Icon and Axe

THE CONFRONTATION

The Early Fourteenth to the Early Seventeenth Century

THE RISE of a distinctive civilization under the leadership of Moscow from the establishment of its metropolitan seat in 1326 to the achievement of military hegemony and the first assumption of imperial titles during the reign of Ivan III, “the Great” (1462-1505). Monastic leadership in the colonization of the Russian north (particularly in the century between the founding by St. Sergius of the Monastery of the Holy Trinity in 1337 and the founding of the Solovetsk Monastery on the White Sea in 1436), and in the creation of a sense of national unity and destiny. Increased militance and xenophobia in the face of attacks by knightly orders from the West, continuing conflict with the Mongols, and the Byzantine collapse of 1453. The growth of prophetic passion as an intensification of the historical bias of Russian theology: the fools in Christ, Moscow as the “third Rome.”

The complex, traumatic confrontation of a powerful but primitive Muscovy with a Western Europe in the throes of the Renaissance and the Reformation. The destruction of the rationalistic and republican traditions of cosmopolitan Novgorod; the victory of the Moscow-oriented hierarchy over the Westward-looking heretics. The importance of Catholic ideas in the formation of the authoritarian “Josephite” ideology of the sixteenth century adopted by the Muscovite Tsars even while denouncing “the Latins.” The growing military and technological dependence—under Ivan IV, “the Terrible” (1533-84), Boris Godunov (1598-1605), and Michael Romanov (1613-45)—on the North European “Germans” despite ideological opposition to Protestantism.

The reign of Ivan IV as both the culmination and the first breaking point in the Muscovite ideal of building a prophetic, religious civilization. On the one hand, his fixation with genealogical sanctification, his attempt to monasticize all of Russian life, and the similarities of his rule with that of the kings of ancient Israel and of contemporary Spain. On the other, Ivan’s breaking of the sacred ruling line (dating back to the legendary summons of Riurik to Novgorod in 862) and preparing the way for the tradition of “false pretenders,” and his involvement of Russia in Western politics through his attempt to move west into the Baltic during the costly Livonian Wars of 1558-83. The coming of the Western European religious wars to Russian soil, as Lutheran Sweden and Catholic Poland begin a long, losing struggle with Muscovy for control of northeastern Europe during the Russian interregnum, or “Time of Troubles” (1604-13).