The Match

Chapter Twenty-Eight

Before sitting down with the FBI, Hester made sure that Wilde had full immunity for breaking into the McAndrews residence and any subsequent crime other than the actual murder. Hester also insisted that the interview take place at her law office, not FBI headquarters, and that the entire interview would be recorded by her firm’s court videographer and stenographer, but the tapes and stenography would not be provided or available to the FBI.

It took a few hours to iron out the details, but in the end, the FBI agreed to Hester’s terms. Now Hester and Wilde sat in the same chairs as before while one FBI agent, a woman who’d introduced herself as Gail Betz, took the chair where Oren had sat, and the other, a man who introduced himself as George Kissell, stood and leaned against the wall.

Betz did the questioning while Kissell stayed silent and looked bored. Wilde didn’t see much reason to hold back in terms of his search for Peter Bennett and how it led him to Henry McAndrews’s house. Hester stopped him several times, especially when Betz pressed for details about his break-in. Betz then turned her focus to Katherine Frole. She asked whether Wilde knew Katherine Frole. The answer was no. Betz searched for possible connections. Frole worked in Trenton — had Wilde ever visited Trenton? Not since a class trip to the New Jersey capital when he was in seventh grade. Frole lived in Ewing, New Jersey. Wilde had never been. Her body was found in an office she rented out in Hopewell. Had Wilde ever been?

“What kind of office?” Wilde asked.

Gail Betz looked up. “Excuse me?”

“Katherine Frole was an FBI agent who worked out of Trenton, right?”

“Yes.”

“So why did she rent an office in Hopewell?”

Kissell spoke for the first time. “We’re asking the questions here.”

“Oh, look,” Hester said. “It speaks. I was about to applaud the FBI for hiring a mute.”

“You’re not funny,” Kissell said.

“Wow, that hurt my feelings. Really. But seriously, my client has been cooperative. He wants to see the murderer of Special Agent Frole brought to justice. So why not answer his question?”

Kissell sighed and peeled himself off the wall. He looked at Betz. “You finished, Special Agent Betz?”

Betz nodded. Kissell pulled out the chair next to her. He sat down heavily, as though he had the weight of the world on him, and wheeled the chair toward the table so that his belly pressed against it. He took his time folding his hands. Then he cleared his throat.

“Have you ever been to Las Vegas, Wilde?”

Warning bells sounded in Wilde’s head. Hester’s too. She put a hand on his forearm, signaling him not to answer.

“Why do you want to know that?” Hester asked.

“I was hoping to get hotel tips,” Kissell replied. Then: “It’s relevant to this investigation.”

“Perhaps you could explain how.”

“Your client knows how. You, Ms. Crimstein, probably know how. But I’m not in the mood to play games, so let me be more direct. We know you were in Las Vegas four months ago. More to the point, we know you visited the home of Daniel and Sofia Carter. I would like to know why.”

Wilde sat stunned.

Hester’s hand was still on his arm. She gave him a little squeeze. “What’s the connection?” she asked.

“Pardon?”

“What’s the connection between this line of inquiry and the murders of McAndrews and Frole?”

“Why don’t you tell me?”

“We don’t know anything about it.”

“Well, see, Ms. Crimstein, neither do I. Yet. That’s why I am asking the question. I hope that if I get an answer, I may find a connection. Then I can ask more questions and find more connections. Or, try to stay with me here, I ask questions and find no connections and so I can move on. That’s how investigations work. So perhaps you can direct your client to tell us why he was in Las Vegas talking to the Carters, and then we can all see if it is relevant or not.”

“I don’t like it,” Hester said.

“That makes me sad,” Kissell said. “I want you to like my questions.”

Hester pointed to her chest. “Hey, pal, listen up. I’ll be the snarky wiseass here, okay?”

“Didn’t mean to usurp your role, Ms. Crimstein. Are you refusing to let your client answer?”

Hester said, “I’d like to confer with my client.”

Kissell shrugged for her to go ahead.

Hester whispered in Wilde’s ear. “Any idea what this is leading to?”

Wilde shook his head.

“I don’t like you answering blind questions like this,” she whispered.

Wilde did a quick calculation. If they’d known about his visit to Daniel Carter, then what was the harm in knowing why?

