Death in Paradise

Chapter Twelve

"I got twelve names," Jesse said to Lilly Summers. "Kids gave their class rings to a girl."

"Makes last year's class seem embarrassingly unromantic," Lilly said.

"Embarrassingly," Jesse said. "Seven of these kids can account for their girlfriends' whereabouts, and we've verified it."

"Which leaves you five."

"Four of them are supposed to be at summer homes with their parents, but we haven't been able to reach them yet. One boy doesn't know where she is."

"And her parents?"

"Kid didn't know anything about her parents," Jesse said.

"How could that be?" Lilly said. "What are the names?"

"Boyfriend's name is William Royce," Jesse said.

Lilly smiled. "Hooker," she said.

"And the girlfriend is Elinor Bishop."

"Oh dear," Lilly said.

"You know them."

"Yes, of course."

"You have an address for her?"

"She called herself Billie. Yes, I have her address."

"Could you talk to me," Jesse said, "about Hooker and Billie?"

"How long do you have?"

"If it's a longish story we could do it over lunch."

Lilly smiled. She was wearing a pale yellow silk dress today.

"What a very good idea," she said.

It was low tide. They sat in a small restaurant that looked out over Fisherman's Beach at the gunmetal Atlantic rolling stolidly in onto the shiny sand. The ocean smell was strong. Even if you didn't look at it, it was there in that mysterious way that the sea asserts itself.

"I hope it's not Billie," Lilly said.

"It's going to be somebody," Jesse said.

They ordered iced tea and looked at their menus. Lilly ordered a house salad, dressing on the side. Jesse had a tuna fish sandwich.

"Hooker Royce," Lilly said, "is our All-American. Honor roll since first grade. Three sports, captain in all of them. All-state in football. Scholarship to Yale."

"And he's handsome and self-effacing," Jesse said.

"How did you know?"

"They're always self-effacing and handsome."

"All of them?"

"All the small-school heroes, it's part of the heroism. The expectations of the town force it upon them."

"Even the handsome?"

"Might be sort of circular. Probably wouldn't be the town hero if he were ugly."

"Even if he were just as good?" Lilly said.

"Maybe," Jesse said.

"Well, that's cynical."

"Or observant."

She smiled at him. "Being observant would make you cynical," Lilly said. "Wouldn't it."

"You seem observant," Jesse said.

"I try."

"But you don't seem cynical."

"I'm in the hope business," Lilly said.

"Education?"

"Yes."

"You think you might be saving them?"

"I have to think so, or hope so," Lilly said. "Otherwise what have I done with my life?"

Jesse sipped his iced tea and looked at her. Lilly's eyes were almond shaped and dark brown, maybe black. Her skin was smooth. She wore quite a bit of makeup, but carefully.

"What about Billie?" Jesse said.

Lilly breathed deeply through her nose. It made her chest move.

"Billie Bishop," she said.

Jesse was quiet. Lilly shook her head gently.

"Billie was…" She stopped to think about it. "Billie was our town pump," she said.

"Don't beat around the bush," Jesse said.

"I know. It's a terrible thing to say, isn't it?"

"We used to say it when I was a kid," Jesse said.

"We all did," Lilly said. "It says everything and nothing."

Jesse nodded. There were potato chips with his sandwich. Jesse ate one.

"I'm more interested in everything," he said.

"Yes."

Jesse looked at the ocean. It was uninterrupted here, stretching to Spain. In Jesse's imagination, the Atlantic was a gray ocean. The Pacific had been blue.

"Teachers hear things, and they gossip."

"I'm shocked," Jesse said.

Lilly smiled. "Billie," she said, "was probably what we would have called, in less enlightened times, a nymphomaniac."

Jesse smiled. "Not a bad thing in a woman," he said.

Lilly looked at him thoughtfully.

"Sexuality is not a bad thing in a woman," she said.

"It certainly isn't."

"But frequent indiscriminate sex probably is," Lilly said. "However outmoded the phrase, it at least served to identify sexuality rooted in something wrong."

"So does 'town pump.' "

"Yes."

"And there's something wrong with Billie?"

"I think so. A school principal knows very little about the souls of her students."

Jesse nodded.

"But I do know her external circumstances."

Jesse waited.

"She is not a discipline problem in the sense of an angry rebellious teenager that we all think of in this context…"

Lilly stopped suddenly and looked at Jesse again. Jesse waited.

"I don't know if I should be talking to you like this."

"It's okay," Jesse said. "I'm the police."

"You are not even one of our police," she said.

"True."

"There's something so quiet about you."

Jesse nodded.

"And it's charming in a way I don't exactly understand," Lilly said.

"Good," Jesse said.

"That it's charming, or that I don't understand?"

"That I have your attention," Jesse said.

They were silent.

"Yes, you do," Lilly said finally.

Jesse smiled at her. She smiled back. Then she let her breath out audibly.

"Billie comes from a home," she said, "that would be officially classified as 'good.' "

"By which we normally mean two parents and some money."

Lilly nodded.

"Anything wrong with the parents?"

"Except that their daughter is a mess," Lilly said. "I don't know. I've never met them."

"Any of her teachers know them?"

"They were invited to come in and discuss their daughter's problems several times. But they never did."

"Siblings?" Jesse said.

"Her older sister graduated this school with honors. There is, I believe, a younger girl as well."

"In school here?"

"No. Still in middle school, I think."

"So aside from a tendency toward frequent indiscriminate sex, what kind of mess is she?"

"She failed a number of courses, which is, as you may know, in today's educational climate, not easy."

"She dumb?"

"No. Extremely passive. Apathetic. She never speaks in class. Between classes she didn't interact with other students."

"Didn't?"

"Excuse me?"

"You've been talking about her in the present tense until you said she didn't interact. Why the tense change?"

"Hooker," Lilly said.

"She interacted with Hooker?"

"Intensely," Lilly said. "Have you met him?"

"No, one of the other cops talked to him on the phone."

"He's a lovely boy," Lilly said.

"So how did the school hero end up with the town pump?" Jesse said.

"I don't know," Lilly said.

"Maybe it was influenced by the nymphomania."

"There's that cynical thing again," Lilly said.

"You have any idea where Billie might be now?"

Lilly shook her head. They both stared out the window for a time at the ocean, always in motion, going nowhere.

"If she's missing, wouldn't her parents have reported her missing?"

"You'd think so," Jesse said.

"But they haven't?"

"Not that I can find out. Swampscott cops have nothing."

"Do you think the girl in the lake is Billie?" Lilly said.

"Be my guess," Jesse said.