Water Like A Stone

Chapter Eleven

At first the darkness at the water’s edge seemed absolute. The sky had filled with mottled clouds, their edges livid with the light of an obscured sickle moon, and little illumination filtered through the overhanging trees.

As his eyes began to adjust, however, he could make out a few gleaming patches of the previous night’s snow, blotched like alien fungi on the soft belly of the towpath.

Carefully, he stepped forward until he could see down into the canal itself. There was no wind and no reflection; he might have been staring into an inky, bottomless void. The sensation was oddly exhilarating, like a glimpse into another universe, and he felt a proprietary surge of pleasure. This was his secret place; he had power here, and the knowledge calmed him.

Things were happening that he hadn’t anticipated, and while he didn’t foresee any real danger, the loss of control made him edgy.

Reaching into his coat, he pulled the curved silver fl ask from his inside pocket and took a sip, then another. Alcohol, he’d learned, was a beautiful thing. Just enough would loosen him up, ease him into a transcendent state where time and action could be manipulated to

suit him. Flow, he thought of it, where the ideas that blossomed in his head melded perfectly with his emotions.

But he never drank too much. Deliberately, he replaced the flask’s cap and screwed it tight. He couldn’t afford to be muddled, not now, when he might have to make an unexpected decision. Nor did he want to lose an iota of the intensity of experience, or the clarity of memory. His recollections were kept like the pearls in his pocket, savored, caressed, treasured.

So he paced himself, with medicinal discipline. Only once had his control faltered, and that was because he hadn’t realized just how intoxicating murder could be.

Gemma watched Rosemary Kincaid fidget for half an hour after Duncan and Kit left for their walk. They’d quickly finished the washing up, and when Hugh had muttered something about splitting wood and slipped out through the scullery, Rosemary had murmured, “That’s his refuge when he’s worried, the woodshed.”

They sat at the kitchen table, nursing mugs of unwanted tea, while Toby still slept on the dog bed near the kitchen stove. He looked positively cherubic, his cheeks flushed and his straw-fair hair tousled, one arm thrown over the patient cocker spaniel’s back. The sheepdog and the terrier had moved aside, looking slightly affronted at the usurpation of their warm cushion.

“It’s a good thing he hasn’t an allergy to dog hair,” said Rosemary, watching him. “Aren’t they lovely when they sleep? When Duncan and Juliet were small, no matter how difficult they’d been or how tired I was, I would always go in and watch them for a few minutes after they fell asleep. It helped keep things in perspective. That was until they started locking their bedroom doors, of course,” she added wryly.

“And even then, you tell yourself that once they’re grown, your worries will be over.” She looked wan, and it seemed to Gemma that the lines bracketing her nose and mouth had deepened since morning.

“It’s not like Juliet, is it?” Gemma asked quietly. “Going off without telling anyone. Leaving the children.” She hadn’t felt comfortable with Duncan’s dismissal of his sister’s unexplained disappearance, nor with his admonition to his parents to ignore it. Of course, she didn’t know Juliet as well as he did, but she seemed a responsible mother, and responsible mothers didn’t walk out on their children in the middle of Christmas dinner.

“No.” Rosemary gripped her mug until her knuckles blanched.

“But then I’d never have thought Caspar capable of the things I heard him say last night. And to think I found him charming, once. He was so earnest. I’m not quite sure when that earnestness turned to self-importance.”

The behavior Gemma had witnessed in Caspar Newcombe the previous night had been worse than self- important—it had been vicious. Remembering the near hysteria in Lally’s voice, she said carefully, “Rosemary, you don’t think Caspar would hurt the children?

Lally seemed awfully worried about her father’s reaction if he even learned she’d rung you.”

