Chapter 7
2-7 December 1876
Yellowstone Kelly didn’t end up finding Miles on Crooked Creek in those two days that Captain Snyder had allotted him. That night of the thirtieth he slept cold and alone before starting back for the battalion in the gray light of dawn that first day of December.
On the second Kelly led the battalion out at first light, pushing south by east for the valley of the Big Dry, where Snyder abandoned a wagon because of a broken axle and worn-out mules. Herding the balky animals on with his little column, the captain pressed the men to put as much country behind them as they could, what with the dwindling rations and forage staring them in the face.
Over those next three days the mules and men visibly slowed their pace not only due to the deepening snow and rugged nature of the country, but to their worsening health as well. The march dragged slower and slower until Snyder grew extremely alarmed that he would not be able to force-march the men and animals all the way back to the cantonment.
“Kelly—grain up the best pair of horses we have,” the captain told the scout on the fifth. “Pick another man sure to make it with you …”
“Just in case one of us doesn’t, Captain?”
Snyder nodded. “We still don’t know where the hell Sitting Bull is, and you two might run right into a pack of them. I want … These men all need one of you to make it back to our base.”
“What do you want me to tell them at the post?”
“Just to send back with you all that they can spare in the way of rations for man and beast, Kelly.” Then the captain’s hollow eyes began to mist over as he held out his hand. “I wish you God’s speed.”
He shook Snyder’s hand and smiled in that bushy, unkempt beard. “Don’t you worry none now, Captain. I won’t need any luck. You just keep an eye out for me on the skyline. I’ll get those supplies for you. Don’t you worry none about that.”
Leading his two orderlies, four mounted soldiers, thirteen wagon drivers, and ninety-three foot soldiers, Lieutenant Frank D. Baldwin and his scout, Vic Smith, had backtracked uneventfully with his weakening mules all the way to Fort Peck, where on the afternoon of 6 December he learned from his advance scout, Johnny Bruguier, that the Hunkpapa were camped no more than fifteen miles east of the agency on Porcupine Creek, north of the Missouri. Although the sun would soon be setting, Baldwin immediately decided to press on.
His quarry was within reach. No more than a matter of miles and hours now. If he could only be the one to capture Sitting Bull—
What a feather in his cap that would be!
“I want you to carry word to General Miles,” he instructed the half-breed as he scribbled out a hurried message.
If I thought you could arrive here in time I would wait … but [I] am afraid the chance will be lost. … I shall start this evening and endeavor to reach the main camp in time to pitch in early in the morning.
Slit-eyed, Bruguier asked, “Soon the Bear Coat takes the rope from my neck, right?”
For a moment Frank studied the half-breed’s face, feeling almost sad for the man who was wanted for murder among the white people, a man who had just turned his back on the Indians who had taken him in as one of their own.
“Yeah,” Baldwin replied. “You’ve done what you promised you would a few days back. Now the general will do what he said he would—since you’ve told me exactly where I’ll find Sitting Bull.”
As the shadows lengthened, Baldwin watched Bruguier and scout Billy Cross mount up and head west with his message to Miles that he was about to engage the Hunkpapa. Then the thirty-four-year-old veteran of the Civil War went against the strong feelings of his officers and prepared for his assault on the Sioux.
“All due respect, sir,” said Second Lieutenant David Q. Rousseau, “we don’t know what size of opposing force we’re going to confront.”
Baldwin bristled at the criticism from the West Pointers. He glared at the rest in turn. “What say the rest of you?”
“Permission to speak honestly?” asked Second Lieutenant Frank S. Hinkle.
“Permission, Mr. Hinkle.”
“Considering the condition of the men and the weather, not knowing the strength of our enemy”—and then he paused—“I would recommend we send out scouts first, sir.”
Baldwin boldly asked them, “Do any of you agree with me that we should strike before Sitting Bull’s village slips away
None of the other three officers spoke up.
“Very well, then,” Baldwin sighed. “You have your orders. We’re going after the Hunkpapa—tonight.”
