The Litter Of The Law

The hum of an overhead fluorescent light distracted Cooper. Outside the police station’s windows, the sun was setting. Opening her metal briefcase, she laid out the papers from Hester’s folder onto the long table in the conference room.

“Precise,” observed Rick, the sheriff, rubbing his chin as he noted a large map with parcels of land and soil types outlined in different colors.

“Sarah was helpful. We went through Hester’s papers a few times, and she reiterated that her aunt didn’t speak of these much, except to say she was extra vigilant about where and from whom she bought her produce.”

He read the numbered key, checked the land to which it referred. “She had properties’ sales reports, too, with the price and when land changed hands, which wasn’t often.”

“From everything we know of Hester, that makes sense. She liked to do business with people she’d done business with for years, preferably whose parents did business with her parents. If a family farm was sold, she wanted to know the new owner’s intentions.”

“That’s one thing about this part of the world. There are times when you can see five generations at a crack.”

“Makes you see quite clearly where bad blood galloped from generation to generation.” Cooper laughed.

He laughed, too. “Does, but other things, little things—like have you ever noticed that Tally Urquhart, Big Mim, Little Mim, all favor bright blue? Blue signs, blue dresses, blue cars.”

“Now that you mention it, they do. Looks like Aunt Tally is going to bust a hundred and one this winter.” She paused at the thought of the wise old woman. “I think I’ll call on Aunt Tally. She knows these farms, knew them before most of the roads were paved. Maybe there’s something we’re missing.”

The sheriff pushed his chair back from the table. “Coop, any time spent with the old dragon is time well spent, but I don’t see the connection between the farms on this map and Hester’s death.”

She sat staring at the paper, thin where it had been repeatedly folded and unfolded over the years. Pointing to Buddy Janss’s holding, she said, “Hester dealt with Buddy for decades. Land value and use are changing. Buddy is certainly aware of it. For one thing, the sale of even one of his parcels would be worth seven figures.”

“To Buddy, not to Hester.”

“She was opposed to development,” said Cooper.

“So is Buddy, up to a point.” Tired, Rick’s voice betrayed it.

“Chief, I told you about the tie between Josh Hill and Hester. The Virginia tribes connection.”

“So they went fishing together,” said Rick, his voice now skeptical.

“Here’s Morrowdale, where Josh was found,” said Cooper, now on a roll. “Hester has a soil outline for it. Also on this map, Hester has all of Neil Jordan’s purchases outlined and soil-typed. I keep coming back to this. It has to do with soil, crops, and organic farming, but as far as I know, no one has ever been killed for applying fertilizer.”

He smiled. “Not yet anyway.”

“But here’s where I’m heading. Some of these farms had to have been formerly owned by the Monacans.”

He shifted in his seat. “Wouldn’t Hester have marked that as well?”

“I don’t know. All the stuff Sarah and I found in a folder on land issues, Indian scholarship funds, housing funds, all hinged on proving one’s Indian blood to the federal government. I think she might have paid Josh Hill to research who was a Monacan tribe member. We just haven’t found his research.”

“That’s a big jump,” he said, holding up his hand. “There is no solid connection between the murders themselves that we know of other than the costumes—no connection to farming practices and no connection to who owned what when.”

“Here’s where I’m going. The Virginia tribes are not recognized by the federal government, but that doesn’t mean they couldn’t work to repurchase such lands, nor does it mean they can’t continue their pressure on the government as well as the state. The state can’t deny them as easily as the feds, but the state would have a difficult time assisting in any purchases.”

He threw up his hands. “So what?”

“These lands are worth millions, but they sure wouldn’t be if returned or repurchased by a tribe, because they would never come on the market again.”

“But if the land was sold now, wouldn’t the tribe have to pay fair market value?”

Cooper leaned toward him. “Maybe. Maybe not. There are so many possibilities. Let’s say a landowner dies without any heirs. If the state takes over and the tribes create an outcry, they could possibly win the right to reclaim the land or maybe the right to purchase it at a reduced rate.”

The lawman remained unconvinced. “But first the tribe has to come up with the money.”

“They can open it for fishing and hunting, find new ways to create revenue based on their history and culture, and lastly, even though the Virginia tribes signed away the right to create casinos, they could possibly fight to reclaim those rights. As they are not now recognized by the federal government, think of the fight—a long fight, national attention, with billions at stake! The federal government would look really bad, and what if the timing was just right, say, during a presidential election? A great case could be made that the Monacans’ rights were signed away and stolen under duress. This could be huge.” She paused. “In Alexandria, preservationists want to save Carver School—built in 1944 for African American children, which means tribal children, too. The purchase price is $675,000. For Alexandria, right outside of D.C., that is not bad. If they succeed, it will energize other preservationists. Obviously, the focus is African American. They may not know about Plecker.”

He drummed his fingers on the table. “Billions of dollars, that seems to me to be more motivation for murder than protecting an ancestral school or home.”

“To us, but we’re white.”

This struck the sheriff. “Coop, you’re grasping at straws, but one of those straws might be the right one. I’ll call the chief of the Upper Mattaponi. I don’t fully understand the hopes of the various Virginia tribes.”

Cooper refolded the map. “Had another thought. Halloween is Thursday. We might want to assign extra people to the hayride.”

“We’re stretched thin as it is,” he said. “I’ve assigned extra officers to the downtown mall. It’s bound to get rowdy. If a private function gets out of control, we’ll be called, but the mall is public. I can’t really spare anyone.”

“If our killer is as arrogant as I think he is, the hayride could be a perfect venue for more of his showmanship.”

“Arrogant, yes, but we still haven’t got a compelling motive for these murders, and I don’t see how the Halloween Hayride, a fund-raiser for the library, ties to the two killings, other than people will be in scary costumes.”