty girl and two old friends and a great big pussy cat and a bottle of liquor to get rid of and later on some food.”

He grinned at her. She shrugged.

“I never saw such a crazy bunch,” she said. “I believe I like it.”

“I like it, too,” said Oop. “Say whatever you will of it, this civilization of yours is a vast improvement over the days of yore. It was the luckiest day of my life when a Time team snatched me hence just at the point when some of my loving brother tribesmen were about to make a meal of me. Not that I blame them particularly, you understand. It had been a long, hard winter and the snow was deep and the game had been very scarce. And there were certain members of the tribe who felt they had a score or two to settle with me-and I’ll not kid you; they may have had a score. I was about to be knocked upon the head and, so to speak, dumped into the pot.”

“Cannibalism!” Carol said, horrified.

“Why, naturally,” he told her. “In those rough and ready days, it was quite acceptable. But, of course, you wouldn’t understand. You’ve never been really hungry, I take it. Gut hungry. So shriveled up with hunger-”

He halted his talk and looked around.

“The thing that is most comforting about this culture,” he declared, “is the abundance of the food. Back in the old days we had our ups and downs. We’d bag a mastodon and we’d eat until we vomited and then we’d eat some more and-”

“I doubt,” Ghost said warningly, “that this is a proper subject for dinner conversation.”

Oop glanced at Carol.

“You must say this much for me,” he insisted. “I’m honest. When I mean vomit, I say vomit and not regurgitate.”

The waiter brought the liquor, thumping the bottle and the ice bucket down upon the table.

“You want to order now?” he asked.

“We ain’t decided yet,” said Oop, “if we’re going to eat in this crummy joint. It’s all right to get liquored up in, but-”

“Then, sir,” the waiter said, and laid down the check.

Oop dug into his pockets and came up with cash. Maxwell pulled the bucket and the bottle close and began fixing drinks.

“We’re going to eat here, aren’t we?” asked Carol. “If Sylvester doesn’t get that steak you promised him, I don’t know what will happen. He’s been so patient and so good, with the smell of all the food…”

“He’s already had one steak,” Maxwell pointed out. “How much can he eat?”

“An unlimited amount,” said Oop. “In the old days one of them monsters would polish off an elk in a single sitting. Did I ever tell you-”

“I am sure you have,” said Ghost.

“But that was a cooked steak,” protested Carol, “and he likes them raw.

Besides, it was a small one.”

“Oop,” said Maxwell, “get that waiter back here. You are good at it. You have the voice for it.”

Oop signaled with a brawny arm and bellowed. He waited for a moment, then bellowed once again, without results.

“He won’t pay attention to me,” Oop growled. “Maybe it’s not our waiter. I never am able to tell them monkeys apart. They all look alike to me.”

“I don’t like the crowd tonight,” said Ghost. “I have been watching it.

There’s trouble in the air.”

“What is wrong with it?” asked Maxwell.

“There are an awful lot of creeps from English Lit. This is not their hangout. Mostly the crowd here are Time and Supernatural.”

“You mean this Shakespeare business?”

“That might be it,” said Ghost.

Maxwell handed Carol her drink, pushed another across the table to Oop.

“It seems a shame,” Carol said to Ghost, “not to give you one. Couldn’t you even sniff it, just a little?”

“Don’t let it bother you,” said Oop. “The guy gets drunk on moonbeams. He can dance on rainbows. He has a lot of advantages you and I don’t have. For one thing, he’s immortal. What could kill a ghost?”

“I’m not sure of that,” said Ghost.

“There’s one thing that bothers me,” said Carol. “You don’t mind, do you?”

“Not at all,” said Ghost.

“It’s this business of your not knowing who you are the ghost of. Is that true or is it just a joke?”

“It is true,” said Ghost. “And I don’t mind telling you, it’s embarrassing and confusing. But I’ve just plain forgotten. From England -that much, at least, I know. But the name I can’t recall. I would suspect most other ghosts-”

“We have no other ghosts,” said Maxwell. “Contacts with other ghosts, of course, and conversations and interviews with them. But no other ghost has ever come to live with us. Why did you do it, Ghost-come to live with us.”

“He’s a natural chiseler,” said Oop. “Always figuring out the angles.”

“You’re wrong there,” Maxwell said. “It’s damned little we can do for

Ghost.”

“You give me,” said Ghost, “a sense of reality.”

“Well, no matter what the reason,” said Maxwell, “I am glad you did it.”

“The three of you,” said Carol, “have been friends for a long, long time.”

“And it seems strange to you?” asked Oop.

“Well, yes, maybe it does,” she said. “I don’t know really what I mean.”

Sounds of scuffling came from the front of the place. Carol and Maxwell turned around in their chairs to look in the direction from which the scuffling came, but there wasn’t much that one could see.

A man suddenly loomed on top of the table and began to sing:

Hurrah for Old Bill Shakespeare;

He never wrote them plays;

He stayed at home, and chasing girls, Sang dirty rondelays

Jeers and catcalls broke out from over the room and someone threw something that went sailing past the singer. Part of the crowd took up the song:

Hurrah for Old Bill Shakespeare;

He never wrote them…

Someone with a bull voice howled: “To hell with Old Bill Shakespeare!”

The room exploded into action. Chairs went over. There were other people on top of tables. Shouts reverberated and there was shoving and pushing. Fists began to fly. Various items went sailing through the air.

Maxwell sprang to his feet, reached out an arm and swept it back, shoving Carol behind him. Oop came charging across the tabletop with a wild war whoop. His foot caught the bucket and sent the ice cubes flying.

“I’ll mow ’em down,” he yelled at Maxwell. “You pile ’em to one side!”

Maxwell saw a fist coming at him out of nowhere and ducked to one side, bringing his own fist up in a vicious jab, hitting out at nothing, but aiming in the direction from which the fist had come. Over his shoulder came Oop’s brawny arm, with a massive fist attached. It smacked into a face with a splattering sound and out beyond the table a figure went slumping to the floor.

Something heavy and traveling fast caught Maxwell behind the ear and he went down. Feet surged all around him. Someone stepped on his hand. Someone fell on top of him. Above him, seemingly from a long ways off, he heard Oop’s wild whooping.

Twisting around, he shoved off the body that had fallen across him and staggered to his feet.

A hand grabbed him by the elbow and twisted him around.

“Let’s get out of here,” said Oop. “Someone will get hurt.”

Carol was backed against the table, bent over, with her hands clutching the scruff of Sylvester’s neck. Sylvester was standing on his hind legs and pawing the air with his forelegs. Snarls were rumbling in his throat and his long fangs gleamed.

“If we don’t get him out of here,” said Oop “that cat will get his steak.”

He swooped down and wrapped an arm around the cat, lifting him by the middle, hugging him tight against his chest.

“Take care of the girl,” Oop told Maxwell. “There’s a back door around here somewhere. And don’t leave that bottle behind. We’ll need it later on.”

Maxwell reached out and grabbed the bottle.

There was no sign of Ghost.

“I’m a coward,” Ghost confessed. “I admit that I turn chicken at the sight of violence.”

“And you,” said Oop, “the one guy in the world no one can lay a mitt on.”

They sat at the rude, square, rickety table that Oop once, in a moment of housekeeping energy, had knocked together from rough boards. Carol pushed away her plate. “I was starved,” she said, “but not any more.”

“You’re not the only one,” said Oop. “Look at our putty cat.”

Sylvester was curled up in front of the fireplace, his bobbed tail clamped down tight against his rump, his furry paws covering his nose. His whiskers stirred gently as his breath went in and out.

“That’s the first time in my life,” said Oop, “I ever saw a saber-toother have more than he could eat.”

He reached out for the bottle and shook it. It had an empty sound. He lumbered to his feet and went across the floor, knelt and raised a small door set into the floor, reaching down with his arm and searching in the space underneath the door. He brought up a glass fruit jar and set it to one side. He brought up a second fruit jar and set it beside the first. Finally he came up triumphantly with a bottle.

He put the fruit jars back and closed the door. Back at the table, he snapped the sealer off the bottle and reached out to pour drinks.

“You guys don’t want ice,” he said. “It just dilutes the booze. Besides, I haven’t any.”

He jerked a thumb back toward the door hidden in the floor. “My cache,” he said. “I keep a jug or two hid out. Some day I might break a leg or something and the doc would say I couldn’t drink…”

“Not with a broken leg,” said Ghost. “No one would object to your drinking with a broken leg.”

“Well, then, something else,” said Oop.

They sat contentedly with their drinks, Ghost staring at the fire. Outside a rising wind worried at the shack.

“I’ve never had a better meal,” said Carol. “First time I ever cooked my own steak stuck on a stick above an open fire.”

Oop belched contentedly. “That’s the way we did it back in the Old Stone Age. That, or eat it raw, like the saber-toother. We didn’t have no stoves or ovens or fancy things like that.”

“I have the feeling,” said Maxwell, “that it would be better not to ask, but where did you get that rack of ribs? I imagine all the butcher shops were closed.”

“Well, they were,” admitted Oop, “but there was this one and on the back door it had this itty bitty padlock.…”

“Someday,” said Ghost, “you’ll get into trouble.”

Oop shook his head. “I don’t think so. Not this time. Primal necessity-no, I guess that’s not the phrase. When a man is hungry he has a right to food anywhere he finds it. That was the law back in prehistoric days. I imagine you still might make a case of it in a court of law. Besides, tomorrow I’ll go back and explain what happened. By the way,” he said to Maxwell, “have you any money?”

“I’m loaded,” Maxwell told him. “I carried expense money for the Coonskin trip and I never spent a cent of it.”

“On this other planet you were a guest,” said Carol. “I suppose I was,” said Maxwell. “I never did figure out our exact relationship.”

“They were nice people?”

“Well, yes, nice-but people, I don’t know.”

He turned to Oop. “How much will you need?”

“I figure a hundred ought to settle it. There is the meat and the busted door, not to mention the bruised feelings of our friend, the butcher.”

Maxwell took his billfold from his pocket and, counting out some bills, handed them to Oop.

“Thanks,” said Oop. “Someday I’ll pay you back.”

“No,” said Maxwell. “The party is on me. I started out to take Carol to dinner and things got somewhat upset.”

On the hearth, Sylvester stretched and yawned, then went back to sleep, lying on his back now, with his legs sticking in the air. Ghost asked, “You’re on a visit here, Miss Hampton?”

“No,” said Carol, surprised. “I work here. What gave you that idea?”

“The tiger,” said Ghost. “A bio-mech, you said. I thought, naturally, you were with Bio-mech.”

“I see,” said Carol. “ Vienna or New York.”

“There is a center also,” said Ghost, “somewhere in Asia. Ulan Bator, if my memory is. correct.”

“You’ve been there?”

“No,” said Ghost. “I only heard of it.”

“But he could,” said Oop. “He can go anywhere. In the blinking of an eyelash. That’s why the folks at Supernatural continue to put up with him. They hope that someday they can come up with whatever he has got. But Old Ghost is cagey. He’s not telling them.”

“The real reason for his silence,” said Maxwell, “is that he’s on Transport’s payroll. It’s worth their while to keep him quiet. If he revealed his traveling techniques, Transport would go broke. No more need of them. People could just up and go anywhere they wished, on their own-a mile or a million light-years.”

“And he’s the soul of tact,” said Oop. “What he was getting at back there was that unless you are in Bio-mech and can cook up something for yourself, it costs money to have something like that saber-toother.”

“Oh, I see,” said Carol. “I guess there’s truth in that. They do cost a lot of money. But I haven’t got that kind of money. My father, before he retired, was in Bio-mech. New York. Sylvester was a joint project of a seminar he headed. The students gave him to my dad.”

“I still don’t believe,” said Oop, “that cat’s a bio-mech. He’s got that dirty glitter in his eyes when he looks at me.”

“As a matter of fact,” Carol told him, “there is a lot more bio than mech in all of them today. The name originated when what amounted to a highly sophisticated electronic brain and nervous system was housed in specific protoplasms. But today about the only mechanical things about them are those organs that are likely to wear out if they were made of tissue-the heart, the kidneys, the lungs, things like that. What is being done at Bio-mech today is the actual creations of specific life forms-but you all know that, of course.”

“There are some strange stories,” Maxwell said. “A group of supermen, kept under lock and key. You have heard of that?”

“Yes, heard of it,” she said. “There are always rumors.”

“The best one that I’ve heard in recent days,” said Oop, “really is a lulu. Someone told me Supernatural has made contact with the Devil. How about that, Pete?”

“I wouldn’t know,” said Maxwell. “I suppose someone has tried. I’m almost sure someone must have tried. It’s such an obvious thing for one to have a go at.”

“You mean,” asked Carol, “that there might really be a Devil?”

“Two centuries ago,” said Maxwell, “people asked, in exactly the same tone of voice you are using now, if there actually were such things as trolls and goblins.”

“And ghosts,” said Ghost.

“You’re serious!” Carol cried.

“Not serious,” said Maxwell. “Just not ready to foreclose even on the Devil.”

“This is a marvelous age,” declared Oop, “as I am sure you’ve heard me indicate before. You’ve done away with superstition and the old wives’ tales. You search in them for truth. But my people knew there were trolls and goblins and all the rest of them. The stories of them, you understand, were always based on fact. Except that later on, when he outgrew his savage simplicity, if you can call it that, man denied the fact; could not allow himself to believe these things that he knew were true. So he varnished them over and hid them safe away in the legend and the myth and when the human population kept on increasing, these creatures went into deep hiding. As well they might have, for there was a time when they were not the engaging creatures you seem to think they are today.”

Ghost asked: “And the Devil?”

“I’m not sure,” said Oop. “Maybe. But I can’t be sure. There were all these things you have lured out and rediscovered and sent to live on their reservations. But there were many more. Some of them fearful, all of them a nuisance.”

“You don’t seem to have liked them very well,” Carol observed.

“Miss,” said Qop, “I didn’t.”

“It would seem to me,” said Ghost, “that this would be a fertile field for some Time investigation. Apparently there were many different kinds of these-would you call them primates?”

“I think you might,” said Maxwell.

“Primates of a different stripe than the apes and man.”

“Of a very different stripe,” said Oop. “Vicious little stinkers.”

“Someday, I’m sure,” said Carol, “Time will get around to it. They know it, of course?”

“They should,” said Oop. “I’ve told them often enough, with appropriate description.”

“Time has too much to do,” Maxwell reminded them. “Too many areas of interest. And the entire past to cover.”

“And no money to do it with,” said Carol.

“There,” declared Maxwell, “speaks a loyal Time staff member.”

“But it’s true,” she cried. “The other disciplines could learn so much by Time investigation. You can’t rely on written history. It turns out, in many cases, to be different than it actually was. A matter of emphasis or bias or of just poor interpretation, embalmed forever in the written form. But do these other departments provide any funds for Time investigation? I’ll answer that. They don’t. A few of them, of course. The College of Law has cooperated splendidly, but not many of the others. They’re afraid. They don’t want their comfortable little worlds upset. Take this matter of Shakespeare, for example. You’d think English Lit would be grateful to find that Oxford wrote the plays. After all, it had been a question that had been talked about for many years-who really wrote the plays? But, after all of that, they resented it when Time found out who really wrote the plays.”

“And now,” said Maxwell, “Time is bringing Shakespeare forward to lecture about how he didn’t write the plays. Don’t you think that’s rubbing it in just a bit too much?”

“That’s not the point of it, at all,” said Carol. “The point is that Time is forced to make a sideshow out of history to earn a little money. That’s the way it is all the time. All sorts of schemes for raising money. Earning a lousy reputation as a bunch of clowns. You can’t believe Dean Sharp enjoys-”

“I know Harlow Sharp,” said Maxwell. “Believe me, he enjoys every minute of it.”

“That is blasphemy,” Oop said in mock horror. “Don’t you know that you can be crucified for blabbing off like that?”

“You’re making fun of me,” said Carol. “You make fun of everyone, of everything. You, too, Peter Maxwell.”

“I apologize for them,” said Ghost, “since neither one of them could summon up the grace to apologize, themselves. You have to live with them for ten or fifteen years to understand they really mean no harm.”

“But the day will come,” said Carol, “when Time will have the funds to do whatever it may want. All their pet projects and to heck with all the other colleges. When the deal goes-”

She stopped abruptly. She sat frozen, not moving. One could sense that she wanted to put her hand up to her mouth and was refraining from it only by iron will.

“What deal?” asked Maxwell.

“I think I know,” said Oop. “I heard a rumor, just a tiny little rumor, and I paid no attention to it. Although, come to think of it, these dirty little rumors are the ones that turn out to be true. The great big, ugly, noisy ones-”

“Oop, not a speech,” said Ghost. “Just tell us what you heard.”

“It’s incredible,” said Oop. “You never would believe it. Not in all your born days.”

“Oh, stop it!” Carol exclaimed.

They all looked at her and waited.

“I made a slip,” she said. “I got all worked up and made a slip. Can I ask the three of you just please to forget it. I’m not even sure it’s true.”

“Certainly,” said Maxwell. “You’ve been exposed this evening to rough company and ill manners and…”

She shook her head. “No,” she said. “No, it’s not any good to ask. I have no right to ask. I’ll simply have to tell you and trust to your discretion. And I’m pretty sure it’s true. Time has been made an offer for the Artifact.”

Silence reverberated in the room as the other three sat motionless, scarcely breathing. She looked from one to the other of them, not quite understanding.

Finally Ghost stirred slightly and there was a rustling in the silence of the room, as if his white sheet had been an actual sheet that rustled when he moved.

“You do not comprehend,” he said, “the attachment that we three hold to the Artifact.”

“You struck us in a heap,” said Oop.

“The Artifact,” said Maxwell softly. “The Artifact, the one great mystery, the one thing in the world that has baffled everyone…”

“A funny stone,” said Oop.

“Not a stone,” said Ghost.

“Then, perhaps,” said Carol, “you’ll tell me what it is.”

And that was the one thing, Maxwell told himself, that neither Ghost nor any one else could do. Discovered ten years or so ago by Time investigators on a hilltop in the Jurassic Age, it had been brought back to the present at a great expenditure of funds and ingenuity. Its weight had demanded energy far beyond anything so far encountered to kick it forward into time, an energy requirement which had made necessary the projection backward into time of a portable nuclear generator, transported in many pieces and assembled on the site. And then the further task of bringing back the generator, since nothing of that sort, as a matter of simple ethics, could be abandoned in the past-even in the past of the far Jurassic.

“I cannot tell you,” said Ghost. “There is no one who can tell you.”

Ghost was right. No one had been able to make any sense of it at all. A massive block of some sort of material that now appeared to be neither stone nor metal, although at one time it had been thought to be a stone, and later on, a metal, it had defied all investigation. Six feet long, four feet on each side, it was a mass of blackness that absorbed no energy and emitted none, that bounced all light and other radiation from its surface, that could not be cut or dented, stopping a laser beam as neatly as if the beam had not existed. There was nothing that could scratch it, nothing that could probe it-it gave up no information of any sort at all. It rested on its raised base in the forecourt of Time Museum, the one thing in the world about which no one could even make a valid guess.

