Rule of Three

Chapter Sixteen

“You can’t use that objectivist crap to justify porn.”

They walked into the condo, continuing the heated discussion that had started on the way home in the car.

Dag laughed. “What? You can’t see that porn is a form of art?”

“Art! Well, okay, some of it might be. But really, it has to have some kind of artistic value.”

“The debate of art versus porn wages on,” Chris said, dropping car keys to the small console table inside the door. “We could argue this for hours. I have a better idea.”

Dag looked at Chris and caught the evil glint in his eye just as Kassidy did too and she burst out laughing. “We’re not making our own porn movie.”

He caught her around the waist and nuzzled her neck. “Aw, why not?”

“I know you’re worried about your sister, Kassidy, but she’s a big girl,” Dag said.

“I know.” Kassidy sighed. “I just wish… Oh never mind.”

“What, sweetheart?” Chris followed her into the living room.

“Yeah, what?” Dag reached out and ran a hand down her hair. He’d longed to touch her all evening, wanting to make her feel better about what had happened, but his role in that family setting was extremely ambiguous.

“I just wish I had a different relationship with my sister. I’ve always wished Hailey and I could be friends.”

“You aren’t necessarily friends with someone just because you’re related,” Dag murmured.

She turned her eyes up to him. “Is that part of the objectivist philosophy too?”

“Yeah. Sort of. We develop relationships with people we share values with—common interests in things like sports, art, music, philosophical outlooks, political beliefs. That includes our families.”

“I always believed you may not like your family, but you have to love them. Because they’re family.”

“Do you feel guilty because you don’t love Hailey?”

A long heavy silence filled the room, and Dag saw that Chris was listening intently too, waiting. “I do love her,” she said finally. “She’s my sister. But I do feel guilty for not liking her.” She put a hand to her mouth. “I do.”

“Don’t.” Dag slid his arms around her and pulled her against him in a warm hug that felt so damn good. “Don’t feel guilty. Think about it rationally. Just because you’re related to her doesn’t mean you have anything in common besides the fact that you’re sisters.”

“That’s kind of sad, though,” she said, peering up at him. “Is that how you feel about your family?”

“That’s how I had to feel about my family,” he said grimly, his mouth tightening. “For me to survive, I had to believe that. Because I hate my family.”

“Oh Dag. That can’t be true.”

“It’s true.” He glanced at Chris. He’d talked to Chris about his family, only once, years ago, when they were getting to know each other, and Chris had known that topic was off limits ever since. But Kassidy didn’t know. “My dad disappeared when I was a baby. My mom was an alcoholic who cared more about getting her next drink and getting another man than she did about me.”

Her eyes filled with pain and sorrow. He closed his own against the sight. He hated pity. “Don’t feel sorry for me,” he said, voice gritty. He opened his eyes and smiled down at her. “I’m fine. I made it. I’m only telling you this so you’ll understand and not feel guilty about your feelings for Hailey. If you’re going to love someone, it’s gonna be the people you choose to be family. Like…like…Chris.” His voice faltered on the last words, and tension in the room thickened as all three became painfully aware once again of the unique nature of their relationship. That it was her and Chris who had the relationship, not him. “You choose your partner, your spouse. That’s who you love,” he finished, still smiling, his chest still aching.

“I understand that.” She laid a hand on his cheek and smiled at him. Her bottom lip trembled and she looked as if she wanted to say something but hesitated. “Dag…” He didn’t want to go where her mind might be heading, so he bent and gave her lips a quick kiss.

A kiss that quickly turned heated. Chris joined them, close up against Kassidy’s backside, pulling her hair aside and laying his mouth on the bare skin of her shoulder, moving the tiny strap aside and kissing her there.

“Even though I don’t understand this,” Kassidy whispered. “Even though I suspect it’s very, very wrong…can I tell you guys how lucky I feel to have both of you in my life?”

Dag’s gut clenched. Amazing–that was exactly how he felt about Chris and Kassidy, the feelings that had swamped him earlier at her parents’ home.

“It’s not wrong,” he replied, sliding his mouth over her soft cheek. “Sex promotes happiness. That’s our goal–to be happy, right?”

Kassidy gave a delicate little snort even as her head fell back to allow both men access to her throat and shoulders. “More objectivism?”

He smiled against her jaw. “Yeah. Sex isn’t just physical pleasure. It’s a celebration of existence.” And an expression of love, but he stopped himself from saying those words aloud. “Celebrating life is essential to happiness. So, it’s moral to make choices that allow that celebration and immoral to deny it. We’re celebrating life.”