In the next hour he had his men unhitch the wagon teams and off-load eighteen thousand rounds for the Springfields onto his mule train. In addition he supplied a hundred rounds to be carried by every one of his 112 men. After putting his last three bags of oats for the mules in the packs, he issued two days’ rations for the men to carry in their haversacks suspended over their shoulders.
By eight P.M. the lieutenant climbed back into his saddle, formed his foot soldiers into column, and headed east in the dark, forcing their way through more than two feet of snow. If he managed to make good time crossing that winter wilderness, his three companies could attack the Hunkpapa camp sometime just after dawn.
As a young man from Michigan, Baldwin had enlisted in the Union Army in 1861 and quickly won a commission. He had served in Sherman’s campaigns down in the Carolinas and in Georgia. At one point he was captured by the Confederates, held for a time at Libby Prison in Richmond, then was released in a prisoner exchange. He went back to active service, fought on, was captured and released a second time.
After Appomattox a restless Baldwin was assigned to various stations in the west until he found a home with the Fifth Infantry and Nelson A. Miles. Time and again during the Red River War against the southern tribes, he served Miles as chief of scouts, winning numerous commendations for gallantry, and received several brevet promotions. It was Baldwin’s gutsy wagon-train raid on Gray Beard’s camp at McClellan Creek that secured the release of the two youngest German sisters in November of 1874.
But even that would pale compared to the glory to be heaped on the shoulders of the man who captured Sitting Bull. How proud his Alice would be of him, though she had repeatedly begged him to leave the army. Yet in Baldwin flickered the same desire that burned bright in Miles. Not to mention all those hopes and dreams Frank committed to the pages of his shirt-pocket diary every day.
As cold stars twinkled overhead, the men trudged through snow some two feet on the level, an icy crust scraping and gouging their shins. On into the deepening darkness they struggled, following the Missouri down to the mouth of Milk River. In the starry darkness about seven miles east of the agency on the Fort Buford Road the column suddenly confronted several small bands of friendlies frightened by Sitting Bull’s swelling village and the arriving soldiers, hurrying now toward Fort Peck.
Baldwin grew elated at the prospect of finding the Hunkpapa camp on the north side of the Missouri. As they marched on through the night, the freezing air carried with it the faint hint of woodsmoke. The hostile camp could not be far now.
Baldwin was certain he would soon be staring Sitting Bull in the eye.
* * *
“The soldiers are near!”
Sitting Bull scrambled to his feet at that first cry from outside, but he was barely standing when his lodge door was thrust aside and in leaped his adopted brother.
“Jumping Bull!”
“My brother,” the warrior said breathlessly, “forgive my discourtesy.”
His eyes quickly darted around the crowded circle. In this lodge, as in every lodge and every tent the Hunkpapa bands still possessed, the people were hunkered close this winter. And in the last few days even more had come to stand with Sitting Bull as it became clear the soldiers were once more come to raid and burn and kill. Just three suns ago, ten-times-nine more lodges had joined the growing camp.
Sitting Bull asked, “Do you bring this alarm of soldiers?”
“Yes,” Jumping Bull replied, pulling his hands from the two wool-blanket mittens and rubbing them over the fire. “The soldiers—they must know where we are. They are marching right for us.”
“The one you trusted,” growled Lame Red Skirt from the far side of the fire. “Big Leggings.”
“Yes,” Sitting Bull said dolefully. “I should have let you kill him when he came among us.”
Jumping Bull whirled on Lame Red Skirt. “You were an old woman ready to surrender when Sitting Bull was standing alone against the Bear Coat. Your anger at Big Leggings does nothing to help us now, Lame Red Skirt!”
Sitting Bull watched the words strike the war chief like a quirt lash across the cheek. Lame Red Skirt’s eyes flared, but the Bull put out a hand to motion him to keep his seat. “Tell me where the soldiers are.”
“South,” Jumping Bull declared, his eyes coming back from the humiliated war chief. “They are near the mouth of the Milk River.”
“How is it you know this?” Black Moon demanded.
“At sundown last night the soldiers talked with Big Leggings at the agency.”
“Were you there?” Lame Red Skirt asked.