“Then,” asked Carol, “why the consternation?”

“Because,” said Oop, “Pete here has the hunch it may, at one time, have been the god of the Little Folk. That is, if the lousy little stinkers had the capacity to recognize a god.”

“I’m sorry,” Carol said. “I am truly sorry. I didn’t know. Perhaps if Time knew…”

“There’s not enough data,” Maxwell said, “to make any talk about it. Just a hunch is all. Just a feeling from certain things I’ve heard among the Little Folk. But even they don’t know. It was so long ago.”

So long ago, he thought. For the love of God, almost two hundred million years ago!

“This Oop,” said Carol. “I can’t get over him. That funny house he has out at the end of nowhere.”

“He’d be offended,” said Maxwell, “if he heard you calling it a house. It’s a shack and he’s proud of it-as a shack. The jump from cave to house would have been too great for him. He’d have felt uncomfortable.”

“A cave? He really lived in a cave?”

“Let me tell you something about old friend Oop,” said Maxwell. “He is an awful liar. You can’t believe all the stories that he tells. The cannibalism, for instance…”

“That makes me feel a little better. People eating one another!”

“Oh, there was cannibalism, all right. There is no doubt of that. But whether Oop himself was headed for the pot is another matter. On items of general information, he is reliable enough. It’s only when he gets to yarning about his personal experiences that you should begin to doubt him.”

“It’s funny,” said Carol. “I’ve seen him around and have wondered a bit about him, but I never thought I’d meet him. Never really wanted to, in fact. Certain people I can draw a line at, and he was one of them. I imagined he would be uncouth…”

“Oh, he’s uncouth,” said Maxwell.

“But charming, too,” said Carol.

Clear autumn stars shone frostily deep in the darkened sky. The roadway, almost unoccupied, wound its way along the ridge. Far below gleamed the far-spreading campus lights. The wind, blowing up the ridge, carried the faint smell of burning leaves.

“The fire was nice,” said Carol. “Why is it, Peter, that we don’t have fires? It would be so simple. A fireplace wouldn’t be so hard to build.”

“There was a time, several hundred years ago,” said Maxwell, “when every house, or almost every house, had at least one fireplace. Sometimes several. The whole thing, the whole business of having fires, was a throwback, of course. Back to the days when fire was a protection and a warmth. But, finally, we outgrew it.”

“I don’t think we did,” she said. “We just walked away, is all. Turned our back upon this one segment of our past. We still have need of fire. A psychological need, perhaps. I found that out tonight. It was so exciting and so comfortable. Primal, maybe, but there still must be some of the primal in us.”

“Oop,” he told her, “couldn’t live without a fire. The lack of a fire was the thing that bugged him most when Time brought him back. He had to be held captive for a time, of course, when he first was brought here-closely watched over, if not actually confined. But when be became his own master, so to speak, he got hold of a piece of land out at the edge of the campus and built himself the shack. Rough, the way he wanted it. And, of course, a fireplace. And a garden. You should see his garden. The idea of growing food was something new to him. Something that no one back in his day had ever thought about. Nails and saws and hammers, and even lumber, also were new to him, as was everything. But he was highly adaptable. He took to the new tools and ideas without a single hitch. Nothing astonished him. He used hammer and saw and lumber and all the rest of it to build the shack. But I think it was the garden that seemed the most wonderful to him-to grow one’s food and not hunt for it. I suppose you noticed-even now he is impressed with the sheer bulk and the easy availability of food.”

“And of liquor,” said Carol.

Maxwell laughed. “Another new idea that he took to. A hobby of his, you might almost say. He makes his own. He’s got a still out in the back of his woodshed and be runs off some of the worst moonshine that ever trickled down your throat. Pretty vile stuff.”

“But not to guests,” said Carol. “That was whiskey tonight.”

“You have to be a friend of his,” said Maxwell, “before he’ll allow you to drink his moon. Those fruit jars he set out…”

“I wondered about those. They seemed to have nothing in them.”

“Clear, rotgut moonshine, that was what was in them.”

“You said he was a captive once. And now? Just how closely is he tied to Time?”

“A ward of the college. Not really tied at all. But you couldn’t drive him off. He’s a more loyal partisan of Time than you are.”

“And Ghost? He lives here at Supernatural? He’s a ward of Supernatural?”

“Hardly. Ghost is a stray cat. He goes anywhere he wishes. He’s got friends all over the planet. He’s big stuff, I understand, at the College of Comparative Religions on the Himalayan Campus. But he manages to drop in here on a fairly regular basis. He and Oop hit it off from the moment Supernatural made its first contact with Ghost.”

“Pete, you call him Ghost. What is he, really?”

“Why, he is a ghost.”

“But what’s a ghost?”

“I don’t know. I don’t think anybody does.”

“But you’re with Supernatural.”

“Oh, sure, but all my work has been with the Little Folk, with emphasis on goblins, although I have an interest in every one of them. Even banshees and there’s nothing that comes meaner or more unreasonable than a banshee.”

“There must be specialists in ghosts, then. What do they have to say about it?”

“I’d guess they might have a few ideas. There are tons of literature on spookery, but I’ve never had the time to go into it. I know that back in the early ages it was believed that everyone, when they died, turned into a ghost, but now, I understand, that no longer is believed. There are certain special circumstances that give rise to ghosts, but I don’t know what they are.”

“That face of his,” said Carol. “A little spooky, maybe, but somehow fascinating. I had a hard time to keep from staring at him. Just a dark blankness folded inside his sheet which, I suppose, is not a sheet. And at times a hint of eyes. Little lights that could be eyes. Or was I imagining?”

“No. I’ve imagined them myself.”

“Will you,” asked Carol, “grab hold of that fool cat and pull him in a foot or so. He’s slipping out onto the faster belt. He has no sense whatever. He’ll go to sleep any time, at any place. Eat and sleep is all he thinks about.”

Maxwell reached down and tugged Sylvester back into his original position. Sylvester growled and mumbled in his sleep.

Maxwell straightened and leaned back into his chair, looking up into the sky.

“Look at the stars,” he said. “There is nothing like the skies of Earth. I’m glad to be back again.”

“And now that you’re back?”

“After I see you safely home and pick up my luggage, I’m going back to Oop’s. He’ll have one of those fruit jars all unscrewed and we’ll do some drinking and sit and talk till dawn, then I’ll get into the bed he has for guests, and he’ll curl up on his pile of leaves… “I saw those leaves over in the corner and was consumed with curiosity. But I didn’t ask.”

“He sleeps there all the time. Not comfortable in a bed. After all, when for many years a pile of leaves has been the height of luxury…”

“You’re trying to make a fool of me again.”

“No, I’m not,” said Maxwell. “I’m telling you the truth.”

“I didn’t mean what will you do tonight. I mean what will you do? You are dead, remember?”

“I’ll explain,” said Maxwell. “I’ll continually explain. Everywhere I go there’ll be people who’ll want to know what happened. There might even be an investigation of some sort. I sincerely hope there won’t, but I suppose there may have to be.”

“I’m sorry,” Carol said, “but, then, I’m also glad. How fortunate it was that there were two of you.”

“If Transport could work it out,” said Maxwell, “they might have something they could sell. All of us could keep a second one of us stashed away somewhere against emergency.”

“But it wouldn’t work,” Carol pointed out. “Not personally. This other Peter Maxwell was a second person and-oh, I don’t know what I mean. It’s too late at night to get it figured out, but I’m sure it wouldn’t work.”

“No,” said Maxwell. “No, I guess it wouldn’t. It was a bad idea.”

“It was a nice evening,” said Carol. “I thank you so much for it. I had a lot of fun.”

“And Sylvester had a lot of steak.”

“Yes, he did. He’ll not forget you. He loves folks who give him steak. He’s nothing but a glutton.”

“There is just one thing,” said Maxwell. “One thing you didn’t tell us. Who was it that made the offer for the Artifact?”

“I don’t know. Just that there was an offer. Good enough, I gather, for Time to consider it. I simply overheard a snatch of conversation I was not supposed to hear. Does it make a difference?”

“It could,” said Maxwell.

“I remember now,” she said. “There was another name. Not the one who meant to buy it, or I don’t think it was. Just someone who was involved. It had slipped my mind till now. Someone by the name of Churchill. Does that mean anything to you?”

Oop was sitting in front of the fireplace, paring his toenails with a large jackknife, when Maxwell returned, carrying his bag.

Oop gestured with his knife toward the bed. “Sling it over there and then come and sit down with me. I’ve just put a couple of new logs on the fire and I have a jug half finished and a couple more hid out.”

“Where’s Ghost?” asked Maxwell.

“Oh, he disappeared. I don’t know where he went; he never tells me. But he’ll be back again. He never is gone long.”

Maxwell put the bag on the bed, went over to the fireplace and sat down, leaning against its rough stone face.

“You played the clown tonight,” he said, “somewhat better than you usually manage. What was the big idea?”

“Those big eyes of hers,” said Oop, grinning. “And just begging to be shocked. I am sorry, Pete. I simply couldn’t help it.”

“All that talk about cannibalism and vomiting,” said Maxwell. “That was pretty low.”

“Well,” said Oop, “I guess I just got carried away. That’s the way folks expect a crummy Neanderthal to act.”

“The girl’s no fool,” said Maxwell. “She planted that story about the Artifact as neatly as I have ever seen it done.”

“Planted it?”

“Sure, planted it. You don’t think it just slipped out, do you, the way she pretended that it did?”

“I hadn’t thought of that,” said Oop. “Maybe she did. But if she did, why do you think she did it?”

“I would guess she doesn’t want it sold. Figured that if she told it to a blabbermouth like you it would be all over the campus before noon tomorrow. A lot of talk about it, she might figure, would help to kill the deal.”

“But you know, Pete, that I’m no blabbermouth.”

“I know it. But you acted like one tonight.”

Oop closed the jackknife and slid it in his pocket, picked up the half-empty fruit jar and handed it to Maxwell. Maxwell put it to his mouth and drank. The fiery liquid slashed like a knife along his throat and he choked. He wished, he thought, that for once he could drink the stuff without choking on it. He took it down and sat there, gasping for breath, shivering just a little.

“Potent stuff,” said Oop. “Best batch I’ve run off for quite a while. Did you see the bead on it?”

Maxwell, unable to speak, nodded.

Oop reached out and took the jar, tilted it up, lowered its level by an inch or more. He took it down and held it lovingly against his hairy chest. He let out his breath in a whoosh that made the flames in the fireplace dance. He patted the bottle with his free hand.

“First-rate stuff,” he said.

He wiped his mouth with the back of his hand and sat, staring at the fire.

“She couldn’t, certainly, have taken you for a blabber-mouth,” he finally said. “I notice that you did some fancy skating of your own tonight. All around the truth.”

“Maybe because I don’t entirely know the truth myself,” said Maxwell. “Or what to do about it. You set to do some listening?”

“Any time,” said Oop. “If that is what you want. Although you don’t need to tell me. Not out of friendship. You know we’ll still be friends if you tell me nothing. We don’t even need to talk about it. There are a lot of other things we could talk about.”

Maxwell shook his head. “I have to tell you, Oop. I have to tell someone and you’re the only one I would dare to tell. There’s too much of it for me to go on carrying it alone.”

Oop handed him the fruit jar. “Take another slug of that, then start any time you want. What I can’t figure out is the goof by Transport. I don’t believe it happened. I would make a guess that it was something else.”

“And you’d be right,” said Maxwell. “There’s a planet out there somewhere. Fairly close, I’d guess. A freewheeling planet, not tied to any sun, although I gather that it could insert itself into a solar system any time it wishes.”

“That would take some doing. It would mess up the orbits of all the other planets.”

“Not necessarily,” said Maxwell. “It wouldn’t have to take an orbit in the same plane as the other planets. That would hold down the effect of its being there.”

He lifted the fruit jar, shut his eyes, and took a healthy gulp. The top of his head came off and his stomach bounced. He lowered the jar and leaned back against the roughness of the masonry. A wind was mewing in the chimney-a lonely sound, but a sound shut outside by the rough board walls. A log fell in the fireplace and sent up a shower of sparks. The flames danced high and ifickering shadows chased one another all about the room.

Oop reached out and took the jar out of Maxwell’s hands, but did not drink immediately. He held it, cuddled, in his lap.

“So this other planet reached out and copied your wave pattern,” he said, “and there were two of you.”

“How did you know that?”

“Deduction. It was the most logical way for it to happen. I know there were two of you. There was this other one who came back before you did. I talked with him and he was you-he was as much Pete Maxwell as you are, sitting there. He said there was no dragon, that the Coonskin business had been a wild-goose chase, and so he came home ahead of his schedule.”

“So that was it,” said Maxwell. “I had wondered why he came back early.”

“I’m hard put to it,” said Oop, “to decide if I should rejoice or mourn. Perhaps a bit of both, leaving some room for wonderment at the strange workings of human destiny. This other man was you and now he’s dead and I have lost a friend-for he was a human being and a personality and that humanity and personality came to an end with death. But now there’s you and if, before, I’d lost a friend, now I have regained that lost friend, for you are as truly Peter Maxwell as that other one.”

“I was told an accident.”

“I’m not sure,” said Oop. “I’ve been doing some thinking about it. Since you came back, I’m not so sure at all. He was getting off a roadway and he tripped and fell, hit his head…”

“You don’t trip when you’re getting off a roadway. Unless you’re drunk or crippled up or awkward. That outside belt is barely crawling.”

“I know,” said Oop. “That’s what the police thought, too. But there was no other explanation and the police, as you well know, require some sort of explanation, so they can close the file. It was in a lonely place. About halfway between here and Goblin Reservation. No one saw it. Must have happened when there was almost no one traveling. Maybe at night. He was found about ten o’clock in the morning. There would have been people traveling from six o’clock on, but probably they’d have been on the inner, faster belts. They wouldn’t have seen too much on the outside of the belt. The body could have been lying there for a long time before it was found.”

“You think it wasn’t an accident? That it may have been a murder?”

“I don’t know. The thought has occurred to me. There was one funny thing about it-something that never was explained. There was a funny smell about the body and the area. A strange sort of odor, like nothing anyone had ever smelled before. Maybe someone found out that there were two of you. For some reason, someone may not have wanted two of you.”

“But who could have known there were two of me?”

“The people on that other planet. If there were people…”

“There were people,” Maxwell said. “It was a most amazing place.…”

It all came back as he sat there talking, almost as if he were there again. A crystal place-or that had been what it had looked to be when he first had seen it. An extensive crystal plain that ran on and on and a crystal sky with crystal pillars reaching from the plain and upward, apparently to the sky, although the tops of them were lost in the milkiness of sky-pillars soaring upward to hold the sky in place. An empty place, to make one think of a deserted ballroom of extensive size, all cleaned and polished for a ball, waiting for the music and the dancers who had never come and now would never come, leaving the ballroom empty through all eternity, shining in all its polished glitter and its wasted graciousness.

A ballroom, but a ballroom without any walls, running on and on, not to a horizon, for there seemed to be no horizon, but to a point where the sky-that strange, milk-glass sky-came down to meet the crystal floor.

He stood astounded in the vast immensity, an immensity not of boundless sky, for the sky was far from boundless, nor from great distances, for the distances were not great, but immensity that was measured as a room would be, as if one were in a giant’s house and lost and were looking for a door, and without a clue as to where a door might be. A place with no distinguishing features, with each pillar like the next, with no cloud in the sky (if it were a sky), with each foot, each mile like every other foot and mile, level and paved with a crystal paving that stretched out in all directions.

He wanted to cry out, to ask if anyone were there, but was afraid to cry out-perhaps in the fear, although he did not realize it then and only thought it later, that a single sound would send all this cold and shining splendor shimmering into a cloud of frosty dust. For the place was silent, with no slightest whisper of a sound. Silent and cold and lonely, all its splendor and its whiteness lost in the loneliness.

Slowly, carefully, fearing that the scuff of his moving feet might bring this whole world into dust, he pivoted and out of the corner of his eye he caught a glimpse-not of motion, but the flickering sense of motion, as if something had been there, but had moved so fast that his eye had failed to catch it. He halted, the short hairs prickling on the back of his neck, engulfed by the sense of utter strangeness rather than of actual danger, apprehensive of a strangeness so distorted and so twisted out of the normal human context that a man gazing at it might go mad before he had a chance to jerk his eyes away.

Nothing happened and he moved again, pivoting inch by cautious inch, and now he saw that he had been standing with his back turned on what appeared to be an assemblage of some sort-an engine? an instrument? a machine?

And all at once he knew. Here was the strange contraption that had brought him here, this crazy crystal world’s equivalent of a matter transmitter and receiver.

But this, he knew at once, was not the Coonskin system. It was no place he had ever heard of. Nowhere in the known universe was there a place like this. Something had gone wrong and he had been hurled, not to the Coonskin planet which had been his destination, but to some far, forgotten corner of the universe, to some area, perhaps, where man would not penetrate for another million years, so far away from Earth that the distances involved became unimaginable.

Now again there were flickering motions, as if living shadows moved against the crystal background. As he watched, the flickering flowed into shifting shape and form and he could see that there were many moving shapes, all of them, strangely, separate entities that seemed to hold, within the flicker of them, individual personalities. As if, he thought in horror, they were things that had once been people-as if they might be alien ghosts.

“And I accepted them,” he said to Oop. “I accepted them-on faith, perhaps. It was either that or reject them and be left there, standing all alone upon that crystal plain. A man of a century ago, perhaps, would not have accepted them. He would have been inclined to sweep them out of his mind as pure imagination. But I had spent too many hours with Ghost to gag at the thought of ghosts. I had worked too long with supernatural phenomena to quibble at the idea of creatures and of circumstances beyond the human pale.

“And the strange thing about it, the comforting thing about it, is that they sensed that I accepted them.”

“And that is it?” asked Oop. “A planet full of ghosts?” Maxwell nodded, “Perhaps that’s one way of looking at it. But let me ask you-what really is a ghost?”

“A spook,” said Oop. “A spirit.”

“But what do you mean by spook? Define a spirit for me.”

“I know,” said Oop regretfully. “I was being a bit facetious and there was no excuse for it. We don’t know what a ghost is. Even Ghost doesn’t know exactly what he is. He simply knows that he exists-and if anyone should know, he should. He has mulled over it a lot. He’s thought about it deeply. He has communed with fellow ghosts and there is no evidence. So you fall back upon the supernatural…”

“Which is not understood,” said Maxwell.

“A mutation of some sort,” suggested Oop.