“Lally’s been a bit prone to dramatizing lately—I suppose it’s understandable.” Rosemary glanced up at Gemma, guilt in the eyes that were so like her son’s. “So at first I thought perhaps she was exaggerating things, looking for attention. But now . . . the thing is, when I spoke to Caspar, I could tell he was drinking. I don’t like the idea of him on his own with the children—not to mention the fact that if Caspar’s been drinking, you can bet his father has as well, and I hate to think of Ralph driving them home . . .” She stood and took her cup to the sink, then wiped at the already spotless worktop with a tea towel. With her back to Gemma, she said, “And Juliet—

Caspar was so angry, but cold with it, as if he’d been storing it up.”

Gemma glanced at Toby, still sleeping despite the rhythmic thunk of the wood splitter from behind the house, and came to a decision.

“How far is it to—what did you say the town was called? Audlem?”

“A half hour from Nantwich. A bit farther for us.”

“Look, why don’t you and Hugh go and get the children. Bring them here. You can leave Juliet a message saying what you’ve done, and I’ll stay here in case she rings. Caspar will let you take the children?”

Rosemary frowned. “I think so, yes. He won’t want to make a scene in front of his parents, especially after what’s already happened. But if Juliet goes home, and Caspar’s there without the children . . .”

“Has he ever hurt Juliet?” Gemma asked gently, trying to mask her own fear.

“I don’t think so. But then I assumed they’d just grown a little distant, that the children growing up and Juliet leaving the office were causing a temporary strain.”

“This partner—do you think there’s any truth to Caspar’s accusations? Could Juliet be having an affair with him?” Gemma had met the man briefly after midnight mass the night before. He’d stood with Caspar, oozing the sort of charm that made her instantly wary. She found it hard to imagine a woman as straightforward as Juliet Newcombe being tempted by such goods.

“I don’t know,” replied Rosemary, her tone bitter. “I’m not sure anymore that I know my daughter at all.”

It hadn’t taken much argument to convince Rosemary that she should fetch Sam and Lally from Caspar’s parents, but when she ended the call to Caspar, Gemma saw that her hands were shaking.

“He was vile,” she said, “but he didn’t disagree. In fact, he seemed eager to be shot of them.”

“No word from Juliet?” asked Gemma.

“No. I can’t think—”

“Don’t.” Impulsively, Gemma hugged her. “I’m sure she’s fi ne. I imagine she just needed some time on her own.”

Nodding against her shoulder, Rosemary said, “Thank you. I’m s

glad you’ve come.” Then she stepped back and began to gather her things briskly. Hugh came in, and when Rosemary explained the situation to him, he instantly agreed that they should go.

Jack the sheepdog watched, sensing an expedition afoot, and began to prance from mistress to master, tail wagging furiously. “No, Jack,” Hugh said. “Stay. Guard the house.”

His tone woke Toby, who sat up, disoriented and cross from his impromptu sleep. He rubbed his eyes and began to cry. Scooping him up, Gemma sat down at the table, holding him in her lap while urging Rosemary and Hugh to go. A moment later the front door slammed and the house was suddenly silent, except for Toby’s grizzling.

“Didn’t want a nap,” he cried. “Now everybody’s gone.”

“You didn’t take a nap,” Gemma assured him, stroking his sleep-damp hair. “You just practiced closing your eyes.” She hugged him but he squirmed, refusing to be placated. “Go on, close your eyes,”

she whispered in his ear. “Just try it.”

Forgetting to sniffle, Toby blinked slowly.

“See how easily you can do it?” Gemma asked. “That’s from practicing.”

He giggled. “That’s silly, Mummy.”

“No, you’re silly. And not everyone’s gone. I’m here, aren’t I? And that means we can do something special, just the two of us.”

Toby slid from her lap, tears forgotten. “Can we do my puzzle?”

Although too young to read the Harry Potter books, he was old enough to be susceptible to the product marketing, and Kit’s gift of a Harry Potter–themed jigsaw had thrilled him.

“Um, okay,” agreed Gemma, deciding she’d worry later about having to dismantle a partially completed puzzle the first time someone needed the kitchen table. “Of course we can.”