He signaled to Hester that he was okay to answer the question and said, “Daniel Carter is my biological father.”

Kissell was a cagey veteran. He was used to hearing crazy answers and keeping a straight face. He glanced at Betz, who didn’t bother hiding her surprise.

Kissell waited a beat and asked, “Can you walk us through that?”

“Walk you through what?” Hester asked.

“We all know Wilde’s history,” Kissell said. “It’s public record. I was always under the impression that no one knew the identity of his parents.”

“That was true,” Wilde said.

“How did you find—?”

“The same DNA genealogy site.”

“Hold the phone.” Kissell pushed back against the table. “Are you telling me that Daniel Carter was a DNA match on a website?”

“Yes.”

“Let me see if I’m following this. You put your DNA sample in this website, the website says ‘Hey, we found a match for you — this is your father.’”

“They do it by percentages, but yes.”

“So you contacted him and the two of you set up a visit?”

“No,” Wilde said.

“No?”

“I tried to reach out to him when I saw the match, but my message bounced back.”

Kissell leaned back and crossed his arms. “Any idea why?”

“The message said his account had been closed.”

“I see. So you contacted him, but he clearly didn’t want to hear back from you so he closed his account.”

“My client didn’t say that,” Hester interjected. “He said the account was closed. He has no idea when or why.”

“I stand corrected,” Kissell said. “What did you do next?”

“I flew to Las Vegas.”

“So you had his address?”

“I got it, yes.”

“How?”

Hester took that one. “Not relevant.”

“It sure as shit is relevant. I know these DNA databases. They don’t give out addresses. If his account was closed down, I need to know how you located Daniel Carter.”

Hester leaned forward. “Agent Kissell, do you have any idea how the internet works?”

“What’s that supposed to mean?”

“It means,” she said, “there are no secrets on the web. We delude ourselves if we think anything we do is anonymous. There are always ways if you’re resourceful. I, Agent Kissell, am resourceful.”

“You found the address, Ms. Crimstein?”

Hester just spread her hands.

“How?”

“Do I look tech savvy to you? Theoretically, let’s say I have people. Theoretically, let’s say the DNA database has people. At the end of the day, all of these websites are run by people. People are motivated by self-interest.”

“In short, you bribed someone.”

“In short, if you’re naïve enough to think it’s hard to get information like that,” Hester countered, “you shouldn’t be an FBI agent.”

Kissell thought about that for a moment. “Okay, so you fly to Las Vegas?”

“Yes.”

“You meet with your biological father?”

“Not right away. I waited a few days.”

“Why?”

“It was opening a big door I had kept closed my entire life,” Wilde said, surprised at how unguarded he sounded. “I wasn’t sure I wanted to see what was behind it.”

“And what was behind it?”

“What do you mean?”

“I assume at some point you introduced yourself to Daniel Carter?”

“Yes.”

“What did he tell you?”

“That he didn’t know of my existence. He said that he spent a summer in Europe while serving in the air force. He theorized that he got a girl pregnant during a one-night stand.”

“Did he tell you who the girl might have been?”

“He said he slept with eight girls from a variety of countries. He only knew first names.”

“I see. So no hint about your mother?”

“No.”

“Which is why you then answered Peter Bennett’s message.”

“Yes.”

Kissell rested his hands on his paunch. “How did Daniel Carter react to the news of having a son?”

“It seemed to throw him off-balance.”

“Did he seem happy about it?”

Hester turned to watch Wilde’s face.

“No. He said that that summer was the only time he cheated on Sofia and that they now had three daughters. He worried my appearance would drop a grenade on their lives.”

“I guess I can understand that,” Kissell said with a nod. “What happened next?”

“He said he wanted a day to think about it. He suggested that we meet the next morning for breakfast and discuss it further.”

“And how did that breakfast go?”

“I never showed. I flew home.”

“Why?”

“I didn’t want to be a grenade.”

“Admirable,” Kissell said. He glanced at Betz and asked, “Have you and the Carter family had any contact since?”

“No.”

“None whatsoever?”

“Asked and answered,” Hester said. Then: “So what does all this have to do with the current murders?”

Kissell smiled and rose. Betz did the same.

“Thanks for your cooperation. We will be in touch.”