“Collins thought so,” said Maxwell. “But he stood alone. I know I didn’t agree with him, but that was before I was on the crystal planet. Now I’m not so sure. What happens when a race reaches an end, when, as a race, it has passed through childhood and middle age and now has reached old age? A race dying as a man does, dying of old age. What does it do, then? It could die, of course. That’s what one would expect of it. But suppose there was a reason that it couldn’t die, suppose it had to hang on, had to stay alive for some overriding reason, that it could not allow itself to die?”

“If ghostliness really is a mutation,” said Oop, “if they knew it was a mutation, if they were so far advanced they could control mutation-”

He stopped and looked at Maxwell. “You think that’s what might have happened?”

“I think it might,” said Maxwell. “I am beginning to think very much it might.”

Oop handed across the fruit jar. “You need a drink,” he said. “And when you’re through with it, I’ll have one, myself.”

Maxwell took the jar, holding it, not drinking right away. Oop reached out to the stack of wood, lifted a chunk in one massive fist and threw it on the fire. A spray of sparks gushed up the chimney. Outside the night wind moaned along the eaves.

Maxwell lifted the jar and drank. The splash of liquid ran down his gullet like a torrent of lava. He choked, wishing that he could drink the stuff, just once, without choking on it. He handed the jar back to Oop. Oop lifted it, then took it down again without drinking. He squinted across its rim at Maxwell.

“You said something to live for. Some reason that they couldn’t die-that they had to keep on existing, any way they could.”

“That’s right,” said Maxwell. “Information. Knowledge. A planet crammed with knowledge. A storehouse of knowledge-and I would doubt that a tenth of it duplicates our own. The rest of it is new, unknown. Some of it material we have never dreamed of. Knowledge that we may not ferret out short of a million years, if we ever ferret it. It is stored, electronically I suppose-arranging atoms in such a manner that each atom carries a bit of information. Stored in metal sheets, like the pages of a book, stacked in great heaps and piles and each layer of atoms-yes, they are arranged in layers-carries separate information. You read the first layer and then go down to the second layer. Again, like pages in a book, each layer of atoms a page, one stacked atop the other. Each sheet of metal-don’t ask me, I can’t even guess, how many layers of atoms in each metal sheet. Hundreds of thousands, I would suspect.”

Oop lifted the jar hastily, took a tremendous gulp, part of the liquor spraying out across his woolly chest. He let out his breath in a lusty belch.

“They can’t abandon this knowledge,” said Maxwell. “They have to pass it on to someone who can use it. They have to stay alive, somehow, until they pass it on. And that, for the love of God, is where I come in. They commissioned me to sell it for them.”

“Sell it for them! A bunch of ghosts, hanging on by their very toenails! What would they want? What’s the price they ask?”

Maxwell put up his hand and wiped his forehead, which had sprouted a sudden mist of sweat. “I don’t know,” he said.

“Don’t know? How can you sell a thing if you don’t know what it’s worth, if you don’t have an asking price?”

“They said they would tell me later. They said to get someone interested and they’d get word to me on what the price would be.”

“That,” said Oop, disgusted, “is a hell of a way to make a business deal.”

“Yes, I know,” said Maxwell.

“You have no hint of price?”

“Not the faintest. I tried to explain to them and they couldn’t understand, maybe they refused to understand. And since then I have gone over it and over it and there’s no way I can know. It all boils down, of course, to what a gang like that might want. And for the life of me, I can’t think of a thing they’d want.”

“Well,” said Oop, “they picked the right place to make their sales pitch. How do you plan to go about it?”

“I’ll go up and talk to Arnold.”

“You pick them tough,” said Oop.

“Look, I have to talk with Arnold and to no one else. This can’t go up through channels. There can’t a word of it leak out. On the surface, it sounds harebrained. If the communications media or the gossip-mongers got hold of it, the university wouldn’t dare to touch it. If it were known and they did consider it and the deal fell through-and, believe me, working in the dark, as I have to work, the deal could well fall through-there’d be just one loud guffaw all the way from here clear out to the Rim. It would be Arnold ’s neck and my neck and…”

“Pete, Arnold is nothing but a big stuffed shirt. You know that as well as I do. He’s an administrator. He’s running the business end of this university. I don’t care if he has the title of president or not, he’s just the manager. He doesn’t give a damn about the academic end of it. He won’t stick out his neck for three planets full of knowledge.”

“The president of the university has to be an administrator…”

“If it could have come at any other time,” mourned Oop, “you might have had a chance. But as it stands right now, Arnold is walking on a crate of eggs. Moving the administration from New York to this jerkwater campus…”

“A campus,” put in Maxwell, “with a great liberal tradition and-”

“University politics,” declared Oop, “doesn’t care about liberal traditions or any other kind of traditions.”

“I suppose not,” said Maxwell, “but Arnold ’s the man I have to see. I could wish it were someone else. I have no admiration for the man, but he’s the one I have to work with.”

“You could have turned it down.”

“The job of negotiator? No, I couldn’t, Oop. No man could have. They’d have had to find someone else and they might get someone who’d bungle it. Not that I’m sure I won’t bungle it, but at least I’ll try. And it’s not only for us, it’s for them as well.”

“You got to like these people?”

“I’m not sure just how much I liked them. Admired them, maybe. Felt sorry for them, maybe. They’re doing what they can. They hunted for so long to find someone they could pass the knowledge on to.”

“Pass it on? You said it was for sale.”

“Only because there is something that they want or need. I wish I could figure out what it is. It would make everything easier for everyone concerned.”

“Minor question-you talked with them. How did you go about it?”

“The tablets,” said Maxwell. “I told you about the tablets. The sheets of metal that carried information. They talked with me with tablets and I talked with them the same way.”

“But how could you read…”

“They gave me a contraption, like a pair of glasses, a pair of goggles, really, but bigger than a pair of goggles. It was a sort of bulky thing. I suppose it had a lot of mechanisms in it. I’d put it on and then I could read the tablets. No script, just little jiggles in the metal. It’s hard to explain. But you looked at the jiggles through the contraption that you wore and you knew what the jiggles said. It was adjustable, I found out later, so you could read the different atomic layers. But to start with, they only wrote me messages, if wrote is the word to use. Like kids writing back and forth to one another on slates. I wrote back to them by thinking into another contraption that was tied into the pair of goggles that I wore.”

“A translator,” said Gop.

“I suppose that’s what it was. A two-way translator.”

“We’ve tried to work one out,” said Oop. “By we I mean the combined ingenuity not only of the Earth, but of what we laughingly call the known galaxy.”

“Yes, I know,” said Maxwell.

“And these folks had one. These ghosts of yours.”

“They have a whole lot more,” said Maxwell. “I don’t know what they have. I sampled some of what they had. At random. Just enough to convince myself they had what they said.”

“One thing still bugs me,” said Oop. “You said a planet. What about the star.”

“The planet is roofed over. There was a star, I gather, but you couldn’t see it, not from the surface. The point is, of course, that there needn’t be a star. You are acquainted, I think, with the concept of the oscillating universe.”

“The yo-yo universe,” said Oop. “The one that goes bang, and then bang, bang again.”

“That’s right,” said Maxwell. “And now we can quit wondering about it. It happens to be true. The crystal planet comes from the universe that existed before the present universe was formed. They had it figured out, you see. They knew the time would come when all the energy would be gone and all the dead matter would start moving slowly back to form another cosmic egg, so that the egg could explode again and give birth to yet another universe. They knew they were approaching the death of the universe and that unless something were done, it would be death for them as well. So they launched a project. A planetary project. They sucked in energy and stored it-don’t ask me how they extracted it from wherever they extracted it or how they stored it. Stored somehow in the very material of the planet, so that when the rest of the universe went black and dead, they still had energy. They roofed the planet in, they made a house of it. They worked out propulsion mechanisms so they could move their planet, so that they would be an independent body moving independently through space. And before the inward drifting of the dead matter of the universe began, they left their star, a dead and blackened cinder by this time, and set out on their own. That’s the way they have been since then, a holdover population riding on a planetary spaceship. They saw the old universe die, the one before this one. They were left alone in space, in space that had no hint of life, no glint of light, no quiver of energy. It may be-I don’t know-that they saw the formation of the brand-new cosmic egg. They could have been very far from it and seen it. And if they saw it, they saw the explosion that marked the beginning of this universe we live in, the blinding flash, far off, that sent the energy streaking into space. They saw the first stars glow red, they saw the galaxies take shape. And when the galaxies had formed, they joined this new universe. They could go to any galaxy they chose, set up an orbit about any star they wished. They could move anytime they wanted to. They were universal gypsies. But the end is nearing now. The planet, I suppose, could keep on and on, for the energy machinery must still be operative. I imagine there might even be a limit to the planet, but they’re not even close to that. But the race is dying out and they have stored in their records the knowledge of two universes.”

“Fifty billion years,” said Oop. “Fifty billion years of learning.”

“At least that much,” said Maxwell. “It could be a great deal more.”

They sat, silent, thinking of those fifty billion years. The fire mumbled in the chimney’s throat. From far off came the chiming of the clock in Music Hall, counting off the time.

Maxwell awoke. Oop was shaking him. “Someone here to see you.” Maxwell threw back the covers, hoisted his feet out on the floor, groped blindly for his trousers. Oop handed them to him.

“Who is it?”

“Said his name was Longfellow. Nasty, high-nosed gent. He’s waiting outside for you. You could see he wouldn’t risk contamination by stepping in the shack.”

“Then to hell with him,” said Maxwell, starting to crawl back into bed.

“No, no,” protested Oop. “I don’t mind at all. I’m above insult. There is nothing that can faze me.” Maxwell struggled into his trousers, slid his feet into his shoes and kicked them on.

“Any idea who this fellow is?”

“None at all,” said Oop.

Maxwell stumbled across the room to the bench set against the wall, spilled water from the bucket standing there into a washbasin, bent and sloshed water on his face.

“What time is it?” he asked.

“A little after seven.”

“Mr. Longfellow must have been in a hurry to see me.”

“He’s out there now, pacing up and down. Impatient.”

Longfellow was impatient.

As Maxwell came out of the door, he hurried up to him and held out a hand.

“Professor Maxwell,” he said, “I’m so glad I found you. It was quite a job. Someone told me you might be here,” he glanced at the shack and his long nose crinkled just a trifle, “so I took the chance.”

“Oop,” said Maxwell, quietly, “is an old and valued friend.”

“Could we, perhaps, take a stroll,” suggested Longfellow. “It is an unusually fine morning. Have you breakfasted yet? No, I don’t suppose you have.”

“It might help,” said Maxwell, “if you told me who you are.”

“I’m in Administration. Stephen Longfellow is the name. Appointments secretary to the president.”

“Then you’re just the man I want to see,” said Maxwell. “I need an appointment with the president as soon as possible.”

Longfellow shook his bead. “I would say offhand that is quite impossible.”

They fell into step and walked along the path that led down toward the roadway. Leaves of wondrous, shining yellow fell slowly through the air from a thick-branched walnut tree that stood beside the path. Down by the roadway a maple tree was a blaze of scarlet against the blueness of the morning sky. And far in that sky streamed a V-shaped flock of ducks heading southward.

“Impossible,” said Maxwell. “You make it sound final. As if you’d thought about it and come to your decision.”

“If you wish to communicate with Dr. Arnold,” Longfellow told him coldly, “there are proper channels. You must understand the president is a busy man and…”

“I understand all that,” said Maxwell, “and I understand as well about the channels. Innumerable delays, a request passed on from hand to hand and the knowledge of one’s communication spread among so many people-”

“Professor Maxwell,” Longfellow said, “there is no use, it seems, to beat about the bush. You’re a persistent man and, I suspect, a rather stubborn one, and with a man of that bent it is often best to lay it on the line. The president won’t see you. He can’t afford to see you.”

“Because there seems to have been two of me? Because one of me is dead?”

“The press will be full of it this morning. All the headlines shouting about a man come back from the dead. Have you heard the radio, perhaps, or watched television?”

“No,” Maxwell said, “I haven’t.”

“Well, when you got around to it you’ll find that you’ve been made a three-ring circus. I don’t mind telling you that it is embarrassing.”

“You mean a scandal?”

“I suppose you could call it that. And administration has trouble enough without identifying itself with a situation such as yours. There is this matter of Shakespeare, for example. We can’t duck that one, but we can duck you.”

“But surely,” said Maxwell, “administration can’t be too concerned with Shakespeare and myself as compared to all the other problems that it faces. There is the uproar over the revival of dueling at Heidelberg and the dispute over the ethics of employing certain alien students on the football squads and-”

“But can’t you see,” walled Longfellow, “that what happens on this particular campus are the things that matter.”

“Because administration was transferred here? When Oxford and California and Harvard and half a dozen others-”

“If you ask me,” Longfellow declared stiffly, “it was a piece of poor judgment on the part of the board of regents. It has made things very difficult for administration.”

“What would happen,” asked Maxwell, “if I just walked up the hill and into administration and started pounding desks?”

“You know well enough. You’d be thrown out.”

“But if I brought along a corps of the newspaper and television boys and they were outside watching?”

“I suppose then you wouldn’t be thrown out. You might even get to see the president. But I can assure you that under circumstances such as those you’d not get whatever it may be you want.”

“So,” said Maxwell, “I’d lose, no matter how I went about it.”

“As a matter of fact,” Longfellow told him, “I had come this morning on quite a different mission. I was bringing happy news.”

“I can imagine that you were,” said Maxwell. “What kind of sop are you prepared to throw me to make me disappear?”

“Not a sop,” said Longfellow, much aggrieved. “I was told to offer you the post of dean at the experimental college the university is establishing out on Gothic IV.”

“You mean that planet with all the witches and the warlocks?”

“It would be a splendid opportunity for a man in your field,” Longfellow insisted. “A planet where wizardry developed without the intervention of other intelligences, as is the case on Earth.”

“A hundred and fifty light-years distant,” said Maxwell. “Somewhat remote and I would think it might be dreary. But I suppose the salary would be good.”

“Very good indeed.”

“No, thanks,” said Maxwell. “I’m satisfied with my job, right here.”

“Job?” asked Longfellow.

“Why, yes. In case you have forgotten, I’m on the faculty.”

Longfellow shook his head. “Not any longer,” he said. “Have you, by any chance, forgotten? You died, more than three weeks ago. We can’t let vacancies go unfilled.”

“You mean I’ve been replaced?”

“Why, most certainly,” Longfellow told him nastily. “As it stands right now, you are unemployed.”

The waiter brought the scrambled eggs and bacon, poured the coffee, then went away and left Maxwell at the table. Through the wide expanse of window, Lake Mendota stretched away, a sheet of glassy blue, with the faint suggestion of purple hills on the other shore. A squirrel ran down the bole of the gnarled oak tree that stood just outside the window and halted, head downward, to stare with beady eyes at the man sitting at the table. A brown and red oak leaf planed down deliberately, from branch to ground, wobbling in the tiny thermal currents of air. On the rocky shore a boy and girl walked slowly, hand in hand, through the lakeshore’s morning hush.

It would have been civilized and gracious, Maxwell told himself, to have accepted Longfellow’s invitation to eat breakfast with him, but by that time he had had all that he could take of the appointments secretary and all that he wanted, at the moment, was to be alone, to gain a little time to sort out the situation and to do some thinking-although probably he could not afford the time for thinking.

Oop had been right; it was apparent now that to see the university president would be no easy task, not only because of that official’s busy schedule and his staff’s obsession of doing things through channels, but because for some reason, not entirely understood, this matter of twin Peter Maxwells had assumed the proportions of a scandal from which Arnold had the fervent wish to be disassociated. Maxwell wondered, sitting there and gazing out the window at the popeyed, staring squirrel, whether this attitude of the administration might go back to the interview with Drayton. Had Security zeroed in on Arnold? It didn’t seem too likely, but it was, Maxwell admitted, a possibility. But be that as it may, the depth of Arnold ’s jittery attitude was emphasized by the hurried offer of the post on Gothic IV. Not only did administration want nothing to do with this second Peter Maxwell, it wanted him off the Earth as well, buried on a planet where in the space of a little time he would be forgotten.

It was understandable that his post at Supernatural had been filled after the death of the other Peter Maxwell. After all, classes must go on. Gaps could not be left in the faculty. But even so, there were other positions that could have been found for him. The fact that this had not been done, that the Gothic IV position had been so quickly offered, was evidence enough that he was not wanted on the Earth.

Yet, it all was strange. Administration could not have known until sometime yesterday that two Peter Maxwells had existed. There could not have been a problem, there’d have been no basis for a problem, until that word had been received. Which meant, Maxwell told himself, that someone had gotten to administration fast-someone who wanted to get rid of him, someone who was afraid that he would interfere. But interfere in what? And the answer to that seemed so glib and easy that he felt, instinctively, that it must be wrong. But search as he might, there was one answer only-that someone else knew of the hoard of knowledge on the crystal planet and was working to get hold of it.

There was one name to go on. Carol had said Churchill-that Churchill somehow was involved in the offer that had been made to Time for the Artifact. Was it possible that the Artifact was the price of the crystal planet’s knowledge? One couldn’t count on that, of course, although it might be so, for no one knew what the Artifact might be.

That Churchill was working on the deal was no surprise at all. Not for himself, of course, but for someone else. For someone who could not afford to have his identity revealed. It was in deals such as this that Churchill might prove useful. The man was a professional fixer and knew his way around. He had contacts and through long years of operation undoubtedly had laid out various pipelines of information into many strange and powerful places.

And if such were the case, Maxwell realized, his job became much harder. Not only must he guard against the rumormongering that was implicit in administration channels, he must now be doubly sure that none of his information fell into other hands where it might be used against him.

The squirrel had gone on down the tree trunk and now was busily scrounging on the slope of lawn that ran down to the lake, rustling through the fallen leaves in search of an acorn he might somehow have missed before. The boy and girl had walked out of sight and now a hesitant breeze was softly rumpling the surface of the lake.

There were only a few others at breakfast in the room; most of those who had been there when Maxwell entered had finished now and left. From the floor above came the distant murmuring of voices, the scuffling of feet as the daily flow of students began to fill the Union, the off-hours gathering place of undergraduates.

It was one of the oldest structures on the campus and one of the finest, Maxwell told himself. For over five hundred years it had been the meeting place, the refuge, the study hall of many generations and in the course of all these generations it had settled easily and comfortably into the functional tradition that made it a second home for many thousand students. Here could be found a quietness for reflection or for study, here the cozy corners needed for good talk, here the game rooms for billiards or for chess, here the eating places, here the meeting halls, and tucked off in odd corners little reading rooms with their shelves of books.

Maxwell pushed back his chair, but stayed sitting, finding himself somehow reluctant to get up and leave-for once he left this place, he knew, he’d plunge into the problems he must face. Outside the window lay a golden autumn day, warming as the sun rose in the sky-a day for showers of golden leaves, for blue haze on the distant hills, for the solemn glory of chrysanthemums bedded in the garden, for the quiet glow of goldenrod and aster in the fields and vacant lots.