“I think you can use philosophy to justify anything,” Chris muttered from behind Kassidy, and Dag laughed.

“I probably could,” he agreed. “But are either of you arguing with me right now?”

“No,” Chris said.

“No,” Kassidy said on a sigh. “No.”

They moved to the bedroom in what was becoming a familiar rhythm of three.

“Wanna make you feel good, baby doll,” Dag murmured against the thin skin of her neck. “So good.”

“Yes,” she whispered, eyes closed, head to one side. “Make me feel good.”

“You’re so sweet,” Chris said, pushing the bodice of her dress down. As Dag had suspected all day, she wore no bra beneath and her perfect round breasts gleamed in the lamplight.

“Oh yeah.”

While Chris helped her out of the dress, Dag bent to take her nipple in his mouth, a delicious hard little nub and she moaned when he sucked on it. Soon she stood naked between them.

“I hate it when you feel bad, sweetheart,” Chris added, nuzzling her hair.

“You guys…” Her voice choked up.

“C’mere.” Chris took her hand and led her to the bed. “Lie down.” He reached behind his neck and pulled the goofy pink polo shirt off over his head, muscles rippling in the dim light.

Dag followed his lead, unbuttoning his shirt and shrugging out of it, his eyes moving between Kassidy’s soft femininity and Chris’s male strength. When he and Chris were both naked, Chris turned his head and met his gaze, his eyes gleaming. “Let’s make her feel good.”

“Yeah.”

As usual, Chris was the one who chose the position–this time he lay on the bed and moved Kassidy into reverse cowgirl. Nice. She faced Dag, her eyes dark and heavy-lidded, her mouth pouty. Dag filled his hands with her breasts as he moved over Chris’s legs, his cock jutting in front of him. Christ, he was hard enough to hit a baseball with it. Kassidy’s stiff little nipples poked his palms.

Then Chris tugged her down, so she lay on top of him, exposing her pussy to Dag.

“Lick her,” Chris instructed Dag in a hoarse voice. “Get her good and ready and then I’ll fuck her ass and you can fuck her pussy.”

Dag smiled. Sounded like a plan. He leaned over Kassidy, supporting his weight on his arms and kissed her, long and lush, as Chris’s hands slid over her breasts and belly stretched out above him. When Dag lifted away, Chris used one hand to grip her jaw and turn her face to him so he could kiss her too. Fuck, that was hot. Dag’s cock surged and he stroked himself, moving back down between both their legs.

Oh yeah, hell yeah, she was so wet and pretty. He inhaled the delicate warm scent of her he’d gotten to know so well, closed his eyes as a wave of emotion rolled over him. When he opened his eyes, the image of Chris’s big masculine hands on her small body, holding her in position, nearly undid him. Christ.

He kissed her inner thighs, so soft, quivering, gave a tiny nip at the tendon there, bringing a gasp from Kassidy. He smiled against her flesh, licked his way up the crease between thigh and pussy, kissing and sucking gently. He loved doing this. He could do it forever. The taste of her melting on his tongue, the hot feel of her against his lips–loved it. Fucking loved it. And Chris’s cock was right there too, thick and shiny, roped with prominent veins, his balls tight and high beneath.

Dag dragged in a breath. He stared at Chris’s cock and his balls, right there in front of his face, all smooth and tempting. Chris’s hand appeared and fisted his cock, and Dag helped Kassidy lift up a little as Chris moved his shaft, searching for her back entrance. Kassidy gave a soft cry as he found it.

“No,” Dag murmured. “First her pussy. She’s so wet.”

Chris grunted and took a few moments to work his cock inside her pussy. Then Dag watched with utter fascination as Chris thrust up into her. Daringly, he set his hands on Chris’s inner thighs, to brace himself as he leaned in to kiss Kassidy’s swollen clit. Chris’s big thigh muscles tightened beneath his palms, but he kept his rhythm, and the room filled with his groans, Kassidy’s breathless panting and Dag’s suckling noises as he drew Kassidy’s clit into his mouth. She gave a soft cry.

Dag’s fingers tightened on Chris’s hair-covered legs, and he licked Kassidy, suckled slowly, licked her soft folds, down, lower, right down to…Chris’s cock. Unable to resist, he drew his tongue over that distended shaft, over the hard ridge of vein, tasting of Kassidy’s sweet cream.

“Ungh! Jesus Christ!”

Chris’s whole body jerked as something stroked his cock. He couldn’t see what it was but it sure as hell wasn’t Kassidy touching him like that, her hands clasped over her own breasts. A harsh tremor shook his body and to his dismay, he slid out of her hot pussy.