Toby tore from the room, and a moment later she heard him pounding up the stairs. The dogs, having returned to the warmth of the stove-side bed, glanced up at the noise. Jack and Tess put their heads down again, but Geordie stretched and came over to her, lay-

ing his head on her knee. As she stroked his head, she realized this was the first moment she’d had on her own since they’d arrived. She felt a little odd, alone in Duncan’s parents’ house, as if she were trespassing, but she was glad of the solitude.

Her peace was short-lived, however. She’d just got Toby settled at the table with his jigsaw when the doorbell rang. She had done enough notifications during her days on the beat that she never felt comfortable with an unexpected caller, but this time the instinctive jab of fear was sharper.

It might be Juliet, she told herself, without a key. Assuring Toby she’d be right back, she shut the barking dogs in the kitchen and went to the door, her heart thumping with a mixture of hope and trepidation.

But the man who stood on the porch when she swung open the door was a stranger. Her first thought was that his slightly battered face seemed an odd match for his well-cut blond hair and his expensively tailored black wool overcoat; her second was that he was rakishly attractive.

Eyeing her with equal interest, he said, “I was looking for Duncan Kincaid. Have I got the right house?” His voice held the drawn-out vowels of the northwest, more pronounced than the faint trace Duncan had retained.

“Yes, but he’s not here just now.” Glancing at the sky, she saw that it had grown later than she’d realized. She forced a smile and added,

“He should be back very soon, though, if you’d like to wait.”

The caller glanced at the darkening sky, as if gauging the time, then shook his head. “No, I don’t want to impose. Just ask him to call Ronnie Babcock, when he comes in.”

“Ronnie Babcock? You’re Chief Inspector Babcock?”

He gave her a quizzical look. “Last time I checked.”

Gemma flushed. “Oh, sorry. I didn’t mean— It’s just that Duncan’s talked about you.” She stepped out on the porch, offering him her hand. “I’m Gemma.”

The surprised look that followed this pronouncement was worse than his previous bafflement. Then his face cleared and he shook her hand heartily, smiling at her as if she’d just won the lottery. “The old bugger. He didn’t say he was—”

Gemma stopped him before he could go any further. “We’re not.

Married. But we live together.” She felt a flash of fury at Duncan, who had obviously not bothered mentioning her, or their relationship, to his old mate. And why should she feel she had to apologize for the fact that they weren’t married?

“Well, he’s a lucky man, in any case,” said Babcock, making a quick recovery with such charm that her resentment evaporated.

“Look, he really shouldn’t be much longer. He’s just gone out for a walk, and it’s almost dark. Why don’t you—”

“Mummy.” Toby’s voice came plaintively from behind her.

“Jack’s scratching at the door, but I didn’t let him out. Can we finish our puzzle now?”

“My son, Toby,” she explained to Babcock, then ruffling Toby’s fair hair, she added, “It’s cold, lovey. Go back inside and I’ll be right there.” She pulled the door a little more tightly closed behind her.

Jack’s high- pitched bark escalated, and she pictured him hurtling through the house towards the intruding stranger like a black-and-white bullet. Did he bite if not properly introduced?

“It wasn’t important. I won’t keep you,” Babcock told her, and she wasn’t sure whether his quick response meant he feared loss of limb or that he might be drafted to participate in puzzle solving.

“Is it about the baby? The one Juliet found?” she asked.

“Well, yes. I thought he might be interested in the results of the—” He paused, and Gemma suspected he was searching for a more delicate way to say “postmortem.” Her irritation with Duncan flared again. Not that she could reasonably have expected him to tell Babcock she was a fellow police officer if he hadn’t mentioned her at all, but she found being treated like the little woman galling.

“Look,” she began. “There’s no need to tiptoe about with me.

I’m—”

A car, which Gemma had vaguely noticed traveling too fast down the lane, its headlamps unlit in the gathering dusk, turned into the farmhouse drive with a squeal of tires.