From behind him he heard the scurrying of many hard-shod feet and when he swung around in his chair, he saw the owner of the feet advancing rapidly across the squared red tiles toward him.

It looked like an outsize, land-going shrimp, with its jointed legs, its strangely canted body with long, weird rods-apparently sensory organs-extending outward from its tiny head. Its color was an unhealthy white and its three globular black eyes bobbed on the ends of long antennae.

It came to a halt beside the table and the three antennae swiveled to aim the three eyes straight at Maxwell.

It said in a high, piping voice, the skin of its throat fluttering rapidly beneath the seemingly inadequate head, “Informed I am that you be Professor Peter Maxwell.”

“The information happens to be right,” said Maxwell. “I am Peter Maxwell.”

“I be a creature out of the world you would name Spearhead Twenty-seven. Name I have is of no interest to you. I appear before you in carrying out commission by my employer. Perhaps you know it by designation of Miss Nancy Clayton.”

“Indeed I do,” said Maxwell, thinking that it was very much like Nancy Clayton to employ an outlandish creature such as this for an errand boy.

“I work myself through education,” explained the Shrimp, “doing anything I find.”

“That’s commendable,” said Maxwell.

“I train in mathematics of time,” declared the Shrimp. “I concentrate on world-line configurations. I am in tizzy over it.”

The Shrimp didn’t look as if it were in any sort of tizzy. “Why all the interest?” Maxwell asked “Something in your background? Something in your cultural heritage?”

“Oh, very much indeed. Is completely new idea. On my world, no thought of time, no appreciation such a thing as time. Am much shocked to learn of it. And excited, too. But I digress too greatly. I come here on an errand. Miss Clayton desires to know can you attend a party the evening of this day. Her place, eight by the clock.”

“I believe I can,” said Maxwell. “Tell her I always make a point of being at her parties.”

“Overjoyed,” said the Shrimp. “She so much wants you there. You are talked concerning.”

“I see,” said Maxwell.

“You hard to find. I run hard and fast. I ask in many places. Finally victorious.”

“I am sorry,” Maxwell said, “I put you to such trouble.”

He reached into his pocket and took out a bill. The creature extended one of its forward legs and grasped the bill in a pair of pincers, folded it and refolded it and tucked it into a small pouch that extruded from its chest.

“You kind beyond expectation,” it piped. “There is one further information. Occasion for party is unveiling of painting, recently acquired. Painting lost and gone for very long. By Albert Lambert, Esquire. Great triumph for Miss Clayton.”

“I just bet it is,” said Maxwell. “Miss Clayton is a specialist in triumphs.”

“She, as employer, is gracious,” said the Shrimp reprovingly.

“I am sure of that,” said Maxwell.

The creature shifted swiftly and galloped from the room.

Listening to its departure, Maxwell heard it clatter up the stairs to the street level of the building.

Maxwell got up and headed for the stairs himself. If he were going to witness the unveiling of a painting, he told himself, he’d better bone up on the artist. Which was exactly, he thought with a grin, what almost every other person invited to Nancy ’s party would be doing before the day was out.

Lambert? The name held a slight ring of recognition. He had read somewhere about him, probably long ago. An article in a magazine, perhaps, to help pass an idle hour.

Maxwell opened the book.

“Albert Lambert,” said the opening page of text, “was born in Chicago, Illinois, January 11, 1973. Famed as a portrayer of grotesque symbolism, his early years gave no promise of his great accomplishments. His initial work, while it was competent and showed a skillful craftsmanship and a deep insight into his subject matter, was not particularly outstanding. His grotesque period came after his fiftieth year and, rather than developing, burst into full flower almost overnight, as if the artist had developed it secretly and did not show his canvasses of this period until he was satisfied with this new phase of his work. But there is no evidence that this actually was the case; rather, there seems to be some evidence that it was not…”

Maxwell flipped over the text pages to reach the color plates and leafed quickly through examples of the artist’s early work. And there, in the space of one page to the next, the paintings changed-the artistic concept, the color, even, it seemed to Maxwell, the very craftsmanship.

As if the work had been that of two different artists, the first tied intellectually to some inner need of orderly expression, the second engulfed, obsessed, ridden by some soul-shaking experience of which he tried to cleanse himself by spreading it on canvas.

Stark, dark, terrible beauty beat out of the page and in the dusky silence of the library reading room it seemed to Maxwell that he could hear the leathery whisper of black wings. Outrageous creatures capered across the outrageous landscape, and yet the landscape and the creatures, Maxwell sensed at once, were not mere fantasy, were no whimsical product of a willful unhinging of the mind, but seemed to be solidly based upon some outre geometry predicated upon a logic and an outlook alien to anything he had ever seen. The form, the color, the approach and the attitude were not merely twisted human values; one had the instant feeling that they might be, instead, the prosaic representation of a situation in an area entirely outside any human value. Grotesque symbolism, the text had said, and it might be there, of course, but if so, Maxwell told himself, a symbolism that could only be arrived at most tortuously after painful study.

He turned the page and there it was again, that complete divergence from humanity-a different scene with different creatures against a different landscape, but carrying, as had that first plate, the shattering impact of actuality, no figment of the artist’s mind, but the representation of a scene he once had gazed upon and sought now to expurgate from mind and memory. As a man might wash his hands, Maxwell thought, lathering them fiercely with a bar of strong, harsh soap, scrubbing them again and yet again, endlessly, in a desperate attempt to remove by physical means a psychic stain that he had incurred. A scene that he had gazed upon, perhaps, not through human eyes, but through the alien optics of a lost and unguessed race.

Maxwell sat fascinated, staring at the page, wanting to pull his eyes away, but unable to, trapped by the weird and awful beauty, by some terrible, hidden purpose that he could not understand. Time, the Shrimp had said, was something that his race had never thought of, a universal factor that had not impinged upon his culture, and here, captured in these color plates, was something that man had never thought of, had never even dreamed.

He reached out his hand to grasp the book and close it, but he hesitated as if there were some reason he should not close the book, some compelling reason to continue staring at the plate.

And in that hesitancy, he became aware of a certain strangeness that might keep him staring at the page-a puzzling factor that he had not recognized consciously, but that had been nagging at him.

He took his hands away and sat staring at the plate, then slowly turned the page and as he glanced at that third plate, the strangeness leaped out at him-a brushed-in flickering, an artistic technique that made an apparent shimmer, as if something of substance were there and twinkling, seen one moment, not quite seen the next.

He sat, slack-jawed, and watched the flickering-a trick of the eye, most likely, a trick of the eye encouraged by the mastery of the artist over paint and brush. But trick of the eye or not, easy of recognition by anyone who had seen the ghostly race of the crystal planet.

And through the hushed silence of the dusky room one question hammered at him: How could Albert Lambert have known about the people of the crystal planet?

“I had heard about you,” Allen Preston said, “and it seemed incredible, of course. But the source of my information seemed unimpeachable and I made an effort to get in touch with you. I’m a bit worried over this situation, Pete. As an attorney, I’d say you were in trouble.”

Maxwell sat down in the chair in front of Preston ’s desk. “I suppose I am,” he said. “For one thing, it appears I’ve lost my job. Is there such a thing as tenure in a case like mine?”

“A case like yours?” the attorney asked. “Just what is the situation? No one seems to know. Everyone is talking about it, but no one seems to know. I, myself…”

Maxwell grinned wryly. “Sure. You’d like to know. You’re puzzled and confused and not quite sure you’re sane. You sit there wondering if I’m really Peter Maxwell.”

“Well, are you?” Preston asked.

“I am sure I am. I wouldn’t blame you, or anyone, if you doubted it. There were two of us. Something happened to the wave pattern. One of us went to the Coonskin system, the other somewhere else. The one who went to Coonskin came back to Earth and died. I came back yesterday.”

“And found that you were dead.”

Maxwell nodded. “My apartment had been rented, my possessions all are gone. The university tells me my position has been filled and I’m without a job. That’s why I asked about the tenure situation.”

Preston leaned back in his chair and squinted thoughtfully at Maxwell. “Legally,” he said, “I think we’d find that the university stands on solid ground. You are dead, you see. You have no tenure now. Not, at least, until it can be reestablished.”

“Through a long process at law?”

“Yes, I would suspect so. I can’t give you an honest answer. There is no precedent. Oh, sure there are precedents in the case of mistaken identity-someone who is dead being mistakenly identified as someone who is still alive. But with you, there’s no mistake. A man who undeniably was Peter Maxwell is undeniably dead, and there is no precedent for reestablishing identity in a situation such as that. We’d have to set our own precedent as we went along, a very laborious beating through the thickets of legal argument. It might take years. To tell you the truth, I’m not sure where or how to start. Oh, it could be developed, it could be carried forward, but it would take a lot of work and thought. First, of course, we’d have to establish, legally, who you are.”

“Who I really am? For God’s sake, Al, we know who I am.”

“But the law doesn’t. The law wouldn’t recognize you as you are today. You have no legal being. Absolutely none. All your identification cards have been turned in to Records and have been filed by now-”

“But I have those cards,” said Maxwell quietly. “Right here in my pocket.”

Preston stared at him. “Yes, come to think of it, I suppose you have. Oh Lord, what a mess!”

He got up and walked across the room, shaking his head. At the wall, he turned around and came back. He sat down again.

“Let me think about it,” he said. “Give me a little time. I can dig up something. We have to dig up something. And there’s a lot to do. There’s the matter of your will…”

“My will? I’d forgot about the will. Never thought of it.”

“It’s in probate. But I can get a stay of some sort.”

“I willed everything to my brother, who’s with the Exploratory Service. I could get in touch with him, although it might be quite a chore. He’s usually out with the fleet. But the point is that there’ll be no trouble there. As soon as he knows what happened…”

“Not with him,” said Preston, “but the court’s a different, matter. It can be done, of course, but it may take time. Until it’s cleared, you’ll have no claim to your estate. You own nothing except the clothes you stand in and what is in your pockets.”

“The university offered me a post on Gothic IV. Dean of a research unit. But at the moment, I’m not about to take it.”

“How are you fixed for cash?”

“I’m all right. For the present. Oop took me in and I have some money. If I had to, I could pick up some sort of job. Harlow Sharp would help me out if I needed something. Go on one of his field trips, if nothing else. I think I might like that.”

“But don’t you have to have some sort of Time degree?”

“Not if you go as a working member of the expedition. To hold a supervisory post of some sort, it would take one, I suppose.”

“Before I start moving,” Preston said, “I’ll have to know the details. Everything that happened.”

“I’ll write out a statement for you. Have it notarized. Anything you want.”

“Seems to me,” said Preston, “we might file action against Transportation. They put you in this mess.”

Maxwell hedged. “Not right now,” he said. “We can think of it later on.”

“You get that statement put together,” Preston told him. “And in the meantime, I’ll do some thinking and look up some law. Then we can make a start. Have you seen the papers or looked at television?”

Maxwell shook his head. “I haven’t had the time.”

“They’re going wild,” said Preston. “It’s a wonder they haven’t cornered you. They must be looking for you. All they have as yet is conjecture. You were seen last night at the Pig and Whistle. A lot of people apparently spotted you there last night, or thought they did. The line right now is that you’ve come back from the dead. If I were you, I’d keep out of their way. If they should catch up with you, tell them absolutely nothing.”

“I have no intention to,” said Maxwell.

They sat in the quiet office, looking silently at one another.”

“What a mess!” said Preston, finally. “What a lovely mess! I believe, Pete, I might just enjoy this.”

“By the way,” said Maxwell, “Nancy Clayton invited me to a party tonight. I’ve been wondering if there might be some connection-although there needn’t be. Nancy used to invite me on occasion.”

Preston grinned. “Why, you’re a celebrity. You’d be quite a catch for Nancy.”

“I’m not too sure of that,” said Maxwell. “She must have heard I had shown up. She’d be curious, of course.”

“Yes,” said Preston dryly, “she would be curious.”

Maxwell expected that he might find newsmen lying in wait for him at Oop’s shack, but there was no one there. Apparently the word hadn’t spread that he was staying there.

The shack stood in the drowsiness of late afternoon, with the autumn sunlight pouring like molten gold over the weatherbeaten lumber scraps of which it had been built. A few bees buzzed lazily in a bed of asters that grew outside the door, and down the stretch of hillside above the roadway a few yellow butterflies drifted in the hazy afternoon.

Maxwell opened the door and stuck in his head. There was no one there. Oop was off prowling somewhere and there was no sign of Ghost. A banked fire glowed redly in the fireplace. Maxwell shut the door and sat down on the bench that stood before the shack.

Far to the west one of the campus four lakes shone as a thin blue lens. The countryside was painted brown and yellow by dead sedges and dying grasses. Here and there little islands of color flared in scattered groups of trees.

Warm and soft, thought Maxwell. A land that one could dream in. Unlike those violent, gloomy landscapes that Lambert had painted so many years ago.

He sat wondering why those landscapes should stick so tightly, like a bur against his mind. Wondering, too, how the artist could have known how the ghostly inhabitants of the crystal planet flickered. It could not be merely happenstance; it was not the sort of thing a man might readily imagine. Reason said that Lambert must have known about those ghostly people, reason just as plainly said it was impossible.

And what about all those other creatures, all those other grotesque monstrosities Lambert had spread with an insane, vicious brush across the canvasses? Where did they fit in? Where might they have come from? Or were they simply mad figments of imagination, torn raw and bleeding from a strangely tortured mind? Were the people of the crystal planet the only authentic creatures Lambert had depicted? It did not seem too likely. Somewhere or other, somehow or other, Lambert must have seen these other creatures, too. And was the landscape pure imagination, brushed in to maintain the mood established by the creatures, or might it have been the landscape of the crystal planet at some other time, before it had been fixed forever in the floor and roof that shut it in against the universe? But that, he told himself, was impossible, for the planet had been enclosed before the present universe was born. Ten billion years at least, perhaps as much as fifty billion.

Maxwell stirred uneasily. It made no sense at all. None of it made any sort of sense. He had trouble enough, he told himself, without worrying about Lambert’s paintings. He had lost his job, his estate was locked in probate, be didn’t have a legal standing as a human being.

But none of that mattered too much, not right now, anyhow. First came the matter of the hoard of knowledge on the crystal planet. It was a knowledge the university must have-a body of knowledge that most certainly was greater than the total of all knowledge in the known galaxy. Some of it would duplicate what was already known, of course, but there would be, he was certain, other huge areas of understanding which were yet unthought of. The little that he had had the time to see bolstered that belief.

Once again, it seemed, he was hunkered down before the table, almost like a coffee table, on which he’d piled the metal sheets he had taken from the shelves, and with the contraption that was a reader, an interpreter, call it what one might, fastened to his head.

There had been the sheet of metal that talked about the mind, not in metaphysical or philosophic terms, but as a mechanism, employing terms and concepts that he could not grasp. He had struggled with the terminology, he remembered, for he knew that here was a treatise on an area of understanding no one yet had touched, but after a time had put it to one side, for it was beyond him. And there was that other piece of metal, that other book, which appeared to be a basic text on the application of certain mathematical principles to the social sciences, although some of the social sciences that were mentioned he could only guess at, groping after the concepts as a blind man might grope after flitting butterflies. There had been histories, he recalled, not of one universe, but two, and natural history which had told of life forms so fantastic in their basic principles and their functions that they seemed unbelievable, and a very thin sheet of metal, so thin it bent and twisted, like a sheet of paper, when he handled it, that had been so far beyond his understanding that he could not quite be sure what it was about. And a thicker piece of metal, a much thicker piece, wherein he read the thoughts and philosophies of creatures and of cultures long since gone to dust that had sent him reeling back, frightened, disgusted, outraged and dismayed, but still full of a fearful wonder, at the utter inhumanity expressed m those philosophies.

All that and more, much more, a trillion times more, was waiting out there on the crystal planet.

It was important, he reminded himself, that he carry out the assignment that he had been given. It was vital that the library of the crystal planet be attained and, probably, although no time limit had been placed, that it be done quickly. For if he failed there was, he felt sure, a good possibility that the planet would go elsewhere to seek another market, to offer what it had, out into another sector of the galaxy, perhaps out of the galaxy entirely.

The Artifact, he told himself, could be the price, although he could not be sure of that. The fact that an offer had been made for it, and that Churchill somehow was involved in it, made that seem reasonable. But at the moment he could not be sure. The Artifact might be wanted by someone for some other purpose, perhaps by someone who might finally have figured out exactly what it was. He tried to imagine exactly what they might have found, but he had no facts to go on, and he failed.

A flight of blackbirds came swirling down out of the sky, skimming just above the roof of the shack, sailing over the roadway. Maxwell watched them settle into the dying vegetation of a stretch of marsh, balancing their bodies delicately on the bending stems of rank-growing weeds, come there to feed for an hour or so before flying off to roost in some secluded woodland they had picked as a bivouac on their migration southward.

Maxwell got up and stretched. The peace and the quiet of the tawny afternoon had soaked into his body. He’d like a nap, he thought. After a time Oop would come back home and wake him and they’d have something to eat and talk for a while before he went off to Nancy ’s.

He opened the door and went into the shack, crossing the floor to sit upon the bed. Maybe, he thought, he ought to see if he still had a clean shirt and an extra pair of socks to don before the party. He reached out and hauled his bag off the floor and dumped it on the bed.

Opening the catches, he threw back the lid and took out a pair of trousers to get at the shirts that were packed beneath them. The shirts were there and so was something else, a contraption with a headband and two eyepieces folded up against it.

He stared at it in wonder, recognizing it. It was the translator which he had used on the crystal planet to read the metal tablets. He lifted it out and let it dangle in his hand. Here was the band to clamp around the head, with the power pack in the back, and the two eyepieces one flipped down into position once the device was fastened on the head.

He must have packed it by mistake, he thought, although be could not, for the life of him, remember packing it. But there it was and perhaps no harm was done. It might even be used at some future time to help substantiate his claim he had been on the planet. Although, he realized, it was not good evidence. It was just a gadget that had an ordinary look about it, although it might not, he reminded himself, seem so ordinary if someone poked around in the mechanism of it.

A light tapping came from somewhere and Maxwell, surprised by so small a noise, stiffened and held himself rigid, listening. Perhaps a windblown branch, he thought, tapping on the roof, although it had a slightly different sound than a branch against the roof.

The tapping stopped and then began again, this time not a steady rapping, but rather like a code. Three quick taps and then a pause, followed by two rapid taps and then another pause, with the pattern of the tapping repeated once again.

It was someone at the door.