“Shit,” he muttered.

“Got it,” Dag said from down below, and goddammit if Dag didn’t take hold of Chris’s cock. Jesus. Surely to god he was just going to quickly direct it back inside Kassidy…

Please…oh god…no. No.

Dag was holding him, stroking his length, shafting him with a practiced hand that knew exactly how hard and how fast. Chris groaned. “Dag…” A shudder raced over him, sensation tore through him, wrenching, fiery sensation. “What the…”

“It’s okay,” Dag murmured.

Then Kassidy tipped her head, looked into his face. “I was so close…”

Oh Christ. They couldn’t stop now. They had to stop this, though, this was wrong, this was bad… It took all his self-control not to toss Kassidy aside and leap off the bed. He gritted his teeth, as pleasure, dark, forbidden pleasure, exploded inside him.

And when Dag’s mouth took him in, he thought his heart might burst out of his chest. “Fuck!” he cried out, but his voice emerged as a feeble croak. Heated suction surrounded him, flames licked over his body. Kassidy whimpered, tensed, squirmed a bit. “It’s okay, sweetheart,” he gritted out. “Oh fuck…”

“What?”

She lifted her head and looked down their bodies and saw…well, Christ only knew what she saw. Chris’s head was glued to the pillow, his body a sparking mass of sensation as Dag’s hard mouth dragged up and down his cock, sucking and licking him with reckless enthusiasm. What the fuck was he doing? Had the guy lost his fucking mind? Jesus!

And Jesus, that felt good.

“Oh god.” Kassidy’s moan sank into his consciousness. “Oh god that’s hot.”

Words failed him; the only words that kept running through his mind were curses, the worst curse words he knew as his blood stirred in a rush of heat and a cascade of sparks.

They could not be doing this. Could. Not.

They were doing it and, holy hell, it felt good.

No. Bad. It felt bad. It had to feel bad. More curses clamored in his head, and he squeezed his eyes shut against the flames raging beneath his skin. He should make Dag stop. He should…but he couldn’t. Instead, he wanted to beg him not to stop.

Then things got worse, much worse, as Dag held up Chris’s cock, rubbed it against Kassidy’s pussy, and licked his balls. Wicked throbbing sensations built inside him, and when Dag’s fingers started teasing his asshole, his hips jerked. “Dag…” The word dragged out of him on a long groan.

“Chris.” Kassidy lifted an arm, touched his face, kissed his jaw. “Chris. It’s okay.”

No, it’s not. He could barely form words, as every nerve ending jumped, sensations sharp and hot exploded in his balls and raced up his spine. “Aw fuck. Dag, Jesus…” He’d never even let Kassidy touch him like that, it was so forbidden, so bad, so very bad. And then Dag’s finger breached him. His eyes stung at the sensations, the sharp slice of pain, the unfamiliar, almost unpleasant feeling…until Dag’s finger touched something else, something inside him, something amazing, and a burst of pleasure shot through him, so extreme it made him blind and deaf and feel as if his body was lifting off the bed. “Jesus fucking Christ.”

And he came. Not even inside Kassidy. He came in Dag’s mouth, Dag’s lips and tongue and cheeks sucking greedily. “No,” Chris almost sobbed. “No, no…”

“Chris.” Kassidy touched his face again, pressed her mouth to his. “Oh Chris…”

Dag sucked him dry, licked him clean, let his shaft slide from his mouth and then Kassidy gasped as Dag no doubt returned to her pussy.

“Oh yes,” she moaned again, plucking her own nipples. Shit. He should be doing that. Too bad he couldn’t lift his arms. Dag would take care of her. His head muzzy, thoughts spinning out of control, Chris drifted, hot and undone. Kassidy made little girl pleasure noises, her body tensed and tightened, and she gave a soft cry as she came.

Feverish, almost delirious, Chris babbled something, knew in the far back of his mind it didn’t even sound like human language that Dag or Kassidy could understand. Dag sprawled on the bed next to them, breathing heavily, one big hand still resting on Chris’s thigh.

And then Kassidy, sweet generous Kassidy, slid off Chris’s limp body and moved over Dag. “Dag,” she whispered, reaching for his cock. “Now you.”

“Aw, Kass, baby.” Dag’s fingers slid into her hair as she knelt beside him. Chris’s chest ached, his throat felt tight, his eyes hurt. Normally he loved to watch Kassidy give Dag head, but at that moment, he could hardly bear to open his eyes in case he looked at Dag. He could never look at him again.