Turning to watch, Babcock muttered, “What the hell is he playing at, the mad bastard?” But as the Vauxhall came to a stop and the driver’s door opened, it was Juliet Newcombe who climbed out. She walked towards them, her gait a little tentative, like a toddler just finding its balance.

Gemma’s first thought was that Duncan’s sister was drunk. Her second, as Juliet drew near enough for Gemma to see her pale face and wide, dark eyes, was that she was ill, or very shocked.

Babcock seemed to have come to the same conclusion, saying, “Are you all right, Mrs. Newcombe?”

Juliet stopped, staring at Babcock for a moment as if trying to place him. “Oh. It’s Chief Inspector . . . Babcock, isn’t it?”

“We’ve been trying to reach you this afternoon, Mrs. Newcombe,”

Babcock said pleasantly, but he was scrutinizing her closely, and Gemma knew he would be automatically checking for the smell of alcohol, or the dilated pupils indicating drug use. “We need to get a formal statement from you,” he continued, apparently satisfied that he didn’t need to nick her for driving while impaired. “About yesterday evening.”

“The baby.” Juliet’s voice held a faint note of surprise, as if she’d forgotten her discovery, then her face creased with concern. “Have you found out anything? Do you know who she is?”

“No, I’m afraid not. But we need contact information for your crew. If you could—”

Gemma stepped into the drive and put an arm round the other woman, feeling her shiver. “Juliet, you’re freezing. Come inside. Mr.

Babcock, surely she can give her statement in the morning? I can bring her into the station myself, if you’d like.”

Seeing him hesitate, Gemma knew his curiosity over Juliet’s behavior was warring with the tact necessitated by the fact that he was dealing with a friend’s—and a fellow officer’s—sister. “That’s very kind of you,” he said at last, and she breathed an inner sigh of relief.

“We’ve set up an incident room at Crewe headquarters. Shall we say about nine?” He nodded at them. “And tell Duncan to give me a ring, if you wouldn’t mind.”

“Duncan—where is he?” asked Juliet. “I’ve been— I’ve got to—” She broke off as Gemma gave her shoulder a sharp squeeze.

However innocent Juliet’s actions of the past few hours, Gemma felt instinctively that she didn’t want her broadcasting them to Babcock just yet. Fleetingly, she realized that this was what it felt like to be on the other side, and she didn’t care for it at all.

“Let’s go in,” Gemma said, steering an unresisting Juliet towards the door. “You’ll catch your death.” Over her shoulder, she called out to Ronnie Babcock, “It was nice to meet you. I’ll tell Duncan you came by.” She pushed Juliet into the house and closed the door on Babcock, who was standing in the drive, staring after them.

Grabbing an old woolly cardigan from among the coats on the hall pegs, Gemma draped it over Juliet’s shoulders. “Kitchen,” she commanded. “It’s warmer in there.”

“My parents,” Juliet said through chattering teeth. “Where—”

“They’ve gone to pick up Sam and Lally from Caspar’s parents’.

Lally rang, saying you’d been gone for hours. They—we—were worried about you.”

“I didn’t mean— I didn’t think—”

“I’m sure you didn’t.” Gemma herded Juliet down the hall. “Let’s get you something hot to drink.”

The dogs crowded round as they entered the kitchen, Tess and Geordie sniffing excitedly at a new person, Jack wagging his tail and laying his ears back in fawning devotion. Juliet reached down, burying her hand in his ruff as if finding solace in his thick coat.

Toby was back at the table, his small legs swinging several inches

short of the floor. Looking up, he said, “Auntie Juliet!” with as much enthusiasm as if he’d known her all his life. “I’ve got a Harry Potter puzzle. It’s got Quidditch in it.”

“Hello, sweetie.” Juliet managed a smile, but Gemma could see the effort it cost her. “That’s lovely.”

“Here. Sit.” She guided Juliet into a chair. Fortunately, she had helped Rosemary enough to have an idea of where most things were, and could at least make tea without fumbling about.

As she turned to put the kettle on, the clock over the cooker caught her eye. With a start, she saw that it had gone fi ve o’clock, and a peep at the windows told her that it was now completely dark.