Maxwell got up from the bed and stood undecided. It might be newsmen who had finally tracked him down, or thought they’d tracked him down, and if that should be the case, it might be best to leave the door unanswered. But the tapping at the door, it seemed to him, was not boisterous enough, not demanding enough, for a newsman, or several newsmen, who had finally run him to his lair. The taps were soft, almost tentative, the kind of tapping that might be done by someone who did not want to advertise their presence, or who, for one reason or another, was not quite sure of purpose. And if it were newsmen, Maxwell realized, it would do no good not to let them in, for in a little while they’d try the door and find it open and then come bursting in.

The tapping, which had stopped for a moment, took up again. Maxwell trudged to the door and threw it open. Outside stood the Shrimp, a ghostly, gleaming white in the wash of sunlight. Beneath one of his limbs, which now served as an arm rather than a leg, he clutched a paper-wrapped bundle tight against his body.

“For the love of God, come in,” said Maxwell sharply, “before someone sees you here.”

The Shrimp came in and Maxwell closed the door, wondering what it was that had caused him to urge it in.

“You need no apprehension,” said the Shrimp, “about news harvesters. I was careful and I noticed. No one followed me. I’m such a foolish-looking creature no one ever follows me. No one ever accords to me any purpose whatsoever.”

“That is a fortunate thing to have,” said Maxwell. “I think that it is called protective coloration.”

“I appear again,” said Shrimp, “on behalf of Miss Nancy Clayton. She knows you carried little on your trip, have had no chance to shop or have laundry done. No wish to embarrass-charging me to say this with goodly emphasis-but wish to send you clothes to wear.”

He took the bundle from underneath his arm and handed it to Maxwell.

“That is nice of Nancy.”

“She is thoughtful person. She commissioned me to say further.”

“Go ahead,” said Maxwell.

“There will be wheeled vehicle to take you to the house.”

“There is no need of that,” said Maxwell. “The roadway runs right past her place.”

“Once again apology,” said the Shrimp, with firmness, “but she thinks it best. There is much hithering and thithering, by many types of creatures, to learn your whereabouts.”

“Can you tell me,” asked Maxwell, “how Miss Clayton knows my whereabouts?”

Said the Shrimp, “I truly do not know.”

“All right, then. You’ll thank Miss Clayton for me?”

“With gladness,” said the Shrimp.

“I’ll take you around to the back,” the driver said. “There is a swarm of newsmen hanging around out front. They’ll be gone later on, but now they’re there in droves. Miss Clayton suggested you might not want to meet them.”

“Thank you,” Maxwell said. “It is thoughtful of you.” Nancy, he told himself, had taken over, as was her usual practice, viewing it as her prerogative to order people’s lives.

Her house stood on the low bluff that hemmed in the western edge of the lake. Off to the left the water gleamed softly in the early moonlight. The front of the house was ablaze with light, but the back was dark.

The car turned off the highway and climbed slowly along a narrow driveway lined by massive oaks. A startled bird flew, squawking, across the roadway, a flurry of desperately beating wings caught for a moment in the headlights. A pair of dogs came raging down the hollow tunnel of the drive, split and swung on either side of the car.

The driver chuckled. “If you were walking, they’d eat you alive.”

“But why?” asked Maxwell. “Why, all at once, must Nancy be guarded by a dog pack?”

“Not Miss Clayton,” the driver said. “It is someone else.”

The question came to Maxwell’s tongue, but he choked it back.

The driver swung the car into a curved driveway that ran beneath an open portico, and pulled up to a halt.

“In the back door,” the driver said. “You don’t need to knock. Then straight down the hall past the curved staircase. The party’s up in front.”

Maxwell started to open the car door, then hesitated.

“You need not mind the dogs,” the driver told him. “They recognize the car. Anyone who steps out of it is OK with them.”

There was, in fact, no sign of the dogs, and Maxwell went swiftly up the three steps of the stoop, opened the back door, and stepped into the hall.

The hall was dark, A little light filtered down the winding staircase-someone apparently had left on a light on the second story. But that was all; there were no other lights. From somewhere in the front of the house came the muffled sound of revelry.

He stood for a moment without moving and as his eyes became accustomed to the darkness, he could see that the hall ran for some distance toward the center of the house, past the foot of the winding stairs and beyond. There was a door back there, or perhaps an abrupt turn in the hall, that would take him party-ward.

It was strange, he told himself. If Nancy had instructed the driver to bring him to the back, she would have had someone there to greet him, or at least she would have seen that there was a light so he could find his way.

Strange, and very awkward, to arrive this way, to grope his way along the hall in search of the others who were there. For a moment he considered turning about and leaving, making his way back to Oop’s place. Then he remembered the dogs. They would be out there and waiting and they looked like vicious brutes.

This whole business, he told himself, was not at all like Nancy. Nancy wouldn’t do a thing like this. There was something very wrong and he did not like it.

He moved cautiously down the hall, alert for chair or table that might be there to trip him up. He could see a little better now, but the hall was still a tunnel without any details.

He passed the stairs, skirting around their base, and now, with the light from the stairway partially cut off, the hall became darker than it was before.

A voice asked, “Professor Maxwell? Is that you, Professor?”

Maxwell stopped in mid-stride, balancing on one leg, then carefully put his lifted foot down against the floor and stood, not stirring, while goose bumps prickled on his skin.

“Professor Maxwell,” said the voice, “I know that you are out there.” It was not a voice, actually, or it didn’t seem to be. There had been no sound, Maxwell could have sworn, yet he had heard the words, not so much, perhaps, in his ear, as somewhere in his brain.

He felt the terror mounting in him and he tried to fight it off, but it didn’t go away. It stayed, crouched somewhere out there in the dark, ready to rush in.

He tried to speak and gulped instead. The voice said, “I’ve waited here for you, Professor. I want to communicate with you. It is to your interest as much as it is to mine.”

“Where are you?” Maxwell asked.

“Through the door just to your left.”

“I do not see a door.”

Good common sense hammered hard at Maxwell. Break and run, it said. Get out of here as fast as you can go.

But he couldn’t break and run. He couldn’t bring himself to do it. And if he ran, which way should he run? Not back to the door, for the dogs were waiting out there. Not clattering down the darkened hall, more than likely to bump into something and raise a terrible clatter, to alert the guests up there in front and to be found, when they investigated, disheveled and bruised and sweating with his fear. For if he ran, he knew, fear would pounce upon him and he’d give way to it.

It was bad enough sneaking in from the back door on a party without being found in a condition such as that.

If it had been just a voice, any kind of voice, it would not have been so frightening, but it was a strange kind of voice-there was no intonation to it and there was about it a certain raw, mechanical, almost rasping quality. It was not a. human voice, Maxwell told himself. There was an alien in that room.

“There is a door,” the flat, hard voice said. “Step slightly to your left and push against it.”

The whole thing was becoming ridiculous, Maxwell told himself. Either he went through the door or he broke and ran. He might try to simply walk away, but he knew that the minute he turned his back upon that hidden door, he would run-not because he wanted to, but because he had to, running from the fear he had turned his back upon.

He stepped to the left, found the door, and pushed. The room was dark, but from a lamp somewhere in the yard outside, some light filtered through the windows, falling on a roly-poly creature that stood in the center of the room, its pudgy belly gleaming with a writhing phosphorescence, as if a group of luminescent sea-dwellers had been imprisoned in a bowl.

“Yes,” the creature said, “you are quite right. I am one of those beings that you call a Wheeler. For my visit here I have given myself a designation that falls easy on your mind. You may call be Mr. Marmaduke. For convenience only, I suspect you understand, for it’s not my name. In fact, none of us have names. They are unnecessary. Our personal identity is achieved in another way.”

“I am pleased to meet you, Mr. Marmaduke,” said Maxwell, speaking slowly, the only way he could, since his lips had become, like the rest of him, slightly stiff and frozen.

“And I you, Professor.”

“How did you know who I was?” asked Maxwell. “You seemed to have no doubt at all. You knew, of course, I’d be coming down the hall.”

“Of course,” the Wheeler said.

Now Maxwell could see the creature a bit more clearly, the bloated body supported on two wheels, the lower part of the body gleaming and twisting like a pail of worms.

“You are Nancy ’s guest?” he asked.

“Yes,” said Mr. Marmaduke, “certainly I am. The guest of honor, I believe, at this gathering she has.”

“Then, perhaps, you should be out with the other guests.”

“I pleaded tiredness,” said Mr. Marmaduke. “A slight prevarication, I must admit, since I am never tired. So I went to rest a while-”

“And to wait for me?”

“Precisely,” said Mr. Marmaduke.

Nancy, Maxwell thought. No, Nancy, he was sure, wasn’t in on it. She had a frothy brain and all she cared about were her everlasting parties and she’d be incapable of any kind of intrigue.

“There is a subject we can talk about,” said Mr. Marmaduke, “with some profit, I presume, to the both of us. You are looking for a buyer, I believe, for a large commodity. I might have some passing interest in that commodity.”

Maxwell moved back a step and tried to find an answer. But there was no ready answer. Although he should have known, he told himself, or at least have suspected.

“You say nothing,” said Mr. Marmaduke. “I cannot be mistaken. You are, without fail, the agent for the sale?”

“Yes,” said Maxwell. “Yes, I am the agent.”

There was no use denying it, he knew. Somehow or other, this creature in the room knew about the other planet and the hoard of knowledge. And he might know the price as well. Could it have been the Wheeler, he wondered, who had made the offer for the Artifact?

“Well, then,” said Mr. Marmaduke, “let us proceed immediately to business and a discussion of the terms. Not forgetting, in the course of it, to mention the commission that will be coming to you.”

“I am afraid,” said Maxwell, “that is impossible at the moment. I do not know the terms. You see, I was first to find a potential buyer and then-”

“No trouble whatsoever,” said Mr. Marmaduke, “for I have the knowledge that you lack. I am acquainted with the terms.”

“And you will pay the price?”

“Oh, without any question,” said the Wheeler. “It will take just a little time. There are certain negotiations which must be terminated. Once those are done, you and I can complete all business and the matter will be done, without any fuss or trouble. The only thing, it would appear to me, is a determination of the commission which you will have earned so richly.”

“I would imagine,” said Maxwell bleakly, “that it might be a good commission.”

“We had in mind,” said Mr. Marmaduke, “of naming you-shall we say librarian?of the commodity we purchase. There will be much to do working out the various commodities and codifying them. For work of this sort we will need a creature such as you, and I imagine that you might find the work highly interesting. And the salary-Professor Maxwell, we pray you name the salary and the conditions of employment.”

“I would have to think about it.”

“By all means,” said Mr. Marmaduke. “In a procedure such as this, a little thought is good. You will find us most disposed to generosity.”

“That’s not what I meant,” said Maxwell. “I’ll have to think about the deal. Whether I’d be willing to arrange a sale for you.”

“You doubt, perhaps, our worthiness to purchase the commodity?”

“That might be it,” said Maxwell.

“Professor Maxwell,” said the Wheeler, “it would be advisable for you to lay aside your doubts. It is for the best that you entertain no doubt of us at all. For we are most determined that we shall obtain what you have to offer. So, in the best of grace, you should deal with us.”

“Whether I want to or not?” asked Maxwell.

“I,” said Mr. Marmaduke, “would have not put it quite so bluntly. But you state it most correctly.”

“You are not in the best position,” Maxwell told him, “to speak in that tone of voice.”

“You are not aware of the position that we hold,” the Wheeler said. “Your knowledge goes out to only a certain point in space. You cannot know what lies beyond that point.”

There was something in the words, something in the way that they were said, that sent a chill through Maxwell, as if from some unknown quarter of the universe a sharp, frigid blast of wind had blown through the room.

Your knowledge goes only to a certain point in space, Mr. Marmaduke had said, and what lay beyond that point? No one could know, of course, except that in certain areas beyond the shadowy frontier of man’s probing it was known the Wheelers had staked out an empire. And seeping across that frontier came horror stories, such tales as any frontier might inspire, stemming from man’s wonder concerning that unknown which lay just a little way ahead.

There had been little contact with the Wheelers and there was almost nothing known of them-and that in itself was bad. There was no thrusting out of hands, no gestures of goodwill, either from the Wheelers or from the humans and their friends and allies. The frontier lay there, in that one great sector out in space, a silent, sullen line that neither side had crossed.

“I would be better able to come to some decision,” Maxwell said, “if my knowledge did extend, if we could know more about you.”

“You know that we are bugs,” said Mr. Marmaduke, and the words fairly dripped with scorn. “You are intolerant-”

“Not intolerant,” said Maxwell angrily, “and we do not think of you as bugs. We know you are what we would call hive mechanisms. We know each of you is a colony of creatures similar to the life forms that here on Earth we think of as insects, and that sets us apart from you, of course, but no more distant from us than many other creatures from many other stars. I do not like the word ’intolerant,’ Mr. Marmaduke, because it implies that there is ground for tolerance and there is no such thing-not for you, nor me, nor any other creature in the universe.”

He found that he was shaking with his anger and he wondered why he should suddenly become so angry at a single word. He could remain calm at the thought of the Wheeler buying the knowledge of the crystal planet, then flare with sudden anger at one specific word. Perhaps because, he told himself, with so many different races who must live together, both tolerance and intolerance had become dirty words.

“You argue well and amiably,” said Mr. Marmaduke, “and you may not be intolerant-”

“Even were there such a thing as intolerance,” said Maxwell, “I cannot understand why you’d resent it so. It would be a reflection upon the one who had exhibited it rather than upon the one toward whom it was directed. Not only a reflection upon good manners, but upon one’s basic knowledge. There can be nothing quite so stupid as intolerance.”

“Then if not intolerance,” asked the Wheeler, “what makes you hesitate?”

“I would have to know how you meant to use the commodity. I would want to know your purpose. I would need to know a great deal more about you.”

“So that you could judge?”

“I don’t know,” said Maxwell bitterly. “How can one judge a situation such as this?”

“We talk too much,” said Mr. Marmaduke. “And the talk is meaningless. I perceive you have no intention to make a deal with us.”

“At the moment,” Maxwell told him, “I would say that you were right.”

“Then,” said Mr. Marmaduke, “we must find another way. You will cause us, by your refusal, a great deal of time and trouble and we’ll be most ungrateful to you.”

“I have a feeling,” Maxwell said, “that I can bear up under your ingratitude.”

“There is a certain advantage, sir,” warned Mr. Marmaduke, “in being on the winning side.”

Something big and moving swiftly brushed past Maxwell and out of the corner of his eye he caught the sudden flash of gleaming teeth and the streak of tawny body.

“No, Sylvester!” Maxwell shouted. “Leave him alone, Sylvester!”

Mr. Marmaduke moved swiftly. His wheels blurred as he spun and swept in a quick half-circle, skirting Sylvester’s rushing charge and heading for the door. Sylvester’s claws screeched as he turned, swapping end for end. Maxwell, seeing the Wheeler bearing down upon him, ducked out of the way, but a wheel grazed his shoulder and brushed him roughly to one side. With a swish, Mr. Marmaduke went streaking out the door. Behind him came Sylvester, long and lithe, a tawny shape that seemed to flow smoothly through the air.

“No Sylvester!” Maxwell screamed, flinging himself through the door and making a quick turn in the hall, his legs pumping rapidly as he skidded on the turn.

Ahead of him the Wheeler was rolling smoothly down the hall, with Sylvester close behind him. Maxwell wasted no more breath in yelling at the cat, but drove his body forward in pursuit.

At the far end of the hall, Mr. Marmaduke swung smoothly to the left and Sylvester, almost on top of him, lost precious seconds as he fought, and failed, to make as smooth a turn. Warned of the turning in the hall, Maxwell took it in his stride and ahead of him he saw a lighted corridor that led to a short marble staircase and beyond the staircase a crowd of people standing about in little knots, with glasses in their hands.

Mr. Marmaduke was heading for the staircase, going very fast. Sylvester was one leap ahead of Maxwell, perhaps three leaps behind the Wheeler.

Maxwell tried to yell a warning, but he didn’t have the breath and, in any case, events were moving much too fast.

The Wheeler hit the top step of the staircase and Maxwell launched his body through the air, arms outstretched. He came down on top of the saber-tooth and wrapped his arms around its neck. The two of them sprawled to the floor and out of the corner of his eye, as he and Sylvester cartwheeled down the corridor, Maxwell saw the Wheeler bouncing high on the second step and beginning to tip over.

And then, suddenly, there was the screaming of frightened women and the yells of startled men and the crash of breaking glasses. For once, thought Maxwell grimly, Nancy was getting a bigger boot out of her party than she had bargained for.

He piled up against a wall, at the far edge of the staircase, and somehow or other, Sylvester was perched on top of him and reaching down to lap fondly at his face.

“Sylvester,” he said, “this was the time you did it. You got us in a mess.”

Sylvester went on lapping and a rasping purr rumbled in his chest.

Maxwell pushed the cat away and managed to slide up the wall to a sitting position.

Out on the floor of the room beyond the staircase, Mr. Marmaduke lay upon his side, both wheels spinning crazily, the friction of the wheel that was bottom-most making him rotate lopsidedly.

Carol came running up the steps and stopped, with fists firmly on her hips, to stare down at Maxwell and the cat.

“The two of you!” she cried, then choked with anger.

“We’re sorry,” Maxwell said.

“The guest of honor,” she screamed at them, almost weeping. “The guest of honor and you two hunting him down the halls as if he were a moose.”

“Apparently we didn’t hurt him much,” said Maxwell. “I see he is intact. I wouldn’t have been surprised if his belly broke and all those bugs of his were scattered on the floor.

“What will Nancy think?” Carol asked accusingly.

“I imagine,” Maxwell told her, “that she’ll be delighted. There hasn’t been this much ruckus at one of her parties since the time the fire-breathing amphibian out of the Nettle system set the Christmas tree on fire.”

“You make those things up,” said Carol, “I don’t believe it happened.”

“Cross my heart,” said Maxwell. “I was here and saw it. Helped put out the fire.”

Out on the floor some of the guests had laid hold of Mr. Marmaduke and were pulling him over to stand upright on his wheels. Little serving robotics were scurrying about, picking up the broken glass and mopping up the floor where the drinks had spilled.

Maxwell got to his feet and Sylvester moved over close beside him, rubbing against his legs and purring.

Nancy had arrived from somewhere and was talking with Mr. Marmaduke. A large circle of guests stood around and listened to the talk.

“If I were you,” suggested Carol, “I’d skin out of here the best way that I could. I can’t imagine that you’ll be welcome here.”

“On the contrary,” Maxwell told her, “I’m always welcome here.”

He started walking down the staircase, with Sylvester pacing regally beside him. Nancy turned and saw him, broke through the circle and came across the floor to meet him. “Pete!” she cried. “Then it’s really true. You are back again.”

“Why, of course,” said Maxwell.

“I saw it in the papers, but I didn’t quite believe it. I thought it was a hoax or a gag of some sort.”

“But you invited me,” said Maxwell.

“Invited you?”

She wasn’t kidding him. He could see she wasn’t kidding.

