Stay of Execution

71

Normally, visits by the chief constable to the outposts of his empire were announced in advance. Sir James Proud did not believe in dropping in casually to divisional headquarters, or to any of the outstations. To some that would imply that he was trying to catch them off guard, and might damage their trust in him. Trust, given and received, was the foundation of his office, and it had seen him through a successful career that was now approaching its conclusion.

Thus, when he swept through the entrance of the Queen Charlotte Street police office, it came as no surprise to the young constable behind the public counter, or to Chief Superintendent Stockton Day waiting in front of it in his pristine uniform, or to Detective Superintendent Mario McGuire, standing beside him, jacketless, a pen clipped into the pocket of his white shirt. They had been alerted in a phone call from his secretary, as he had left Fettes.

Two men followed him into the building; one was in NYPD uniform, while the other, slightly younger, wore a grey tailored suit and a grim expression.

‘Good morning, gentlemen,’ the chief exclaimed. ‘We didn’t need the welcoming committee but thank you anyway.’

As he spoke McGuire and Nolan Donegan nodded to each other, reached across and shook hands. ‘You know each other?’ Sir James asked.

The superintendent nodded. ‘Yes, sir. Colin Mawhinney introduced us when he took me on a tour of some of the precinct offices. Sorry it’s like this, Nolan.’

‘Me too, Mario, me too.’

The chief constable introduced the two Americans to Chief Superintendent Day. ‘I thought it right,’ he said, ‘that they should come straight to the heart of the investigation. Is DI McIlhenney in?’

‘Yes, sir,’ McGuire replied. ‘He’s in the office he’s using. I told him I’d bring you through when you arrived.’

‘Shall I organise refreshments, Chief?’ asked Day.

‘I’d appreciate that.’ He turned to the Americans. ‘How about you, gentlemen?’

Donegan nodded. ‘To be truthful, I’m flagging after that flight. I’d welcome some coffee.’ He turned to his colleague. ‘Eli?’

The crew-cut lieutenant seemed to stand even more stiffly than before. ‘No, thank you. I should check in on the investigation right away.’

As Donegan and the chief were led away by the divisional commander, McGuire showed Huggins through to the CID suite. ‘Good trip?’ he asked casually.

‘No,’ the American replied curtly.

McIlhenney saw them coming through the glass panel in the door of the cubicle that McGuire had described as his office; he rose from behind his desk and opened it for them, then introduced himself to the visitor. ‘Eli Huggins, Lieutenant, Internal Affairs Bureau, NYPD,’ the man replied shortly.

Name, rank and serial number, thought McGuire. He sees us as the fucking enemy.

‘Who’s the senior investigating officer?’ asked Huggins.

‘I am.’ McIlhenney was always amiable; but on occasion it was a little forced.

‘You are? Maybe I misunderstand your ranking structure here, but isn’t a superintendent superior to an inspector in your force?’ He turned to McGuire. ‘And are you, sir, not the divisional detective commander here?’

‘Well done, you’re right both times.’

‘In that case, sir, I have to tell you that I do not believe that my chief of detectives would approve of command of this investigation being delegated to a junior officer.’

‘Nor would he approve of me walking into his office and telling him how to do his job. You’re not going to be a fucking seagull, are you, Eli?’

‘What’s a seagull?’

‘It’s a name the managers of American-owned companies in Scotland sometimes give to the guys from head office. It means that they fly in from far away, make a lot of noise, shit all over you and then fly away again. The story is that the man at the top of our chain of command has decided that it would not be appropriate for me to command this one. Colin and I became good friends in the time we knew each other. .’

‘You mean your objectivity is in doubt?’

‘I mean I’m a potential witness to his state of mind.’

‘There is another reason,’ said McIlhenney quietly. ‘When these people are apprehended, we do not want to have them carried into court by paramedics.’

‘It’s my Italian blood,’ McGuire added. ‘Makes me excitable; that and my Irish blood.’

Huggins showed his first sign of loosening up. ‘Don’t you have Scots blood to calm you down?’

‘Nope. Fifty per cent Wop, fifty per cent Mick, that’s me.’

‘With breeding like that you’d be Commissioner of Police in New York.’

‘I doubt that, very much. I’d probably be at war with myself over control of a labour union.’ He reached out to open the door. ‘I’m going to leave you guys alone, now. By the way, Lieutenant, Neil isn’t on my staff, so I haven’t delegated anything to him. He’s Special Branch.’

‘Is that something like me?’

‘If you mean that you’re both secret policemen, I suppose he is. But that’s as far as it goes.’ He left the room with a smile.

‘Take the weight off your feet,’ said McIlhenney, as the door closed, ‘and tell me why you came in here like a man with a thistle up his arse.’

‘I’m sorry,’ said Huggins, as he accepted the first invitation. ‘Before I left I had an interview with my boss and his boss. They both explained to me what the personal consequences would be if any of the information I’m carrying got into the public domain.’

‘That’s good man management.’ The big inspector chuckled.

‘Maybe, but I can understand why.’

‘Are you telling me that your man Mawhinney was bent?’

‘Absolutely not. There was no straighter officer on our force.’

‘What’s the story, then?’

‘I’ll get to that,’ said the New Yorker, ‘but maybe you could bring me up to speed on your investigation.’

‘Sure.’ McIlhenney ran him through everything they had, detailing all of Mawhinney’s movements since he and McGuire had arrived for the second leg of the exchange visit, and ending with Spoons’s statement, and the search for a single Land Rover among over a hundred thousand vehicles.

‘He wasn’t forced into the automobile?’