“No, but some Yanktonais were,” Jumping Bull said. “They came in search of me, found me out hunting, then told me the soldiers were marching—even now into the dark of night.”
“That never means any good will come of the next few days,” Sitting Bull commented quietly. His fingers slowly played up and down one braid.
“I went to see for myself, brother,” Jumping Bull continued. “In the dark at the agency, and bundled in my blanket coat, I must have been taken by the soldiers as one of their own scouts. I came up behind the wasicu, rode past the long string of their walk-a-heaps, and even passed right by the soldier chief leading them this way.”
Suddenly Sitting Bull was decisive. “Let there be no delay! Tell everyone we are leaving. Now! Take down the lodges and tents. Men must ready their weapons to protect the women and children if the soldiers find us while we escape in the dark.”
Already the chiefs were moving from his lodge with the Bull’s instructions. In minutes the covers were slipping from the lodgepoles and the travois attached to rib-gaunt ponies were loaded with what the Hunkpapa still possessed.
In less time than it takes for a hungry man to eat his breakfast, the warrior bands who owed allegiance to Sitting Bull had slipped away from the mouth of Porcupine Creek, following the east bank of the Milk toward the frozen Minisose.
There in the predawn darkness of 7 December they planned to cross to the south bank a few at a time, horses and dogs, women, children, and old ones first. As the temperature had continued to drop over the last few days, new ice had formed on the river. For now the black of night rumbled with the muffled sounds of frightened children crying, women wailing their despair at being driven from their homes once more, and old men resolutely chanting their strong-heart songs to give courage to the young ones who would cover their retreat.
Those sounds seemed to be swallowed by the cold, clear night, buried beneath the creak and groan of the new snow as it strained beneath the weight of so many hooves, so many moccasins.
As the warriors took up positions in the timbered breaks overlooking the crossing so they could delay the soldiers sure to come … the first of the Sitting Bull band stepped out of the skeletal trees, onto the icy Minisose River, and began to flee south toward the rugged, broken countryside, into the darkness, into a frightening unknown once more.
“Why the hell didn’t any of you say anything?” Frank Baldwin demanded, feeling his gorge rise.
He glared at his junior officers and noncoms, those men who nervously shifted from foot to foot in the cold and the snow. The rising wind was brutal, and it smelled of even more snow here after midnight in the darkness of 7 December as Baldwin’s battalion stood shivering on the north bank of the Missouri River.
He grew more frustrated because of their silence, because of the darkness of the night, because of this bone-numbing cold that made even a strong man want to lie down and go to sleep and never wake up again … because he had just been told by one of his new scouts, eighteen-year-old Joe Culbertson, that they had likely passed by the enemy village in the dark less than an hour ago.
“All right,” Baldwin said quietly, fighting down his own despair at letting the Hunkpapa slip through his fingers. “Let’s turn this battalion about and see if we can’t still catch the Sioux napping.”
Culbertson and Edward Lambert, hired on by Baldwin just hours ago at Fort Peck, both led the column toward the bottomland where the Porcupine dumped into the Milk River. Even in the snowy darkness as Baldwin led his cautious troops into the village, they could tell it was abandoned. The cold, quiet night made the men spooky about an ambush. So quiet that Frank knew better. Plain too that the Hunkpapa had fled in very great haste. Fires still smoldered and some actually burned. Camp gear and hides lay scattered and abandoned on their route of retreat.
Baldwin glared into the distance along that trail taken by the fleeing Sioux toward the Missouri—a path more than thirty feet wide—knowing his quarry expected him to follow. Sensing the irresistible urge to go charging after … knowing that sort of thing had killed many a soldier and their impetuous officers.
“Look there, men!” he called out above the soldiers as his horse stamped and pawed at the snow, snorting jets of frost from its wide nostrils. “We can see-where they’ve gone. A wide trail for us to follow. Put out flankers and see that we aren’t surprised. Move out!”