“You mean you didn’t send the Shrimp…”

“The Shrimp?”

“Well, a thing that looked like an overgrown shrimp.”

She shook her head and, watching her face, Maxwell saw, with something of a shock, that she was growing old. There were many tiny wrinkles around the corners of her eyes that cosmetics failed to hide.

“A thing that looked like a shrimp,” he said. “Said it was running errands for you. It said I was invited to the party. It said a car would be sent to fetch me. It even brought me clothes, because it said-”

“Pete,” said Nancy, “please believe me. I did none of this. I did not invite you, but I’m glad you’re here.”

She moved closer and lay a hand upon his arm. Her face crinkled in a giggle. “And I’ll be interested in hearing about what happened between you and Mr. Marmaduke.”

“That I’m sorry about,” said Maxwell.

“No need to be. He’s my guest, of course, and one must be considerate of guests, but he’s a really terrible person. Pete, he’s basically a bore and a snob and-”

“Not now,” Maxwell warned her softly.

Mr. Marmaduke had disengaged himself from the circle of guests and was wheeling across the floor toward them. Nancy turned to face him.

“You’re all right?” she asked. “You really are all right?”

“Very right,” said Mr. Marmaduke.

He wheeled close to Maxwell and an arm extruded from the top of his rolypoly body-a ropelike, flexible arm more like a tentacle than arm, with three clawlike fingers on the end of it. He reached out with it and draped it around Maxwell’s shoulders. At the pressure of it, Maxwell had the instinct to shrink away, but with an exercise of conscious will, forced himself not to stir.

“I thank you, sir,” said Mr. Marmaduke. “I am most grateful to you. You saved my life perhaps. Just as I fell I saw you leap upon the beast. It was most heroic.”

Pressed tight against Maxwell’s side, Sylvester lifted his head, dropped his lower jaw, exhibiting his fangs in a silent snarl.

“He would not have hurt you, sir,” said Carol. “He’s as gentle as a kitten. If you had not run, he’d not have chased you. He had the fool idea that you were playing with him. Sylvester likes to play.”

Sylvester yawned, with a fine display of teeth.

“This play,” said Mr. Marmaduke, “I do not care about.”

“When I saw you fall,” said Maxwell, “I was fearful for you. I thought for a moment you would burst wide open.”

“Oh, no need of fear,” said Mr. Marmaduke. “I am extremely resilient. The body is made of excellent material. It is strong and has a bouncing quality.”

He removed his arm from Maxwell’s shoulder and it ran like an oily rope, writhing in the air, to plop back into his body. There was no mark on the body surface, Maxwell noticed, to indicate where it might have disappeared.

“You’ll excuse me, please,” said Mr. Marmaduke. “There’s someone I must see.” He wheeled about and rolled rapidly away.

Nancy shuddered. “He gives me the creeps,” she said. “Although I must admit he is a great attraction. It isn’t every hostess who can snag a Wheeler. I don’t mind telling you, Pete, that I pulled a lot of wires to get him for a house guest and now I wish I hadn’t. There’s a slimy feel about him.”

“Do you know why he’d be here-here on Earth, I mean?”

“No, I don’t. I get the impression that he’s a simple tourist. Although I don’t imagine such a creature could be a simple tourist.”

“I think you’re right,” said Maxwell.

“Pete,” she said, “tell me about yourself. The papers say-”

He grinned. “I know. That I came back from the dead.”

“But you didn’t, really. I know that’s not possible. Who was that we buried? Everyone, you must understand, simply everyone, was at the funeral and we all thought it was you. But it couldn’t have been you. Whatever could have-”

“ Nancy,” said Maxwell, “I came back only yesterday. I found that I was dead and that my apartment had been rented and that I had lost my job and-”

“It seems impossible,” said Nancy. “Such things just don’t happen. I don’t see how this happened.”

“I’m not entirely clear about it all myself,” Maxwell told her. “Later, I suppose, I’ll find out more about it.”

“Anyway,” said Nancy, “you are here and everything’s all right and if you don’t want to talk about it, I’ll circulate the word that you would rather not.”

“That’s kind of you,” said Maxwell, “but it wouldn’t work.”

“You don’t need to worry about newspapermen,” said Nancy. “There are no newspaper people here. I used to let them come. A handpicked few, ones I thought that I could trust. But you can’t trust any of them. I found that out the hard way. So you won’t be bothered with them.”

“I understand you have a painting…”

“You know about the painting, then. Let’s go and look at it. It’s the proudest thing I have. Imagine it, a Lambert! And one that had dropped entirely out of sight. I’ll tell you later how it happened to be found, but I won’t tell you what it cost me. I won’t tell anyone. I’m ashamed of what it cost me.”

“Much or little?”

“Much,” said Nancy, “and you have to be so careful. It’s so easy to be swindled. I wouldn’t even talk of buying it until I had it examined by an expert. In fact, two experts. One to check against the other, although I suppose that was unnecessary.”

“But there’s no doubt it is a Lambert?”

“No doubt at all. I was almost sure, myself. No one else ever painted quite like Lambert. But he could be copied, of course, and I had to be sure.”

“What do you know about Lambert?” Maxwell asked. “Something more than the rest of us? Something that’s not found its way into books?”

“No. Really not a great deal. Not about the man himself. Why do you ask?”

“Because you are so excited.”

“Well, really! Just finding an unknown Lambert is enough, of course. I have two other paintings of his, but this one is something special because it had been lost. Well, actually I don’t know if lost is the word or not. Never known, perhaps, would be better. No record of his ever painting it. No record that survived, at least. And it is one of his so-called grotesques. You would hardly think one of them could be lost or mislaid or whatever happened to it. One of his earlier ones, that might be understandable.”

They worked their way across the floor, skirting the little clustered groups of guests.

“Here it is,” said Nancy.

They had pushed their way through a crowd that had been grouped in front of the wall on which the painting hung. Maxwell tilted his head to stare up at it.

It was somehow different than the color plates he had seen in the library that morning. This was because, he told himself, of the larger size of the painting, the brilliance and the clarity of color, some of which had been lost in the color plates. But this, he realized, was not all of it. The landscape was different and the creatures in it. A more Earth-like landscape-the sweet of gray hills and the brown of the shrubby vegetation that lay upon the land, the squatty fernlike trees. A troop of creatures that could be gnomes wended their way across a distant hill; a goblinlike creature sitting at the base of a tree leaned back against the bole, apparently asleep, with some sort of hat pulled down across his eyes. And others-fearsome, leering creatures, with obscene bodies and faces that made the blood run cold.

On the crest of a distant, flat-topped hill, about the base of which clustered a large crowd of many kinds of creatures, a small black blob stood outlined against the grayness of the sky.

Maxwell drew in his breath in a startled gasp, took a quick step closer, then halted and stood stiff and straight, afraid to give himself away.

It seemed impossible that no one else could have noticed it, he told himself. Although, perhaps, someone had and had not thought it worth the mention, or had been unsure and thus reluctant to say anything about it.

But for Maxwell there could be no doubt. He was sure of what he saw. That small black blob on the distant hilltop was the Artifact!

Maxwell found a secluded corner, a couple of chairs screened by a huge flowering plant of some sort, planted in a marble tub of generous proportions. There was no one there and he sat down.

Out beyond the corner where he sat, the party was drawing to its close, beginning to dwindle down. Some people had left and those who still were there seemed to be less noisy. And if one more person asked him what had happened to him, Maxwell told himself, he’d belt them in the jaw.

I’ll explain, he had told Carol when she had asked the night before-I’ll explain over and over again. And that was what he’d done, not entirely truthfully, and no one had believed him. They’d looked at him with glassy eyes and they had figured that either he was drunk or was making fools of them.

And he, he realized, had really been the one who had been made a fool. He had been invited to the party, but not by Nancy Clayton. Nancy had not sent him clothes to wear and had not sent the car that had let him out at the back door to walk down the hall, past the door where the Wheeler waited. And ten to one, the dogs had not been Nancy ’s either, although he had not thought to ask her.

Someone, he realized, had gone to a lot of trouble in a very awkward and involved manner to make sure the Wheeler had a chance to talk with him. It was all so melodramatic, stinking so of cloak and dagger, that it was ridiculous. Except that, somehow, he couldn’t quite bring himself to think of it as ridiculous.

He coddled his drink with both his hands and listened to the clatter of the dying party.

He peered out around the greenery of the plant roosting in the tub and he could not see the Wheeler, although the Wheeler had been around for a good part of the evening.

He passed the drink, absentmindedly, from one hand to the other, and he knew he didn’t want it, that he’d had a touch too much to drink-not so much, perhaps, too much to drink, as the wrong place to be drinking it, not with a warm, tight group of friends in a friendly room, but with too many people who were either strangers or only slightly known, and in a room that was too large and too impersonal. He was tired, more weary than he’d known. In just a little while, he’d get up on his feet and say good night to Nancy, if she were around, and stumble back to Oop’s shack, the best way that he could.

And tomorrow? he asked himself. Tomorrow there were things that he should do. But he’d not think of them tonight; he’d wait until tomorrow.

He lifted the drink over the rim of the marble tub and poured it on the soil.

“Cheers,” he told the plant.

Carefully, bending slowly so as not to loose his balance, he set the glass upon the floor.

“Sylvester,” asked a voice, “do you see what we have here?”

He twisted around and there, on the reverse side of the plant, stood Carol, Sylvester close beside her.

“Come on in,” he invited them. “It’s a hideaway I found. If the two of you stay very quiet…”

“I’ve been trying to get you by yourself all evening,” Carol told him, “but there never was a chance. I want to know what was this routine of you and Sylvester hunting down the Wheeler?”

She came farther back into the corner and stood waiting for his answer.

“You were no more surprised than I was,” he said. “Sylvester’s showing up fairly left me gasping. I had no idea-”

“I get invited around a lot,” said Carol coldly. “Not for myself, of course, since I suppose you’re wondering, but because of Sylvester. He makes a good conversation piece.”

“Well, good for you,” said Maxwell. “You’re one up on me. I was not invited.”

“But you got here just the same.”

“But don’t ask me how. I would be somewhat pressed for an explanation.”

“Sylvester has always been a decent cat,” she said accusingly. “Perhaps a little greedy sometimes, but a gentleman.”

“Oh, I know,” said Maxwell. “I’m a bad influence on almost everyone.”

She came all the way around the plant and sat down in the other chair. “Are you going to tell me what I asked?”

He shook his head. “I don’t know if I can. It was somewhat confusing.”

“I don’t know,” she said, “that I’ve met a more exasperating man. I don’t think you’re being fair.”

“By the way,” he said, “you saw the painting, didn’t you?”

“Why, of course I did. That was what the party was all about. The painting and that funny Wheeler.”

“Did you notice anything unusual?”

“Unusual?”

“Yes, about the painting.”

“I don’t think I did.”

“Up on the hill there was a tiny cube. Black, sitting on the hill. It looked like the Artifact.”

“I missed it. I didn’t look that closely at it.”

“You saw the gnomes, I presume.”

“Yes, I noticed them. Or, at least, they looked like gnomes.”

“And those other creatures,” Maxwell said. “They looked different, somehow.”

“Different from what?”

“Different from the other creatures Lambert usually painted.”

“I didn’t know,” she said, “you were a Lambert expert.”

“I’m not,” he said. “I went to the library this morning, after I learned about this party and the painting Nancy had and hunted up a book that had plates of his paintings.”

“But what if they were different?” Carol asked. “A painter surely has a right to paint anything he wants to.”

“Of course he has,” said Maxwell. “There’s no question of that. But this painting was of Earth. Or, at least, if that was the Artifact, and I think it was, then it was of Earth. But not this Earth, not the Earth we know. Perhaps the Jurassic Earth.”

“And you don’t think his other paintings were of Earth? They’d have to be of Earth. When Lambert lived, there was no other place to paint. There wasn’t any space travel-not any real space travel, just out to the Moon and Mars.”

“There was the space travel of imagination,” Maxwell told her. “Space travel and time travel of the mind. No painter ever has been circumscribed by the here and now. And that’s what everyone had thought, of course-that Lambert painted in the realm of imagination. But after tonight I wonder if he might not have been painting actual scenes and actual creatures-places where he’d been.”

“You may be right,” said Carol, “but how could he have gotten there? This business of the Artifact is exciting, of course, but-”

“It’s something that Oop is always talking about,” he explained. “He remembers the goblins and the trolls and all the rest of the Little Folk from Neanderthaler days. But there were others then, he said. Others that were worse. They were more malicious and mischievous and the Neanderthal people were scared to death of them.”

“And you think some of these things in the painting may be the creatures Oop remembers.”

“It was in my mind,” he admitted. “I wonder if Nancy would mind if I brought Oop here tomorrow so he could see the painting.”

“I don’t imagine that she would,” said Carol, “but, actually, it’s not necessary. I took pictures of the painting.”

“But you…”

“I know, of course,” she said, “that it’s not the proper thing to do. But I asked Nancy and she said she didn’t mind. What else could she say? I didn’t take the pictures to sell or anything like that. I just took them to have them for my own, for my personal enjoyment. A sort of pay, perhaps, for bringing Sylvester with me so people could have a look at him. Nancy knows what the score is and there wasn’t anything that she could do about the picturetaking. If you want Oop to have a look at them…”

“You mean you would?” he asked.

“Why, of course I would. And don’t blame me, please, for taking the pictures. It’s a way of getting even.”

“Getting even? With Nancy?”

“Not with her, particularly, but with all these other people who invite me to their parties. With everyone who does. For they don’t want me, really. It’s Sylvester they invite. As if he were a trained bear or a clown of some sort. And, of course, to get him to their parties, they must invite me, too. But I know why they’re inviting me and they know that I know and they keep on inviting me.”

“I think I understand,” he said.

“I think,” she said, “it’s very patronizing of them.”

“So do I,” he said.

“If we’re going to show Oop the pictures,” she said, “perhaps we’d best get going. This party is dying on its feet. You are positive you won’t tell me what happened with the Wheeler.”

“Later on,” he said. “Not right now. Maybe later on.” They left their place behind the potted plant and walked across the floor, heading for the door, threading their way through the thinning clusters of guests.

“We should hunt up Nancy,” Carol suggested, “and say good-bye to her.”

“Some other time,” said Maxwell. “We can write her a note or phone her to say we couldn’t find her and thank her for the evening, say how much we enjoyed it, how her parties are the ones we try to never miss, how much we liked the painting and how clever it was of her to get hold of it and-”

“Cut out the clowning,” Carol said. “You are forcing it too much. You’re not very good at it.”

“I know it,” Maxwell said, “but I always try.”

They came to the door and started down the long flight of wide, curving stone stairs which led down to the roadway.

“Professor Maxwell!” cried a voice.

Maxwell turned. Coming down the stairs was Churchill.

“Just a moment, Maxwell, if you please,” he said.

“Yes, what is it, Churchill?”

“A word. Alone, if the lady doesn’t mind.”

“I’ll wait for you at the road,” Carol said to Maxwell. “Don’t bother,” Maxwell said. “I’ll settle him real fast.”

“No,” said Carol, “I’ll wait. I don’t want any trouble.”

Maxwell waited while Churchill came swiftly down the stairs. The man was slightly out of breath and he reached out a hand to grab Maxwell by the arm.

“I’ve been trying to get to you all evening long,” he said, “but you were always with a crowd.”

“What is it that you want?” Maxwell asked him sharply.

“The Wheeler,” Churchill said. “You must pay no attention to him. He doesn’t know our ways. I didn’t know what he intended to do. In fact, I told him not to.”

“You mean you knew the Wheeler might be laying for me?”

“I told him not to,” Churchill protested. “I told him to leave you alone. I’m very sorry, Professor Maxwell. Believe me, I did my very best.”

Maxwell’s hand shot out and grabbed Churchill by the shirt front, twisting the fabric and pulling the man close to him.

“So you’re the Wheeler’s man!” he shouted. “You’re fronting for him. It was you who made the offer for the Artifact and you made it for the Wheeler.”

“What I did,” declared Churchill angrily, “was my own business. I make my living representing people.”

“The Wheeler isn’t people,” Maxwell said. “God knows what a Wheeler is. A hive full of insects, for one thing. What else we do not know.”

“He has his rights,” said Churchill. “He’s entitled to do business.”

“And you’re entitled to help him,” Maxwell said. “Entitled to take his wages. But be careful how you earn them. And don’t get in my way.”

He straightened his arm and flung Churchill from him. The man staggered, lost his balance, fell and rolled down several steps before he could catch himself. He lay there, sprawled, not trying to get up.

“By rights,” said Maxwell, “I should have thrown you down the stairs and broken your filthy neck.”

He glanced up toward the house and saw that a small crowd of people had collected at the door and were staring down at him. Staring and muttering among themselves.

He turned on his heel and went stalking down the stairs.

At the bottom Carol was clinging desperately to a frantic cat.

“I thought he was going to get away and go up there and tear that man to pieces,” she gasped.

She looked at Maxwell with disgust written on her face.

“Can’t you get along with anyone?” she asked.

Maxwell got off the roadway at the point where it crossed the mouth of Hound Dog Hollow and stood for a moment, staring at the rocky cliffs and bold headlands of the autumn bluffs. A short distance up the hollow, he caught a glimpse, through the red and yellow of the tinted leaves, of the bare rock face of Cat Den Point and up there, high against the sky, standing just back of the most prominent of the headlands, he knew he’d find the castle of the goblins, with one O’Toole in residence. And somewhere in that wilderness lay the mossy bridge that served as a den for trolls.

It was still early in the morning, since he had started out well before the dawn. A frosty dew lay upon the grass and twinkled on clumps of weeds the sun had not yet found. The air had a winy flavor to it and the sky was so faint and delicate a blue that it seemed to have no color and over all of it, over the entire landscape, hung a sense of strange expectancy.

Maxwell walked across the high-arched foot bridge that spanned the double roadway and on the other side he found a path that led him up the hollow.

The trees closed in around him and he walked through a fairy land that held its breath. He found himself moving slowly and very carefully so that no quick movement or noise would break the forest hush. Leaves came planing down from the canopy above, fluttering wings of color falling gently to earth. Ahead of him a mouse ran, humping in its haste, moving through and over the fallen leaves, but making scarcely a rustle in its fleeing. Far up the hollow a bluejay screeched, but among the trees the screech was muted and robbed of its customary harshness.

The path forked, with the left-hand fork continuing up the hollow, while the right-hand fork angled up the bluff. Maxwell took the right-hand path. Ahead of him lay a long and wearying climb, but he would take it easy and stop to rest at frequent intervals. It would be a shame on a day like this, he told himself, not to stop to rest as often as he could, begrudging the time that eventually would take him out of this place of color and of silence.