She drew the blinds and put another log in the stove while she waited for the water to come to the boil, the busyness an antidote to the disquiet clutching at her stomach. Duncan and Kit should have been back ages ago, surely.

Then she chided herself for worrying. This was Duncan’s territory. He knew what he was doing, and he was certainly capable of finding his way home after dark—this rural landscape was alien only to her.

They had probably stopped to watch badgers, she thought, recalling a snatch of a television sitcom she’d once seen about country life. But no, badgers hibernated, she was quite sure, and she was waffling from nerves.

Juliet seemed to be listening to Toby’s rather confusing version of the rules of Quidditch, but she glanced up as Gemma took out the box of PG Tips. “No, wait,” she said. “Under the sink. Dad always keeps a bottle of apple brandy there.”

Opening the lower cupboard door, Gemma discovered that there was indeed a half-full bottle of Calvados tucked away behind the washing-up liquid. “Handy,” she commented as she poured a generous slosh into the mug she’d intended for Juliet’s tea.

“His emergency stash. Medicinal, he says. He always gave us apple brandy, lemon, and honey for sore throats when we were kids.”

Juliet grasped the mug like a life raft and tossed back a swallow.

Gasping, she screwed up her face like a child forced to take cough medicine, then took a more considered sip. Color crept back into her cheeks. “You said Mum and Dad have gone to get the children? But Caspar will be furious. He won’t let—”

“He will. Your mum spoke to him and he agreed.” Gemma didn’t add anything else. Having seen a bag of rawhide treats beside the brandy, she fished out three of the pressed bones and distributed them to the dogs. Jack bared his teeth when Geordie and Tess ventured too close, but after circling for a moment, the three dogs found separate corners and settled down with their prizes.

“Mum said she’d bring them here?” Juliet looked both relieved and horrified. “It’s not that I want them going home with him,” she hastened to explain. “Especially when he’s in a foul temper. But—

How am I going to explain my leaving to Lally and Sam? I can’t—

No one will—” She stopped, shivering convulsively.

Gemma slipped into a chair beside Juliet and tipped a much smaller portion of Calvados into her own cup. Someone would be back soon, either Duncan and Kit or Rosemary and Hugh with the children, and she suspected that if she was to get anything out of Juliet it had better be now. Gently, she said, “Why don’t you start by telling me?”

Babcock climbed reluctantly back into the BMW and sat for a moment, engine idling, letting the heater blow the remains of the engine’s warmth into the frigid cocoon of the car’s interior. He slipped on his gloves, then drummed his

leather-

padded fingers on the steering

wheel.

Something was up with Juliet Newcombe and he didn’t like it one bit. Nor did he like being brushed off, even when it was done as smoothly as it had been by Duncan’s very attractive red-headed girlfriend. She hadn’t wanted Juliet to tell him where she’d been, or why she seemed so upset.

His thoughts strayed to Duncan. What had he expected? That his old mate would be living the conventional suburban married life with a bored but well- preserved wife and surly teenagers in public school?

But here he was, apparently cohabiting with this fresh-faced woman young enough to put him in the “lucky bastard” category, and she was sharp as a tack, with an engaging directness. He noticed, however, that she’d referred to the towheaded kid as “my son,” not “our son.”

Things were never as simple as they first appeared.

Take the whole situation with Juliet Newcombe. She was the wife of a locally respected financial consultant, recommended for the job on the old dairy barn by her husband’s partner, who just happened to live up the lane, and who had not been at home when the uniformed constables did their house- to- house interviews.

Babcock had instructed the officers to keep trying to reach Dutton, but perhaps he should give Dutton a try himself. Dutton was, after all, the ideal person to offer some unbiased insight into Juliet Newcombe’s behavior.