G, H, and I companies found the going much easier on the trail now, what with all the hooves and feet that had beaten down the snow in that hasty retreat toward the frozen Missouri. Baldwin marched them until they reached the Milk River just after three A.M., where he allowed them to fall out and prepare a meal. If he was going to keep his men up and possibly pitching into a fight, then they best have something in their bellies.
Just before dawn, as the lieutenant stood staring at the faint outline of the bluffs on the south side of the river, yelps and screeches made the hair stand on the back of his neck.
At first fearing they had stumbled into an attack, he ordered his officers to prepare the men to face a frontal assault, moving some soldiers here, deploying others there, to protect his flanks. But for all the alarm it turned out to be only a dozen or so cocky warriors racing past the column in an attempt to spook the mules in his supply train. Rifles cracked and men bellowed as the warriors sang out their courage. While mules brayed, the last of the shots died and the warriors were gone. At least one of them lay across the withers of his pony as the Hunkpapa disappeared through the timber.
“We got one, sir!” a voice in the darkness boasted.
“I saw it, soldier,” Frank replied. “Son of a bitch is riding off.”
“Must’a got us two of ’em, Lieutenant,” an old veteran asserted. “The boys cutting the hair off a body back yonder right now.”
“We got two of ’em, did we?” Baldwin said, taking what small satisfaction he could.
Still, he could not allow his men to tarry long. Baldwin got them re-formed and moving out once more within a matter of moments, pushing on for the river. They didn’t have far to go.
At the banks of the frozen Missouri he halted his battalion and gave them permission to fall out, to make themselves as comfortable as they could without starting any fires in these coldest moments of the day. Then Baldwin turned to look east a moment, searching the horizon for that gray band foretelling sunrise.
“If we’re going to catch Sitting Bull,” Baldwin vowed, “then let it be this day, gentlemen.”
A horseman loomed out of the darkness. Culbertson.
“General—the Yanktons—there’s at least four camps of ’em back there to the north.”
“What of them?”
“Figgered you oughtta know,” the young man replied. “There’s Injuns you’re hunting, and Injuns you’re not.”
He chewed his lip in frustration. “How close?”
The young scout threw his thumb over his shoulder. “Not far.”
Muttering something to himself, Baldwin called his officers together and gave them a final, strict order. “I’ve just learned we’ve got some friendly agency bands camped nearby. Inform your men that there’ll be hell to pay if they fire on the Yanktons. Make sure of your enemy. Dismissed.”
After deploying his 112 men along the riverbank—G Company taking up the left flank and I on the right, with H to act as the rear guard—the lieutenant waited for the sky to lighten, for the Sioux to do something, anything. Pacing and watching the eastern horizon, he would then turn and gaze to the west for a few minutes.
He didn’t have long to wait.
Baldwin and some others suddenly saw them—out there on the ice. Dim forms moving slowly in the murky dawn light: the rear guard of the Hunkpapa still making its crossing of the river.
Now his men were beginning to stir. In the ashen darkness they could just begin to make out the ghostly, shadowy images of the enemy too. Farther still, beyond the warriors, against the stark grayish-white of the hillsides, Frank could discern the winding caravan of the women and children: the rest of the village on the run.
Sitting Bull was at hand!
Baldwin turned so fast, so suddenly in the snow, that he nearly stumbled. His eyes shooting over the men, his officers, determining who was closest to the bank.
“Battalion!” he bellowed as he lunged into the saddle, then leaped his horse down by the edge of the ice himself, waving them on as he rode parallel to the river—pointing at the Hunkpapa rear guard. “There’s the enemy! Follow me—on the double!”
At once the entire line of his skirmishers were hustling out of the trees back to the trampled Fort Buford Road, trudging, stomping, stumbling upriver through the snow. As he neared the mouth of Bark Creek, the lieutenant halted his men, watching the village scurrying into the bare timber on the far side of the frozen Missouri.
“Culbertson,” he instructed, “I want you to take these two men—make a crossing and see what you can find out about the enemy’s position on the south bank.”
He watched the scout motion to the pair of mounted infantrymen, then move down to the trampled crossing.
Baldwin said to his officers, “Tell your men they may fall out and fix breakfast while we’re waiting for our scouts to return.”