The path was steep, with many turnings to dodge the massive boulders crouched upon the ground, anchored in the soil, gray-bearded with their crops of lichens. The tree trunks crowded close, the rough, dark bark of ancient oak, the satin whiteness of the birches, showing little tan blotches where the thin bark had peeled off but still clung, fluttering in the wind. In the cluttered trash of the surface rose the fat red pyramid of the jack-in-the-pulpit fruit, the shriveled hood drooping like a tittered purple robe.

Maxwell climbed slowly, saving his breath, stopping often to look around, to soak in the feel of autumn that lay all about. He reached, finally, the fairy green where Churchill’s flier, with himself as passenger, had come crashing down under the spell of the trolls’ enchantment. Just up the hill a ways lay the goblin castle.

He stood for a moment on the green, resting, then took up the climb again. Dobbin, or another horse very similar to him, was cropping at the scanty grass which grew in ragged bunches in a pole-fenced pasture. A few doves fluttered about the castle’s turrets, but there were no other signs of life.

Sudden shouts shattered the morning’s peace and out of the open castle gate came a gang of trolls, moving rapidly and in curious formation. They were in three lines and each line had a rope across its shoulders, exactly, Maxwell told himself, like the old painting he had seen of the Volga boatmen. They charged out onto the drawbridge and now Maxwell could see that the three ropes were attached to a block of hewn stone which bounced along behind them, raising a hollow, booming racket when it hit the drawbridge.

Old Dobbin was neighing wildly, kicking up his heels and galloping madly around the inside perimeter of the fence.

The trolls, their fangs gleaming against the brown, wrinkled viciousness of their faces, their roached hair seeming to bristle more stiffly than was the usual case, came pounding down the path, with the massive stone bouncing along behind them, raising puffs of dust as it gouged into the ground.

Boiling out of the gate behind them came a cloud of goblins, armed with clubs, with hoes, with pitchforks, apparently with anything they could lay their hands upon.

Maxwell leaped out of the path as the trolls bore down upon him. They were running silently and with vast determination, their weight bent against the ropes, while the goblin horde pursued them with wild war whoops and shrieks. In the forefront of the goblin band, Mr. O’Toole ran heavily, his face and neck violet with his anger, a two-by-four brandished in his fist.

At the point where Maxwell had leaped out of the way, the path took a sudden dip, toboganning downward in a rocky slide to the fairy green. At the top of the dip the block of stone took a mighty leap as its forward edge struck a rocky ledge. The ropes hung slack and the block came down and bounced and then, with the ropes flying, started pinwheeling down the hill.

One of the trolls looked behind him and shouted a frantic warning. The trolls dropped the ropes and scattered. The block of stone went tearing down the slope, gaining speed with every revolution. It struck the fairy green and gashed a great hole in it, made one last bounce into the air, mushed down into the grass and skidded, ripping up the sod, tearing an ugly gash across the place of dancing. Crashing into a large white oak at the far end of the green, it finally came to rest.

The goblins went roaring down the hill in pursuit of the trolls, scattering out into the trees to hunt down the stealers of the stone. Hoots of fear and yelps of rage floated up the hill, intermingled with the sound of many bodies thrashing through the underbrush.

Maxwell crossed the path and walked over to the pole fence. Old Dobbin now had quieted down and stood with his lower jaw resting on one of the topmost poles, as if he needed it to prop him up. He was staring down the hill.

Maxwell reached out a hand and stroked Dobbin’s neck, pulled gently at one ear. Dobbin slanted a gentle eye toward him and whuffled his upper lip.

“I hope,” Maxwell said to him, “that they won’t expect you to drag back that stone. It’s a long, steep pull.”

Dobbin flicked one ear languidly.

“If I know O’Toole,” Maxwell said, “I don’t expect you’ll have to. If he can round up the trolls, they’ll be the ones who’ll do it.”

The uproar down the hill had quieted now and in a little while Mr. O’Toole came puffing up the path, carrying the two-by-four across one shoulder. He still was purple of face, but apparently from exhaustion rather than from rage. He hurried from the path toward the fence and Maxwell walked out to meet him.

“My great apology,” said Mr. O’Toole, in as stately a voice as he could manage with the shortness of his breath. “I glimpsed you and was happy of your presence, but engaged most earnestly and very urgently. You witnessed, I suspect, the low-down happening.”

Maxwell nodded.

“My mounting stone they took,” raged Mr. O’Toole, “with malicious intent of putting me afoot.”

“Afoot?” asked Maxwell.

“You comprehend most feebly, I see. My mounting stone, up which I must scramble to get astride Old Dobbin. Without a mounting stone there gets no horseback riding and I must trudge afoot unhappily, with much pain and puffing.”

“I see,” said Maxwell. “As you say, at first I did not comprehend.”

“Them dirty trolls,” said Mr. O’Toole, grinding his teeth in fury, “at nothing will they stop. After the mounting stone it would have come the castle, piece by piece, stone by stone, until there be no more than the bareness of the rock upon which it once had roosted. It is necessary, in such circumstance, the bud to nip with quick determination.”

Maxwell jerked his head in a downhill direction. “How did it come out?” he asked.

“We root them out,” said the goblin with some satisfaction. “They scatter like the quail. We dig them out from under rocks and from hiding in the thickets and then we harness them, like so many mules, of which, indeed, they bear a striking likeness, and they drag the mounting stone, most laboriously, I think, back to where they found it.”

“They’re getting back at you,” said Maxwell, “for tearing down their bridge.”

Mr. O’Toole jigged in exasperation. “You are wrong!” he cried. “Out of great and misplaced compassion, we refrained from the tearing of it down. Just two little stones is all-two tiny little stones, and much effective roaring at them. And then they betook the enchantments off the broomstick and also off the sweet October ale and, being simple souls much given to good nature, we let it go at that.”

“They took the enchantment off the ale? I would have thought that impossible once certain chemical changes…”

Mr. O’Toole fixed Maxwell with a look of contempt. “You prate,” he said, “in scientific lingo, which brings no more than errant nonsense. I fail to fathom your engagement in this science when magic you could have for the asking from us and the willingness to learn. Although I must confess the disenchantment of the ale left something for desire. It has a faintly musty touch about the tasting of it.

“Although,” he said, “it is a notch or two improved upon no ale at all. If you would only join me, we could do a sample of it.”

“There has been nothing all day long,” said Maxwell, “that sounds as good as that.”

“Then leave us retire,” cried Mr. O’Toole, “to the drafty halls built so inexpertly by you crazy humans who thought we doted upon ruins and regale ourselves with foaming mugs of cheer.”

In the drafty great hall of the castle, Mr. O’Toole drew the foaming mugs from a mighty cask set upon two sawhorses and carried them to the rough-hewn table before the large stone fireplace in which a smoldering and reluctant fire was smoking rather badly.

“The blasphemy of it,” said Mr. O’Toole, as he lifted his mug, “is that this preposterous outrage of the mounting stone was committed at a time when we goblins were embarked upon a wake.”

“I’m sorry,” Maxwell said. “A wake, you say. I had not been aware…”

“Oh, not one of us,” Mr. O’Toole said quickly. “With the possible exception of myself, in disgusting good health is all the goblin tribe. We were in observance of it for the Banshee.”

“But the Banshee is not dead.”

“Not dead,” said Mr. O’Toole, “but dying. And, oh, the pity of it. He be the last of a great and noble race in this reservation and the ones still left elsewhere in the world can be counted upon less than the fingers of one hand.”

He lifted the mug and buried his muzzle in it, drinking deep and gustily.

When he put it down there was foam upon his whiskers and he left it there, not bothering to wipe it off.

“We die out most notably,” he said, in somber tones. “The planet has been changed. All of us Little Folks and some who are not so little walk down into the valley, where shadows hang so densely, and we are gone from the ken of all living things and that is the end of us. And the very shame of it makes one tremble when he thinks upon it, for we were a goodly people despite our many faults. Even the trolls, before degradation fell upon them, still had a few weak virtues all intact, although I would proclaim that, at the moment, they are destitute of virtue. For surely the stealing of a mounting stone is a very lowdown trick and one which clearly demonstrates they are bereft of all nobility of spirit.”

He put the mug to his mouth again and emptied it in several lusty gulps. He slammed it down on the table and looked at Maxwell’s mug, still full.

“Drink up,” he urged. “Drink up, then I fill them yet again for a further wetting of the whistle.”

“You go ahead,” Maxwell told him. “It’s a shame to drink ale the way you do. It should be tasted and appreciated.”

Mr. O’Toole shrugged. “A pig I am, no doubt. But this be disenchanted ale and not one to linger over.”

Nevertheless he got to his feet and shuffled over to the cask to refill his mug. Maxwell lifted his mug and took a drink. There was a mustiness, as Mr. O’Toole had said, in the flavor of the ale-a tang that tasted not unlike the way that leaf smoke smelled.

“Well?” the goblin asked.

“It has a strange taste to it, but it is palatable.”

“Someday that troll bridge I will take down,” said Mr. O’Toole, with a surge of sudden wrath. “Stone by stone, with the moss most carefully scraped off to rob the stones of magic, and with a hammer break them in many smallish bits, and transport the bits to some high cliff and there fling them far and wide so that in all eternity there can be no harvesting of them. Except,” he said, letting his shoulders droop, “so much hard labor it would be. But one is tempted. This be the smoothest and sweetest ale that was ever brewed and now look at it-scarcely fit for hogs. But it be a terrible sin to waste even such foul-tasting slop if it should be ale.”

He grabbed the mug and jerked it to his face. His Adam’s apple bobbed and he did not take down the mug until all the ale was gone.

“And if I wreak too great a damage to that most foul bridge,” he said, “and should those craven trolls go sniveling to authority, you humans will jerk me on the rug to explain my thinking and that is not the way it should be. There is no dignity in the living by the rule and no joy, either, and it was a rotten day when the human race arose.”

“My friend,” said Maxwell, shaken, “you have not said anything like this to me before.”

“Nor to any other human,” said the goblin, “and to all the humans in the world, only to you could I display my feeling. But I, perchance, have run off at the mouth exceedingly.”

“You know well enough,” said Maxwell, “that I’ll not breathe a word of it.”

“Of course not,” said Mr. O’Toole. “That I did not worry on. You be almost one of us. You’re the closest to a goblin that a human can approach.”

“I am honored,” Maxwell told him.

“We are ancient,” said Mr. O’Toole, “more ancient, I must think, than the human mind can wonder. You’re sure you don’t want to polish off that most foul and terrible drink and start another one afresh?”

Maxwell shook his head. “You go ahead and fill your mug up again. I’ll sit here and enjoy mine instead of gulping it.”

Mr. O’Toole made another trip to the cask and came back with a brimming mug, slapped it on the table, and settled himself elaborately and comfortably.

“Long years gone,” he said, shaking his head in sadness, “so awful long ago and then a filthy little primate comes along and spoils it all for us.”

“Long ago,” said Maxwell. “As long as the Jurassic?”

“You speak conundrums. I do not catch the term. But there were many of us and many different kinds and today there be few of us and not all the different kinds. We die out very slowly, but inexorably. A further day will dawn to find no one of us. Then you humans will have it to yourselves.”

“You are overwrought,” Maxwell cautioned him. “You know that’s not what we want. We have gone to much effort…”

“Loving effort?” asked the goblin.

“Yes, I’d even say to much loving effort.”

Weak tears ran down the goblin’s cheeks and he lifted a hairy, calloused hand to wipe them away.

“You must pay me slight attention,” he told Maxwell. “I deep am in the dumps. It’s this business of the Banshee.”

“The Banshee is your friend?” Maxwell asked in some surprise.

“No friend of mine,” said Mr. O’Toole. “He stands on one side the pale and I upon the other. An ancient enemy, but still one of us. One of the really old ones. He hung on better than the others. He dies more stubbornly. The others all are dead. And in days like this, old differences go swiftly down the drain. We could not sit a wake with him, as conscience would decree, but in the absence of this we pay him the small honor of a wake for him. And then these low-crawling trolls without a flake of honor in them-”

“You mean no one, no one here on the reservation, could sit the deathwatch with the Banshee?”

Mr. O’Toole shook his head wearily. “No single one of us. It is to the law contrary, to the old custom in violation. I cannot make you understand-he is outside the pale.”

“But he is all alone.”

“In a thorn bush,” said the goblin, “close beside the hut that was his domicile.”

“A thorn bush?”

“In the thorns,” the goblin said, “dwell magic, in the tree itself…”

He choked and grabbed hastily at the mug and raised it to his mouth. His Adam’s apple bobbed.

Maxwell reached into the pocket of his jacket and pulled out the photo of the lost Lambert that hung on Nancy Clayton’s wall.

“Mr. O’Toole,” he said, “there’s something I must show you.”

The goblin set down the mug.

“Let me see it, then,” he said. “All this beating amongst the bushes, when there was something that you had.”

He reached for the photo, bending his head to puzzle over it.

“The trolls,” he said, “of course. But these others I do not recognize. As if I should, but fail. There be stories, old, old stories…”

“Oop saw the picture. You know of Oop, of course.”

“The great barbarian who claims to be your friend.”

“He is my friend,” said Maxwell. “And Oop recalls these things. They are old ones from the ancient days.”

“But what magic is called upon to get a picture of them?”

“That I don’t know. That’s a picture of a painting, painted by a man many years ago.”

“By what means…

“I do not know,” said Maxwell. “I think that he was there.”

Mr. O’Toole picked up his mug and saw that it was empty. He tottered to the cask and filled it. He came back with his drink and picked up the photo, looking at it carefully, although somewhat blearily.

“I know not,” he finally said. “There were others of us. Many different ones no longer present. We here are the tail end of a noble population.”

He pushed the photo back across the table. “Mayhaps the Banshee,” he suggested. “The Banshee’s years are beyond all telling.”

“But the Banshee’s dying.”

“That he is,” said Mr. O’Toole, “and an evil day it is and a bitter day for him, with no one to keep the deathwatch.”

He lifted his mug. “Drink up,” he said. “Drink up. Can one drink enough, it may not be so bad.”

Maxwell came around the corner of the tumble-down shack and saw the thorn tree standing to one side of it. There was something strange about the tree. It looked as if a cloud of darkness had settled along its vertical axis, making it appear to have a massive bole, out of which emerged short and slender, thorn-armed twigs. And if what O’Toole had said was true, Maxwell told himself, that dark cloud clustered in the tree must be the dying Banshee.

He walked slowly across the intervening space and stopped a few feet from the tree. The black cloud moved restlessly, like a cloud of slowly roiling smoke.

“You are the Banshee?” Maxwell asked the tree.

“You’ve come too late,” the Banshee said, “if you wish to talk with me.”

“I did not come to talk,” said Maxwell. “I came to sit with you.”

“Sit then,” the Banshee said. “It will not be for long.”

Maxwell sat down upon the ground and pulled his knees up close against his chest. He put his hands down beside him, palms flat against the mat of dry and browning grass. Below him the autumn valley stretched to the far horizon of the hills north of the river-unlike the hills of this southern shore, but gentle, rolling hills that went up toward the sky in slanted, staircase fashion.

A flurry of wings swept across the ridge behind him and a flock of blackbirds went careening through the blue haze that hung against the steep ravine that went plunging downward from the ridge. But except for that single instant of wings beating in the air, there was a soft and gentle silence that held no violence and no threat, a dreaming silence in which the hills stood quiet.

“The others did not come,” the Banshee said. “I thought, at first, they might. For a moment I thought they might forget and come. There need be no distinction among us now. We stand as one, all beaten to the selfsame level. But the old conventions are not broken yet. The old-time customs hold.”

“I talked with the goblins,” Maxwell told him. “They hold a wake for you. The O’Toole is grieving and drinking to blunt the edge of grief.”

“You are not of my people,” the Banshee said. “You intrude upon me. Yet you say you come to sit with me. How does it happen that you do this?”

Maxwell lied. He could do nothing else. He could not, he told himself, tell this dying thing he had come for information.

“I have worked with your people,” he said, “and I’ve become much concerned with them.”

“You are the Maxwell,” said the Banshee. “I have heard of you.”

“How do you feel?” asked Maxwell. “Is there anything I can do for you? Something that you need?”

“No,” the Banshee said. “I am beyond all needing. I feel almost nothing. That is the trouble, that I feel nothing. My dying is different than your dying. It is scarcely physical. Energy drains out from me and there’s finally nothing left. Like a flickering light that finally gutters out.”

“I am sorry,” Maxwell said. “If talking hastens-”

“Talking might hasten it a little, but I no longer mind. And I am not sorry. I have no regret. I am almost the last of us. There are three of us still left, if you count me, and I am not worth the counting. Out of the thousands of us, only two are left.”

“But there are the goblins and the trolls and fairies…”

“You do not understand,” the Banshee said. “No one has ever told you. And you never thought to ask. Those you name are the later ones, the ones that came after us when the planet was no longer young. We were colonists, surely you know that.”

“I had thought so,” Maxwell said. “In just the last few hours.”

“You should have known,” the Banshee said. “You were on the elder planet.”

Maxwell gasped. “How did you know that?”

“How do you breathe air?” the Banshee asked. “How do you see? With me, communicating with that ancient planet is as natural as is breath and sight with you. I am not told; I know.”

So that was it, thought Maxwell. The Banshee had been the source of the Wheeler’s knowledge and it must have been Churchill who had tipped the Wheeler to the fact that the Banshee had the information, who had guessed the Banshee might have knowledge no one else suspected.

“And the others-the trolls, the…”

“No,” the Banshee said. “The Banshees were the only ones to whom the road was open. That was our job, that was our only purpose. We were the links with the elder planet. We were communicators. When the elder planet sent out colonies, it was necessary that some means of communicating should be established. We all were specialists, although the specialties have little meaning now and nearly all of the specialists are gone. The first ones were the specialists. The ones who came later simply were settlers meant to fill the land.”

“You mean the trolls and goblins?”

“The trolls and goblins and the rest of them. With abilities, of course, but not specialized. We were the engineers, they the workers. There was a gulf between us. That is why they will not come to sit with me. The old gulf still exists.”

“You tire yourself,” said Maxwell. “You should conserve your strength.”

“It does not matter. Energy drains out of me and when the energy is gone, life is gone as well. This dying I am doing has no concern with matter or with body, for I never really had a body. I was all energy. And it does not matter. For the elder planet dies as well; you have seen my planet and you know.”

“Yes, I know,” said Maxwell.

“It would have been so different if there had been no humans. When we first came here there were scarcely any mammals, let alone a primate. We could have prevented it-this rising of the primates. We could have pinched them in the bud. There was some discussion of it, for this planet had proved promising and we were reluctant at the thought that we must give it up. But there was the ancient rule. Intelligence is too seldom found for one to stand in the way of its development. It is a precious thing-even when we stepped aside for it most reluctantly, we still had to recognize that it was a precious thing.”

“But you stayed on,” said Maxwell. “You may have stepped aside, but you still stayed on.”

