I ran to my grandfather again, ran until my lungs ached in the cold and my legs felt brittle, made of glass. It was snowing still, a layer now half a foot thick and made of nothing, my feet sinking through as if the snow were only air. The city disappearing, all edges softened, the sky the same as the land. Only streetlights and windows remained, and the dark tracks cars made in the road.
I had to walk, to catch my breath. Heart pounding and skin slick with sweat under my coat. I didn’t want a secret life, hidden from my mother. I couldn’t imagine living that way.
There was no telling where the sun might be. The faint light an emanation that came from everywhere at once, the sea vanished, this road shortened at both ends and the sky close enough to touch. The sound of my own breath.
I ran again, but it seemed to take forever to reach the aquarium. Inside felt hot, and I stripped off my coat.
I found him at the largest tank just as a school of mackerel came at us with their mouths hung open, straining for plankton.
Look, my grandfather said. You can see right through their mouths to the water behind. Their mouths go nowhere.
I had never noticed that before. The food would never reach their stomachs. They’d be forever hungry, always eating and finding nothing. That’s wrong, I said.
I don’t understand it, he said. Where does it connect?
What I saw was every part of a fish wandering the oceans on its own. One of these gaping mouths straining through endless water with no body attached, a tail like a boomerang flinging itself through blue empty space, an eye floating alone. What if everything was unfinished? What if everything was made incomplete?
They’re alive, my grandfather said. And they’re fast swimmers, so obviously it all works out somehow, but I don’t see how. And what are plankton, really? They seem made up, like fairy tale. Some huge whale skimming through nothing with an open mouth and ending up fed.
I think it’s not finished, I said. I think none of it is finished.
What do you mean?
I felt overwhelmed. I don’t know, I said.
I think I see what you mean, he said. We think the world is done, that this is the way it is, but it’s really still making itself. In a million years, the mackerel will have some balloon opening to its stomach to match that head.
That’s not what I mean, I said.
What do you mean?
That we’re not put together yet. Parts are missing.
So the first version isn’t done? Not that there will be other versions, but even the first one isn’t yet complete?
Yeah.
Hm. I understand that. But I don’t think it’s true, Caitlin. I think we’re okay. I think we’re complete. I mean our lives are all screwed up, but I think we have everything we need.
The mackerel were far away now, at the other end of the tank, pale shadows gathering, tricks of light, no more than dust motes in air. The sea a great blindness, too thick, shapes coming into view only up close. No warning.
Cod in close now, low against the rocks and weeds, fattened and slow, yellow-brown and aimless, dull eyes. A kind of saltwater catfish, waiting only to be eaten. The flat rounded plates of their heads, armor, thick sad lips, one white tendril for finding food in sand. Perhaps they were complete, but for what purpose?
What’s that? my grandfather asked.
Cod.
Dinner. I didn’t know they looked like that. They’re so yellow, they make the water around them look yellow. I never would have noticed them if you hadn’t been looking.
I looked up again to where the mackerel were coming around, bright silver heads gasping open, and they did make the water itself brighter, bluer, just like he said. You’re right. The cod make the water look muddy and yellow.
The mackerel were so fast, kinks of light with black racing stripes, turned and gone.
Most of the fish here we don’t even see, my grandfather said. Someone visits the aquarium. They look at the sharks, see the king crab, point at the brightest colors, but most of the fish go unnoticed, anything drab or brown, anything slow.
That’s true, I said. I’ve never seen anyone look at the cod for this long.
And the cod will be here forever. The mackerel look like they’re trying to escape. Like they’re looking for a way out. And they’ll probably find it. But the cod don’t care. They’re willing to believe this aquarium is the whole world. They’re going to have lunch or be served for lunch, and it’s all the same.
I feel sorry for the cod, I said.
Me too. They just look sad. I don’t think I can keep looking at them. We have to move on to something else.
I know where we can go, I said. Just upstairs. This same tank, but the highest part, all open water. The mola mola. Have you seen him?
I didn’t know there was an upstairs.
I was so excited I felt like jumping up and down. I could show my grandfather something new.
Let’s hurry then, he said. I’m dying to see.
We walked up a narrow dark ramp with round portholes, like a submarine. Don’t look, I said. You have to close your eyes until I say to open them.
I took my grandfather by the hand and led him up to the small room that looked out on a deep and endless blue. No rock formations, no seaweed, no cod or other bottom fish, and even the mackerel and albacore and sharks made only brief visits on their rounds. But the mola mola loved to lie flat on the surface, open to the sky, one eye looking upward. And then he’d submerge just below and swim all along the edge of the tank in his unlikely, twisting way. My grandfather kept his eyes closed patiently, and I waited until the fish was right in front of us.
Open, I said.
Oh, he said. Oh my god. It’s the man in the moon.
And suddenly I could see it. A crescent moon in white, and his face looking upward.
That mouth, he said. And the white eye. Not his real eye, in darkness, but that small white one just ahead forms another face. His real eye looks afraid, but with that other eye he’s seeing god, looking into the heavens in rapture.
The mola mola turned and twisted away, the dark side of the moon all we could see now, dark craters and canyons fading into the deeper blue on great fins we weren’t normally allowed to witness, what propels each planet and moon.
Caitlin, he said. That was nothing less than a vision. Thank you.
He pulled me close against his side, and we watched the shadow form circling, waited for its orbit to come close again.