“Look. You won’t tell anyone else, will you? What I did—it’s not exactly kosher.” Juliet waited for Gemma’s nod before going on, hesitantly. “I went to the office. Caspar and Piers’s. I hadn’t any intention of driving, even, but when I found myself in Nantwich, I realized that I could get into the office while no one else was there. I could look through Piers’s things.” She glanced at Gemma as if expecting censure, but Gemma merely nodded again.

“Does this have something to do with Caspar shouting at you last night?” Gemma asked.

Juliet glanced at Toby, who had gone back to his puzzle, humming quietly to himself as he moved the pieces about. “Yes. But it’s not what you think.” Her voice was bitter. “When Caspar and Piers first went in together, I thought Piers Dutton was the most considerate man I’d ever met. He’d never let me open his mail, or file his

paperwork for him. He said he wanted to save me the trouble. Of course, I knew he’d been on his own before, and it was clear from early on that he was

particular—even

obsessive—about having

things done a certain way. I just assumed he was more comfortable doing things himself. And I wasn’t that sure of myself at first—I’d been home with the kids for years when Caspar suggested I come and help out.

“I should bloody well have stayed at home. It’s hard to believe now, but I thought I had a good life, a good marriage.” She gave Gemma a crooked smile. “You’ve got the right idea—don’t get married to begin with, then it can’t go pear-shaped on you.”

“It’s not quite that simple,” Gemma protested. “What changed?”

she prompted Juliet, eager to change the subject. “Did something happen with Piers?”

Juliet stared intently at the cottage pattern on her Dunoon mug, as if she might find an answer there. “It was an accumulation of little things, like when you notice a tap dripping somewhere in the house.

At first you’re not sure you’re hearing anything at all, then it grows on you until you think you’ll go mad if you don’t find the source.

“He’d take the mail before I finished sorting it. He’d shut his door on phone calls with clients. He kept his file drawers locked.”

“And Caspar didn’t? ”

“Why should he? Clients’ investment information is confidential, of course, but it’s not like it’s a matter of national security.”

“Not unless you’re doing something unethical, or illegal,” said Gemma, and Juliet nodded.

“So I started to suspect. I just couldn’t work out what he was doing. And all the while I thought I was crazy for even entertaining the idea. Then, one day, when Piers had gone out to lunch, I noticed that one of his fi le drawers wasn’t quite shut. I was standing in his office, trying to decide if it was worth the risk to have a peek, when he came back.” Juliet glanced up from the brandy she hadn’t tasted since she’d begun to talk. “I remember I jumped, and I must have looked guilty,

but he smiled. Piers always smiles. But, just for an instant, I saw something in his eyes.” She swallowed. “Afterwards, I tried to convince myself I’d imagined it. I suppose I should be grateful I’ve led such a sheltered life that at first I didn’t recognize it for what it was.”

Gemma nodded, understanding what Juliet meant, and why she was reluctant to name what she had sensed. She had seen it, too, only a few times, but those glimpses into the abyss would stay with her for the rest of her life.

Juliet glanced at Toby, who was now flying his puzzle pieces rather than trying to put them together, with suitable sound effects, and seemed oblivious to their conversation. “You don’t expect . . . ,” she went on slowly. “Not in your friends, acquaintances, business partners . . .” She shook her head as if to clear it. “Not long after that, the way Piers treated me began to change. The friendly hand on the shoulder escalated to pats on the bum; the mildly flirtatious comments got more suggestive. But it was all still subtle enough that I didn’t want to make a scene, so I tried to pretend I hadn’t heard, or that I hadn’t understood what he meant. I started to dread going in to work, or being left alone in the office with him.

“There was something so calculated about it, so inevitable, as if he’d worked out a plan and he never doubted I’d go along. But maybe that’s hindsight.”

“But you didn’t go along.”

Juliet met Gemma’s gaze, memory like a bruise in her eyes. Her chest rose and fell more quickly, but she kept her voice low. “He cornered me in his office, one day when Caspar was out calling on a client in Macclesfield. I had to kick him to get him to let me go. It was only after that, when he knew he couldn’t seduce me, that he started to turn Caspar against me.”