“It was too late,” the Banshee told him. “There was no place for us to go. The elder planet was dying even then. There was no point in going back. And this planet, strange as it may seem, had become home for us.”

“You must hate us humans.”

“At one time, we did. I suppose there still is hatred. But hate can burn out in time. Burn low, perhaps, but never entirely disappear. Although, perhaps, even in our hatred, we held some pride in you. Otherwise, why should the elder planet have offered you its knowledge?”

“But you offered it to the Wheeler, too.”

“The Wheeler-oh, yes, I know who you mean. But we did not really offer it. The Wheeler had heard about the elder planet, apparently from some rumor heard far in space. And that the planet had something that it wished to sell. It came to me and asked one question only-what was the price of this commodity. I don’t know if it knew what might be for sale. It only said commodity.”

“And you told it the price was the Artifact.”

“Of course I told it that. For at the time I had not been told of you. It was only later I was told I should, after a suitable time, communicate the price to you.”

“And, of course,” said Maxwell, “you were about to do this?”

“Yes,” said the Banshee, “I was about to do it. And now I’ve done it and the matter’s closed.”

“You can tell me one thing more. What is the Artifact?”

“That,” the Banshee said, “I cannot do.”

“Can’t, or won’t?”

“Won’t,” the Banshee said.

Sold out, Maxwell told himself. The human race sold out by this dying thing which, despite what it might say, had never meant to communicate the price to him. This thing which through long millennia had nursed cold hatred against the human race. And now that it was gone beyond all reaching, telling him and mocking him so that he might know how the humans had been sold out, so that the human race might know, now that it was too late, exactly what had happened.

“And you told the Wheeler about me as well,” he said. “That’s how Churchill happened to be waiting at the station when I returned to Earth. He said he’d been on a trip, but there had been no trip.”

He surged angrily to his feet. “And what about the one of me who died?”

He swung upon the tree and the tree was empty. The dark cloud that had seethed around its trunk was gone. The branches stood out in sharp and natural relief against the western sky.

Gone, Maxwell thought. Not dead, but gone. The substance of an elemental creature gone back to the elements, the unimaginable bonds that had held it together in strange semblance of life, finally weakening to let the last of it slip away, blowing off into the air and sunlight like a pinch of thrown dust.

Alive, the Banshee had been a hard thing to get along with. Dead, it was no easier. For a short space of time he had felt compassion for it, as a man must feel for anything that dies. But the compassion, he knew, had been wasted, for the Banshee must have died in silent laughter at the human race.

There was just one hope, to persuade Time to hold up the sale of the Artifact so he could have the time to contact Arnold and tell his story to him, persuade him, somehow, that what he told was true. A story, Maxwell realized, that now became even more fantastic than it had been before.

He turned about and started down the ravine. Before he reached the woods, he stopped and looked back up the slope. The thorn tree stood squat against the sky, sturdy and solid, braced solid in the soil.

When he passed the fairy dancing green a gang of trolls were grumpily at work, raking and smoothing out the ground, laying new sod to replace that which had been gouged out by the bouncing stone. Of the stone there was no sign.

Maxwell was halfway back to Wisconsin Campus when Ghost materialized and took the seat next to him.

“I have a message from Oop,” he said, ignoring any preliminary approach to conversation. “You are not to return to the shack. The newspaper people seem to have sniffed you out. When they came to inquire, Oop went into action, without, I would guess, too much thought or judgment. He put the bum’s rush on them, but they’re still hanging around, on the lookout for you.”

“Thanks,” said Maxwell. “I appreciate being told. Although as a matter of fact, I don’t imagine it makes too much difference now.”

“Events,” asked Ghost, “do not march too well?”

“They barely march at all,” Maxwell told him. He hesitated, then said, “I suppose Oop has told you what is going on.”

“Oop and I are as one,” said Ghost. “Yes, of course he’s told me. He seemed to take it for granted that you knew he would. But you may rest assured…”

“It’s not that,” said Maxwell. “I was only wondering if I had to recite it all again for you. You know, then, that I went to the reservation to check on the Lambert painting.”

“Yes,” said Ghost. “The one that Nancy Clayton has.”

“I have a feeling,” Maxwell told him, “that I may have found out more than I had expected to. I did find out one thing that doesn’t help at all. It was the Banshee who tipped off the Wheeler about the price the crystal planet wanted. The Banshee was supposed to tell me, but he told the Wheeler instead. He claims he told the Wheeler before he knew about me, but I have some doubt of that. The Banshee was dying when he told me, but that doesn’t mean that he told the truth. He always was a slippery customer.”

“The Banshee dying?”

“He’s dead now. I sat with him until he died. I didn’t show him the photo of the painting. I didn’t have the heart to intrude upon him.”

“But despite this he told you about the Wheeler.”

“Only to let me know that he had hated the human race since it first began its evolutionary climb. And to let me know that he was finally getting even. He would have liked to have said that the goblins and the rest of the Little Folk hated us as well, but he never quite got around to that. Knowing, perhaps, that I would not believe it. Although something that the O’Toole had said earlier made me realize that there probably is some ancestral resentment. Resentment, but probably not any real hatred. But the Banshee did confirm that a deal is being made for the Artifact and that the Artifact actually is the price for the crystal planet. I thought so from the first, of course. And what the Wheeler said last night made it almost a certainty. Although I couldn’t be absolutely sure, for it doesn’t seem that the Wheeler himself is actually sure of the situation. If he were, what would have been the point of waylaying me and offering me a job? It sounded to me as if he were trying to buy me off, as if he were afraid that there was something I could do to louse up his deal.”

“It looks fairly hopeless, then,” Ghost observed. “My good friend, I am very sorry for this. Is there anything that we can do to help-Oop and me and perhaps even that girl who drank with you and Oop so staunchly. The one who has the cat.”

“It looks hopeless,” Maxwell told him, “but there are a couple of things that I still can do-go to Harlow Sharp at Time and try to convince him to hold up the deal, then crash in a door or two up at Administration and back Arnold into a corner. If I can talk Arnold into duplicating the Wheeler’s offer in funding for Harlow ’s Time projects, I am sure that Harlow will turn down the Wheeler’s offer.”

“You will make a noble effort, I am sure,” said Ghost, “but I fear for the results. Not from Harlow Sharp, for he’s a friend of yours, but President Arnold is a friend of no one. And he will not relish the breaking down of doors.”

“You know what I think,” said Maxwell. “I think that you are right. But you can’t tell until you try. It may be that Arnold will have a lapse of moral fiber and will, for once, set prejudice and stuff-shirtedness aside.”

“I must warn you,” said Ghost. “Harlow Sharp may have little time for you or for anyone. He has worries. Shakespeare arrived this morning-”

“Shakespeare!” yelled Maxwell. “For the love of God, I’d forgotten about him coming. But I do remember he speaks tomorrow night. Of all the lousy breaks. It would have to be at a time like this.”

“It would seem,” said Ghost, “that William Shakespeare is not any easy man to handle. He wanted at once to go out and have a look at this new age of which he’d been told so much. Time had a rough time persuading him to change his Elizabethan dress for what we wear today, but they positively refused to let him go until he agreed to it. And now Time is sweating out what might happen to him. They have to keep him in tow, but they can’t do anything that will get his back up. They have sold the hall down to the last inch of standing room and they can’t take the chance that anything will happen.”

“How did you hear all this?” asked Maxwell. “Seems to me you manage to come up with campus gossip ahead of anyone.”

Ghost said modestly, “I get around a lot.”

“Well, it’s not good,” said Maxwell, “but I have to take the chance. Time is running out for me. Harlow will see me if he’ll see anyone.”

“It seems incredible,” said Ghost sadly, “that such a dire combination of circumstances should have arisen to block what you try to do. Impossible that through sheer stupidity, the university and Earth should fail to obtain the knowledge of two universes.”

“It was the Wheeler,” Maxwell said. “His offer puts the pressure on, sets up a time limit. If I only had more time, I could work it out. I could talk to Harlow, could finally get a hearing from Arnold. And if nothing else, I probably could talk Harlow into a deal, Time, rather than the university, buying the planet’s library. But there isn’t any time. Ghost, what do you know about the Wheelers? Anything the rest of us don’t know?”

“I doubt it. Just that they could be that hypothetical enemy we’ve always figured we would finally meet in space. Their actions argue that they, at least potentially, are that enemy. And their motives, their mores, their ethics, their entire outlook on life, must be different than ours. We probably have less in common with them than a man would with a spider or a wasp. Although they are clever-and that is the worst of it. They have absorbed enough of our viewpoints and manners that they can mix with us, can pass with us, can do business with us-and they have demonstrated that in the deal they are trying to make for the Artifact. My friend, it is this cleverness of theirs, this flexibility, that I fear above all. I doubt if the positions were reversed that man could do as well.”

“You are right, I think,” said Maxwell. “And that is why we can’t afford to let them have what the crystal planet has to offer. God knows what’s to be found in that library. I had a whack at it, but I could do no more than sample it, could barely touch the edge of it. And there was material that I couldn’t come within ten light-years of understanding. Which doesn’t mean that given time and skills that I haven’t got, that perhaps I’ve not even heard of, man wouldn’t be able to understand it. I think man could. I think the Wheelers can. Vast areas of new knowledge that we haven’t any inkling of. That knowledge might just be the margin between us and the Wheelers. If man and the Wheelers ever come into collision, the crystal planet’s knowledge just possibly could be the difference between our victory or defeat. And it might mean as well that the Wheelers, knowing that we had this knowledge, might never allow that collision to happen. It might spell the difference between peace and war.”

He sat crouched in the seat and through the warmth of the autumn afternoon felt a chill that blew from somewhere other than the colorful land and the sky of China-silk that enclosed this portion of the earth.

“You talked with the Banshee,” said Ghost. “Just before he died. He mentioned the Artifact. Did he give you any clue as to what it really is? If we knew what it really was…”

“No, Ghost. Not in so many words. But I got the impression-no, you’d better call that a hunch. Not strong enough to be an impression. And not at the time, but afterward. A funny feeling and no basis for the belief-if it is a belief. But I think that the Artifact is something from that other universe, the one before this one, from the earlier universe in which the crystal planet was formed. A precious thing, perhaps, preserved through all the aeons since that other universe. And something else as well-that the Banshee and the other Old Ones that Oop remembers are natives of that other universe as well, related somehow to the creatures on the crystal planet. Life forms that rose and developed and evolved in that past universe and came here, and to other planets as well, as colonists, in an attempt to establish a new civilization which could follow in the crystal planet’s tracks. But something happened. All of those colonization attempts failed. Here on earth because man developed. For other reasons, perhaps, on the other planets. And I think that I know why some of those other attempts failed. Maybe races do die out. Quite naturally and for no other reason than that they must die out to make room for something else. A natural law of some sort that we don’t understand. Maybe a race can only live so long. Maybe ancient creatures carry their death warrants with them. Some principle that we have never thought about because we are so young, a natural process that clears the way for evolution, so that no race can live forever and stand in the way of evolution.”

“It sounds reasonable,” said Ghost. “That all the colonies died out, I mean. If there had been a successful colony anywhere in the universe, it would seem likely the crystal planet would pass on its heritage to it instead of offering it to us or the Wheelers, to some race that had no connection with the crystal planet.”

“What bothers me,” said Maxwell, “is why the people of the crystal planet, so close to death that they are no more than shadows, should want the Artifact. What good will it do them? What use can they make of it?”

“Maybe if we knew what it was,” said Ghost. “You’re sure that you have no idea? Nothing that you heard or saw or…”

“No,” said Maxwell. “Not the least idea.”

Harlow Sharp had a harried look about him.

“Sorry you had to wait so long,” he told Maxwell. “This is a hectic day.”

“I was glad to get in any way at all,” said Maxwell. “That watchdog of yours out at the desk was not about to let me.”

“I’ve been expecting you,” said Sharp. “Figured you’d turn up soon or late. Been hearing some strange stories.”

“And most of them are true,” said Maxwell. “But that’s not what I’m here for. This is a business matter, not a social visit. I won’t take much time.”

“OK, then,” said Sharp, “what can I do for you?”

“You’re selling the Artifact,” said Maxwell.

Sharp nodded. “I’m sorry about that, Pete. I know you and a few others had an interest in it. But it’s been out there in the museum for years and, except as a curiosity to be stared at by visitors and tourists, it’s done no one any good. And Time needs money. Surely you know that. The university holds the purse strings fast and the other colleges feed us tiny driblets for specific programs and-”

“ Harlow, I know all that. I suppose it’s yours to sell. I recall the university, at the time you brought it forward, would have no part of it. The cost of moving it was yours and-”

“We’ve had to scrape and beg and borrow,” said Sharp. “We’ve worked up project after project-good sound, solid projects that would pay off in knowledge and new data-and submitted them and no one’s buying them. Can you imagine it! With all the past to dig around in and no one interested. Afraid, perhaps, that we’ll upset some of their pet theories they have worked out so nicely. But we have to get money somehow to carry on our work. Do you think I’ve liked some of the things we’ve done to get some extra money? Like this Shakespeare circus we are putting on-and a lot of other stunts as well. It’s done us no good, I tell you. It’s degraded our image, and the trouble-Pete, you can’t imagine the trouble that we have. Take this Shakespeare, for example. He’s out there somewhere, like a tourist, casing the joint, and me sitting back here with my nails chewed down to the elbow, imagining all the things that could happen to him. Can you envision the ruckus there would be if a man like Shakespeare should not be returned to his proper age-a man who-”

Maxwell broke in to head him off. “I’m not arguing with you, Harlow. I didn’t come to-”

“And then, suddenly,” said Sharp, interrupting him, “there was this chance to sell the Artifact. For more money than we’ll ever get from this crummy university in a hundred years. You must realize what this sale meant to us. A chance to do the job we’ve not been able to do because of the lack of finance. Sure, I know about the Wheelers. When Churchill came sucking around to sound us out, I knew he was working for someone behind the scenes, but I wasn’t dealing with anyone behind the scenes. I nailed Churchill hard and refused to talk business until I knew who it was he was fronting for. And when he told me, I gagged a bit, but I went ahead, because I knew it was our only chance to set up a decent fund. I’d have done business with the Devil, Pete, to get that kind of money.”

“Harlow, all I want to ask,” said Maxwell, “is for you to hold up the deal, to give me a little time…”

“Time? Time for what?”

“I need the Artifact.”

“You need the Artifact! Whatever for?”

“I can trade it,” Maxwell told him, “for a planet-for a planet crammed with knowledge, with recorded knowledge, not from one universe, but from two, knowledge that may span fifty billion years.”

Sharp leaned forward, then sank back into his chair.

“You mean this, Pete? You aren’t kidding me? There are some funny stories that I’ve heard. There were two of you and one of you was killed. And you’ve been ducking the newsmen, perhaps the cops as well. You’ve gotten into some sort of hassle with the administration.”

“ Harlow, I could tell you all of it, but it wouldn’t help. You probably wouldn’t believe me. But what I say is true. I can buy a planet…”

“You? For yourself, you mean?”

“No, not myself. The university. That’s why I need time. To get in to see Arnold…”

“And sell him on it? Pete, you haven’t got a chance. You had a row of some sort with Longfellow, and Longfellow runs the joint. Even if you had a legitimate proposition…”

“It is legitimate. I tell you it’s legitimate. I talked to the people on the planet, I saw some of the records.”

Sharp shook his head. “We’ve been friends for a long, long time,” he said. “I’d do almost anything for you. But I can’t go along with this. I can’t throw away this opportunity for Time. Besides, I’m afraid you came too late.”

“Too late?”

“The purchase price was paid this afternoon. The Wheeler takes possession of the Artifact tomorrow morning. He wanted to immediately, but there was a hitch or two in arranging transportation.”

Maxwell sat silent, stunned by what he’d heard.

“So I guess that’s it,” said Sharp. “There’s not much I can do about it.”

Maxwell started to get up, then sat back in the chair.

“ Harlow, if I could see Arnold tonight. If I could talk him into duplicating the price…”

“Don’t be ridiculous,” said Sharp. “He’d faint when you mentioned the price.”

“It was that much?”

“It was that much,” said Sharp.

Maxwell got slowly to his feet. “One thing I will say, however,” Sharp told him, “you must, somehow or other, have thrown a scare into the Wheeler. Churchill was here this morning, nervous as a cat, frothing at the mouth, to close the deal at once. I wish you could have seen me earlier. We might have been able to work something out, although I can’t imagine what it might have been.”

About to turn away, Maxwell hesitated, turned back to the desk behind which Sharp was sitting.

“One thing more. About time travel. Nancy Clayton has a Lambert painting…”

“I heard she had,” said Sharp.

“In the background there’s a hill and a stone upon it. I could swear that stone is the Artifact. Oop says the creatures in the painting are like the ones he remembers from Neanderthal days. And you did find the Artifact on a Jurassic hilltop. How could Lambert have known about it being on that hilltop? The Artifact wasn’t found until centuries after he had died. I think Lambert saw the Artifact and the creatures that he painted. I think he traveled back to the Mesozoic. There is an argument, isn’t there, about a man named Simonson?”

“I see what you’re getting at,” said Sharp. “It’s just barely possible. Simonson did some temporal investigation back in the twenty-first century and claimed some measure of success, but admitted he had problems in control. There is a legend that he lost a man or two in time-sent them back and couldn’t get them out. But there always has been a question as to whether he had any actual success. His notes, the ones we have, aren’t too revealing, and he never published. He carried the work on secretly because he seemed to have the idea that time travel would turn out to be a gold mine, that he could rent it out to scientific expeditions, transport hunters back to the big-game fields-stuff like that, you know. One idea that he seemed to have was going back in time to South Africa and clean out the Kimberley diamond fields. So he kept it secret; no one ever knew too much about what he really did.”

“But it could have been possible,” Maxwell insisted. “The time is right. Simonson and Lambert were contemporaries and there’s an abrupt break in Lambert’s style-as if something had happened. That something could have been going into time.”

“Sure it’s possible,” said Sharp. “But I wouldn’t bet on it.”

When Maxwell came out of the Time building, the stars were coming out and the night wind had an edge of chill. The great elms were clumped masses of a deeper darkness, blotting out the lights of the windows in the buildings across the mall.

Maxwell shivered and turned up the collar of his jacket close about his throat, and went quickly down the stairs to the sidewalk which flanked the mall. There were few people out.

He realized that he was hungry. He had not eaten since early morning. And that he should think of hunger when the last hope he had held had been shattered seemed to be amusing. Not only hungry, he thought, but roofless as well, for if he hoped to dodge the newsmen he could not go back to Oop’s. Although, he reminded himself, there was no longer any reason he should shun the newsmen. Now there’d be nothing gained or lost in the telling of his story. But he shrank from the thought of it, from the thought of the incredulous expressions their faces would assume, from the questions they would ask, and then, more than likely, the tongue-in-cheek style they would employ in the writing of the story.