‘Not according to the witness statement,’ the inspector repeated. ‘He stopped, there was a period of communication with the people inside, then Colin got in himself, and the vehicle drove off. Next morning he was found in the dock.’

‘Do you think he was meant to be found?’

‘It is only an opinion, you understand, but I don’t. If he was, why bother taking him there? Why not just dump him in the river, or in one of the lochs in Holyrood Park? He was weighted down and dropped in deep water. It was a pure accident that the chain snagged and he didn’t go to the bottom. He wouldn’t have stayed there for ever, but I reckon the thinking was that he’d be down there long enough to fuck up the forensics.’ He looked up. ‘So what have you got?’

‘Before I begin,’ said Huggins, ‘I need to know who will have access to this information.’

‘If it’s that sensitive, only two people: me and Bob Skinner, our deputy chief, my boss.’

‘It will remain secure?’

‘Bet on it.’

‘I’m betting my career. That’s why I was so awkward earlier. Okay, here goes. As you know, I am a member of our IAB. Before he was transferred to patrol division, Colin Mawhinney was also an IAB officer.’ Huggins hesitated. ‘You probably think of us in the way that most people do, that we’re real bottom-feeders, cops who persecute other cops. But everything we do, and every investigation we undertake, is in response to a complaint from the public of corruption or serious misconduct, with the emphasis on serious. We don’t go looking for work; we don’t have to. It comes to us, by telephone, by letter and these days even by e-mail.’

‘Understood,’ said McIlhenney. ‘It’s a dirty job, but it has to be done properly in everyone’s interests, cops included.’

‘Right. In Mawhinney’s time as a sergeant in IAB, he investigated a detective officer named Luigi Salvona. The complaint followed a killing in Brooklyn, a gangland execution in which the victim, one Al Tedesco, was lured to a restaurant in a quiet street and strangled as he ate. Salvona was at the table with him; he was the man who set up the meeting. He testified that the men who did the job wore masks, and that he was beaten unconscious. There were no witnesses; they were the only diners in the restaurant and both waiters were conveniently in the kitchen when the killing took place. Under questioning he said that Tedesco had been an informant of his, and that he assumed the execution had been a reprisal.’ Huggins leaned across McIlhenney’s desk, picked up his water carafe and a glass. ‘May I?’

‘Of course.’

He poured some water and took a sip. ‘The complaint came from the victim’s widow,’ he continued. ‘She said that her husband had been set up by Salvona, and that far from being a police informant, he was an organised-crime member himself, and that Salvona was on his payroll, not the other way around. When the FBI was consulted they confirmed that Tedesco had indeed been on their surveillance list, and that he had been under investigation, although not actively at that time. Such a complaint, a mobster’s wife admitting his past and accusing a policeman of complicity in his assassination, remains unique in the annals of IAB. Sergeant Mawhinney was the investigating officer; he saw a problem from the outset with Salvona’s story. He was a patrol officer, not a detective. How would he come to have an informant as connected as Tedesco?’

Huggins took another sip from the glass. ‘Mawhinney did all the correct things. He interviewed Salvona’s fellow officers, but learned nothing. He pulled his telephone records, but found nothing incriminating. He pulled his mother’s telephone records: nothing. He gained access to his bank account: nothing. So he returned Officer Salvona to duty, and he put him under surveillance. Three weeks later it paid off. The officer was married; he also had a girlfriend, as the investigators discovered when they tailed him to her apartment one night, and watched him leave at three in the morning.’

He drained the glass. ‘Bingo. Her name was Irene Falcone, and she was the sister of a senior figure in a rival family to that of which Tedesco was a member. Mawhinney pulled her phone records; he found regular calls to her brother, but crucially, two days before the hit, he found one to Al Tedesco. Then he checked her bank accounts: the day after Tedesco’s murder, the sum of one hundred thousand dollars was paid into a new joint account. It had two signatories, Irene Falcone and Luigi Salvona. That finished them both. They pleaded guilty to second-degree homicide and they were sentenced to ten to twenty years each. On the day he was sentenced, the judge asked Salvona if he had anything to say. He said, and I quote, “Yes, Your Honour, I would like to say the following. Sergeant Mawhinney, you are a fucking dead man.” This is not an unusual remark from a convicted felon but. .’

‘But what?’

‘Salvona and Irene Falcone were both released, on the same day, four weeks ago, and set up home together in an apartment in Queens. They had a scheduled meeting with their parole officer last Wednesday. They failed to appear: officers were sent to collect them but they were not at home. Then yesterday they walked into the parole office, apologised, and said that they had gone on vacation to Florida and had mixed up the date of their meeting.’

‘Can you prove they left the country?’

‘Not a chance. Irene’s brother is still a very large fish; they’d have used fake passports.’

‘But if we can match either of them to the hire of a Land Rover within the last week or so. .’

‘Yes, Inspector, only this is where it gets complicated. The day Salvona was arrested he was fired from the force. When he was arraigned, it was as a civilian, and his connection with NYPD was covered up. His presence at the Tedesco murder had never been revealed, nor was it announced in court, because of the guilty plea. However wrong it may have been, this was a decision taken to protect the image of the force. If it all becomes public now. .’

‘The shit flies ten-fold.’ McIlhenney looked at the American. ‘Are you asking me to fold my investigation?’

‘A colleague of yours used the word “discretion” to me this morning, Inspector. I use it now to you.’

The big Scot leaned back in his chair and folded his arms. ‘I don’t have any,’ he said. ‘In these circumstances, discretion belongs with DCC Skinner. I think you’d better meet with him.’